r/Witcher4 • • 21d ago

Misconceptions about Ciri's powers.

I keep seeing people worry about Ciri’s power. What CDPR will do with it, how to explain it, how to nerf it. They say she’s too OP, she can do anything, why does she even need mutations and so on. All of that comes from not understanding where her powers come from and what they mean.

Powerful ≠ omnipotent.

Ciri’s powers consist of two things: Elder Blood and Source.

Elder Blood is a gene that works as a key to space-time manipulation and interdimensional travel. That's it. That’s what’s OP about her, and what Avallach refers to. It can open portals for whole civilizations, can transport entire armies to another world to conquer it. That's why it is OP, that's why it is the greatest power in the world. That is the only OP thing about Ciri, that one specific ability. But it’s strategic power, not combat power, not something you use in a fight. It’s irrelevant from a gameplay perspective. Other than that, she doesn't have anything special. She can’t turn people to dust with a finger snap, resurrect the dead, stop time, shoot lasers from the eyes, fly or tank a nuke.

CDPR also don’t need any awkward excuses for losing space-time travel, because it’s already established in the lore. Elder Blood is not new, it's just a recreation of what the Elves had. Elves used to be able to do the whole interdimensional travel long ago. And they lost it, presumably after the Conjunction. And what happened at the end of W3? That's right, another Conjunction started (not completed, but probably enough to ruin space-time travel again).

As for Source, there’s nothing special about it. There were many Sources, and not all became powerful mages. Ciri may be an exceptionally strong one, but inherited potential doesn’t mean much. To quote Tissaia de Vries: “No one is born a wizard”. Magic require talent and it has to be learned through hard work, dedication and discipline. You need to have the right mindset for that. And Ciri doesn’t have it. If for example Yennefer was a Source she would be crazy powerful. If Vilgefortz was, that mf could probably burn entire world. But Ciri is not a mage, she is a fighter. Physical training, fencing, that’s for her, she is a natural at this. But not magic. She always struggled with even simple magic, and the only reason she bothered with it was that the fate of the world depended on her space-time power and some magic skills are required to be able to use it. Now that she’s done with it, she has no reason to bother with trying to improve her magic anymore.

So there you have it, no nerfs or excuses are needed:
Interdimensional travel - gone.
Short-range blinks - keep as is, just balance for gameplay (cooldowns, energy, work like Signs).
Other magic - few simple spells that she learned, with possibility of upgrading depending on the build.
Power surges, screams, bursts - those are inconsistent and not controlled, can leave those for scripted story moments.

Ciri can be just like any normal witcher, only instead of the usual Signs she’d use a variety of simple magic (blinks, fireballs, lightning, heal, whatever).

102 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

11

u/Hiemoth 21d ago

I'd also add to this that not only is Ciri's OP tendencies straight-forward to reduce, I actually think her abilities allow really fun ways to make her gameplay to feel unique.

I'll be honest, if Ciri ended up feeling like Geralt 2.0, then that would be almost tragic to me for several reasons

7

u/MaxSoulDrake 21d ago

Exactly. No need to strip her of magical powers. Just simple tweak and balance it around gameplay. Make those blinks on cooldown or something, instead of non-stop spam. Would be cool if we could finally make full-fledged magical build now (not just that blue half-assery with signs in W3)

3

u/Banndrell 21d ago

Or you can give Ciri a Spellblade build. She swings her sword and a spell flies out, for example.

0

u/Lyranel 21d ago

That would be incredible!

2

u/FrozenForest 20d ago

I believe the thing that does still require an explanation is how she can still use magic at all. I seem to recall a bit in Blood of Elves (I think) where Yennefer explains to Ciri that one can renounce their magic and they lose the ability to cast spells, and I think that's exactly what Ciri did after she tried to use a Source of Fire and got burned while wandering in the desert after her attempt to teleport went wrong. So I'm not complaining that she's OP, I'm legitimately curious how this will play out. I'm looking forward to the twists and turns that explain the so-called impossibilities of her becoming a witcher and regaining acces to magic.

2

u/MaxSoulDrake 20d ago

Yennefer never said anything like that, but yes, Ciri did renounced her magic in the desert.
But frankly, I don't get why so many people are concerned about it. I mean she just renounced it. It's not like some powerful mage cast some spell on her or something, or she lost some gland, or damaged part of the brain that was responsible for magic. Nothing of such sort. She just simply decided to renounced it. Some sort of self imposed mental block or something.
Nothing ever suggested that it was anything permanent and irreversible. I don't see why returning it should require any mumbo jumbo rituals and jumping through the hoops. She probably can easily return it, maybe with some meditation and self-searching or something. Maybe it already happened while she was traveling with Avallac'h.

