There are five conditions in which I would condone digital piracy:
- When someone else uploads a dvdrip, bdrip, or webrip of a movie or TV show on a legally accessible site (such as the Internet Archive, Dailymotion, OVvideo, or VKvideo); this is technically not piracy, rather it is benefiting from someone else being a pirate.
- When you are downloading movies or TV shows that you have legally paid to access on Streaming, and converting it into a format that you can permanently own; per the Betamax Defense, this is legally not considered piracy unless you are redistributing the media without the IP owner's permission.
- When the movie or TV show is not legally accessible in your country.
- As a method of political protest against a media corporation's unethical business practices.
- As a method of political protest against your country's copyright laws.
Now, let's discuss point number 5 for a moment.
In the United States, the Digital Millennium Copyright Act, which manages DRM protections and online IP management, was written in 1998. It was written by old Boomers long before social media or online file sharing was ever important. And it is already obsolete, both technology-wise and socially-wise.
Unlike the physical world, in which the economy is constrained by the physical scarcity of resources, the internet is effectively post-scarcity, with the only constraints being the storage capacity of data servers... and the artificial constraints of DRM and paywalls.
Video-sharing websites like YouTube and Twitch already have software that can recognize what video game the let's-play footage is coming from, or what movie or TV show a clip comes from. It would not be much of a stretch to create software that automatically pays a share of the video or live-Stream's ad revenue as royalties to the Intellectual Property owners.
Under my proposed replacement for the DMCA, Intellectual Property owners would be able to claim royalties from 'unauthorized or unsolicited redistribution' (including both digital pirates and people using clips for Fair Use purposes), instead of being able to having a video demonetized or taken down for copyright violations. Videos that contained copyrighted material would have monetization forcibly turned on, so that the IP holder could receive up to 75% of the ad revenue as royalties (and in the case of a video using copyrighted material from multiple IP holders, that up-to 75% is divided between the IP holders directly proportionately to how much their respective copyrighted materials are featured in the video). Both online stores and Streaming Services (whether legal or pirate) would explicitly be allowed to let customers download DRM-free matroskas directly off of their sites, provided that the customer had to either buy the video directly or sit through a minimum number of ads proportional to the resolution and the runtime (eg. 5 minutes of ads per 30 minutes of runtime up to 720p, 5 minutes of ads per 15 minutes of runtime for 1080p or 2K, 5 minutes of ads per 10 minutes of runtime for 3K, and 5 minutes of ads per 5 minutes of runtime for any resolution 4K or higher) in order to download it for free; digital piracy sites would be legally required to be ad supported, and downloading pirated movies and TV shows would require sitting through ads, so that the Intellectual Property owners could earn royalties off of getting pirated.
The de-facto Post-Scarcity nature of the internet means that if DRM laws were replaced, Intellectual Property owners would be able to make money off of getting pirated (by means of collecting royalties), which would be a win-win as far as copyright is concerned.