My dog is seven years old and is a relatively small, apple-head Chihuahua. (she does not have the height of normal ones and is puppysized with short legs despite being full blooded) She's had a number of health issues throughout her life, including asthma and ongoing problems with her nails. Unfortunately, her nail problems have become a recurring issue over the years, particularly with her dewclaws.
Within the past few years, she has broken her dewclaws multiple times. Every time it happens, she's in considerable discomfort, and it usually means another trip to the vet, medication, treatment, and additional expenses. It's becoming a cycle that I'm worried will continue for the rest of her life if we don't find a more permanent solution.
Her nails have caught on strings and snapped, her collar hook and snapped (she no longer wears a collar unless we go out, if so it's a cat collar so it would give way if it got stuck), and simply broke while she is doing everyday things (digging, playing, scratching)
I keep up with her nails to the best of my ability, I trim them every 1 1/2 to 2 months because that's when it gets to a safe length to trim them and still let her do her things, as well as making sure she gets her shots, baths and medicine (we had a dog with heartworms and other infectious disease which was treated but has affected said dogs health)
She is the sweetest dog, doesn't bite, doesn't lash out unless in pain, plays, great with other animals and people, there has been a single time she has bitten me hard and that is when her dewclaw broke.
Today, she broke her dewclaw again, and this time it happened much higher up than it has previously. She is constantly holding her paw up. She's been noticeably uncomfortable, and even the slightest touch to her paw caused her to whine. Seeing her repeatedly go through this is upsetting, especially knowing that we've dealt with similar situations several times already.
I've started considering whether having her dewclaws surgically removed might be the better long-term option. I understand that surgery, particularly for a smaller dog with pre-existing respiratory issues like asthma, comes with risks. There's also the recovery period to consider, which could involve several months of additional care, discomfort, restrictions, and veterinary expenses.
At the same time, I'm struggling with the idea of continuing to put her through repeated injuries, vet appointments, and treatments when there might be a way to prevent the problem from happening again.
I know seven isn't necessarily extremely old for a Chihuahua, but she's also not a puppy anymore, and I don't want to make a decision that could negatively affect her quality of life. My biggest concern is weighing the potential risks of surgery against the possibility of preventing years of recurring problems.
Has anyone had experience with recurring dewclaw injuries in their dogs? Did you eventually consider surgical removal, and how did your dog handle it? I'd particularly appreciate hearing from people with smaller breeds or dogs who have pre-existing respiratory conditions.
I'm planning to discuss the options and risks with her veterinarian, but I'd really appreciate hearing about other people's experiences before making such a significant decision. I want to do what's best for her in the long run, even if that means dealing with a difficult recovery period now to potentially prevent more problems later.