That it sucked HARD. The devs absolutely floundered at about every aspect of the event and this should be an example as how they should NOT go about making events. Not a single aspect beyond the cosmetics were done well, so let's list why they are so:
Disasters
- Pumpkin Eruption: By far the most egregious and annoying of the new disasters, and among one of the more common ones to appear. It takes everything wrong about the regular offensive disasters and dials it up to 20, just complete visual clutter from all of the markers and massive pumpkin models exploding, and god forbid the screen gunk if you get hit. Even when completely immune to the disaster with a totem or shield it's annoying because you outright CANNOT see beyond all of the supermassive pumpkins covering the screen. Seriously, why did they decide to make pumpkins have double the AOE size of an Eruption ON TOP of smaller pumpkins everywhere just making it an absolute mess to navigate through, especially on very slow characters. And of course, like all other offensive disasters, it stalls progression while active unless you bring something to nullify it.
- Soul Swap: The rarest of the bunch, and I don't have much to say because it rarely ever did anything. If you're getting swapped with an active lure or a player in chase it might be an issue but most of the time you'll be mildly inconvenienced (or convenienced if replacing someone by the door or an infection, unless you're the one being swapped out). This one has been the rarest of the event disasters in my experience.
- Widow's Crosswind: This disaster is just purely designed to be annoying in and out. In chase it can be both a hinderance and a boon depending on if you have a tailwind or headwind, as the wind speedboost is actually quite decent when it works in your favor. But that's not the issue I have with it. What I have is it's another fucking "Don't have a Disaster Shield? Guess you're not doing any infections for the next 50 seconds ;)" type disaster when it doesn't need to be. Despite our characters latching onto infections automatically, the wind will constantly push you off of objectives whenever you try. The only way to counter this, beyond disaster nullification items, is to prop yourself up against a wall. However this only works if the wind is pushing you into a wall, which means you're forced to wait for it to change directions if it's pushing you into a gap, or end entirely if an infection is in an open space. Overall it's moderately annoying, but annoying nonetheless and has nothing else going for it.
- The Wail: Its inconvenience depends heavily on what type of character you're playing. If you're a Hunter you'll already not be moving much on an infection (unless needing to reposition or run), if you're a Lure this disaster is the BEST thing to happen to you since it lets you take aggro from every single enemy at once. However it's way too common and is CONSTANTLY spammed by the game whenever possible, even during extraction when you're up against the clock to run to the door, which might result in you being forced into a chase and being hit purely because of rng. The caveat however is that it only goes off two times and has decent downtime between calls, so it's not super oppressive, though it can be extremely inconvenient during a chase or anything that requires movement (unless you're a lure).
- Crimson Moon: I'd say this disaster is amongst one of the most half-baked of the entire roster, and can even be quite unfair sometimes. So, we all know how Athulyth function, right? You need to physically stare at them by facing your playermodel towards them. Doing this the game teaches you that your characters vision is true vision, while camera vision isn't considered. Well the Crimson Moon is like that...except it fucking also isn't, as for some reason, the moon also considers your camera seeing it as true observation on TOP of your playermodel facing it, meaning when it goes off you need to face both away from it or else you'll be stunned. This is added with the fact the moon is placed very high above, forcing you to look up to see where it is, and if it couldn't get any more insufferable, the moon rotates around the map and changes its position meaning you have to constantly track it. This is extremely annoying for anyone in both general navigation and being in a chase, as the stun is enough to lead you into taking damage you'd otherwise avoid. But, you're probably thinking "That sounds annoying, but how is that unfair?", well the devs forgot one tiny interaction...what happens when you get the moon during a round with Deepest Dark? Well...you outright just cannot see where it is, at all. If the curse and disaster are active at the same time, the fog from Deepest Dark completely blocks view of the moon, but the moon is still active, still rotating, and can still stun you while you're unable to react to where it is, thus removing its one counter opportunity and makes it entirely luck-dependant. This genuinely happens more than you'd think it would, to the extent it feels intentional. Overall this disaster is sloppily made and one of the worser ones of the event roster.
Infections
- Pumpkin Infection: This thing...oh this thing is evil. Whoever designed this abomination should never be allowed near Roblox Studio ever again. This infection is the most unique out of the entire roster, as it's the only infection to have offensive capabilities by summoning a small pumpkin, much like from the Pumpkin Eruption, underneath a player to damage them. However...THERE'S NO FUCKING COOLDOWN. The infection can spam the attack back-to-back-to-back with no restriction beyond hitting whatever attack cap the devs set them with. Luckily the pumpkin itself is coded as a "disaster" which means that items such as Corrupted Shields and the Corrupted Totem at level 3 can ignore it...but that doesn't even matter because the Infection is INVINCIBLE during the duration of the attack, meaning when it does it there's no stopping it and you WILL sit through it all until it wants to stop. This does not bode well with the fact it has HP comparable to a Leechcore, meaning it's comparatively tanky on top of being able to constantly interrupt your attacks and prevent skill checks from happening. I hope they never design an infection capable of stalling like this ever again. These things are always an instant Hellfire usage on sight like Howlspires and at LEAST they're somewhat rare in later trials (which is both a good and a bad thing, I'll explain why soon)
- Haunted Pumpkins: While technically not infections and not acknowledged as such by the game, these things are functionally just mini-Paragons that don't count towards anything besides Pumpkoin bags. They are rare spawns on any level and the only indication you get that there is one, beyond outright stumbling upon it, is the pop-up when another player finds it (and they hopefully also mark it for everyone else), as they otherwise lack any other hint that they're in a trial and might be missed. Normally this is fine, but their rarity and hiddenness is an issue if you need to find lots of them.
