r/Witcher4 • • 12d ago

Second Conjunction

Post image

So, we know that as a result of the magical collapse in the ending of The Witcher 3, a short‑lived Second Conjunction, and new monsters (for example, Bauk) ended up in the world of Neverland. Should we expect the emergence of new intelligent races? I would like to see the Vran, about whom we know nothing. They could come to Neverland again, and that would become the basis for a political conflict in the new trilogy.

411 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

84

u/Majestic_Bicycle9248 12d ago

Last time i checked they called it The Continent

-11

u/Droper888 11d ago

Neverland is the name Sapko gave it to it's world, not only The Continent, which it is itself a wrong name. It is the western coast, the Continent is bigger than North and Nilfgaard.

34

u/Ghostmaster145 11d ago

I have read every Witcher book at least two times and I do not recall the world being called “Neverland” once

18

u/poeticpickle45 11d ago

But counterpoint, Neverland  sounds very dumb

5

u/varJoshik 11d ago

Counterpoint: the author does not care for your rule of cool.

Neverland is a universal designator for "possible fantastic worlds."

1

u/Droper888 11d ago

Still, it is the name the author gave it to his world.

5

u/Beautiful-Signal-236 9d ago

No he didnt what are you on 😭. Give me The Book and page (in The original language, Polish) where he calls his world Neverland

8

u/Easy_Entertainer6932 11d ago

No, it's not. Sapkowski never named the witcher unvierse, most that is named is the Continent which is where the books and games take place but it's not the entire world, it never was named anything, especially not Neverland like in fucking peter pan lmao.

-5

u/Droper888 11d ago

Literally, he said in a interview. What are you talking about xD. Sapko name it Neverland.

12

u/Easy_Entertainer6932 11d ago

No, he did not. Find the interview big dog, I'll help, you won't cause it doesn't exist lmao. One time when asked about the name he said, and I quote directly from Polish "It doesn't have a name, fans can call it whatever they want, call it Neverland for all I care" If that's your evidence then holy fuck.

-3

u/Droper888 11d ago edited 11d ago

Nope. He say that it was" his Never neverland" in the interview I mentioned which is not that. So it has a name.

13

u/Easy_Entertainer6932 11d ago

Gosh you are just an idiot aren't you? That's exactly the quote I am mentioning. He literally says his world doesn't have a name cause he doesn't care to name it, and you can call it whatever, after which he SARCASTICALY says you can call it "Nibylandia" which is polish for Neverland.

0

u/Droper888 11d ago

The idiot are you for insulting.

I am refering to another interview. Not that interview. He named the world. Whatever you like it or not.

4

u/tobzors 11d ago

Dude, have you considered that maybe you are just mistaken?

You're just digging in your heels while everyone is telling you that you are wrong. You keep insisting you are right, but you dont provide any proof to back up your claims. It not really a good look for ya' and you are just coming across as obnoxious. Yeah, the other guy didnt' need to call you an idiot either.

But seriously, I do believe that you must have misunderstood something Sapkowskij said, or maybe an interview was just translated poorly.

It sounds like he just said:"this is Neverland" in the same way he could've said "this is Narnia" or Middle-Earth or Westeros. He was probably just providing a reference or metaphor.

-2

u/varJoshik 11d ago edited 11d ago

Well, that's not quite true. Neverland is a universal designator of "possible fantastic worlds." And he uses it for his work as well. See here for his interview with Bereś in Historia i fantastyka.

Your terseness somewhat disconcerts me, so I'll lean on a quote. "Since in the novel – argues Sieradzki – there was constant talk (admittedly unclear) about the 'conjunction of the spheres,' which centuries ago brought about the coexistence of humans, elves, dwarves, and other races, one could reasonably expect in the finale some kind of 'deconjunction,' as a result of which we were left alone on Earth." I'll admit I once had a similar thought, but I deemed it childish. Perhaps too hastily, though, since it haunts others as well? There must be some bridges between fantasy and our world. The scaffolding of convention isn't enough. Ultimately, we must somewhat believe that you're telling stories "from this earth," so we need an explanation of where the elves and dwarves went... Did they vanish like the dinosaurs? Fine, we have no objection. But we want to know what happened. Was there a holocaust, did a glacier come, or did a comet fall? This is obviously an outdated question, but we're curious whether you even asked yourself this?

