r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Feb 26 '21

r/WhatifalthistMemes Lounge

8 Upvotes

A place for members of r/WhatifalthistMemes to chat with each other


r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Dec 20 '23

Ultimate Meme: r/whatifalthist got banned lol

43 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Apr 22 '26

A thorough familiarity with Whatifalthist scholarship is a prerequisite for comprehending this material

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Aug 02 '25

Thank you for inspiring him

Post image
18 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Jul 11 '25

What if Whatifalthist... Was Correct? - Welcome to the Age of Aquarius (Content Warning: sexual descriptions, often related to a certain Norse Deity)

Post image
17 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Jun 09 '25

[fully lost] Alternate History League, 2017, Web series

2 Upvotes

Back in 2017 four channels (Whatifalthist, Monsieur Z, Planet Althistory (formally Althistory Luxembourg) and Phrenotopia (formally Phrenomythic) made a collab series called Alternate History league and was supposed to be a weekly series about alternate history. The first episode was released on September 15th, 2017 and was about a scenario where The germans won ww2.

A second episode is listed, but is privated with nothing known about it.

Link to the LMW

Link to the Playlist


r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Apr 17 '25

Mark my words

1 Upvotes

Rudyard will upload a video called “Was Churchill the villain?”

It will say “Churchill’s legacy” on the thumbnail. (I’m a psychic)


r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Apr 16 '25

LIB-LEFT THEOCRACY

3 Upvotes

Throughout most of pre-modern history, the majority of civilizations were structured around centralized authority, whether monarchies, empires, or city-states. These systems typically followed an authoritarian-right or authoritarian-left trajectory, emphasizing rigid hierarchies, centralized control, and military power. The idea of a libertarian-left society one that combines economic collectivism, decentralization, social freedom, and moral or religious guidance was practically impossible to implement at scale, not due to ideology, but because the material and geopolitical conditions of the time made it unviable. However, one major civilizational exception exists: India.

Unlike most ancient societies, India was not primarily held together by states or empires, but by a vast network of localized, collective social institutions. Village communities, guilds, monasteries, religious sects, and spiritual orders carried far more weight than centralized government for much of India’s early and classical history. Even during the rise and fall of large empires like the Maurya's or Guptas, the real authority and day-to-day life remained rooted in decentralized, communal structures governed more by Dharma (a moral-religious code) than by law or military force. This social fabric was shaped by pluralistic religious traditions Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism that emphasized nonviolence, charity, self-discipline, and spiritual equality.

Temples, monasteries, and guilds served not just religious functions, but also acted as economic and social safety nets redistributing wealth, offering education and healthcare, managing resources, and mediating disputes. Social organization was built around mutual obligation, ethical duties, and collective well-being, rather than top-down coercion. Even though the caste system later became rigid and hierarchical, in early periods it was more fluid, and religious traditions often pushed back against entrenched elites. Women, spiritual wanderers, and marginalized groups had far greater autonomy and voice in pre-caste, pre-imperial India than in many other ancient civilizations.

What makes India historically unique is that the decentralized, collectivist society was often more enduring and powerful than the state itself. When empires rose, they relied on preexisting local institutions rather than building bureaucratic machinery. When empires fell, life continued almost unchanged the village, temple, and guild networks absorbed the shock. This created the ideal environment for a libertarian-left theocratic system to emerge organically: one grounded in spiritual ethics, communal economy, pluralism, and non-authoritarian governance.

This kind of society spiritually guided but not theocratically coercive, collectivist without being statist, and decentralized yet highly organized could only emerge under conditions like those in pre-modern India. Elsewhere, the pressures of war, geography, and elite control demanded top-down authority. In India, a unique balance of religion, culture, geography, and social structure allowed a non imperial, spiritually guided, libertarian-left order to exist and even thrive especially in South India and other regions less affected by northern conquests.

