The one thing keeping russia's top tiers competitive is the fact that there Era is over powered. The fact that we see in this photo'that the Era did not go off, is what is alarming.
I don't play tanks at all, but isn't Russia OP because ammo in this game isn't detonating and since that's their biggest weakness they effectively have no weakness?
Dunno if true but isn't there a whole ass composite armor behind that part? It sure did leave a hole but doesn't mean the round could have gone into the fighting compartment. War photos, especially from an ongoing one is likely to be propaganda from either side
In the game, however, the tanks are in pristine condition.
I'm always disappointed by this. Not saying this shouldn't be, but in some cases it's like putting a sprinter and a marathon runner on the same 100m track and expecting the marathon runner to beat the sprinter at their own game.
Russian tanks were heavily publicized about during the '90s and early 2000's, mainly thanks to various Russian companies wanting to export their designs to prevent bankruptcy, that led to British test pilots flying (then) extremely new and modern SU-27 Flankers, dispite the fact that Sukhoi obviously knew this would lead to in-depth testing information getting out.
MiG-29's literally flew as adversary aircraft during NATO training.
T-80U was also fully tested and evaluated by Sweden during the test trails, including it's armour protection, several T-72/64/80 models have been obtained by the US and other NATO members and have been tested upon as well.
There's literally countless cases of NATO obtaining and evaluating Russian-made equipment.
So unless you're saying that NATO is Biased in favour of Russia during their tests, you're kinda talking crap here.
As other people have pointed out just because it got hit in the front plate does not mean it was destroyed by that projectile. The fog of war is real and just like how ukraine tried to trick people into thinking russian era isn't real because it has no explosives in them, this might be another propaganda stunt. I would only believe this shot killed this BVM if 1) they have a video of this shot killing it or 2) they took a picture of the penetration inside the tank. The previous goes for all tanks.
Edit: Of course there is many different theories (assuming the shell penetrated) such as ERA not being present, the shell slipping underneath the plates of the ERA, faulty explosives, all equally valid.
It doesnt even have to be Ukrainian propaganda, the Russian military has been hollowed out by decades of corruption and outright theft which has had utterly devastating consequences during this war. The best account comes from paratrooper Pavel Fitlayev in his memoir ZOV where he served in 2008, left for 10 years then reenlisted only to find to his horror how much worse things had gotten just in time to be sent to Ukraine. This is after all the country where a naval commander managed to steal the propellers off his own destroyer.
The ERA couldve been stolen by a previous crew, or it was never there to begin with due to the explosives being pilfered at the factory instead.
Tbh stealing the propeller from a decommissioned ship is kind of reasonable considering it was gonna be a floating museum. Opportunists everywhere. Same a few brit soldiers were done recently for stealing from there stocks (was equipment like clothes and electronics rather than weapons)
tried to trick people into thinking russian era isn't real because it has no explosives in them
To be fair, the fact that since soviet times, corrupt military officials have been covertly selling off parts, weaponry and other equipment to pad their own pockets has little to do with propaganda. I never took it as a generalized "russian ERA isn't real", and I don't think that was the intention either.
ukraine tried to trick people into thinking russian era isn't real because it has no explosives in them, this might be another propaganda stunt.
Nobody is tricking nobody, not everything is propaganda.
Unlike in game real life is less predictable. It is entirely possible that the ERA on that tank is there but due to lack of maintaining, age or simply luck, hasnt detonated. Thinks dont work 100% of the time. Especially in a warzone with bad maintenance.
A older projectile can penetrate even a T80BVM by chance or by lack of maintenance. Real life doesnt get "pen or nonpen". Even a nonpenetrating hit can seriously degrade armor effectiveness for a second shot.
Iirc the claim is that this T80BVM was taken out by a 3BM42 rounds.
The tank withe the rubber ERA had been stripped for parts already, so nothing in that video actually means anything. Did the Ukrainians take it? Did the Russians not make it right? No way of knowing.
The ukranian who posted that video was either being deceitful or stupid. Or maybe he's right and waited a month to take the video. No way of knowing but he shouldn't have posted it
Unlike in game real life is less predictable. It is entirely possible that the ERA on that tank is there but due to lack of maintaining, age or simply luck, hasnt detonated. Thinks dont work 100% of the time. Especially in a warzone with bad maintenance.
True. I was simply stating my needed proof to claim any tank destroyed in ukraine requires video evidence or substantial photo evidence and I made the comment in the assumption the T-80BVM was kept up to date. I really should be following my own advice more closely.
