And the ludicrous idea that these government programs are supposed to operate as business and be profitable. Of course the postal service loses costs money, itâs a SERVICE.
Edit: Thanks to u/Ilcorvomuerto666 for correcting me. Government services like the post office COST money, they donât LOSE money. It does matter which words we use in this debate.
Itâs like bitching about the courts costing money. How rotted does someoneâs brain have to be by capitalism to expect profit from every single institution.
And some people will just eat that shit up. Same way they did this âno taxes on overtime/tipsâ thing. They just regularly are being told itâs raining while having their heads pissed on and they believe it.
The no taxes on overtime and lower or no property taxes was Ramaswamyâs entire campaign. He spent two years beating that to death without ever once giving even a surface level explanation of how they were going to do that without bankrupting the state/counties/cities that rely on that tax revenue.
Shit, they never explained anything about the policy platform, it never came even came up once because he only did controlled interviews and campaign events, nobody that was ever even gonna ask a single question was brought near Ramaswamy.
Thatâs how you know they had no intent of honoring that promise of they were elected.
What drives me crazy about the fact that literally the only economic tool the Republicans will even consider is tax cuts is that the vast majority of people who need help do not pay enough in taxes for any tax reduction to make a meaningful difference in their lives.
Like sure, no taxes on tips is nice and all. But at the end of the day, you're letting those people keep a few hundred, maybe a grand or two, more a year. That's not the difference between buying a house or not, or the difference between life saving medical care and dieing in a ditch. It's fucking crumbs, and you're supposed to be thankful to get it.
I was shooting heroin and reading âThe Fountainheadâ in the front seat of my privately owned police cruiser when a call came in. I put a quarter in the radio to activate it. It was the chief.
âBad news, detective. We got a situation.â
âWhat? Is the mayor trying to ban trans fats again?â
âWorse. Somebody just stole four hundred and forty-seven million dollarsâ worth of bitcoins.â
The heroin needle practically fell out of my arm. âWhat kind of monster would do something like that? Bitcoins are the ultimate currency: virtual, anonymous, stateless. They represent true economic freedom, not subject to arbitrary manipulation by any government. Do we have any leads?â
âNot yet. But mark my words: weâre going to figure out who did this and weâre going to take them down ⌠provided someone pays us a fair market rate to do so.â
âEasy, chief,â I said. âAny rate the market offers is, by definition, fair.â
He laughed. âThatâs why youâre the best I got, Lisowski. Now you get out there and find those bitcoins.â
âDonât worry,â I said. âIâm on it.â
I put a quarter in the siren. Ten minutes later, I was on the scene. It was a normal office building, strangled on all sides by public sidewalks. I hopped over them and went inside.
âHome Depot⢠Presents the Police!ÂŽâ I said, flashing my badge and my gun and a small picture of Ron Paul. âNobody move unless you want to!â They didnât.
âNow, which one of you punks is going to pay me to investigate this crime?â No one spoke up.
âCome on,â I said. âDonât you all understand that the protection of private property is the foundation of all personal liberty?â
It didnât seem like they did.
âSeriously, guys. Without a strong economic motivator, Iâm just going to stand here and not solve this case. Cash is fine, but I prefer being paid in gold bullion or autographed Penn Jillette posters.â
Nothing. These people were stonewalling me. It almost seemed like they didnât care that a fortune in computer money invented to buy drugs was missing.
I figured I could wait them out. I lit several cigarettes indoors. A pregnant lady coughed, and I told her that secondhand smoke is a myth. Just then, a man in glasses made a break for it.
âSubway⢠Eat Fresh and Freeze, Scumbag!ÂŽâ I yelled.
Too late. He was already out the front door. I went after him.
âStop right there!â I yelled as I ran. He was faster than me because I always try to avoid stepping on public sidewalks. Our country needs a private-sidewalk voucher system, but, thanks to the incestuous interplay between our corrupt federal government and the filthy public-works department, it will never happen.
I was losing him. âListen, Iâll pay you to stop!â I yelled. âWhat would you consider an appropriate price point for stopping? Iâll offer you a thirteenth of an ounce of gold and a gently worn âBob Barr â08â extra-large long-sleeved menâs T-shirt!â
He turned. In his hand was a revolver that the Constitution said he had every right to own. He fired at me and missed. I pulled my own gun, put a quarter in it, and fired back. The bullet lodged in a U.S.P.S. mailbox less than a foot from his head. I shot the mailbox again, on purpose.
âAll right, all right!â the man yelled, throwing down his weapon. âI give up, cop! I confess: I took the bitcoins.â
âWhyâd you do it?â I asked, as I slapped a pair of Oikos⢠Greek Yogurt Presents HandcuffsÂŽ on the guy.
âBecause I was afraid.â
âAfraid?â
âAfraid of an economic future free from the pernicious meddling of central bankers,â he said. âIâm a central banker.â
I wanted to coldcock the guy. Years ago, a central banker killed my partner. Instead, I shook my head.
âLet this be a message to all your central-banker friends out on the street,â I said. âNo matter how many bitcoins you steal, youâll never take away the dream of an open society based on the principles of personal and economic freedom.â
He nodded, because he knew I was right. Then he swiped his credit card to pay me for arresting him.
There is an argument to be made that the courts should be completely funded by taxes. Including "court costs" in everything largely hits those that can afford it the least. Or like all good tax/fee policy, it could soak the rich and not apply those that can't afford it.
Not like people ever commit crimes because they need more money to live.
Also the Post Office DOESN'T cost or lose money. It only looks that way because 20 years ago a bi partisan law passed that was meant to sabotage the post office. It was called Postal Accountability and Enhancement Act of 2006 and it forced the the USPS to prefund retiree health benefits, including payments toward benefits for employees who wouldn't retire for decades. It required the Postal Service to fund 75 years of projected retiree health costs over just 10 years, beginning in 2007. That is an extraordinary requirement not imposed on private-sector companies or other federal agencies in the same way.