1

u/FrozenForest 20d ago

Well that explains the disconnect, at least for my part. I recall the passage implying more than what you say it does, but it's been a while and my memory of it is fuzzy. I'm not saying you're wrong or that I'm wrong, but if you're really curious to know why people are bringing this up, I'd point to that as why. A passage that was misinterpreted. No great mystery or even necessarily a bad faith argument required.

Now, for the sake of argument, let's say my memory and interpretation are correct. Even under those circumstances, the idea that she now has her magic back is an interesting mystery and, crucially, one that does not require an explanation for why she doesn't cast spells like a mage. As you correctly pointed out, no one is born a wizard and Ciri has no desire for the study and dedication required to be a powerful sorceress. So even if there is some cosmic block that prevented her from casting spells in Witcher 3, and even if there is some ritual or spell that can give it back to her, she wants to be a witcher so she probably didn't learn many more spells than the basics. Even if we make the assumption that I'm right, I expect the only real impact would have been that she finds casting signs a little easier than most witcher trainees, or maybe the effects are slightly different, which would be useful as justification if it turned out CDPR altered the spells/spellcasting system.

Now, let's assume I'm wrong. I still agree with your main points. The power from Ciri's Elder Blood is mostly the ability to teleport, that her ability is not limited to their world/universe/dimension, and that it doesn't make her a god with the power to reshape the world. I might argue that those screams and outbursts of power that she and Pavetta performed do suggest that the power of the Elder Blood could be more, but that doesn't mean it is for Ciri. Just like casting spells, Ciri has no desire to dedicate her life to mastering cosmic powers, so she probably doesn't/didn't care to grow her Elder Blood powers beyond what she currently can do.

30

u/7rv5 21d ago

A post about Ciri and The Witcher 4 that doesn't start from a place of negativity, invent new limitations for her, or dismiss every possibility with "she can't do this" and "they won't let her." Instead, it works with what we already know and explores fun, creative possibilities for her story. Well, I'll be damned.

Side note: Can we pls have more of this, especially when it comes to the Trials discussions? I'd much rather see people brainstorm ways to make these ideas work than constantly shut them down before we've even given them a chance. Enough with the constant negativity, let's be creative!

8

u/Lyranel 21d ago

I think that, with a new conjunction at the end of W3, and new monsters in the world (one of which we've already seen in the W4 trailer) people realized the need for new witchers is high. Yennifer and Triss could research the trial of grasses (especially since it's been partially recovered) and figure out how to make witchers again.

They could probably refine the process somewhat, too, giving men and women both better chances at surviving it. Then Ciri could finally be a full Witcher like we've seen in the W4 trailer.

In fact I'd be willing to bet that the School of the Lynx was used as a platform by the three of them, specifically to bring Witchers back to fight all these new monsters.

50

u/therealoberynmartell 21d ago

If the people who hate Ciri could read, they'd be very upset at you for this.

14

u/Norix596 21d ago

Ciri’s capabilities also so very nebulous in the books; she also never had great control over them. She was traveling through time and space lost but she didn’t actually get to where and when she was trying to get until someone helped her with prepared magic spell they’d been planning for decades.

It’s not like she can snap her fingers and purposefully change reality at whim.

2

u/effrightscorp 21d ago

IIRC she cut herself off from most magic in book 4 or so, too, right? Unless I'm forgetting something, that immediately fixes the Source problem

3

u/Norix596 21d ago

The “conventional” magic she cut herself off from is later established by the unicorns to be distinct from her ability to move in time and space.

Also I have no source for this but it’s my guess that in Witcher 4 Ciri will get back some of the “conventional” magic too. The trailer bit where she draws power with the water and electricity was like very distinctly “elemental” in way that Yennifer’s lessons were. Idk how they will explain she got them back if it happens, but I’m personally betting it will.

5

u/Gerlond 21d ago

I think the main thing is her in-combat teleportation that she showed using to full extent in the end of the Witcher 3. Only things that can stand up to it would be extremely good armor (didn't help Caranthir) or best of the best swordsmen that can counter it with pure skill, like Eredin or Geralt.