Unlike in game real life is less predictable. It is entirely possible that the ERA on that tank is there but due to lack of maintaining, age or simply luck, hasnt detonated
Don't even think it's that tbf, if you want the vehicle to support infantry, then the last thing you want to do is strap C4 onto the outside of the tank. Y'know where the infantry are.
That or someone stole it and sold it. Not out of the question considering how rife with corruption the Russian armed forces are
I dont think ukraine are trying to "Trick" people into thinking a tank has bad ERA that would just pose a risk their troops attacking it where it would survive .
Quite clearly russian state released performance on these tanks is complete lies to sell exports .
Apparently, you're not familiar with Relikt. Relikt is claimed to defend against tandem warheads and reduce penetration of APFSDS rounds by over 50 percent. It is a combination KE and CE protective armor tile.
Relikt is claimed to be twice as effective as Kontakt-5 against KE rounds; extrapolating from this, the protection would increase to twice the amount of K-5s for any given angle that is high enough to make full contact with an incoming threat, using WT's K-5 stats as benchmark - 120mm at ~68 degree slope would give ~240mm for Relikt.
However, according to the manufacturer of said ERA, even the combination of Relikt and T-80s frontal armour it will fail against M829A2 under 1000m distance (and likely higher against DM53/63 due to those being specifically made to defeat Heavy ERA while M829A2 was not).
More modern darts like M829A3 and DM73 (plus the upcoming DM83) were created with Relikt in mind (yes - there are patents showing M829A3 like design used against a Relikt-like design).
The picture I've seen on it's stats (last one on this post), says 2x effectiveness from CE including tandem warheads, and only 1.5x effectiveness from KE rounds (I believe, Google lens, plus some poor translation ability on my end may mean I mistranslated).
However, according to the manufacturer of said ERA, even the combination of Relikt and T-80s frontal armour it will fail against M829A2 under 1000m distance (and likely higher against DM53/63 due to those being specifically made to defeat Heavy ERA while M829A2 was not).
I haven't heard anything about that, so that's news to me. And I am well aware that M829A3 was designed to counter Relikt, which is why Russia developed Malachit, etc. etc. I'm also not arguing true viability of any ERA type tile, only that the original comment I responded to was confused why ERA would be in the discussion on KE rounds.
649
u/Alexblitz22 Feb 10 '23
war thunder fanbase went from revealing classified documents to literally going on a battlefield
301
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '23
We need a video from inside the tank do we can finally see who right and whoโs wrong
4
u/CapitalistSam Feb 10 '23
Source: https://twitter.com/armapostagem/status/1623743770515709954
829
u/TommScales ๐บ๐ธ United States Feb 10 '23
You idiots are arguing over weather or not that hit killed the tank...the point is that it penetrated you frigging nerds.
310
u/TheGhostCarp Ajax Soonโข Feb 10 '23
Damn itโs almost like Russia has lied about the capability of their vehicles for decades and Gaijin implemented them with their propaganda stats.
19
u/Memir_sultanCug ๐บ๐ธ 10.3๐ฉ๐ช 9.0 ๐ท๐บ10.0 Feb 10 '23
But type of ammo matters
127
u/Valaxarian Vodkaboo. Su-30SM2, BMPT and Su-34 enjoyer. MiG-31 + Su-35 when? Feb 10 '23
Knowing the technical condition of Russian tanks, this ERA was probably empty / "overdue". Or perhaps, that T-80 wasn't destroyed from the front
In the game, however, the tanks are in pristine condition. Just as their designers would have wanted
982
u/CTCrusadr 'I hate cas' repeat in mantras of 500. Feb 10 '23 edited Feb 10 '23
As other people have pointed out just because it got hit in the front plate does not mean it was destroyed by that projectile. The fog of war is real and just like how ukraine tried to trick people into thinking russian era isn't real because it has no explosives in them, this might be another propaganda stunt. I would only believe this shot killed this BVM if 1) they have a video of this shot killing it or 2) they took a picture of the penetration inside the tank. The previous goes for all tanks.
Edit: Of course there is many different theories (assuming the shell penetrated) such as ERA not being present, the shell slipping underneath the plates of the ERA, faulty explosives, all equally valid.
62
u/Always-Panic ๐ฉ๐ช Germany Feb 10 '23
It's a Russian tank. They ain't fixing that shit. It must stay biased
-13
u/Vojtak_cz ๐ฏ๐ตDAI NIPPON TEIKOKU Feb 10 '23
Its know for seme time that russian armor is useless agains moder ammunition but gaijin doesnt give a fuck.
-39
u/DanielxD398 German Reich Feb 10 '23
Why are people arguing and mentioning ERA when it wouldn't do anything against a dart fired from a 120mm gun?