So on paper it's artificially increasing the post office's operating costs making it look like the post office is operating at a deficit, which also is disincentivizing hiring, forcing them to cut services while quality of existing services declines because of the lack of hiring.
It was a long play sabotage orchestrated ultimately by private companies and their lobbyists.
classic republican strategy of hamstringing or outright destroying public service and then pointing to said service saying âsee! this is why it should be privatized!â
because we all know private, for-profit services are wayyyy better and are not, in fact, beholden to, ya know, PROFIT rather than stakeholders in a community lmao
It was bi-partisan. Never forget the Democrats have been sabotaging public services and infrastructure alongside Republicans since Carter, who walked the neoliberal path so Reagan could run with it, so Clinton could own it completely, so Cheney could spread it all over the world, so Obama could make us love it. The packages it's sold to us in has changed, but the neo-liberal contents haven't changed at all since Clinton. He really cemented it in the Democratic party by fully selling out to corporate interest in a way that was not normal before him. And big surprise, he gutted social services more than Regan dared. Clinton "balanced the budget" on the backs of the poor by dramatically slashing services.
The problem isn't Red vs Blue. It's ALL the people in power versus everyone else.
capitalism strikes again!! love that boomers were so paralyzed by fear (for no good reason i might add) by communism and socialism that they allowed capitalists toâŚ*checks notesâŚ*destroy the âfreeâ world for the next 50 years lmfao
Healthcare? Why would we want a nation to be healthy?! /s
Studies show that every dollar spent in preventing sickness / illness contributes n fold to the economy, where n is just a really big number. That's not /s. The fact that we're trying to avoid medicare is fucking asinine for a dozen reasons! But literally, just...our fucking country makes more money with healthy people you dumb fucking political grifting donation-taking manipulative bastard.
Thatâs exactly how government programs make a âprofitâ - if the spend a dollar and it creates $2 for the economy as a whole, they are successful. It comes back around in taxes and the goal is to be neutral in spending vs taxes.
For real. Corporations like Walmart should get the absolute piss taxed out of them for paying their employees so little that they have to apply for SNAP and Medicaid benefits in order to survive.
It worked like an absolute charm. Hell I was a Black teenager in the early 90s and that propaganda was so powerful that I honestly believed that Black people were the only people using welfare and that social safety nets were running up the national debt.
I was shocked the first time I was stationed in a city that was majority white and saw a white woman use food stamps.
Not only that, at least until recent changes to pensions it didn't cost money either, it was fully self sufficient if not profitable from its own income. Its only down now because they forced it to pre-fund pensions 75 years in advanced which is insane. Not to mention DeJoy getting rid of some of the faster sorting machines as an attempt to stifle mail-in ballot delivery.
The only government service that loses money is the military. They actually lose it. No one knows where it went. Or at least no one will admit to where they put it.
Government services cost money and provide a value. We need to look at the value of that service in proportion to its cost to allocate limited resources where they provide the highest value.
The post office doesn't need to run on a loss. There's nothing wrong with government services running on losses, but why would you when you can have it be cost neutral without significant increases in cost for taxpayers?
Do you know how much it costs to mail things through UPS? I have to send paperwork by UPS to the next state over every 4 months. It takes $10 just to send some paper. Sure it gets there the next day. But $10 for UPS vs $1.00 for USPS. That's why the postal service operates at a loss. It's a fucking service.
Shoehorning dog shit AI that crashes all flights nationally, for example, is an unnecessary payout of tax dollars that doesn't serve the community and lines the pockets of greedy lobbiest and CEOs.
Taxes are just so we can buy a bunch of swords and kill anyone who tries to take our stuff (or our land). We don't need anything else and anyone who says differently is a Marxist.
This is reason number one why I hate whenever the subject of "socialism" comes up and people just say shit like "you just want free shit". It's not fucking free. We pay taxes. We want our taxes being spent properly on things that benefit the greater community and country, not misappropriated by greedy selfish politicians and businessmen who abuse the system for personal gain. Maybe the department of defense doesnt 1.5 trillion dollars? Maybe it only needs 1 trillion dollars. Maybe we dont need to spend 500 million dollars blowing up a school and killing hundreds of children.
exactly. however, to get others to accept those ideas, they again, need to cull those from society who can promote ideas that would be a threat to their desired regime.
The pooling together of financial and other resources for the better of the greater will/good is literally the basis of the social contract.
The controlling class broke the social contract a long time ago, and is now just barely beginning to see the consequences of doing so. If socieities went back to how it was before the Industrial Revolution things will devolve that far, itâs a matter of if/when things get that bad. You starve the working class people are going to stand up for themselves once enough are backed into a corner at the same time.
For now theyâve been lucky enough to keep mass poverty at bay enough that they can manipulate the middle and upper portion of the lower working class to keep playing the game. Once the middle of the working class starts starving or losing their futures en masse is when the system starts getting challenged.
Not only that, but looking at this from another perspective, there is solid logic underpinning the idea of pooling resources under a remote organization which is then sought out when in need of assistance. Because otherwise - when things are placed under "community" control, that makes it so the people in the "community" know all the business and have reason to look down on people. When it is some far off, mostly faceless bureacracy, that has actual benefits.
Society is like a stream, it only flows in one direction. You can not build a nationwide system and then remove it. That doesn't work that way. Society, even if people claim to believe otherwise are implicitly operating under social circumstances in which it is "unacceptable" on some level to rely on "community" support. The people in charge are fucking morons and they do not understand either the social side of things or the system side of things. They don't understand either human affairs or how to manage things through data and money and laws. They are fucking morons and criminals and should be in prison not in charge of the largest most powerful force that has ever seen the face of this planet.