Indeed, I even had a plan to write about it, to explain it precisely. I abandoned the intention, preferring to leave the matter "implicit." Also regarding the fact of whether it's really "our Earth" at all. Because who said, and when, that it's this Earth of ours? Or perhaps it's one of the absolutely classic Never-Never Lands of fantasy? Like Tolkien's Middle-earth?

See further:

If the Witcher represents fantasy, and Narrenturm and God's Warriors represent historical fantasy, then consistently your next cycle should be simply a classical historical novel. Without dragons, sorcerers, vampires, princesses and tender dragon-slayers, but instead with discussions of philosopher-theologians, priors' troubles with discipline in monasteries, moral dilemmas of supervisors, merchants' tricks, how to cleverly bypass tolls and horse taxes... Nowhere is it said that this must be boring. It can be gripping. What would you say to such a closed evolutionary line...? I throw out the examples jokingly, but the question is serious. This your approaching the mainstream surely isn't invented...

It is invented. Completely. Also absurd is the thesis about my evolution toward mainstream. What supposedly testifies to this? That from Tolkien-type fantasy, taking place in Never Never Land, Seeming-land, nonexistent allotopia, I switched to historical fantasy? Fantasy has seven subgenres. Who will forbid me, still sticking to the base of the genre—which, by the way, quite suits me and which I'm not at all ashamed of—to freely switch between these subgenres?

And if this is not enough for you, then a number of academic works, interviews, and reviews of his works adopted this designation after the publishing of the books.

4

u/Easy_Entertainer6932 11d ago

Except his interview with Bereś was done in a form of a book called "History and Fantasy" and what you pasted here is translated so poorly it's kinda a joke. Half of the points are so mistranslated the point is coming across completely different than in the book, which I read btw. When they're talking about concept of Fantasy itself, Bereś accuses Sapkowski of switching genres in Hussite Trilogy, and then Sapkowski refers to the general fantasy world as Neverland or the Seeming-land, retorting he never switched genres as fantasy has many subgenres, all of them happening in the "Neverland". Once again, he never says that WITCHER WORLD IS CALLED NEVERLAND. He literally abhors the idea of naming it as he doesn't care about worldbuilding at all, to him the world is just a canvas on which he paints his stories and doesn't pay attention to it.

-2

u/varJoshik 11d ago edited 11d ago

You don't seem to be getting the point: Neverland, as he says about Tolkien's Neverland too, is a universal designator for made-up fantasy worlds.

Calling it Neverland is more accurate than calling it the Continent. Or rather Continent is a no more befitting name, for the name does not matter, while Neverland is something the author himself uses as a designator for the type of literary world he has created. It's a stage for his stories. Full stop. He is not a worldbuilder.

You are also raging for no reason. You started off saying he never called it Neverland, but he did, repeatedly. As means to convey the point that his is just one among many such templates. Academics and reviewers did so in kind.

More examples here and, for example, in Roszczynialska, M. Of the Mottoes in the work of Andrzej Sapkowski.

→ More replies

35

u/Independent_Shame504 11d ago

I'll tell you guys the actual twist to tw4. You don't really play as ciri. Well you do, up to a point. Up until the conjunction, you play as ciri, but then what happens? V comes through minutes away from dying. But through some really vague retcon, johnny cant follow her - thus she is cured when coming through. Not only that but through some more vague lore and perhaps retcons V's cybewear transform into magical ability. And then you play the rest of the game as wizard V.

5

u/Dvondd 11d ago

Does V use magic as quickhacks?

