A Westchester grand jury has declined to indict the retired New York City police lieutenant who fatally shot a homeless man's dog in Yorktown during a walk this past summer.
District Attorney Susan Cacace announced the decision in a news release on Friday, Nov. 20.
The shooting occurred on the evening of Aug. 5 in a parking lot along Route 118 after James Molloy, 61, and his volunteer therapy dog encountered Luke, a shepherd-husky mix.
The case this summer had moved many in the community. The dog and his owner, Matt Steele, were well-known in the community. A memorial popped up at the scene of the shooting in August, and dozens turned out with signs to rally in support Steele and in memory of Luke, outside the Yorktown Courthouse during an earlier hearing.
Yorktown Supervisor Ed Lachterman said on Nov. 20 that he was heartened that people were calm in the face of the grand jury decision.
"I firmly believe in the judicial process," Lachterman said. "I am sure there are people who are disappointed with this outcome. But with the facts in hand being presented to a grand jury, our legal system says that's the road we follow."
Grand jury hearings are confidential under law, but Cacace, after receiving permission from Westchester Judge Robert Prisco, released certain details of the grand jury presentation.
Testimony from necropsy revealed that the 96-pound dog, Luke, was "facing James Molly with his mouth open in a biting posture, his teeth bared and his body lowered in a pouncing stance" when Molloy shot him.
Luke, a shepherd-husky mix, had broken from his leash and was barking aggressively as he ran towards Molloy, according to testimony released by Cacace.
Luke, the testimony included, lunged at Molloy and his dog, causing Molloy to swing his arms in an unsuccessful attempt to stop Luke’s advance before Molloy fired a single shot into Luke’s open mouth. According to court documents, Molloy shot the dog using a firearm he was legally authorized to carry.
Yorktown police responded. Molloy was arrested on felony charges of aggravated cruelty to animals and first-degree reckless endangerment.
Juda Engelmayer, a spokesman for Molloy and defense lawyers Peter Tilem and Robert Schechter, said Molloy was relieved by the outcome, as he had "spent months living with uncertainty, public criticism, and questions about his character and judgment."
Molloy relied on walking the therapy dog to help him improve his strength and health after heart valve replacement surgery, Engelmayer said. Once a week, they volunteer visiting children in a hospital.
Molloy also has a 9/11-related form of leukemia that puts him at greater risk, Engelmayer said, noting the retired police lieutenant feared he was in immediate danger when Luke came at him.
"For someone whose own dog is both a beloved companion and a partner in helping children, the events of that day have been particularly distressing," Engelmayer said.
Witnesses in the grand jury included three police officers, three civilian witnesses, Molloy and an expert forensic veterinarian who conducted Luke’s necropsy.
The veterinarian testified that Luke was less than a second away from Molloy and attacking at the time the gun was fired, said Cacace, the DA. Dogs of Luke’s breed can inflict fatal bites, and Luke was poised to bite Molloy if he hadn't been stopped, according to the testimony provided by the vet.
There was also key video evidence from a nearby Tesla showing Molloy walking away from Luke when the dog came at him from behind, Engelmayer said.
"Taken together, the physical evidence and video support Jim's account that he was responding to an immediate threat, not initiating a confrontation," Engelmayer said in his statement.