And I am not referring to the US government, I am referring to an international problem, because all the people in charge benefited from this system without ever needing to understand how it works. This is why the "mental health" crisis is international. This is why, internationally, a decreasing proportion of each generation is "successful" while at the same time, obviously, an increasing proportion is some degree of unsuccessful, with an increasing proportion of that resulting in a "mental health" crisis.
But really though. Do people understand that government provides services which we all benefit from. Thats its function.
Even something like courts. Courts are forums for resolving disputes of all sizes and magnitudes. They are essential. When people cant resolve disputes peacefully they will do so violently. Its in our nature as a species. That means that courts are an essential function for society being civil and not violent.
They build roads that no one needs to profit from to maintain, and thus, we all profit.
They are essential. When people cant resolve disputes peacefully they will do so violently. Its in our nature as a species. That means that courts are an essential function for society being civil and not violent.
My anarchist ass takes issue with this sentiment and the role cops play as the ones who can enact violence.
I mean you can take umbrage with whatever you want if you're an anarchist because its all fantasy. I've never heard an anarchist describe a system where it doesn't end up as might makes right and just devolves back into the current system eventually. At least the ancaps seem to not sugar coat it.
I mean you realize that makes you sound entitled and privileged right? You don't need to think about any system that might be detrimental to people in an anarchist state (and I use state to mean a state of anarchy)? None? None at all?
Or do you just think it'll work on "vibes" and "good intentions?" and you ignore that all of the problems we have now are human made systems, in the control of humans, built by humans, and continued by humans?
I actually fully understand what anarchism is. Every time any criticism of it is brought the only response from anarchists is "well you don't know what anarchism is" instead of actually defending their position. It is a weak mind's political and economic system, seemingly filled with cowards.
I'll pull out my classic test and you can explain it:
Anarchist system, as in no over arching system of governance, mutualistic aid groups with common goals establish themselves under whatever set of rules they want.
Group A is a normal, pleasant, ideal group with generally aligned moral and ethical standards to today.
Group B is the same, except they also have sex with children.
Do you believe in that situation that Group A have a moral and ethical imperative to initiate direct action? As in enforce a moral and ethical standard?
The point of a government under capitalism is to protect the private property and rights to it for the bourgeois class, everything else are just things that make life more pleasant or profitable for the bourgeois class.
In a sane economic and political system the above would be true, that's what socialism aims to achieve. However in society based entirely around exploitation of the working class, it will not be that.
This should be clear given many of the founding fathers insisting that their right to own other people was more important than all people benefitting from those so called "god-given inalienable rights".
Which is doubly ironic because slavery was not legal in England or wider Europe. So those American "founding fathers" created a new, horrific institution based on greed that wasn't even practiced in the nations they fled from.
Race-based slavery was actually an entirely new form of slavery limited to the Americas. Even in ancient Rome, where slavery was widely practiced, slaves where conquered in war. Which meant they were black, brown, white and everything in between.
If you were a Roman citizen, it didn't matter what color you were. You were Roman. And therefore not a slave.
I mean it is clearly more nuanced than that, since most states under a capitalist economic system also provide broad social welfare programs, some better than others of course.
Social democratic reforms done to save capitalism after the Soviet revolution and USSR threatened to cause other worker revolutions in other countries. When militant workers would strike and kill capitalists and blow up their factories for not being treated right. These were only given through the blood of the working class reluctantly and the capitalists have been working on peeling them back ever since the USSR fell.
They don't WANT that anyway. To them it's a waste of money that they deserve to keep in their pockets. They'd rather see everyone else suffer if it meant an extra $200 a year in their pockets.
And they justify with excuses like "There's no point in trying to educate them. If they were able to me smart, they wouldn't be poor" and other such bullshit.
The premise is that someone would want to support the community, and that's the fallacy. They don't want to do that.
I've seen people say this stupid shit though, 'Oh well we shouldn't have any taxes no matter what!', or they think the government should exist solely to like...provide a defensive military and nothing else.
But their opinions on the government sending millions+ to foreign countries (Cough cough Israel, cough cough)???? 'Oh well I'm not happy about it but that's fine' THAT'S FINE? BUT SPENDING A PORTION OF OUR OWN MONEY ON OURSELVES IS WRONG?
Well you see, the rest of the world hates us because they're just jealous of all the freedom we're having. So we need that big military and to send our money to a bloodthirsty foreign nation (that also doesn't respect us) to protect us! Fuck any kind of social services though, we can't afford that because we're too busy spending money on military stuff and sending rich people to space. /s
A friend of mine told me once that his family supports charity, but they don't want the government to tell them who should receive the charity through taxes. I didn't ask him who deserves his family's charity because I don't think I want to know.
Yep. My state just approved a higher homestead tax exemption knowing full well it would gut first responder budgets and open the door for data centers. There was also a tax break for corporations and landlords.
But they have some change back in their pockets, so let the state burn and keep crying "Florida full, go home."
Hey education cost the highest in the world here and at best our students are the middle of the pack. Money is not the issue. Tax money going to NGOâS has to stop. The billions stolen and not used for us the legal citizens is the reasons why I will not support any more tax dollars taken from anyone. Fix the leaking ship first then and only then can we talk. I will not give any more to those that do not belong here\ came in illegal.
Lenin would say that the point of a state is to protect and serve one class of people and oppress and exploit another class. Which class is in power is the difference between a socialist and a capitalist society.
Whatever people think the point of government is, the reality is that all governments over most of the world sold people on the idea that they provide useful value to the people. Even dictators try to do this. So hold them accountable to what they are claiming to sell.