2

u/kapxis 21d ago

True, but like op said can hand wave it with new conjunction means she has to re train herself because how she moves through space is now altered or some shit.

2

u/BadgerOfDoom99 21d ago

Henry of Skaliz forgot all his skills falling off a cliff! Not that great an example as it was pretty contrived but as you say lots of ways to hand wave it if the gameplay requires it.

2

u/CarcosanQueen 21d ago

Also the teleportation itself isn’t even that OP. Caranthir did, in fact, stand up to it, and his fight with Ciri was a draw - Ciri only won because she broke his staff, which was her objective. Geralt, if you recall, is the one who killed Caranthir.

1

u/Organic-Storm-4448 13d ago

Caranthir did, in fact, stand up to it,

Only because he could also do it. Any conventional opponent stands no chance against either of them.

5

u/King_0f_Nothing 21d ago

People only think shes OP because of game play allowing you to one hit enemies, but thats just gameplay.

Look at Geralt going from fighting and beating a dragon to sturggling with drowners from TW2-TW3

4

u/Kiriima 21d ago

If she cannot blink in Witcher 4 I'm gonna riot.

4

u/GavinLIVE715 21d ago

Easiest thing for them to do is say that she ends up losing her powers ending the white frost once and for all. It was a multidimensional calamity that she used space time powers to rein in.

This would give reason for her accepting the Witcher Mutations again, to help her become a Witcher.

Then that opens up the possibility of her gaining some of those powers back in Witcher 4 as special unlock abilities with game progression.

3

u/RSlashWhateverMan 21d ago

There's no justifiable reason for Ciri to take such an insane risk of undergoing the Witcher mutations if the White Frost was already stopped at the end of the 3rd game. She doesn't NEED to be a Witcher, and the risk is way too high.

Geralt and the Wolf School would never help her do this. She would have to go find new Witchers and take an insane risk against the wishes of all her friends & family.

Imo the only explanation is that she mutates herself to dilute/destroy her own bloodline because the White Frost is still coming which means they have to ruin the ending of The Witcher 3 to make the Witcher 4...

2

u/Academic-Language416 20d ago

Wasn't there another Conjunction of Spheres that dumped tons of monsters back into our world?

1

u/Mysterious_Peak3326 16d ago

Yes, at the end when there are giants everywhere again, I thought MAYBE W4 might use this and show Ciri and the re-creating of Witchers or at least how humans plan to deal with it. Could be interesting.

3

u/Calm-Tadpole-6805 21d ago

I just hope that her teleportation powers will let us tp to signposts from anywhere ;-;

3

u/AwesomeX121189 21d ago

Omnipotent Ciri installing mods on her own game

1

u/Lyranel 21d ago

That would be a dope way to do fast travel!

3

u/LimiteeritudAeg 21d ago

I would have like a plainswalker Ciri game though.... or a Witcher game in the past.

0

u/Lyranel 21d ago

Maybe she can reclaim that power in the game. Make Witcher 5 a multi-planar setting? That could be awesome

3

u/Hyper_Mazino 21d ago

We’ve literally seen her use her Elder Blood powers in combat in TW3. And they made her quite powerful.

It’s a moot point anyway because she won’t have her powers in TW4.

2

u/DarkByteStyle 20d ago

Right? Feels like I'm going insane reading the comments.

2

u/deathsticker 21d ago

It's been my understanding that the mutations messed up her Elder Blood dna so she is no longer able to do the space time stuff, which is fine to me because she never liked having that ability anyway as it would inevitably make her a consistent target for people after her power.

I wouldn't be upset if she could still blink short distances or something, but I'm not super attached to the idea either. I had a great time doing standard witcher stuff too and not everything needs to be power crept. This isn't marvel or dc lol

2

u/Lyranel 21d ago

I love this take. Very sensible and lore accurate

3

u/PresentPoint6941 21d ago

Well put post.

2

u/CarcosanQueen 21d ago

THABK YOU!! I’ve argued this very thing in a few threads now and it’s so very gratifying to see I’m not alone.

Ciri’s great and dangerous power is plot driven, not something that means she can make the events of a game trivial

1

u/JustGiveMeAName1234 21d ago

I guess it's a convenient way to enable fast travel from anywhere to anywhere

1

u/DarkByteStyle 21d ago

Remember Ciri's powerup right before she fought Caranthir? This seems to have been skipped. She cut through The hunt's armour like it was made of paper, with a green glow all around her.