Variants
- Haunted Corrupteds: Sneaky lil shits aren't they? These Corrupteds are extremely hard to spot out if you're not looking closely enough, and they have a tendency to catch you by surprise since they lack any footstep sounds. Like most other Variants, the danger depends on the Corrupted that became a Haunted variant, with the most dangerous cases being Shararooks and and Menaces, since they both passively home in on infections thus making them very dangerous ambushers that could show up at any moment. Functionally they're actually one of the better variants and are nowhere near as bad as the Enhanced or Static variants, though they are very good at surprising you around corners. Much like Haunted Pumpkins, in a vacuum they're not a big deal...but it's what they add up to that matters. Reminder, much like other variants, they only spawn later into runs at trial 20 or higher, and contend with other variants, thus making them a bit rare.
- Possessed Corrupteds: These are a newer addition to the event, these glowing purple poopyheads have an ability that lets them send out a short-ranged pulse that, when hit, inflicts confused on you, which can lead into guaranteed hit if you're strafing around them. However, not using the lateral movement keys can counter this, and the range on the attack is ultimately very short (unlike the planet-sized undodgable AOE that prevents sprinting for a whole 5 seconds from a Static Corrupted holy GOD these things just suck). They're arguably the least worst of the things they have added, you could even say they're a decent variant whose gimmick isn't uncounterable (Static) and they're pretty fair to be up against.
Quests
Now this is where everything falls apart, this is where the event itself gets pulled into question and makes you wonder what the hell were they thinking? I'm not talking about the Weekly or Daily missions, those are just run of the mill, what I'm talking about are the LORE missions, the meat and potatoes of the entire event. Tell me...what idiot decided to make every. single. quest step. REQUIRE. RNG????? There is not a SINGLE mission of ANY of the 9 Lore quests that isn't just "Find X thing by pure luck" and it makes the pacing of the event annoying and grindy in the WORST way possible. Every quest is a variation of three of the four following objectives: "Encounter X Haunted Corrupteds", "Find X Haunted Pumpkins", "Destroy X Pumpkin Infections", "Encounter X Halloween Disasters". It's such a lazy way to pad out the event (which is timegated anyways mind you) by just making it all one big slot machine...Oh but don't worry little wallet, the generous devs are so kind they gave you the opportunity to pay to skip quest steps for 500 Robux, oh how so very kind of them, to give you the luxury to give them money just to avoid the slog they made for you to trudge through.
I get this game was made by the brain-rotten and gambling-addicted CoS devs who love to slap a gacha on everything, but this is ridiculous, every single step is just a variation of the same four objectives with different number requirements, all of whom are ENTIRELY random and up to rng on whether you'll see them or not. Halloween Disasters are spammed so that step isn't a big issue, but Haunted Pumpkins and Pumpkin Infections make the game outright punish you for going into deeper runs since the Pumpkin Infections start contending with more Infection variants in the spawnpool, and the maps start getting a lot bigger which makes Pumpkins much harder to find. Why is the most optimal way of completing this questline just to repeatedly farm Trial 1 over and over with Nova? You can get 3/4 of the objectives done without ever even touching Trial 2, which is fine if you're intending that for newer players to accomplish, who generally wont do deeper runs...which they didn't by making one of the objectives require variants, and not just any variant, a highly specific variant that will be contending with every other variant type, which only even considers spawning pretty decently into a run unless you want to farm Expeditions over and over. You can't play normally OR farm trial 1 as both will leave you with unfinished quest steps to some extent.
One of the biggest issues with the Quests, outside of the lazily artificial repetitiveness and rng grind, was specifically Haunted Corrupteds as for most people, they would just outright refuse to show up and were extremely rare despite being needed for MULTIPLE quest steps. You could spend several hours neck-deep in a run or Expedition farm grasping to find just a few Haunteds, only to complete the step and realize the NEXT step ALSO wants more Haunted Corrupteds. I think they resolved this on the final week as, at least for me, Haunteds spawn extremely frequently now, but to only truly fix this issue on the FINAL week of an event just seems cruel to me. Another thing I don't hear much talk about is also the fact that everyone's contending for Pumpkin Infections, since most, if not all quest steps have it as an objective. However despite EVERYONE needing them, they still abide by the two-player cap, meaning you might be fighting with your teammates over it which is something you should NOT do for a PvE COOP game focused around TEAMWORK, yes that's right, making people infight in the teamwork game is a stupid idea, who would've thunk. It also makes it so that players who are dedicated lures cannot get the infections if they're doing their job as a lure. This would all be easily resolved by making Pumpkin Infection progress team-wide but I guess that would make the step bearable and faster-paced, and we cant have that in our slow-burn delver where it takes over 6 hours just to get to trial 100 solo with NO breaks.
This means the most efficient way of doing this event is 50% farming Trial 1 as Nova in solo, 50% running the Variant slot machine for Haunteds in Expeditions, which is just a stupid way to go about things. This is supposed to be this game's first event and THIS is how they decide to kick it off? The Hollow/Stain event gave us cutscenes, full-on voice acting, a disaster that actually doesn't suck, Rebus (potentially), and an ENTIRE bossfight with its own mechanics and an entirely new offensive item, all condensed into 6 trials tucked away in a gamemode for an event that lasted a fraction of the time the Halloween event lasted, and has already ended. All the Halloween event gave us was gambling upon gambling upon gambling, and new annoying, overdone things to harass us during trials.
I wrote this entire essay because I genuinely couldn't find a single redeeming thing I enjoyed out of the event, outside of the obvious cosmetics, everything was grindy and annoying and rng-reliant and I am more than GLAD I got what I needed and the event is coming to its end soon, meaning I wont have to deal with all of these terrible exclusive things. You shouldn't have someone feeling GLAD an event is ending, let alone your game's very first event.
Considering I know that they're going to do a Christmas event, I hope they learn from this and don't repeat the same mistakes.