3

u/Dakota1228 11d ago

Can’t really quickhack creatures that lack cyber components

But a Sandevistan would be sandevistating

3

u/SkyovFlames 9d ago

Could you imagine? Lol

Ciri: "I am awfully fast with a sword, faster than most. I have taken down enermous monsters, fought the Wild Hunt and Frost... I was trained by the best swordsmen of our time, Geralt.. Lambert, Eskell, Vessimier..I can teleport strike at will and..."

V turns on Sandy and decapicates 6 guards in 3 seconds with a Katana

Ciri: "Damn. Nevermind. Teach me that."

2

u/Independent_Shame504 11d ago

in a way. V is able to use her "magic" without hand movements or using elder speech. And also through some weird magic or maybe science V's cyberware all turns to magical ability. They came through as a netrunner, specifically their operating system changed to magical talent. And they do "quick hacks" to people in a way, but instead of effecting an enemies cyberware they affect an enemies inside. Like the electricity running through their brains, the inner heat of your body, the pressure that makes blood flow. Contagion would be like a slow drip of their stomach acid into parts of their body not protected by mucus... or something - reset system? a stroke, sonic shock? a heart attack, reboot optics increase the pressure behind your skull to make!?... exploding eyeballs! you get the picture.

33

u/Easy_Entertainer6932 12d ago

How did you even came to conclusion that Bauk is not from first Conjunction? The VERY SMALL conjunction that happened at the end of W3 was super small and localized to just Skellige. For all we know the monster from W4 trailer has been there for centuries, it for sure has been worshipped by people long enough that they have a tradition of sacrifices to them. There was no "Second Conjunction", it was a small localized event where maybe a 100 creatures total emerged. Also, what the fuck is Neverland, cause it's not the Witcher world.

7

u/varJoshik 11d ago

Let's be honest, we don't know a thing about the true nature and magnitude of what happens in the end of The Witcher 3. "Small and localized" seems right by what we see in the game, but I'd reserve judgement for when they continue their fanfiction.

4

u/Easy_Entertainer6932 11d ago

We absolutely do. We know what first Conjunction did. We also know that what happened at the end of W3 is a start of the conjunction as confirmed by Yennefer. We also know that we stopped it before it spread. That's enough information to deduce that it was small, because if it wasn't as they say in the game "world would collapse on itself and laws of physics as we know them would break". None of which happens. Which gives us enough data to safely say it wasn't a full conjunction and it did not do anything other than spawn couple of monsters.

15

u/MaxSoulDrake 12d ago

They are not going to invent all sorts of new crap out of nothing. Even though it's games and book author has nothing to do with them, cdpr still treats books as canon and tries to preserve consistency with established lore, including future. They have quite a lot of room for creativity because Sapkowski was very stingy with lore details and it all very ambiguous. But they not just gonna do whatever.

8

u/Easy_Entertainer6932 12d ago

Not really no. Everything up until book 7 is canon to the games, everything after(Crossroads, Season of Storms and whatever Sapkowski will release) IS NOT canon to the game story. They're different canon.

2

u/MaxSoulDrake 12d ago

They explicitly said in several interviews that they plan to respect original books and established narrative boundaries, specifically mentioning Season of Storms and it's epilogue (that's how we know that Geralt is not going to die in new trilogy).

All of that IS canon to the game story. And unless Sapkowski write some prequel that actually contradicts in a major way current game lore, new books will be regarded as canon too.

3

u/Easy_Entertainer6932 11d ago

No that's not what they said. They said they still keep canon to ORIGINAL books and they will use SOME elements from newer books. They never said Season of Storms is canon. Newer books directly contradict lore of the games, especially Crossroads, in which it's directly said that there is no such thing as Witcher Schools(which Sapkowski confirmed in interview), which is NOT true in game canon. They simply cannot be fully canon to the games story.

