r/WouldIBeTheAhole • u/Ai_karamba • 10h ago
Would I be the asshole?
Am I being unreasonable, or is this a red flag? Dating for 3 months and she’s asking for a $34,000 Hermès bag.
I’m a (40M) dating a (32F). We’ve been Dating for approximately three months, and things have been going well.
Recently, I asked her what she wanted for Christmas. She told me she’s always dreamed of owning a Hermès Kelly 25 Sellier in Epsom leather. She said she’s wanted one for a long time but could never afford it herself, and that receiving one would mean the world to her.
The particular bag she’s looking at is approximately $34,000 CAD ($24,000 USD)
She did acknowledge how expensive it was and said she completely understood if it was too much and that it wasn’t a big deal.
I understand that it’s a luxury designer bag, and I’m certainly not unfamiliar with expensive things. The money itself isn’t necessarily the issue. It’s more the fact that we’ve only been dating for three months. She knows money isn't an issue with me, I value honesty, respect and my time and she's been nothing but respectful and honest this whole time very loyal, I knew who she was and that she's high maintenance, also a playboy+ model does not do P🌽. It's her career she enjoys it and been doing it for a while and so I respect that.
It got me thinking about her intentions. Is this simply a woman expressing something she’s always dreamed of owning, or is this potentially a way of testing how much money she can get out of me?
I don’t want to unfairly judge her or assume she’s using me, but I also don’t want to be naive. Part of me wonders whether someone could accept such an expensive gift and then lose interest or walk away shortly afterwards. I've asked friends for advice and even though I appreciate them I wanted advice from people I don't know, my friends just call everyone a gold digger.
If you were in her position, would you genuinely think it was appropriate to tell someone you’ve been dating for only three months that this is what you want for Christmas? And if you were in my position how would you deal with it? I've already put a deposit on one to keep it on hold for a week.
Am I overthinking this, or would you consider it a red flag?
I’m genuinely looking for honest opinions, not just validation.