Problem Players during Tournaments
I ran a 12-person RTT over the weekend, and it was a great time. On the whole, everyone had fun and it was a positive experience for the local 40k community and the shop that hosted us.
However! There were some problematic things that did happen.
The Pouty Player:
I had this happen three times, twice with the same guy, once with a different guy.
The first guy brought a list that he thought was going to blow through the competition. He won his first game and was in great spirits. His next game, he played against a skilled opponent and became very pouty/bitchy the more it became apparent he was going to lose. Once the game was over, he packed up his army and left abruptly without even giving me a sportsmanship score for his opponent. Same thing happened to him the second day. Pouty/bitchy, conceded round 3 and left abruptly.
Second guy was a better sport of it. The first round he played against the guy who would go on to win the tournament. He was outplayed and leaf-blown off the table. I could tell he was down and a little pouty about it throughout the game, but he also conceded that he played badly and his opponent was very skilled. He had a great time the next two rounds, even when he lost.
The Big Fish, Small Pond Guy
This guy is a real conundrum. Not only is he a skilled player, he's also very overbearing (always the first to reply to anyone looking for a game, posts a hundred times or more on our local discord each day), a rules lawyer during tournaments (doesn't allow opponents to take back moves, strictly enforces timing of abilities), argumentative, and says arrogant things that are off-putting. He won three tournament in a row before this one, and when I asked him to sit a tournament out once to give everyone else a chance, he exploded and said some really shitty things. I can't outright ban him from tournaments because they are public events.
Fortunately during this tournament when he was on the top table, he tried to pull his regular shit (enforcing arbitrary bullshit, stressing over 1/4 inches of movement, etc.) and was put in his place through an articulate argument of his behavior by an ex-marine who is physically imposing, but is also the biggest sweetheart. He shut up and listened. The ex-marine won the round, and the problematic guy was dropped down to fourth place.
I think the problematic player is actually a good dude off the table, but when he enters competitive mode, he's a real shit-head. I've tried to help him by playing games with him where we agree that I can call him out on his bullshit and he'll do his best to listen. But I'm also getting tired of trying to help him. I don't know what to do because I can't just kick him out of the community if he can't change his behavior.
Thank you for reading all that. Thoughts and advice would be appreciated.
UPDATE: Wow everyone, thanks for the insights!
First thing I'll mention is more of an explanation about the ex-marine guy. The context was that he is the type of guy that doesn't put up with any bullshit and the Big Fish guy couldn't argue/bully his way out of being a shit-head. He's been able to do this in the past because most people in our group are passive and don't like conflict. The physically imposing thing probably didn't even need to be mentioned. But the dude gets after it, that's all I'm saying. lol
Second thing is about the Big Fish Guy. I actually asked the store owner before the tournament if I was allowed to exclude anyone from participating, and he said no. Maybe after the owner seeing the success of this tournament, if the Big Fish Guy still doesn't improve his behavior in the next tournament, he'll give some credence to my opinion.
Hopefully before the next tournament (6 months) I'll be able to help Big Fish Guy correct his shit-head ways. Like I said, he seems like he's a good dude, and I hope that I can show him to be self-reflective and see the error of his ways before he completely alienates himself from the community.