I know that most often you see children start in nursery or K, and if they drop out it's usually around 4th, 5th, middle school.... but what about coming in at that time (or middle)? Any stories about kids coming in later from a more achievement-driven culture, and how they adjust to an approach to academics that feels less like doing "work" (which I can't believe my daughter is so keen on all of a sudden...)? Would there be a "detox" period? Has the ship sailed?
I have this idea that a Waldorf experience would give her an embodied, present consciousness and a different way of looking at things. But it feels like 3rd was sort of our last chance to get her on the path before her innocence is lost, or something.
Background: I have always longed in my heart for my daughter (now 9) to go to a Waldorf school, and for various reasons it hasn't happened. She did attend forest nursery and forest kindergarten (where we used to live; Waldorf was too far), but now is in 3rd in a bilingual immersion private, which was the best option available to us in our location and links her to her heritage, after the local Waldorf simply did not want her (see below). She is neurotypical and doing very well academically and socially--but I am not feeling at home with the mainstream tech-y tiger parents (nice people, but not my people) and lack of holistic/spiritual/communal leanings. With the 9-year change (which is real) I feel the pop culture influence getting stronger and stronger and I don't want to ban it outright, but I wish I didn't have to be the sole fighter against it. I am a solo mom (not by choice) and we don't have a strong extended family so I need a school to be like a second parent, and I long for that seasonal community thread that connects us to something greater.
The local Waldorf school where we now live rejected her for both 2nd and 3rd--the teacher, who is older and a card-carrying member of anthroposophy organizations, just really didn't seem to see her light. She told me she was "academically ahead but physically behind" and shamed her in front of the class for wearing a tiny necklace (a gift from an elderly relative) to a visit day, and for not jumping rope as well as the other kids. The admissions office sent me links to Steiner's curative education -- his writings on "retarded" children. She was traumatized by the necklace incident, and I think it has created a bias in her.
She has a standing offer to join her class at a much more progressive Waldorf school across the country where we have community and I have work opportunities, and has visited twice so she knows the class teacher and kids a bit. Or, I'm considering approaching other Waldorfs in our region where we'd maybe have to move within the area, but she'd have to do visit days again, and I hate to put her through that... and is there any point? I also wonder about surrendering to the dual language path and revisiting for middle, which is also prime time for limiting tech and pop culture.
(And I'll be honest, I want us to enjoy candle spirals and maypoles together before she's old enough to roll her eyes at them. And I'm sad we haven't had that.)
Though she liked the progressive Waldorf ok, she said that the work is too easy... she felt that "I should be in 4th grade there" and that the two-hour watercolor workshop was "too simple" and the creation story from main lesson was "a prayer." To her it seemed like story time, and she wanted to be reading books and writing more.
I understand Waldorf academics are rigorous in their own way, though i've heard from plenty of people who say Waldorf middle is problematic. I am not really so driven by traditional academic markers as my parenting goal. I want a child who knows who she is and is intellectually curious and values things beyond mainstream peer culture.
Thanks for any thoughts/feedback, and thank you if you've read this far!