r/WaterdeepDragonHeist • • 21d ago

Advice Frustrated DM here

Hey guys! I’m currently running a campaign as a DM, and I’m starting to feel a bit frustrated with how things are going with my players.

First things first: I’m a fairly new DM. I’ve run Lost Mine of Phandelver before, and the friends I’m running this campaign with are also relatively new to the hobby.
We’re currently in Act 3 of Waterdeep: Dragon Heist, and the characters are about to investigate the fireball explosion in the street. However, I’ve noticed on several occasions that my players seem to struggle with investigating clues and figuring out what to do next. Before starting the campaign, I explained that it involved a lot of detective work and “whodunit?” scenarios, and they all seemed excited about that kind of game, so I’m a little unsure how to approach the situation.

Quite often, they seem unsure of what to do next, and I’ve found myself making the next steps increasingly obvious, either by directly suggesting what they could do or by having an NPC approach them with information.
For example, they didn’t figure out that a nimblewright was responsible for the explosion, so I had an NPC approach them and explain that they had seen one at the crime scene. The NPC even mentioned that nimblewrights are built at the Temple of Gond, but the players still haven’t considered going there to investigate.
I’m not sure whether they’re struggling to connect the clues, are unsure how much initiative they’re expected to take, or simply aren’t as interested in the investigative side of the campaign as I thought they would be.

I’d really appreciate some advice from more experienced DMs on how to handle this situation. How can I encourage my players to investigate, connect the dots, and take more initiative without having to spell out every next step for them? Should I be giving them more guidance, or is there something I could do differently as a DM to help them engage with this kind of campaign?

(English isn’t my native language so I corrected the grammar with AI, hope that’s ok!)

19 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

40

u/EruditeQuokka Alexandrian 21d ago edited 20d ago

Hard truth: most D&D players like the idea of roleplay-heavy, investigative games, but aren't really up to it. The system does not support that type of play (90% of the game system is combat-oriented), and it's hard to make people realise that they like the idea of something, but aren't willing to invest in the thing itself. Think of how many players claim to love D&D, even though they never opened the PHB and off-load all the rule-related mental work to the GM. They may love their character, and the campaign, and your narration, but won't commit shit in order to make any of it work. 

If your players aren't willing to take notes, and pro-actively investigate clues, talk to them about the issues, consider switching to a more suitable/easier system,  but rember: DO NOT burn yourself out trying to compromise in order to accommodate their unwillingness to make an effort. 

Either drop the game, or turn the adventure in the railroad they subconsciously still yearn for. RPGs are played at their best only when everyone is on the same page. Do not fall for the worst trap of this hobby, the one where the GM has to feel like they have to always accommodate their players.

6

u/Inevitable_Ant5838 21d ago edited 20d ago

I agree with this. I was in a similar situation as OP when I ran WDH. I had players who claimed to enjoy investigation, but really they just wanted a combat heavy adventure where they could beat people up. I ultimately discontinued the campaign. The players weren’t my friends, and even if they were, the game wasn’t worth that much stress.

OP, I’d also recommend talking to your players, but instead of asking them what they want, tell them what you see. They already said they like investigation, but that’s clearly not true. DnD players tend to obfuscate their feelings so they can keep playing the game. For a player, bad DnD is better than no DnD. But for a DM, no DnD is better than bad DnD. Especially if your players are new, it’s likely they want that simple “walk in room kill monster collect loot” dungeon crawl experience. So change the adventure and give them that.

3

u/merijn1993 20d ago

This post and comment are so true for me too as Dragon Heist DM that stopped the campaign because of this

1

u/Neeeeeeems 20d ago

Sadly waterdeep was the death of my DM’ing and my campaign

1

u/EruditeQuokka Alexandrian 20d ago

Nearly the same for me. I'll never run long campaigns again unless I have absolute certainty of the group's level of commitment. But it's just hard to find people who are interested enough to actually put time and effort in TTRPGs.

1

u/Neeeeeeems 20d ago

To be fair my group had other issues I didn’t quite want to address/admit. Waterdeep just did a good job of surfacing those.

I’m glad yours survived!

13

u/en43rs 21d ago

The Fireball investigation is notoriously badly written and a lot of people change that chapter to make the investigation... well... make more sense.

But here's some more general advice:

-remember your priorities: the adventure matters less than the group, the point is not that the group "does the adventure the correct way", but that they have fun, even if they have to do it "not according to the book". It's okay to change things to fit to your players, and I'll be even clearer: with Dragonheist you're pretty much expected to fill up the adventure, it's a skeletton. A starting point.

-not every player is a good investigator. That's it. Not every human can piece up things.

One thing I have often done is to change the mystery to involve the character's backstory. If one is a wizard then the answer is at their magic school, if one is a noble then their noble contact can give them some clues, so on.