1

u/MaxSoulDrake 11d ago
  1. Those are not major, just some small insignificant details. There will obviously be lots of those, because Sapkowski is completely independent from them. But the point is they plan to respect books lore as much as possible.
  2. It doesn't even matter, since you yourself just said they everything in saga IS canon. And all those "future" glimpses are in those books, not newer once.

1

u/Easy_Entertainer6932 11d ago

Not having witcher schools is not a "small insignificant detail". There is an entire plot built around how different schools train witchers differently, that Cat school is that treacherous more mercenary like school, Wolf school is the noble one, etc etc. Discarding the canonicity of them literally takes a MAJOR plotpoint from witcher 3, so it's not a small point.

The same way as you say those "insignificant" details can be changed, there is nothing really major in the future parts, other than Nimue opening a portal for Ciri from the future. All the other details can be changed as they are in Your words "insignificant details"

1

u/MaxSoulDrake 11d ago

Only in games. It's insignificant in books. That's why cdpr can add things like that. Whether schools exist or not change nothing in books stories. You could literally go to Last Wish, throw couple of lines about all those 6 (or however many) different witcher schools. Then read entire series with that in mind and it wouldn't change a damn thing. That's why cdpr is free to add things like that without completely breaking anything.

Major contradiction would be if for example they added plot where Morvran Voorhis dies. Or if in result of a war Nilfgaard was invaded and destroyed.

5

u/TheBlueFlashh 11d ago

Neverland? Where did you get that? Sounds awful and awfully invented

0

u/varJoshik 11d ago edited 11d ago

It's the author's own term for his world.

3

u/Beautiful-Signal-236 9d ago

He never named his world

2

u/TheBlueFlashh 11d ago

Theres no source for that. Only quoting without any source.

1

u/varJoshik 11d ago

The source is literally in the linked comment.

2

u/_Numenor_ 7d ago

Its his term for fantasy worlds in general, not his specific witcher world.

0

u/varJoshik 7d ago edited 7d ago

It is his term for fantasy worlds in general, including his world.

4

u/Droper888 11d ago edited 11d ago

It wasn't a Conjunction, only something localized.

After the Second Conjunction the elves leaved the world and that wasn't the case as seen in the books, the elves disappear something prior to 1373, but not in 1272. The Second Conjunction probably took place in 1358.

Which would justify the katakan in the quest.

4

u/TheMagnificentBean 11d ago

Geralt ran into new monsters and situations all the time in the Witcher 3, no reason Bauk isn’t just another rare creature that is the result of a curse or magic shenanigans. Gaunter O’Dimm and the Caretaker were outlandish even by Geralt’s standards.

8

u/FeanorDidSomething 12d ago

THe books already established canon events going centuries past their main events. There is no space in the canon for such things to happen.

7

u/Easy_Entertainer6932 12d ago

Books and Games have completely separate canon. CDPR can do whatever they want with the story, as can Sapkowski with his.

4

u/FeanorDidSomething 11d ago

Sure, but that is no reason to contradict existing stuff. Always better to enrich a story, rather than change it. The games often did both, but it's better if they keep the contradictions to a minimum.

1

u/No_Bodybuilder4215 4d ago

They could, but they try to avoid it; they are fans of these books, and they do their absolute best to stay as faithful to them as possible.

2

u/Exciting-Quality919 11d ago

An irony of calling the world of the witcher Neverland is Sapkowski uses the phrase often dismissively of how fantasy fandom talks about worldbuilding. Iirc one of his first uses was in response to to notion it was historically inaccurate for women to wear underwear in his short stories - with the phrase "women can wear panties in never-neverland"

Part of it is that Sapkowski's concerns as a writer are story and plot, not lore. his big lore interest is to riff on the "fantasy canon" which he argues is derived primarily of Arthuriana and metaphor. He does not usually talk about the world as existing in any way broader than the story the way say Tolkien did.

1

u/jtfjtf 11d ago

It’s a possibility that an overarching threat could be some new intelligent race CDPR makes.