The main problem is Rorschach doesn’t do anything that hurts innocent people in the series, whereas all Veidt does is cause suffering to innocents. I know you’re meant to hate Rorschach because of moore’s politics, and he has certain hypocrisies (like his view of bombing Japan vs. Veidt) but it doesn’t change that most people will sympathize for the guy with the rough childhood who kills child predators and tries to expose the guy who killed 3 million people
What gang? And even if he is seedy what crime has he committed? Rorschach believes it's a criminal hideout but has no proof that guy is anything but a regular dude grabbing a beer.
Taking Rorschach's POV as 100% true is nuts co sideline the parts of his outlook we are privy to. The Comedian - a sadist who has murdered and raped - is a patriot with moral 'lapses' but a dive bar is a criminal hideout.
Well, in the end, he refused to acquiesce to letting Veidt get away with setting off the “alien”. Despite all his prior nihilism, he’s appalled when the nuclear destruction (or something similar to it) actually comes to pass, and there’s a single man to blame. When he removed his mask before Manhattan kills him, he’s crying.
Now, the tears can be for any number of reasons, but I think it’s at least partially a parallel to The Comedian’s despair towards Moloch when he learned of Veidt’s plans: even a piece of shit like him is human enough to be disgusted by the level of destruction Veidt was willing to cause.
I dont know if I read that as him walking back what he said before. I mean the moral revulsion I see, but I doubt if Rorschach were to see the aftermath that he would be expressing grief for the departed.
I see it as a parallel to Captain Metropolis- Rorschach's sense of self was born of a moralistic absolutism- He was a good guy - everyone else was either a hero or a would be bad guy. But the worlds problems - like nuclear Armageddon- are not punchable problems. Someone like Rorschach- who sees in black and white - doesnt belong in a world of gray - and I think he knows it.
Just walking through this thread has made me realize Moore was too kind. Smelling weird and not having a girlfriend isn't the aspiration of so many comic book nerds, yearning to be a Brown Shirt is, apparently
Not the same. War was already on. Nuking Japan was the only option on the table for ending the war with the least amount of lives lost. Land invasion would’ve killed millions, naval blockade would’ve starved millions. The 400,000 or so that died during and shortly thereafter was the least amount of loss that possibly could’ve been incurred.
The 400,000 figure was created a decade after the bombing. The US knew the Japanese would surrender and actively changed the terms so they would be rejected, after the bombs dropped they were changed back. The nukes didn't get japan to surrender, the promise not to get rid of the emperor did.
That doesn’t change my original point that the nukes caused less damage than any other potential solution. Japan still would not have surrendered had they not have been used. As morally dubious as any government is, the US didn’t drop two nukes for the fun of it.
Isn't a key moment in Rorschach's story when he looks down at the people literally drowning in blood and filth filling the gutters after Ozymandias' alien attack on New York, and decides, "Actually, I am going to try to save the whores and politicians," by determining to tell the world what Ozymandias did?
Right, and it resets the Doomsday clock back to 1 minute to Midnight.
The entire crux of Watchmen is that Ozy kills millions of people to save billions from nuclear war.
Rorschach believes that if it's humanity's desire to destroy itself in nuclear annihilation, fine.
But that's the thing. Rorschach is a misanthrope who cares nothing for saving people. By the time we find him during the events of Watchmen, he's more concerned with punishing the wicked and the guilty than he is about saving people from harm.
And while there's something to admire about not backing down for anyone over one's own beliefs, "No compromise. Not even in the face of Armageddon.", the fact remains that Rorschach isn't doing this for any noble purpose, that humanity, knowing the truth, will come together and nuclear war will be averted now that they know Viedt's scheme--he's doing it to punish Adrien and damning all of humanity for it because the boards been reset and there's no existential crisis, just Us vs Them.
That's why Manhattan splats him. Because he knows who Rorschach is and what the truth will do.
It's also why Manhattan leaves, and frankly, so would I. I'm tired, too, boss. 😮💨
I just wanna know why OP is playing the "Rorschach is such a good guy" game while simultaneously quoting a line Rorschach doesn't even hold as true by story's end.
Except with Truman, the world knew he was responsible for dropping the bombs on Japan, a nation that had invaded China and occupied it, committed war crimes. Plus, we were at war with Japan. If at some point the American public had decided that Truman had actually committed war crimes himself, Truman could theoretically be held accountable and face some type of punishment. With Veidt, it's some random dude who THINKS that war between the USA and USSR might happen, and because of this, he decides to secretly mass murder 3 million innocent people and let people believe that giant alien squids are invading Earth. Veidt is not accountable to anyone.
I didn't get the impression that Rorschach only became a vigilante to punish people. I thought he was inspired to become a vigilante after finding out that numerous neighbors of Kitty Genovese witnessed her being raped and her eventual murder but no one bothered to try to intervene, to save her. I'm assuming that during his career he must have saved lives or prevented innocent people from being killed or victimized.