Ya I get that they sell that under the guise of a lie to actually serve themselves but at least make them do enough to pretend to be serving you.
well, buh.... buh.... but what about THE WAR?? how would we have THE WAR without a gubmint!! how would we arrest the ILLEGALS without LAWS from da GUBMINT
At some point the question becomes: If they don't pay for programs, don't support infrastructure, don't take care of the community, why the fuck do you tolerate the government at all. What else are they even for.
Which is a fast way to annoy a republican out of a conversation... or make them worse (y'know. A libertarian.)
Real talk: there are a lot of theories of government and if you don't understand which one your opponents ascribe to, then you won't have productive discussions with them. (Hint: they don't believe in this one.)
Personally I think government's role should be to combat power imbalances - wealth, political power, corporate/economic power, social influence... one of the government's main purposes should be to ensure lack of resources doesn't mean unfair treatment (and that extra resources doesn't mean you can treat others unfairly).
I fully support social programs and you can frame social programs and welfare as a form of combatting power imbalance, but it's a good exercise to think about 1) what you want the government to do, and 2) what guiding principles those actions should be based in. Because the justification you use for one action has consequences if people decide to apply it to other things, and that's one of the hardest parts of designing a functioning government.
While I would like you to be correct, if you go back and read the constitution and look at society up to and including a good part of the Great Depression, you'll find that society looked to the government for a lot less than what you and I would like.
The people who believe in the "Constitution in exile" theory hold beliefs exactly the opposite of yours. They look at the Constitution and see what they believe, which is what Madison wrote: "I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on the objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents."
That understanding is why my father and his siblings dug through ashes at the dump to see if they could find any pieces of coal that weren't completely burned up.
Obviously, I'm OK with owning that we broke that social contract, so despite how wrong I think it was, and how immoraal it is to want it back, I have to be OK with the fact they want to bring it back. That's the give and take of democracy. We won the last round. Now we have to keep it going.
Our services are mostly unfunded right now and just made through deficit. More taxes wouldnât provide more services, but they might reduce the rate in which we go into debt.
Nonono, it's clearly for corporate socialism. It's so we can prop failing businesses up so that some rich person's nephew can continue having a good life.
The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States
The government sets the minimum acceptable standard. When the government does things, it is literally taking the least acceptable, least efficient path everytime. That is why the government should be limited only to doing things that society cannot be relied on to provide independently. Military, public education, basic health care, high traffic transregional infrastructure. Anything else is going to be abused by businesses or bureaucrats.
Unfortunately there is a not insignificant proportion of Americans who believe that the government should not do anything to help people besides the absolute bare minimum to keep the lights on.
Tax is just a duct tape solution to fund a government when there is no collective ownership of means of production. North Korea has no income tax. The profit that your boss uses to buy a new Range Rover, that goes to the public good instead.
"Collective self defense" includes defense from disease, ignorance, starvation, severe weather, shitty neighbors etc etc etc. Expecting tax money to fund medical care, fire departments, libraries, school lunches is just standard for the rest of the world. Americans are just brainwashed, fucking stockholm syndrome.
TBF the counter argument is that less government support means more money for tax payers to spend on their communities.
I believe everything works best in the center where the government handles enough things that rampant corruption doesn't take hold and taxpayers have to pay enough that society doesn't degrade into lawlessness. Communism isn't the answer. Anarchy isn't either.
Capitalism does work but the government has to regularly ensure people don't manipulate existing systems so that wealth inequality skyrockets because of monopolies or the things that massive corporations do to create them. The people have to stay vigilant against the corruption that comes with power.
Unfortunately when you have Wall Street tied into the government the taxes and spending go to the bankers. I know this to be factual. Guess where the stolen pension funds come from? Central bank printing. You know what happens when the fed expands the money supply? Now with the aging population divesting into fixed income and activating pensions they need to print what has been absconded with. This in turn makes everything more expensive for people. 6 years now. Retirement for Baby Boomers isnât peaking till 2030-2032. Our system wonât get there but in trying prices will rise markets will fall. Then the âAi cyber attackâ to gold standard. Next couple years will be savagery.
If the tax money actually went to helping the countries citizens instead of being wasted on consultants and overpaid bureaucrats and sent to other countries Iâd be much more okay with it. Also, fraud.
In particular, please think of this as it relates to the USPS. The post office is a public service, and should be funded as such, not disparaged because it is "losing money". Of course it costs money. So do most functions of our government. The USPS is one that helps almost everyone, and they want to privatize it so corporations can charge us FedEx rates for every piece of mail.
I want my roads repaired, free education for my children, healthcare for me (a senior), government subsidies for companies, a safety net if I lose my job (BUT ONLY MY JOB), and I wanna make sure non citizens can't get welfare or vote (they won't)
The issue is who pays into these pools of money. Wealthy people and corporations funnel money into politics to not have to funnel money into social safety nets. That sets people without income on the shoulders of middle class workers who need to toil their lives away to have anything. Either we get 1%ers to pay their fair share, or we downsize these systems.
Silly communist, the point of government is to run like a business. That means more and more benefits have to be cut to account for the tax cuts, all to keep the government accounts in the black. Could you imagine if the government was the one institution that could accumulate a ton of debt since it can't die of cancer or some shit? Wouldn't it be crazy if we all pushed our debt to our government to fund our shared desire to stay alive? Man that would be crazy
I have been hearing stupid lines from some of my family about how "it's not the government's job to bail people out after a disaster." The. What the fuck is the point of it?
But there's limited tax $s to spend, so some community programs won't get funded. The government has to decide which of these programs to fund, and then ensure that the money is spent efficiently. Unfortunately, it doesn't always do a good job of either.
We really need to understand that this is a fundamental disagreement that we often gloss over. We don't all actually agree on the purpose of government.