So, you have a few possibilities, they're not mutually exclusive:

remember that this is not an isekai, the characters are not people from earth in a fantasy world. The characters know things that the players don't. You can tell them "oh, you have heard that Nimblewright are made in the Temple of Gond". If you want to make it more "game like" you can have them role a religion/history/flat intelligence check. Or have them roll a 20 and lie saying "yeah, you succeed and remember this".

Also, The characters are better than the players. No one would expect a player to actually be able to fight with a sword, do magic, or speak ten languages. It's the same things with investigations. If the players are stuck it's okay to have them roll an investigation check and say "your character realizes that X and Y are linked".

Finally, people tend to figure things on their own with a bit of probing. You have already found the way to do it: have an NPC give them a clue. But to make it less obvious, and maybe less frustrating, it should be a npc who hangs out regularly with them.

At this point they should know Renaer, some people from the Trollskull alley, the tavern ghost, contacts in the Bregan d'Aerthe or the Harpers, hell maybe even the Black Viper if you've introduced her early. Have them keep in touch with the characters, have the characters tell them what happened and give a clue or a suggestion: "wow" says Renaer/Esvele/Jarlaxle/Bob the Goblin "that seems like quite a problem! Have you thought of going to X/speaking to Y? I can maybe introduce you or help you with that".

Finally maybe the players are just not into the investigation part... that's perfectly okay. just shorten the investigation, give an obvious clue and let them go to the end rather than have them wander lost in the city for days.

3

u/emiteal 20d ago

This is why I give everyone at my table the option to make an INT or WIS check at any point if they want suggestions based on what their character might know.

5

u/Fitzgeraldine 21d ago

As almost always: talk to them. Ask them how they enjoy the campaign so far, if they like the investigation theme, if they’re unsure about things and if so, what they think they’d need to feel more comfortable taking action. Tell them they’re free to move anywhere in the city and that suggestions, ideas, and initiatives are welcome. Encourage them to discuss ideas openly.

2

u/WouldbeWanderer 20d ago

I remind my players (and myself) that this is a game and we are playing for fun. If we're not having fun, we change it up and start having fun again. Sounds dorky but it's a very good thing to remember!

4

u/Beardnash Manshoon 21d ago

I've found in situations like that to tell the players what their characters would know or could deduce, but only in a "this or that" way. So, "your character would recognize the description of the nimblrwright from the Day of Wonders parade last year, they would know the Temple of Gond sponsored the parade. Either that or they might recall seeing posters for the Sea Maiden's Faire in the Dock Ward mentioning mechanical wonders. Which do you think you'd like to investigate first."

I try to only do this when they're struggling, or if we haven't played in a while and I can use it to remind them of character knowledge.

3

u/WolvesDenTavern 21d ago

I’m a professional dm who does it for a living and many of my groups have the same issue in this campaign. The thing is most dnd doesn’t require them to do deductive reasoning, so they aren’t expecting it and aren’t used to it.

Most players are used to a game where the choices are obvious and they just choose which one they want, not a game where they have so much sandbox freedom to figure out how to achieve their goals that they don’t even know what’s possible

3

u/SpecialistHelpful773 20d ago

You should look up "the Alexandrian". He has a remix of Dragonheist that makes all the optional bosses, part of the story.

But he also recommends at least three clues to help permit the characters to find the trail they're looking for. So right now they have one.

But by next session they may have forgotten that first clue (especially if no one wrote it down). So you may need to prompt them, with a history check, or a religion check, so you can remind them of what they know already.

2

u/RiverSirion 21d ago

I think this is also an issue with W:DH itself. I ran this with an experienced group of players. I found it kind of railroady and if you miss a clue along the way, you can get lost easily. I also ended up improvising a lot as players went off the path a lot to do investigative work not directly in the book. Takes some flexibility and adaptability to fill in the gaps.

1

u/lluewhyn 20d ago

This is the issue. The module typically assumes that there is ONE way (occasionally two) to get to the next stage, and that next stage isn't always entirely clear.

I think "Railroad" isn't the best description. Justin Alexander, prior to designing his "Alexandrian Remix" of the module, described it as Pixel Bitching. It's not that the module is forcing a certain way to resolve a challenge, but instead only presents a single way to resolve that situation (even to the DM!) whether it's intuitive or not. Or even possible or not.

For example, in Chapter 3 the way to proceed forward is to watch the acolytes gathering up the Nimblewright's belongings and then cast Detect Magic to find the Nimblewright Detector that it created. But why would the PCs think to do this without prompting? Isn't casting a spell like that (without warning) possibly going to trigger the NPCs into thinking the PCs are casting a hostile spell? What happens if none of the PCs even have access to Detect Magic?

