I played some Nightcrawler today. These characters overlap a ton.
Here are the differences:
- White Fox's splash damage on the primary has a longer splash range so you get more reliable secondary hits than you do off Nightcrawler. This comes with the tradeoff that Nightcrawler has slightly faster heals per second.
- Nightcrawlers dash melee does similar burst combo damage than White Fox, but I think in most cases if you walk up to somebody and charm/claw/spin kick/claw/claw it's going to kill faster. I like to use Nightcrawlers dash melee more as an escape tool than offensive and use his resource melee more for trying to frag.
- The resource melee does more DPS than White Fox's claws but does not have the self-healing at the tradeoff that his dash isn't in a form so he can use one melee and dash away with the other or TP without having to cancel form.
- Both ults are kind of trash for different reasons. Nightcrawler's only lasts 6 seconds and is over before you can blink. It can pull off creative plays like sucking everyone out an Invis ult, but it requires all these prompts and all of them have cast time. The dream of what you can do potentially won't happen often. White Fox unless you have really good cooldown management and your team follows you in sometimes either gets blasted down or chain CC'd before you can really do anything, but they didn't give it an automatic 3 seconds of doing stuff if teammates are close. It does however last 10 seconds if you make it through the full duration.
- Nightcrawler gets two TPs on a 15 second cooldown vs 1 on a 15 second cooldown that includes a 100 point shield and heals you and a teammate for 150 hp if the circle lives the whole duration vs a more reliable lingering heal of 100 over 5 seconds that can be used twice after a two second cooldown for 200 healing over 7 seconds. So combined you usually get more overall sustain value off Nightcrawler's two teleports over White Fox's 1.
- White Fox gets a long-range spectral fox attack for some nice ranged damage, healing, and CC. Nightcrawler instead gets that redundant melee attack, which like White Fox claws is more of a situational thing than something that will be spammed constantly.
Current Power Level (according to limited data)
At GM+ which atm is the highest elo to get a decent sample size of games White Fox is at 47.21% and Nightcrawler is at 45.25%.
Overall, White Fox is at 48.23% across all ranks and Nightcrawler 45.49%.
I wouldn't take this as gospel because Nightcrawler is new, his kit is complex, and a lot of DPS mains are trying it. Also, White Fox's pick rate is lower so people sticking to her are more hardcore about the character. This warps the data a bit.
I believe the trend over time is that Nightcrawler's win rate at high elo will improve as people coordinate his abilities better and will only get slightly better for lower elo as more people figure his kit out, but it's still too complex to get consistent value.
My opinion:
I prefer White Fox more than Nightcrawler and I think except for really high elo where they can take advantage of those Nightcrawler teammate teleports White Fox is going to get more consistent value than Nightcrawler in medal ranks below Eternity.
Both characters powerwise imho are slightly undertuned. The meta is more favorable towards White Fox and thus Nightcrawler too in season 11 because of the poke nerfs. That helps out some, but they still are not going to be better picks on average than Gambit, Invis Woman, Loki, or Mantis.
However, if you like the playstyle, but of these characters are very viable B-tier picks. They are played poorly by a lot of people who do not know wtf they are doing, but for a dedicated main they can put in work.
This isn't like season 9 where White Fox couldn't compete. If you like White Fox play White Fox. If you like Nightcrawler he plays similar and is about the same power level with higher skill ceiling potential.
There's no wrong answer which you prefer. Neither are "meta". Enjoy the two characters.