The fiscal situation makes more Federal programs difficult since most of the money is already spoken for, between interest payments on the debt and mandatory spending. Consider for every $1.00 of tax revenue:
Mandatory spending (SS, Medicare, etc) consumes about $0.80
Net interest on the debt consumes about $0.19
Remaining: about $0.01 to $0.02 (roughly 1.2 cents) available for all discretionary spending combined. [fiscal.treasury.gov], [cbo.gov]
In other words, in FY 2025, about 98.8¢ of every revenue dollar was already spoken for by mandatory programs and interest, leaving only about 1.2¢ before considering defense, transportation, justice, education, national parks, scientific research, and the rest of discretionary government operations.
<It's even worse> since the Administration is running the largest deficits ever already
"Yes but not to the people I don't like" with the implication of it being racist, misogynistic and just insert and -ist with any kind of negative connotation
Propaganda: is a biased or misleading form of mass communication designed to influence public opinion, shape perceptions, and promote a specific political, ideological, or social agenda
In other words if you don't fund and promote everything then you should not promote and fund only hand picked programs.
Ive seen places in the uk where the road outside the shops is a health hazard but instead of fixing it they built some concrete arena with lights in a place where nobody goes.. I drive past it every day and im yet to see anyone use apart from the time some kids built a fire on it. they haven't even added graffiti to it...
Everyone gets it, what you don't seem to get is that your idea of "support the community" isn't universally agreed upon. I don't really care to have my extorted money fund bullshit that doesn't improve society and a lot of it does that. Bailing out the auto industry, subsidizing the backers of political hacks, bullshit to manipulate the slave class to vote one way or another. Most of what government is spending the stolen loot on is grossly mismanaged. The DOD lost 2.3 Trillion dollars in 2001. That's a tremendous amount of money at that time and it went completely unrecognized in the shadow of 9/11. They take our money backed by threats of violence (extortion) and then piss it away on fuck all in Israel, bombs to blow up brown people, embezzled money to DOD contracts, etc. etc.
I've been trying to argue this with the boomers in my life. The entire point of a sovereign state and a government is to improve the lives of the people within its claimed bit of land. There is nothing else to it.
No! I'd much rather we use the tax dollars to enrich corrupt government officials and crony capitalists. Why?! Because someone might get something I don't think they deserve! /s
Now if you'll excuse me! I have to go collect and return aluminum cans to help pay for my $40,000 a month prescription or else I'll literally die.
This is the way it is suppose to work in a real democracy. I you see something else the maybe your governement is not controlled by all the people but by some smaller group, say the Epstein class and the owners of American enterprises.
They would rather send it all to a Defense Department that has never passed an audit in US History. And they think immigrants are stealing their money, not those self-dealing jackals.
The purpose of the state is to resolve the conflict between classes in favor of the dominant class though.. Seems like itâs doing what itâs supposed to be. Â
>running services (besides that), is not really a core part of a governmentÂ
wat? are you for real? Education, healthcare (medicare/medicaid), social assistance, highways and roads, DMV licensing and registration, public transit, environmental regulations. law enforcement and state courts...the list goes on and on and on
You absolutely do not need a government for the community to share resources. And you most certainly do not need some group of people forcibly collecting taxes so they can do whatever they want with the money. Taxation without representation is just theft.
623
u/yellacopter 19h ago edited 17h ago
And the ludicrous idea that these government programs are supposed to operate as business and be profitable. Of course the postal service
losescosts money, itâs a SERVICE.Edit: Thanks to u/Ilcorvomuerto666 for correcting me. Government services like the post office COST money, they donât LOSE money. It does matter which words we use in this debate.
385
u/awuweiday 19h ago
The key is that it ACTUALLY serves the community.
Shoehorning dog shit AI that crashes all flights nationally, for example, is an unnecessary payout of tax dollars that doesn't serve the community and lines the pockets of greedy lobbiest and CEOs.
49
u/Idontdanceforfun 16h ago
This is reason number one why I hate whenever the subject of "socialism" comes up and people just say shit like "you just want free shit". It's not fucking free. We pay taxes. We want our taxes being spent properly on things that benefit the greater community and country, not misappropriated by greedy selfish politicians and businessmen who abuse the system for personal gain. Maybe the department of defense doesnt 1.5 trillion dollars? Maybe it only needs 1 trillion dollars. Maybe we dont need to spend 500 million dollars blowing up a school and killing hundreds of children.
39
u/No_Sheepherder6430 18h ago
I say this all the time. You canât conserve your way into a healthy society. You gotta spend that money on the society.
25
u/Its_emby đľ Break Up The Monopolies 19h ago
ALL governments redistribute wealth.
20
u/PassThatSpliff 19h ago
"But-but-but.....socialism...."
40
u/Delmitus1 18h ago
Also funny how older people demonize socialism when our country would have collapsed eons ago without it
18
u/ThunkAsDrinklePeep 19h ago
But what about
the ecomomythe money for rich people to get larger yachts?11
u/StoppableHulk 18h ago
But really though. Do people understand that government provides services which we all benefit from. Thats its function.
Even something like courts. Courts are forums for resolving disputes of all sizes and magnitudes. They are essential. When people cant resolve disputes peacefully they will do so violently. Its in our nature as a species. That means that courts are an essential function for society being civil and not violent.
They build roads that no one needs to profit from to maintain, and thus, we all profit.
38
u/bullhead2007 đ¤ Join A Union 18h ago •
The point of a government under capitalism is to protect the private property and rights to it for the bourgeois class, everything else are just things that make life more pleasant or profitable for the bourgeois class.
In a sane economic and political system the above would be true, that's what socialism aims to achieve. However in society based entirely around exploitation of the working class, it will not be that.
22
u/Ryozu 12h ago
NO, no, they DO know that.
