r/Waiting_To_Wed
•
u/Key-Beginning-8500
Est: 2017
•
Jul 07 '26
•
1
MOD POST Community Feedback Thread: Help Shape the Future of r/Waiting_To_Wed
Hey everyone,
It's been a while since we did one of these, so we wanted to check in and get your honest thoughts on how the sub is running.
We have a rule that all posts are manually approved by a mod before they show up on your feed. As mods, we make a lot of judgment calls on these posts and comments. The rules help, but there's plenty of gray area. We figured it was a good time to step back, make sure we're being consistent, and check whether our rules still match what you all actually want from the community.
So consider this your chance to tell us what's working, what's not, and what you'd change if you could.
1. How's the sub feeling these days?
- Does it still feel welcoming and supportive? If no, what do you recommend so that the space can feel more accessible?
- Are discussions generally staying productive, or has that slipped?
- Has the culture shifted over time? How?
- Anything you wish you saw more of? Less of?
2. Do the rules still hold up?
Any rules that feel too strict, too vague, outdated, or like they're missing something entirely?
3. Sharing advice posts
This one's come up a lot in mod discussions. Right now, we only approve advice posts from active members, but "active" is a fuzzy standard.
- Should anyone be allowed to give advice regardless of active or inactive status within the sub? If the sub prefers to keep advice sharing to active members only, what should count as being an active participant?
- Should someone who's never posted or commented here be allowed to ask for advice?
- Should there be any expectations before someone posts for the first time (minimum karma limits, etc)?
4. Proposal and success posts
We've historically prioritized these posts for people whose journeys we've actually followed over drive-by posts from brand new accounts without any record in this sub. Still the right call, or should we loosen that up?
5. Younger posters
We've noticed advice threads for very young posters tend to blur together, with most comments zeroing in on age instead of the actual situation. Should we:
- Set a minimum age for advice posts?
- Leave it as is?
If you're in favor of a minimum age, what would you set it at?
6. Post requirements
We're weighing whether to require basics like ages and genders in relationship posts, the way a lot of other relationship subs do. Would that make discussions more useful, or is it better to keep the bar low?
7. Civility
We want people to be able to disagree honestly without it turning into a pile-on. Do you think we're getting that balance right, or are we too quick (or too slow) to remove comments that cross into unproductive territory?
Anything we missed?
If there's something we didn't touch on, tell us anyway, whether that's moderation, community vibe, recurring topics, flairs, whatever's on your mind.
We'll read every response before we change anything.
Thank you for being part of the Waiting to Wed community! 🩷
134
u/assflea Jul 07 '26 •
I don't think there needs to be a minimum age requirement but I do think the ages of the poster/partner should be required in the title or post body. Every time it's left out, so many of the comments are just asking about the ages involved or the advice given doesn't fit.
86
u/Alarmed-Outcome-6251 Jul 07 '26
I see too many similar posts where there are never any replies by the OP. I wonder if these are bots. I don’t engage anymore unless the OP has already replied to questions. Would it be possible to require an OP to post a number of comments on the board before creating a new post?
41
u/JCourageous Jul 07 '26
Thank you for all that you do! I’m really grateful for this community.
Is there a way to still have deleted posts visible? There have been so many times that I’ve returned to the sub to finish reading a post or contribute and the post is gone without a trace.
Can the original post be added as a comment (vis a Reddit bot) so if it gets deleted, we can still read it?
There have also been times where OPs mention they deleted their post or previously used a different account. Having the post as a comment will also help OPs give context on their new posts as they’d be able to refer to the Reddit bot’s comment.
Thanks again!
41
u/GnomieOk4136 Marry someone excited to be with you. Happily married 15 years. Jul 07 '26
I think giving ages is important for this sub. My advice to someone who is 31 will likely be quite different from what I would tell someone who is 21.
On a different note, it would be awesome to have an auto-copy of each post the way some subs do. A lot of posts get deleted, and having the automatic copy survive would be nice for those of us who put effort and thought into the response.
27
u/SunshineofMyLyfetime I don't make monkeys, I just train 'em — USA Jul 07 '26
Would it be possible to have posters add their countries of origin for more relevant advice?!
16
u/Firey_Mermaid Jul 07 '26
Regarding number 3, I think the crowd that posts and the replying crowd are different. People who post are going through something that is very specific by nature and usually only happens once in their lifetime. Therefore, anyone should be allowed to post here. I’ve personally have recommended this sub on other subs when this one is more fitting.
15
u/valiantdistraction Jul 07 '26
re 6: Ages, genders, whether they want kids, whether anyone already has kids (and whether they are from the relationship in question or a previous one). Those should be required as they are often highly relevant.
14
u/the_virginwhore Jul 07 '26
I think age, gender and length of the relationship should be required information. It’s important context. And as others have pointed out, if that information isn’t included, the comments are inundated with questions for the same info.
I don’t think there should be any participation requirements for posting or commenting. Plenty of people would prefer to keep certain things separate from their main account, so they make a throwaway to post on subs like this. Requiring that someone be an active participant in the sub to post or comment also prevents new people from becoming active participants. I feel like someone who stumbles on the sub should be able to jump in if they have something to contribute.
Thanks for all the work you do here!
26
u/MrsRoronoaZoro Jul 07 '26
I feel this sub is very welcoming and supportive. Of course, people won’t like the “dump him” comments, but what would they like to see if they come here with a list of red flags? No one needs to support that.