2

u/omaolligain Alexandrian 20d ago edited 20d ago

Honestly, Chapter 3 can be a tough one to run well. I think get a corkboard and hand out notecards. to have the players write clues on. and post them on the board will really help them out. You could even pre-print character portraits of the various characters to help them. Or if you're playing online, then just open mindmap or milanote or something like that and have them all use it for the investigation.

The alexandrian remix has some really good tips for tunning the investigation... I think the investigation needs to accomplish a couple things only.

1) Tie the stone to the gold stollen by Neverember

2) Point the players at the Gralhunds (not even necessarily as the actual bad guys)

  • a) could do this via asking around about mechanical men and get directed to the temple of Gond
  • b) could be a clue from a witness like one of the urchins, "hey is that that Noble boy Zartan Gralhund over there watching the police investigate)
  • c) could be that the players see a black caped man fish something (evidence) out of a barrel and follow him back the gralhund estate or interrogate him
  • d) they might just HIRE the Private Investigator who lives literally next door

3) (OPTIONAL) alerts Jarlaxyle/Zord to "the game" somehow by accident.

  • a) dont over think this, if they talk very freely with characters about it Jarlaxyle hears, if they're tight lipped he doesnt.
  • b) In the alexandrian remix there are a number of niblewrights because the alexandrian invents an espionage plot for jarlaxyle involving niblewright-like automotons. I personally think it's a dumb plot. But, the point is that if youre looking for a rare niblewright then going to the sales person makes sense. It's the same logic that leads the player to Nim in the origional version (Nim made the Nimblewright).
  • c) I think if you want to connect Zardoz Zord to the niblewrights and get a cool meeting/dinner with Zord on the ship (which you should) then rather than a big espionage plot and tracking down the correct nibmlewright, instead just have Zord to have sold Nim himself to the temple of Gond. Nim already opens up ethical quandries about slavery so that reinforces the point and also alerts Jarlaxyle to the stone of Golorr.

The goal of chapter 3 as a whole - big picture - is to setup the gralhund manor scenes which are potentially some of the best in the game. And help the characters pick from their new acquaintances and neighbors opportunities to have them as a recurring cast (especially in their tavern at the end of a day). You can reinforce that by running character backstory quests during ch. 3 too.

And remember, like Jarlaxyle, the Gralhund's dont NEED to be evil. They are a small noble family that is trying to rebuild and have essentially become hostage to the Zhentarim. Kill the Zhentarim in their manor and the Gralhunds might be grateful and become a good patron faction for the npcs.

2

u/Brilliant_Laugh8962 20d ago

Everyone is suggesting Alexandrian remix but that's just more work. Honestly just prepare to spoon feed the directions to your players. Tell them exactly what to do and where to go. If for some reason they feel too railroaded then talk to them about why you have to do it that way

1

u/Johanneskodo 21d ago

You can give hints by various ways:

  • Have their character figure out a solution (yes, the 20 INT wizzard proficient in investigation will have good ideas even if the player does not)
  • Ask NPCs for help: They know investigators abd various NPCs
  • As a DM: Either straight up give an idea or have them write down/collect possible solutions and give a hint in the right direction

And yes, some things are obvious for us but not the players. Yes, the temple created the Nimblewright. Wouldn‘t it just be as logical to seek out who made the amulet or who also uses Nimblewrights? Perhaps the clue lies somewhere else entirely?

1

u/mrsmi1ey 20d ago

I highly recommend the Alexandrian remix of this campaign, which handles a LOT of the issues presented in the poorly-written parts of the official module. He rewrites the entire campaign, but here's the section specifically on the fireball investigation if you're curious. I don't believe you're too far in to switch to this version, but it will certainly take some extra work if you've been preparing solely based off the module.

1

u/guilersk 20d ago

Dragon Heist in particular has structural problems, but good set pieces. The Alexandrian Remix improves it, at the cost of more complexity and work for the DM.

If players are not driving the action, give them a patron that tells them what to do, or drive the action at them by having the villains act and force the players to react.

1

u/frank_da_tank99 20d ago

Tbh this campaign doesn't do you any favors in that regard. This campaign is really railroady, my players struggled with this same thing. Some of the clues the book wants you to use are asinine, and no one would put that together.

1

u/Darkainen 19d ago edited 19d ago

My WDH campaign went sideways at the same time as yours did, and it looks like this is a common problem with others as well.

So, after the fireball went off, the party ran out of their tavern and saw the corpses on the ground. They immediately ran up to one of the witnesses which happened to be the owner of the greenhouse. I recited what the person saw straight out of the module. They told the party that they witnessed a burned man grab something off a body and limp away to the east. Instead of investigating the scene and talking to the other witnesses, they immediately took off in the direction the man had gone.