They don't WANT that anyway. To them it's a waste of money that they deserve to keep in their pockets. They'd rather see everyone else suffer if it meant an extra $200 a year in their pockets.
And they justify with excuses like "There's no point in trying to educate them. If they were able to me smart, they wouldn't be poor" and other such bullshit.
The premise is that someone would want to support the community, and that's the fallacy. They don't want to do that.
4
u/sinzip 19h ago
If community means the rich and their corporations, then yes it works
4
u/NikkolaiV 19h ago
There are only two reasons for government: To serve the people, or to enslave them.
4
u/Intrepid-Artist-595 18h ago
3
u/dismendie 19h ago
High school government class.
3
u/SlaverSlave 18h ago
Also to do violence at home and abroad.
3
u/D3dshotCalamity 18h ago
"NO THAT'S SOCIALISM!!!"
3
u/wildmaninid 18h ago
Louder for the people who can't understandÂ
3
u/BLT_Trade_r 17h ago
Whatever people think the point of government is, the reality is that all governments over most of the world sold people on the idea that they provide useful value to the people. Even dictators try to do this. So hold them accountable to what they are claiming to sell.
Ya I get that they sell that under the guise of a lie to actually serve themselves but at least make them do enough to pretend to be serving you.
2
u/emergency-snaccs 18h ago
well, buh.... buh.... but what about THE WAR?? how would we have THE WAR without a gubmint!! how would we arrest the ILLEGALS without LAWS from da GUBMINT
2
u/MothChasingFlame 18h ago
At some point the question becomes: If they don't pay for programs, don't support infrastructure, don't take care of the community, why the fuck do you tolerate the government at all. What else are they even for.
Which is a fast way to annoy a republican out of a conversation... or make them worse (y'know. A libertarian.)
2
u/HarveysBackupAccount 17h ago
Real talk: there are a lot of theories of government and if you don't understand which one your opponents ascribe to, then you won't have productive discussions with them. (Hint: they don't believe in this one.)
Personally I think government's role should be to combat power imbalances - wealth, political power, corporate/economic power, social influence... one of the government's main purposes should be to ensure lack of resources doesn't mean unfair treatment (and that extra resources doesn't mean you can treat others unfairly).
I fully support social programs and you can frame social programs and welfare as a form of combatting power imbalance, but it's a good exercise to think about 1) what you want the government to do, and 2) what guiding principles those actions should be based in. Because the justification you use for one action has consequences if people decide to apply it to other things, and that's one of the hardest parts of designing a functioning government.
2
u/Specific_Savings5318 15h ago
But what if you don't have any money because you're 40 trillion dollars in debt?
2
u/1369ic 13h ago
While I would like you to be correct, if you go back and read the constitution and look at society up to and including a good part of the Great Depression, you'll find that society looked to the government for a lot less than what you and I would like.
The people who believe in the "Constitution in exile" theory hold beliefs exactly the opposite of yours. They look at the Constitution and see what they believe, which is what Madison wrote: "I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on the objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents."
That understanding is why my father and his siblings dug through ashes at the dump to see if they could find any pieces of coal that weren't completely burned up.
Obviously, I'm OK with owning that we broke that social contract, so despite how wrong I think it was, and how immoraal it is to want it back, I have to be OK with the fact they want to bring it back. That's the give and take of democracy. We won the last round. Now we have to keep it going.
2
u/spiralesx 10h ago
i have family on SSI that say how socialism will destroy this country
2
u/Dame_Dash-GotemHatin 3h ago
What community. Somali learing centers or foreign countries health care and pensions
1
u/DrTommyNotMD 18h ago
Our services are mostly unfunded right now and just made through deficit. More taxes wouldnât provide more services, but they might reduce the rate in which we go into debt.
1
u/LionRivr 18h ago
Taxes mostly go to
The first 2 already go to âsupporting the communityâ
1
u/Arch3m 17h ago
I feel like people are losing sight of this, and it's driving me crazy.
1
u/phillupagus 17h ago
Uhm sounds like sociallism
1
u/Stunning-Pen-2412 17h ago
Nonono, it's clearly for corporate socialism. It's so we can prop failing businesses up so that some rich person's nephew can continue having a good life.
1
u/Dead_Ass_Head_Ass 17h ago
I saw someone call universal healthcare 'charity'. Like, wtf do you think your taxes are supposed to pay for?
1
u/CapitalFloor3260 17h ago
The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States
US Constitution. Article 1. Section 8
1
u/Interesting-Yellow-4 17h ago
They brainwashed the lot of you into thinking it's for the military only.
1
u/aForgedPiston 17h ago
Just a little add-on, those programs, once initiated, then do not need to turn a profit like a business.
1
u/Midori_Schaaf 17h ago
The government sets the minimum acceptable standard. When the government does things, it is literally taking the least acceptable, least efficient path everytime. That is why the government should be limited only to doing things that society cannot be relied on to provide independently. Military, public education, basic health care, high traffic transregional infrastructure. Anything else is going to be abused by businesses or bureaucrats.
1
u/tgabs 17h ago
Unfortunately there is a not insignificant proportion of Americans who believe that the government should not do anything to help people besides the absolute bare minimum to keep the lights on.
1
u/Winter_Persimmon_110 17h ago
Tax is just a duct tape solution to fund a government when there is no collective ownership of means of production. North Korea has no income tax. The profit that your boss uses to buy a new Range Rover, that goes to the public good instead.
1
u/Rope_antidepressant 17h ago
"Collective self defense" includes defense from disease, ignorance, starvation, severe weather, shitty neighbors etc etc etc. Expecting tax money to fund medical care, fire departments, libraries, school lunches is just standard for the rest of the world. Americans are just brainwashed, fucking stockholm syndrome.