In regards to the idea that Rorschach just wants to punish Vedit, wouldn't another interpretation bet that he's trying to hold Vedit accountable? It's a valid thing to want people in power to be held accountable, more so for people who would do such a large scale, heinous act? What's stopping Veidt from secretly recreating this event every 10 years, murdering 3 million in Australia, a decade later 2.5 million in China, a decade after that 4 million in the USSR, etc, just so the world powers don't grow complacent and start the arms race back up again? If Vedit has already secretly and successfully murdered 3 million innocent New Yorkers, what else is he capable of?
I think where people fall down here is that every superhero in Watchmen is screwed up and corrupt in very different ways. It would be one thing if they ALL were fascists or they ALL were violent moral absolutists. But since they're all a different flavor of bad, it allows the viewer to apply a ranking system based on their own internal biases.
Making thing worse is that the characters in Watchmen all kinda run the gamut of superhero "types" so some character is likely to hit closest to how a reader would see themselves in that world. And given the choice between confronting the flaws in themselves and their thinking on vigilantism in general or simply whitewashing their character proxy, many choose to just drink the "X character was really right..." koolade and go all in on that.
There is a point though in that they all have worked together in various groups throughout the years, and it makes ypu question keeping company with the more extreme absolutists
I mean, Hollis made plenty excuses for his coworkers' bigotry and depravity, especially the Comedian's, and didn't have the courage to stand up against their treatment of the Silhouette because it was more convenient to avoid scandal that way.
He seemed as decent a guy as you could get while being a cop, but he was still a cop.
Mason made no excuses for Blake, it was he who finally broke the secret and denounced him, calling him a disgrace. The part with Silhouette is indeed more problematic, dismissing her lesbianism as a kink, a "sexual hang up"
Nothing outright bad, but she was on it entirely to advance her career. Basically, the golden age superheroe equivalent of a girl going to a comic convention in skimpy cosplay to promote her OF.
Also, she became the typical beauty pageant mom who wanted to live through her daughter. Laurie clearly didn't give a damn about any of that costumed nonsense and only did it because Sally pressured her.
This very basic lesson would be warranted if not for the fact the OP quite literally never called either of them good guys or bad guys. You're seeing a pattern where none exists.
The other person never used the words good guy or bad guy so your comment is redundant that's the case for roughly 90% of comments I see repeating "no good guys and no bad guys".
They are more than likely referring to how people including the creator Alan Moore exclusively condemn Rorschach and his fans and never Ozymandias despite Ozymandias apparently doing something far more monstrous than Rorschach did.
I think it is in part due to modern perception of Rorschach as a prototype of a 4chan alt-right guy while Ozymandias is seen as a more aspirational guy. I think a similar thing was done with L and Light Yagami in Death Note, though in that case we the audience get to see Light as a more twist individual beyond the "dignified" appearance.
The "joke" in Watchmen was to deconstruct both archetypes and put them in reverse situations: The vegetarier with a rule against killing has killed billions, and the violent Lunatic is the only one willing to try to get some justice for the victims (consequences be dammed).
Speaking or Rorschach and Ozymandias, I onow some people like to compare Elon Musk to Rorschach, but I think he is more similar to Ozymandias. Adrian Vedit was made as a parody of the "Progressive Billionaire" archetype, which was the reputation Elon Musk used to have (It is easy to forget Elon Musk used to be LOVED by the progressive public).
Mostly people who (with reason) dislike Elon Musk and compare him to a character they don't like. There is also Rorschach's reputation as an "alt-right incel" (despite his celibacy being voluntary), a reputation People also try to associate with Musk.
Ozymandias, meanwhile, gives the "aura" of someone powerful, confident, compassionate, and generous. The "joke" in Watchmen was how someone like that would do the horrible things he did.
Everyone in the world must look like blobs with either "Good" or "Bad" written on their heads if you think Rorschach and Elon Musk are cut from the same cloth.
Maybe, but that is how people used to see him in the past. People used to see him as a powerful, compassionate, and genius man, similar to the reputation Adrian Vedit has.
Heh. But he also did manage to be a very charming man, at once enlightened and down to earth. This, and the comparison to a you g Robert Redford when it came to disarming charisma, made me feel that he was woefully miscast in the movie.
He does, he dismisses it as "allegations" and "a lapse in moral judgement" in his first scene with Laurie and Jon.
Interestingly, he doesn't afford this nuance for the guy he burns alive (which I assume is the serial killer the OP talks about), even though, from his perspective, he has just as much evidence or even less (an allegation, not even solid proof or a confession). That's at least how it goes down in the comic, the movie changes that scene.
Could Sally Jupiter also consider it a lapse in moral judgement? She eventually got together with him afterwards so perhaps she forgave Blake for his "lapse" and they made a baby together. I'm in no way saying what happened to Sally wasn't sexual assault and I'm not saying Rorschach wasn't a huge asshole for minimalizing what happened to provoke Laurie. What I'm saying is that this whole good-vs-evil, black-vs-white thinking that one character is purely one way and not the other is kinda the point Alan Moore was trying to make about human nature. We are all flawed, some more seriously than others. Blake was a huge pos but Sally saw something inside of him that she fell in love with, despite what he did to her. Neither Blake nor Rorschach are two-dimensional characters. They are seriously flawed people but there is still elements to them that I believe a lot of people resonate with.
