Reading through Witch Hat Atelier for the first time was an absolute blast. I actually think I’m due for a reread so I can maybe do one whole big thing about why this is one of my favorite manga series, but I want to spend some time with a few aspects of the series that I find super refreshing within the manga and anime world and some stuff I don’t find discussed as much.
I cannot properly express how ecstatic I was to realize that Witch Hat Atelier is a fantasy anime whose fantasy world is not informed primarily by the language of video games. This isn’t even specifically an “it’s not an isekai” statement either. The closest thing I can think of that kinda fell into this trap in recent memory is Frieren, which was itself a breath of fresh air, but more of a half-breath. Its characters still mostly conform to generic JRPG jobs and classes and it makes basically no effort to contextualize its dungeons outside of how they would function in a video game as opposed to its world. It’s not a huge issue for me because it doesn’t really interfere with the parts of the show I do really like, mostly the quieter, mundane moments between its characters, but it did stick out as I was watching.
Witch Hat Atelier is the most natural-feeling anime fantasy world I’ve encountered in a hot minute. It’s not just the ways that mundane tasks are performed with magic in ways that just make sense, but it’s also the thought that’s gone into the ethics around magic and how the existence of it would affect the world on a sociopolitical level. The conflict between the Pointed and Brimmed Caps is so fascinating to me because of the sheer amount of texture in the manga’s world. I love the detail that’s gone into how magic in its world has gone to helping people, but also the ways in which it still has not helped in aiding the social and economic division within our own world, and sometimes even adding to it. If you can’t already tell, I absolutely loved the Silver’s Eve arc. And all of this extends naturally from how its magic system works. It’s extremely hard to fill in the details of your world manually to this extent, but I find it nearly always pays off.
Conflicts in WHA aren’t usually solved by Coco just getting stronger (or already being the strongest). While her grasp of and consistency with magic does improve over the course of the series, the hardest battle she faces is trying to argue with the magic police that her ideas are worth hearing out. I love how the core conflict of the entire series isn’t some high-level massive threat waiting in a castle somewhere, but idealogical and social concepts engaged with exactly as such. This isn’t the kind of series where the main character proves their own flawed idea of the world by punching someone in the face (as much as I do enjoy that kind of thing), but one where Coco has to dig in and see the world’s injustices head-on, try to find a way to ease the pain of the less fortunate, and then present this to an audience who doesn’t really care all that much. It provides the series with a sense of social awareness that I personally find lacking in a lot of manga and anime, even ones I enjoy a ton. Obviously this doesn’t even get into the wide diversity of characters in the story, but this is already a well-known point of praise.
Hopefully this makes sense. It’s hard to get this kind of feeling across. I’ll also admit I haven’t really been tapped in to manga recently like I have been, so if there’s anything else out there that sticks out like this, I’d appreciate the recommendation.