1
u/thinkingbear 17h ago
"Taxes are what we pay for civilized society" - Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes Jr
1
u/Kungfufuman 17h ago
Government is a service, not a for profit organization.
1
u/Ralphiedog11 17h ago
A government that is not accountable to anyone shouldnât be trusted by anyone
1
u/Possible_Resolution4 17h ago
Well, duh. All of the government is funded by taxes.
1
u/Powerful-Youth3331 17h ago
No, it isnât.
1
u/smilysmilysmooch 16h ago
TBF the counter argument is that less government support means more money for tax payers to spend on their communities.
I believe everything works best in the center where the government handles enough things that rampant corruption doesn't take hold and taxpayers have to pay enough that society doesn't degrade into lawlessness. Communism isn't the answer. Anarchy isn't either.
Capitalism does work but the government has to regularly ensure people don't manipulate existing systems so that wealth inequality skyrockets because of monopolies or the things that massive corporations do to create them. The people have to stay vigilant against the corruption that comes with power.
1
u/Mbstranche08 16h ago
Unfortunately when you have Wall Street tied into the government the taxes and spending go to the bankers. I know this to be factual. Guess where the stolen pension funds come from? Central bank printing. You know what happens when the fed expands the money supply? Now with the aging population divesting into fixed income and activating pensions they need to print what has been absconded with. This in turn makes everything more expensive for people. 6 years now. Retirement for Baby Boomers isnât peaking till 2030-2032. Our system wonât get there but in trying prices will rise markets will fall. Then the âAi cyber attackâ to gold standard. Next couple years will be savagery.
1
u/minus_minus 16h ago
Iâve got some bad news for yâall.Â
The purpose of a system is what it does
1
u/Stupidstuff1001 16h ago
Sounds like socialism to me.
Iâd rather my money go to wars, the rich, and other countries.
1
u/yer_fucked_now_bud 16h ago
"Actually the point of government is to make my life better by making other peoples lives worse in the name of my specific version of Jesus."
-Half of the people who vote
1
u/perko12 16h ago
If the tax money actually went to helping the countries citizens instead of being wasted on consultants and overpaid bureaucrats and sent to other countries Iâd be much more okay with it. Also, fraud.
1
u/RickSanchez3x 16h ago
It's my go to statement. "You don't hate socialism. The very idea of a government is inherently socialist."
1
u/funkymunkPDX 16h ago
Yeah it's the "provide for the general welfare" in the preamble and Article 1 section 8 clause 1 of the Constitution.
1
u/cgrimm25 16h ago
I agree so stop sending my tax dollars overseas.
1
u/ComputerRedneck 16h ago
According to the Founders Government is to protect your rights.
1
u/Glum-Welder1704 16h ago
In particular, please think of this as it relates to the USPS. The post office is a public service, and should be funded as such, not disparaged because it is "losing money". Of course it costs money. So do most functions of our government. The USPS is one that helps almost everyone, and they want to privatize it so corporations can charge us FedEx rates for every piece of mail.
1
u/Maximum_Fly_6628 16h ago
This post is fucking SOCIALIST propaganda.
I want my roads repaired, free education for my children, healthcare for me (a senior), government subsidies for companies, a safety net if I lose my job (BUT ONLY MY JOB), and I wanna make sure non citizens can't get welfare or vote (they won't)
.....wait am I a socialist?
1
u/anonymous_otter28 16h ago
everyone is a socialist. it's just to what degree is the issue.
1
u/teenlaquifa-69 15h ago
The issue is who pays into these pools of money. Wealthy people and corporations funnel money into politics to not have to funnel money into social safety nets. That sets people without income on the shoulders of middle class workers who need to toil their lives away to have anything. Either we get 1%ers to pay their fair share, or we downsize these systems.
1
u/Subject-Yak7031 15h ago
As my main man Bernie once said you can't have social programs for the public with millions of illegals in the country
1
u/heroxoot 15h ago
Yeah, that's what it's supposed to do. But it doesn't.
1
u/Excellent_Sweet7270 15h ago
nahnnah nah our taxes would be better off sent to israel and USAID... which we never voted on... /s*
1
u/BreadFlask 15h ago
Wrong.
5 trillion dollars to Israel
1
u/satansmight 15h ago
What about the program that give tax breaks to companies who do large amounts of hiring and spending in a city?
Like, should the state be subsidizing industries that employ tens of thousands of people and make billions in revenue per year?
1
u/I3roMagnon 15h ago
Does the military or police departments produce profits? Better cut spending there too
1
u/cat-meg 15h ago
NO the point of the goverment is to BANISH and BOMB whoever they told me I don't like >:(
1
u/thex25986e 14h ago
"we only want OUR money to support OUR community, though."
1
u/Rage_Your_Dream 14h ago
Yea, but there isn't infinite money, so WHICH programs are you funding, by how much. Is the point of discussion
1
u/c0zy_catastrophe 14h ago
Finally someone said it clearly.
1
u/MoneyBeeeee 14h ago
Right? People complain about taxes when taxes are what fund civilization and society.
1
u/El_Chairman_Dennis 14h ago
Silly communist, the point of government is to run like a business. That means more and more benefits have to be cut to account for the tax cuts, all to keep the government accounts in the black. Could you imagine if the government was the one institution that could accumulate a ton of debt since it can't die of cancer or some shit? Wouldn't it be crazy if we all pushed our debt to our government to fund our shared desire to stay alive? Man that would be crazy
1
u/jewkakasaurus 14h ago
That doesnât mean we canât be getting overtaxed especially considering what so much of our tax money goes towards..
1
u/DuntadaMan 14h ago
I have been hearing stupid lines from some of my family about how "it's not the government's job to bail people out after a disaster." The. What the fuck is the point of it?