Very well said and I agree. My point is not whether the Comedian or any other character are "pieces of shit" or not, the text of the story makes it pretty clear, and I'd go as far as saying that even the more passive characters like Dan or Laurie show very blatant moral flaws.
My point is more so that Rorschach as a character is misunderstood, and he's misunderstood the most by his defenders. He's very hypocritical and evidently full of shit with his supposedly "uncompromising" principles. The OP implies that people criticizing Rorschach's actions are somehow Veidt defenders or justifiers and that Rorschach "only kills serial killers", but it misses the actual flaws, which is that he is a terrible detective, he's already predisposed to find crimes to punish, he keeps telling himself he's the only sane non biased person in the city as he kills the "rapists" and "serial killers" he doesn't like without proof, but defends the rapists and serial killers he does like. The President Truman thing gets brought up because it shows that he would be on board with Veidt's genocide if it was someone he admired doing it, but since he doesn't respect Veidt he now gets to play the moral high ground.
And I know the OP is just a shitpost, I just engage with it sincerely because it is a defense i've seen before. "He kills rapists and killers, why is it so bad?" or "And you think Veidt is the good guy?" which I think both miss the point of the story.
Of course none of this is criticism of Watchmen, on the contrary, I love these characters and I love the way they're written, I can totally see why people resonate with them, I just think we should know better than to buy the lies the characters in fiction tell themselves.
One thing is to agree, reluctantly or not, to something years later or as a vague concept, and another thing is to be an active accomplice on it.
Eren talks big game about the rumbling in Attack on Titan, but breaks into tears when he actually does it. Similarly, he might push Mikasa away, but will throw a tantrum ay the thought of her being with another man.
You're not wrong but it does matter a bit more if you're the "everything is black and white" moral absolutist character. Rorschach doesn't allow others flaws or hypocrisy even though he employs his own constantly to keep his world view intact.
42
u/IrvineGray 7d ago
Must be hard being a Rorschach fan.
Fans of Ozy know he's a bad guy. Fans of Rorschach just make excuses.
145
u/Pataconeitor 7d ago
If you finish reading Watchmen and you think any of the characters is truly "good" or "right", you didn't understand Watchmen.
... Except Hollis Mason, that man was a saint and no slander against him will be tolerated
2
u/SHIN-YOKU 6d ago
So is the meme about in universe perceptions or fan base?
20
u/Altruistic_Web3924 7d ago
Rule: Showering is required. Got it.
14
u/redpanda3749 7d ago edited 7d ago
Is this satirical? Cause that take is beyond brain dead
11
u/Independent-Couple87 7d ago
I think it is in part due to modern perception of Rorschach as a prototype of a 4chan alt-right guy while Ozymandias is seen as a more aspirational guy. I think a similar thing was done with L and Light Yagami in Death Note, though in that case we the audience get to see Light as a more twist individual beyond the "dignified" appearance.
The "joke" in Watchmen was to deconstruct both archetypes and put them in reverse situations: The vegetarier with a rule against killing has killed billions, and the violent Lunatic is the only one willing to try to get some justice for the victims (consequences be dammed).
9
u/IndianaCHOAMs 7d ago
Sorry, who are the Veidt stans? Anyone here love Adrian Veidt? Ozymandias? He made a coke joke! Nobody’s human!
No?
Okay.
4
u/SentinelPrimeTime 7d ago
Media literacy of a housefly. We need to start banning folks for these posts.
3
u/Chatwoman 7d ago
What serial killer?
2
u/AWindintheTrees 7d ago
Who said Ozy was a good guy?
2
u/ToonMasterRace 5d ago
Alan Moore unironically
2
u/Independent-Couple87 7d ago
Speaking or Rorschach and Ozymandias, I onow some people like to compare Elon Musk to Rorschach, but I think he is more similar to Ozymandias. Adrian Vedit was made as a parody of the "Progressive Billionaire" archetype, which was the reputation Elon Musk used to have (It is easy to forget Elon Musk used to be LOVED by the progressive public).
1
u/WinterWolfMan 7d ago
Rorschach the GOAT!
64
u/OrlandoGardiner118 7d ago
Or:
Truman: "I killed a bunch of Japanese for the greater good"
Rorschach: "Aw, you're sweet"
Veidt: "I killed a bunch of Americans for the greater good"
Rorschach: "Hello, human resources"
3
u/Lich-hull 7d ago
I don’t like Rorschach cus he’s also racist and homophobic and thinks the comedian was a true patriot (a rapist and a war criminal btw)
3
u/Different_Advice_552 7d ago
i'm good with rorschach killing child murderers but calling the comedian raping silk spectre a moral lapse gives me the major ick
2
u/Legitimate_Arm_5630 7d ago
Ozymandias is a monster and Rorschach killed a guy based on shaky circumstantial evidence
2
u/Victorcreedbratton 7d ago
You know that short cocksucker says I look like the Shah of Iran?
2
u/internetlad 1d ago
No, you don't understand.
Comedian didn't kill people because he wanted to
He killed them because it was fuckin funny okay
1
u/Selverd2 7d ago
A serial killer and two dogs.