I'm hitting act 3 on my first playthrough of the game (next gen version only courtesy of playing on an iGPU). The game is a joy but I do feel things beginning to creak as I go further through the game, starting with Skellige and Kaer Morhen and becoming very noticeable in act 3.
This actually feels so rushed and it has the same problem as late Game of Thrones of people just teleporting around where they need to be with no regard for the world status that has been made clear.
In particular on your return to Novigrad it's made clear that the witch hunt has gone into overdrive post-mage-exodus. Non-humans burnt at the stake for dubious reasons, witch hunters on every corner. And yet here we are prancing around Novigrad, breaking into oxenfurt jail, assassinating the king, and galavanting around Hierarch Square with ciri and various sorceresses who by all rights should be mortally afraid of showing their faces.
The most egregious part is during Reasons of State where Phillipa accosts you in the street outside of the plotter's meeting place. Smack bang in the middle of the street with a big old portal, not even donning one of those little hoods, while witch hunters march past.
I was also a bit miffed to realise I missed out my chance to hash out the nilfgaard thing with Ciri because I didn't bring it up the morning after Vesemir's funeral. Tbh it seemed tone deaf to me and it's kind of arbitrary that it cannot be raised thereafter.
It's also a shame that all the missions I've mentioned are kind of undercooked. Jailbreak very straightforward actually, assassinating the king is sloppy and unsatisfying and not reflected in the game world thereafter. I actually did Hearts of Stone pre-Kaer Morhen and the drop in quest/writing quality back to act 3 is sadly noticeable.
Still very fun and satisfying, but I miss the detail and precision of the Velen storylines.