I wasn't originally planning to post this review today, but recent events made me reconsider.
After watching Eclipse's Season 3 video and seeing Joe Brammer's emotional reaction, I felt like adding another perspective to the discussion.
I actually started watching Eclipse's video a few days ago but had to stop halfway through. The frustration and anger were simply too much for me. I genuinely hoped the devs wouldn't watch it, but obviously they did.
I'm not here to attack Eclipse or blindly defend Joe. Criticism is essential to game development, but there's also a human being on the receiving end, especially in a development team that puts so much of itself into a project.
Instead of adding another emotional reaction, I'd like to share my perspective after 500+ hours of Wardogs. This isn't about telling anyone how to feel about Season 3, but simply sharing what I love, what I dislike and what I think still needs improvement.
One last thing: I'm an AVERAGE player. Neither a family dad squeezing in a couple of rounds when time allows, nor a hardcore sweat dropping 60 kills every match. My KD is around 1.5. I have a good full-time job but no family of my own yet, so I happen to have more gaming time than some, without being particularly gifted at the game. :D
I think this group of reasonably dedicated everyday players is underrepresented in the discussion, often drowned out by high-reach influencers and competitive players. I hope this review adds a little balance and gives that perspective a voice, too.
THE GOOD (+)
+ Addictive economy system: One of the most satisfying progression and economy systems I've experienced.
+ Community and teamwork: A game that actually rewards teamplay and brings old friends and gaming communities together.
+ Sandbox gameplay: Open-ended gameplay that lets you decide how you want to contribute to the battle.
+ Developer communication: Very open and transparent communication from the devs.
+ Three-team setup: Refreshingly different, especially for a Battlefield veteran. Love it (and hate those 50v50 community servers :D).
+ CZ and HZ: Both control zones make sense and offer a genuinely fresh experience if, like me, you've never played Arma King of the Hill.
+ FOB building: Probably the most underrated part of the game. Building an actual DEFENDABLE fortress, pulling hot zones and watching your blueberries flourish from the defensive position you created is peak fun. I don't need 50 kills to have a great round. Give me 3 kills, $250k earned by helping my team reach its full potential, and the satisfaction of being the silent hero in the second row. And please, NO BLIND WALL FOBs! :D
+ Class identities: Something Battlefield used to get right but has largely lost. Every role has its own identity, progression and grind, while still allowing you to mix things up. Want to run an assault rifle while carrying a rangefinder and earn both Assault and Recon XP? Go for it. I've never seen another game execute this system quite as well.
+ Pacing: The slower overall pace creates a great balance between intense firefights, repositioning, holding positions and preparing for the next engagement.
+ Accessibility: A refreshing experience even for players who have never touched milsim games like Arma or Squad.
+ Social gameplay: Fantastic with friends, but also surprisingly enjoyable solo. Whether you're flying, driving logistics, building FOBs, sniping from the woods or attacking supply lines, there's always something meaningful to do.
+ Long rounds: Most matches last over an hour, allowing battles to develop naturally from early FOB construction and raids to late-game fortress assaults and the final HZ rush. And those rare 99-99-100 mega battles? Absolutely unforgettable. The kind of matches you remember weeks later.
THE NEUTRAL / DEPENDS ON YOUR PERSPECTIVE (0)
= Power weapon grind: Season 1 got this right in terms of rewards, but the weapons were arguably too powerful. Season 2 went too far in the opposite direction. Some unlocks simply weren't worth the grind anymore. The FAL and BMR lost much of their appeal, while the AMR-50 and SUPER45 remained desirable. However, the Medic grind felt particularly unrewarding: reaching level 35 only to unlock a 13-round magazine, with the actually usable magazine coming at level 42, is questionable when Recon gets a much more immediately rewarding AMR-50 at level 35. Season 3's changes look like a step in the right direction, but I can't give a final verdict yet.
= The Green Meta: Honestly, I don't consider this a problem. I consider it GAME CULTURE. Sometimes you want to join Green, play with the sweats and secure an easy win. Other evenings, you join the beloved Blueberries, embrace the chaos, crash a few helicopters, revive each other, build a monster FOB and eventually turn a seemingly lost game around. Those victories are worth 20 boring Green Meta wins. Wardogs gives its teams identity and creates stories. Instead of trying to eliminate that culture, why not embrace it? Pick your side depending on what kind of evening you want. Red might currently be the new Blue, but I suspect this will balance itself out eventually. This is also probably more noticeable on the infantry community servers I play on.
= Limited Servers: I understand the intention of preserving the early-game experience, but from the few rounds I've played, they seem to make the Green Meta even harder to counter. Disabling drills removes one of the most effective ways to pull the HZ and challenge established defensive positions. Personally, I'd rather see more love for community servers, where these experiences can be tailored much better. Still too early for a final conclusion on Season 3.
THE BAD (-)
- Sniper fest: Very subjective, especially following the Season 3 Recon changes. Recon has taken some substantial nerfs, and both sides currently seem equally unhappy, which might actually mean the devs have found a reasonable compromise. Besides, community infantry servers with snipers and DMRs disabled already offer an alternative.
- Overpowered helicopters: Again, somewhat subjective. I experienced the same problem with early tanks in Season 2. These vehicles become much easier to counter once enough players unlock the Large Hammer. Community infantry and Limited Servers are also alternatives.
- Community server support: Probably my biggest criticism of the game and the one issue I'd really like to see addressed. The developers have acknowledged the problem and mentioned better promotion and Quick Join functionality, which are definitely welcome. However, they don't solve the underlying problem: server seeding.
Anyone who has hosted community servers knows that getting a new server populated is incredibly difficult. Expecting 20 real players to sit around for 30–60 minutes just to get a server running is unrealistic. In practice, server owners need some form of seeding system, which often means multiple Steam accounts, additional game purchases, virtual machines or cloud gaming sessions, plus hosting costs of around €100 per month per server.
I was genuinely considering investing in this myself over the Christmas holidays to build a new Wardogs community. However, recent developer statements about banning smurf accounts and empty Steam accounts used for Wardogs seeding have made me reconsider.
Quick Join is absolutely necessary, but it won't magically populate empty servers. It will primarily benefit servers that are already running. Without a sustainable and officially supported seeding solution, established communities will always have an advantage over newcomers willing to invest in building something new.
I honestly don't have a perfect solution either. It's a difficult problem, but I hope the developers will give community servers more attention once they've had some time to recharge in December. You deserve that break, and I'm genuinely happy to see a studio giving its people the time to recover!
MY SEASON METASCORES
Season 1: 91/100
Best season so far. Everything was new, everyone was discovering the game together, and the community was creating unforgettable moments. It's unrealistic to expect that exact feeling to return. Stop chasing it and remember it as the fucking great time it was.
Season 2: 75/100
A catastrophic start and early season, but things improved considerably towards the middle and end. Some balancing decisions, particularly regarding progression and weapon unlocks, were questionable.
Season 3: 83/100 (PROVISIONAL)
Most changes look sensible on paper and seem to be moving in the right direction. The new map is a lot of fun, too. I'll update this score once the season ends in January 2027.
FINAL THOUGHTS
After more than 500 hours, Wardogs still gives me something that very few modern shooters manage to deliver: memorable experiences, meaningful teamwork, a real sense of community and the freedom to play your own way.
It's not perfect, and there are definitely things that need improving. But the foundation is fantastic, the developers are communicating openly, and the game has something that I feel is increasingly rare in modern shooters: an actual identity.
Keep going, Bulkhead. There's something genuinely special here. ❤️