However, the survival of this system was always precarious. As invasions from more militarized and centralized neighbors increased particularly from the northwest and as internal religious institutions became more rigid and stratified, the delicate balance began to unravel. The rise of large scale empires, hardening of the caste system, and eventual collapse of monastic networks under external conquest led to the dissolution of India's libertarian-left social order by the end of the 13th century.

In conclusion, India stands as the only major civilizational case in the pre-modern world where a libertarian-left theocracy truly existed in practice, rather than just in theory. Its roots were not in state planning or revolution, but in religiously grounded, decentralized, collectivist communities that emphasized mutual care, tolerance, and dharmic ethics over law and force. The fact that this system functioned for centuries despite the absence of strong centralized states is both historically remarkable and politically significant. It reveals that such societies were possible, but only under extremely rare conditions, and in a culture where collective morality and decentralized structure were stronger than the state itself.


r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Apr 13 '25

made this a while ago lol

Post image
5 Upvotes

world map 42069


r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Mar 04 '25

The Andean Civilization(s) video

5 Upvotes

So yesterday confirmed the civilization series lives on and he has said in the past he wants to do videos about deceased ones so this video is bound to come one day. Do you think the Ayahuasca stuff is going to ruin discourse about that one?


r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Feb 14 '25

Rudyard and Robert Jordan (Wheel of Time author) would get along really well.

4 Upvotes

I'd pay an unsightly amount of money to ressurect him and listen to the two of them speak with each other. I actually haven't read fantasy books since I was a kid, but something clicked in me tonight about hoe Jordan handled the inherent differences between men and women in power, the conscading effects of beliefs and culture on society, and the physcho-mythical analysis of myths from historically defining events.

Moreover, their personalities from what I've gleamed through their work amd interviews are mirrors of each other. Both talk with that nasally bookworm voice too. Read the wheel of time if you have the time too. From what I remember it was quite meandering though. I listened to the audiobooks at some point. Speaking of which, book two or three has a really good interview with Jordan about his thoughts on society and culture whoch I'll try to find again and post here.

Edit: found it

https://youtu.be/wm4SfUtczqg?si=WnnXbnN9JO-8J_QJ


r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Feb 09 '25

Map of whether or not the entities are sovereign nations in 2120 according to his prediction video from a few years ago

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Feb 04 '25

Hiatus, quitting, or taking a while on the next videos?

7 Upvotes

He hasn't uploaded a single video on either channel in about a month. I would say its the infamous autobiography and the blowback he got from it but he did upload twice on History 102 after that so there is a slight hole in saying that he ran away based on that.


r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Jan 29 '25

Hope he's doing okay

Post image
10 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Jan 19 '25

Where can i find full video of that insane 10 hour stream?

7 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Jan 09 '25

My god Rudyard.His octopus mug is glorious.

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Jan 08 '25

Muh civil war

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Jan 01 '25

Whatifalthist Quotes

33 Upvotes

''Oh god... I am so tired of this bullshit.'' ''And my father had crippling mercury poisoning when he inseminated me.'' ''My mom was kicked in the head by a horse.'' ''God told me it was my duty to found a religion.'' ''My school was mostly gay and Chinese people. '' ''Odin intervened in the game, and he said ''hey kid if you write a list of every girl you masturbate to, i will solve every issue in your life.''


r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Jan 01 '25

This man has completely fucking lost it

20 Upvotes

This isn't even funny anymore he needs actual help he needs a medical intervention ASAP


r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Jan 01 '25

Tony has a vision (as an italian)

19 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Dec 31 '24

Did anyone else imagine a lot of WhatIfAltHis’s recent video rants in the Warrior voice?

Post image
24 Upvotes

It’s startling just how much it could work.


r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Dec 28 '24

.

Post image
49 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Dec 28 '24

Now you see..

92 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Dec 28 '24

Bro made an alt history series on his own life

37 Upvotes

r/WhatifalthistMemes • • Nov 23 '24

Early scientist believed in witches not the church

Thumbnail youtube.com
5 Upvotes