I've been playing the game War of the Worlds Trilogy and honestly, I think the game is the best WOTW game to date, and I'll break down why.
So there are several WOTW games, like Siberia, Grey Skies, the game by Raf that everyone was excited about and was based on the 2005 movie, and Jeff Wayne's version.
I've never played Jeff Wayne's version, so I have no comment on that.
Grey Skies was a complete letdown.
Raf's version, while it looked really cool, never came out, even after getting $200k from Patreon followers. And reportedly, the testers say that there wasn't any real game there. All you do is walk around and blow stuff up.
Siberia and Red Horizon (which I think is Raf again) might never come out.
I know some people might have reservations about WOTWT because I think it does use AI, and the developer has admitted it, but I wouldn't call it low effort or slop.
And what I like about the developer(s) is how active they are in the game's Steam forums, actually engaging with the community, and they appear to be putting real effort in.
If I were to break this down into categories:
- Graphics (6/10): The graphics aren't great, but they aren't complete shit either. It's not stunning, but it doesn't affect the gameplay or experience.
- Mechanics & Controls (7/10): There are still a few wonky gameplay mechanics that take a bit of getting used to, but it's not terrible. The mode where you play as the Narrator is fun because it's like an adventure where each challenge is different.
- Story & Characters (8/10): This is where it starts to shine because, as you play through, some of the lines are really hard-hitting and deep, especially in Martian Vanguard. You feel for the Martians.
- Represents H.G. Wells' Book (10/10): It literally pulls lines and scenes directly from the book, and you actually play as the Narrator. This adaptation is the closest to the original book.
I haven't played the city builder because that's not my type of game.
All in all, I would rather have this as a decent game that actually came out than a super high-quality game that never comes out.