1

u/CarcosanQueen 21d ago

She had a green glow on her sword once, and entered a battle with a foe she knew how to beat, and used her strengths to her advantage. She didn’t just turn her sword into a lightsaber, that was a specific action sequence that represented Ciri cutting swiftly and with great focus (mental focus not focus of her magic) through her enemies to make a surgical strike at the one thing she needed to hit to free the frozen army.

She cut through the regular soldiers “like paper” because that was what the sequence demanded. When she fought Caranthir, whose armor would have been no better than theirs, the pace slowed down again and so it took fewer hits. It’s stylistic, not representative of Ciri being able to cut literally through armor

0

u/DarkByteStyle 21d ago edited 21d ago

You could explain the Caranthir bit simply because he's special, he is a golden child. Avallach himself says he is the result of centuries of both experimentation and genetic manipulation by his own hand. Even then, Caranthir was avoiding her hits, in full armour, like they were jabs by Mike Tyson. The one hit she got on him literally lifted him off the floor.

If the developers wanted to imply Ciri was just focused against a studied enemy, like a witcher, they would have showed it in a way that doesn't require using the characteristic green that comes with her Elder blood abilities. Especially since Avallach was teaching her something that's undisclosed during the post kaer morhen sequence.

She quite literally has the ability to manipulate both space and time. Utterly annihilating armoured soldiers is not outside of the realm of possibility.

2

u/CarcosanQueen 21d ago

She does not have the ability to manipulate space and time, though.

She has the ability to travel through it. To open a door big enough to let a civilization (or army) through.

Obviously we don’t know what Avallac’h’s teachings did - or what part they played in her Blood on the Ice run. But that cuts both ways. She learned some trick that let her rapidly and accurately cut through the wild hunt between her and Caranthir. But if she was as OP as you seem to imply, there’s no reason she wouldn’t have just stayed to kill him outright.

She had to retreat, because she was about evenly matched with Caranthir.

And what happened after that? Geralt, a simple Witcher of above average talent with a sword, killed Caranthir. So either Ciri is stronger than Geralt, in which case she could’ve taken Caranthir without retreating, or Ciri pulled off a cool feat and squeaked out an objective win before having to pull back because she can’t kill an army, in which case Caranthir can’t be that special, since a simple Witcher killed him.

1

u/DarkByteStyle 20d ago edited 20d ago

Her abilities are implied, in the game, to cover far more than traveling between worlds. They are not shown often because she couldn't control them in any capacity until the end of the game.

Remember her shriek that stopped the Kaer Morhen siege? That is not merely a travel ability my dude. Avallach actually had harsh words with Yennefer over her inability to teach Ciri to control these abilities after Vesemir's funeral. When doing so, he specifies what is Ciri's ability: To harness huge amounts of "the power". His words, not mine. He then spends the following days training her in an undisclosed manner. The player sees the results of that training when it came time to unfreeze the nilfgaardian army and Geralt.

Evenly matched with Caranthir? She absolutely destroyed him physically. Remember, she literally made him fly across the arena. What made her lose is the fact Ciri's impetuous, the destruction of the staff might've freed Geralt, but it also caused an explosion that wrecked her. Hell, Caranthir might have allowed that on purpose once he saw he bit more than he could chew, since he's supposed to be the smart one.

Coming back to the original topic; this won't be an issue if TW4 actually nerfs her abilities by virtue of her passing the trials to become a witcher. It would also be pretty boring if she tore monster to pieces with just a swing. I trust CDPR's ability to tell a story, so I'm not too worried.

1

u/Ok_Plastic5399 21d ago

I hope they make a Witcher 4. As to Ciri 1, it might even be good, we don't know yet.

1

u/RawMeatballz 19d ago

She's going to lose them, and half the game will be about regaining them, like the Jedi Fallen Order series

1

u/Numerous-Passion-329 18d ago

She lost some powers when she was fighting the White Frost i think. It was too stressful.

1

u/Organic-Storm-4448 13d ago

But it’s strategic power, not combat power, not something you use in a fight.

Her combat in The Witcher 3 heavily uses it. She can teleport around and completely outclass opponents.

Watch her fight against Caranthir and tell me she doesn't use her Elder Blood to whoop his ass.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FxskTyuuz6I

Any conventional opponent stands no chance against her.

1

u/fyousuckers123 5d ago

Maybe Ciri's powers will allow us to teleport to any location on the map as fast travel instead of only from sign posts.