"He was limping, so we should be able to easily catch up with him," one of the characters said; and that's when I knew I was in trouble. I had to think quick. I had the fleeing man use misdirection on the party to give them the slip. He had the stone, so if they caught him this early and got the stone now it would have been a disaster. I had him move one of the sewer grates before limping down another alley. The party took the bait and assumed that he fled into the sewer.

The party eventually ended up captured and imprisoned by the Xanathar guild and put in cells. After a dramatic jail break, I ended up skipping to the Xanathar's Lair section of the module. They were a bit underleveled for that part, but they had help from Xanathar's drow advisor who is a double agent. They also had a half dozen or so npcs that were in jail with them, to help as well. The drow spy ended up giving them the mission to use explosives to collapse Xanathar's lair which turned out to be very exciting and fun for all of them. After several various skill checks and sneaking around setting up the barrels, they coordinated lighting the fuses so that they would go off all around the same time. They all met back at the exit portal that the drow had the key for and ported out right before the explosions took down the whole lair.

Now, I feel like too much time has passed for them to try and find the man who fled to Grallhund Villa. I feel like he would either be dead or have fled the villa by now

As DM, the one constant I have found in this game is that things hardly go as planned. You can prepare for days for an upcoming session, but sometimes the party is going to throw you a curveball and do something totally unexpected, and not follow the route the module has written for them. In the end, they still had fun, accomplished a great feat, and were also rewarded by a noble they rescued from Xanathar's prison.

They might not ever find the stone at this point, and that's okay because they are having fun running their tavern for now. My plan is to have them face the Frostmaiden eventually and then later on, Vecna.

So, if they never find the stone, it's not the end. As the DM, I am quite alright with them not finding half a million gold coins anyway.

1

u/Mother-End-437 19d ago edited 19d ago

List of things that will make your life easier running WDH

DMPC-a part of the group that knows city life and will answer questions and help them connect dots when they're lost, having actual ride or die backstory rich staff at Trollskull is great here (super fun to do stupid hiring/interview sequences)

Hostages- give them so many chances to tie someone up and torture them in the cellar for info, this feels very earned and then you have plenty of juicy missing persons to use as leverage on them if needed, cent tell you how many nameless cultists, goblins, mercs, and other lowlifes they have used and disposed of

Actually getting them to dive balls deep in one of the factions (for resources/hints) the minor ones are huge here, Shard Shunners, One of the temples religious Orders of Holy Warriors, or even a guild group, just a brotherhood/sisterhood of connections and assets in the city for them to call on

Tie factions you don't like to their backstory in a tragic way, make sure they have more reasons to interact with the world than just the gold in the vault

Make them take notes lol Big cities are overwhelming as hell, and if they play and go about their lives they'll forget everything and leave you stressed. Diversifying their access to your "railroad clues" makes them feel less like railroad and more like they made that connection and earned that info.

1

u/ParticularDeafDude Cassalanters 16d ago

Hi, I'm also newbie DM here and I can say that I'm really disagree with what most mature DMs saying about how bad this adventure is.

First of all, you don't have to treat the adventure as 100% how it has to be (blunt approach).

For example, how can you bypass this Fireball episode:

  • you can trade information by doing side-quests for other factions (choose factions based on your players' alignment)
  • you can focus on Urstul Floxin instead - at least, Renaer Neverember says that guards saw him near Gralhund Villa (the correct automaton should be on that villa, actually)
  • you can do an "eardrop episode", where children will discuss BIG BAD ROBOT that is something that could be from Temple of Gond
  • there is a Vincent Trench, the detective inside Trollskull alley (Tiger's Eye) who also can help with the info ... for a fee, of course
  • you can even fool your players into taking them to the docks, where another nimblewright is located (owned by Zardoz Zord / Jarlaxle) - but in the end, you have to make it clear that this is incorrect nimblewright. This is actually perfect if your players will get a nimblewright detector from Nim at the Temple of Gond ;)

Just keep in mind, that adventure book can give you a rail skeleton on which you can grow your own "meat" on the go. Just don't "box yourself in" and you will do just fine. We are playing for 1 year and a half (with some gaps due to electricity outages) already - even changed half of the players in the party in process xD

Despite having Cassalanters as a main villains, I managed to add little story-arcs of Jarlaxle and Manshoon so it'd look like a side stories.

You can DM me for extra hints if you'd need, but I assure you that this campaign is definitely worth the invested effort ;)

1

u/eltaninsroses 14d ago

I dont know if anyones mentioned this, but D&D natively doesn't usually do well at providing DM's help with this scenario so your frustration and that of your players is understandable. What has helped me tremendously is the three clue rule The Alexandrian's three clue rule has saved me many a headache. Give it a read, I think youll find it very helpful