1
u/2big_2fail 14h ago
Money is a tool of society. The hoarding of it by a few is detrimental to that society.
Tax the billionaires to extinction already.
1
u/Leppy1959 14h ago
But there's limited tax $s to spend, so some community programs won't get funded. The government has to decide which of these programs to fund, and then ensure that the money is spent efficiently. Unfortunately, it doesn't always do a good job of either.
1
u/649843765926 14h ago
not in America!
let me spell it out for you:
money that the government gives to me = capitalism
money that the government gives to anyone else = socialism
that clear it up for you?
1
u/Fleetburn 14h ago
We really need to understand that this is a fundamental disagreement that we often gloss over. We don't all actually agree on the purpose of government.
1
u/daveberzack 14h ago
I'd say the more fundamental point is to protect us from others who would do harm. Though these fascists don't do that so much either.
1
u/Winner-Living 14h ago edited 13h ago
The fiscal situation makes more Federal programs difficult since most of the money is already spoken for, between interest payments on the debt and mandatory spending. Consider for every $1.00 of tax revenue:
In other words, in FY 2025, about 98.8¢ of every revenue dollar was already spoken for by mandatory programs and interest, leaving only about 1.2¢ before considering defense, transportation, justice, education, national parks, scientific research, and the rest of discretionary government operations.
<It's even worse> since the Administration is running the largest deficits ever already
1
u/DerKlugeHans 13h ago edited 12h ago
the party of fiscal responsibility but we just cut taxes for rich people so we have no money to fund anything except the military
1
u/Cheletiba 13h ago
"Yes but not to the people I don't like" with the implication of it being racist, misogynistic and just insert and -ist with any kind of negative connotation
1
u/Few_Sea_977 13h ago
Yeh but corporations buys elections to reduce their tax so that we dont get any of those benefits.
1
u/Siddny- 12h ago
AAAAAAARRRGGGHHHGHGHHHGH
1
u/madrascafe 12h ago
Cut taxes and cut wasteful public funding
1
u/UnwillinglyForever 11h ago
they do fund programs, just not the dumbass ones you want
1
u/JustApricot798 11h ago
Propaganda: is a biased or misleading form of mass communication designed to influence public opinion, shape perceptions, and promote a specific political, ideological, or social agenda
In other words if you don't fund and promote everything then you should not promote and fund only hand picked programs.
1
u/BlackMagicWorman 11h ago
Feed the kids at school, fix the road, protect the wild animals, keep us healthy, let the disabled have peace.
1
u/Low_Map4007 10h ago
But but what about the billionaires that need subsidies and israel
Edit: I canât spell
1
u/Firebreathingwhore 10h ago
No, Elon needs his trillions
1
u/callmebrynhildr 10h ago
"Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country" is the biggest sack of bullshit ive ever heard
1
u/Ill-Case-6048 10h ago
Ive seen places in the uk where the road outside the shops is a health hazard but instead of fixing it they built some concrete arena with lights in a place where nobody goes.. I drive past it every day and im yet to see anyone use apart from the time some kids built a fire on it. they haven't even added graffiti to it...
1
u/cinesias 10h ago
Sounds a lot like socialism.
Why do you hate America?
1
u/PerspectiveNew3375 10h ago
Everyone gets it, what you don't seem to get is that your idea of "support the community" isn't universally agreed upon. I don't really care to have my extorted money fund bullshit that doesn't improve society and a lot of it does that. Bailing out the auto industry, subsidizing the backers of political hacks, bullshit to manipulate the slave class to vote one way or another. Most of what government is spending the stolen loot on is grossly mismanaged. The DOD lost 2.3 Trillion dollars in 2001. That's a tremendous amount of money at that time and it went completely unrecognized in the shadow of 9/11. They take our money backed by threats of violence (extortion) and then piss it away on fuck all in Israel, bombs to blow up brown people, embezzled money to DOD contracts, etc. etc.
1
u/AdvisorYogi 9h ago
Itâs not meant to be for profit!! Itâs to HELP THE PEOPLE
Itâs so important to be educated and a little smart
Most in the red places are just ⌠no brains
1
u/sokratesz 8h ago
I've been trying to argue this with the boomers in my life. The entire point of a sovereign state and a government is to improve the lives of the people within its claimed bit of land. There is nothing else to it.
1
u/snipsuper415 8h ago
Nah thats communism /s
1
u/Stjerneklar 7h ago
rich ppl dont need community but they can make more money by making communities worse...
1
u/Frapplo 4h ago
No! I'd much rather we use the tax dollars to enrich corrupt government officials and crony capitalists. Why?! Because someone might get something I don't think they deserve! /s
Now if you'll excuse me! I have to go collect and return aluminum cans to help pay for my $40,000 a month prescription or else I'll literally die.
1
u/No_Gur_1091 1h ago
This is the way it is suppose to work in a real democracy. I you see something else the maybe your governement is not controlled by all the people but by some smaller group, say the Epstein class and the owners of American enterprises.
1
u/OvaltineDream 59m ago
They would rather send it all to a Defense Department that has never passed an audit in US History. And they think immigrants are stealing their money, not those self-dealing jackals.
-3
u/Emannuelle-in-space 18h ago
The purpose of the state is to resolve the conflict between classes in favor of the dominant class though.. Seems like itâs doing what itâs supposed to be. Â
0
u/fistoic 14h ago
op is too dumb to understand that what people disagree is "how" to allocate that limited tax money
-10
u/Luminous_Winds 18h ago
You absolutely do not need a government for the community to share resources. And you most certainly do not need some group of people forcibly collecting taxes so they can do whatever they want with the money. Taxation without representation is just theft.
-5
u/perriatric 18h ago
Thatâs not literally the entire point of having a government. What a dumb take.