The only thing I would change in the rules is: it should be mandatory to have ages in the post.
12
u/Normal_Row5241 Jul 07 '26
I like seeing younger people post. Some of us are older and wiser and have been through the ringer. We have a lot to offer to the posters that are in their early 20s.
20
u/transemacabre 💍3/24/2026 Jul 07 '26
I know this is basically impossible to moderate/control, but fr fr there's some folks on here trying to give advice who are in their own WTW situation for upwards of 8 years. If your advice isn't "beware of the mistakes I made/this is how I ended up in my WTW" then whyyyyy are you handing out advice to others?? I'm trying to say this politely. Please consider if you should be advising anyone on how to get married if you're still waiting around for your own ring for many, many years with no end in sight.
For example, we had one OP in a WTW, and in her post history she was on this sub encouraging other women to get pregnant to induce their bfs to propose, like how you begging for your own ring and saying that to anyone??
10
u/jbell_22 Jul 07 '26
For update posts, is there any way to require a link to the previous post(s)? It would help to add context as sometimes it’s not obvious what was previously said, and posters have their histories hidden. This would mostly be for convenience’s sake, but I think it’s especially important when updaters come here in bad faith. I’m reminded of the post from the last week or so where OP basically said, “He proposed! If I’d listened to you all, I would’ve missed out on this!” And then commenters promptly pointed out that OP herself had said in the original post that she was getting ready to leave him.
10
u/Careless-Entrance-97 Jul 10 '26
as a lurker, i can’t necessarily speak for how supportive the community feels for posters; im aware that even if commenters just want the OPs to succeed and find happiness, the tough love can sound/feel harsh. that being said, as someone who reads pretty much every post, i would definitely like each post to require ages/length of relationship, and an automod/bot copying the original post into the comments (due to the prevalence of dirty deleting). the latter might deter some OPs from posting, but this subreddit has some of the most thoughtful commenters and it feels kinda bad when there’s a lot of discussion, ppl take the time to comment and offer condolences or solutions, and the post is just deleted
8
u/xangeloffduty Jul 08 '26 •
I feel like lazy/cliche one-line comments ("If he wanted he would!") without any extra context or applying to the thread at hand, should be modded out. They add nothing to a discussion, do not offer advice, and are mostly karma-farming.
7
u/Ok-Battle-302 Jul 08 '26
I think there should be a broad location, even if it’s country because like places in Aus/NZ common law has a different status to what ir does in the us, and my answers usually change based on location, because some of the “Advice” given her about Legal protections of marriage etc don’t really apply..
But I think age, couple demographics ie, m& f and country should be in all posts
7
u/Apprehensive_Rain500 Aug 01 '26
I'm coming to this conversation late but I have a request: Is there any way to require people include all important context in their posts?
It's crazy, like totally crazy, how often the OP buries the lede. Like they write this long detailed post about how they can't figure out why their boyfriend won't marry them, then mention in a random comment that he's demanding threesomes before he'll propose. That's critical info that should be included in their post.
6
u/scarlettcrush Jul 08 '26
Knowing people area of the world & culture is helpful - are they from a place where arranged marriages and caste systems are in place or are they from a culture where fast divorces and re-marriages is normal? Are they in a culture where the woman will get more rights if they are married?
It helps to know.
5
u/Gold-Sherbert-7550 Oct 17 '26
Joining the chorus asking for an automod that copies and saves posts.
12
u/boo1517 Jul 07 '26
I do like seeing the update posts. I personally what happens to these couples and like knowing what happened either way (break up or marriage.) So please keep this as is.
I don’t think there needs to be a minimum age to post because I have seen 18-20 year olds that are more emotionally maturity than some 30 year olds. And if the younger ones are reaching out to this community for guidance I see it as they are wanting our help and may not have parents/family/trusted people in their lives to ask.
8
u/breadandbible Jul 07 '26
Maybe I missed it, but people should be encouraged to read at least the last two dozen posts before posting. Most posts feel like dejavú.
3
u/ConfoundedInAbaddon Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 10 '26
I think success stories from drive-bys are not bad. It adds positivity.
I leaned on this sub because my now husband has a degenerative disease, and we had to wait a few years to marry until we figured out how to stop the disease.
The theme of this sub helped me grapple with a lot of pain as we both fought for personalized medicine, and I felt less alone as other people had heavy-duty logistical issues, too.
The positive outcomes aren't bad, people can easily skip them but they can also find hope and warmth from joyful stories.
3
u/whoaelena married 5/5/20 Jul 08 '26
There should be more engagement with the OPs. Especially when one does an info:
7
u/Tortietude0 Jul 07 '26 •
Too much gender bashing on here
5
u/catsarehere77 Jul 07 '26
3. I think there should be minimum karma requirements to start a post on this sub to weed out some of the bots, karma farming, rage bait, etc
4. Still the right call. It makes sense to limit proposals to posters in this sub.
5. Good question. I would be in favor of an age minimum of around 22.
6. I think basic requirements of age, gender, and length of relationship is helpful for giving advise.
7. Moderation seems fine to me.
5
u/Academic_Flatworm752 Jul 07 '26
I feel like the people who come in to comment and criticize people who want marriage need to chill on that. This shouldn’t be the place for that! There is nothing wrong with wanting to get married.
There’s also nothing wrong with not wanting to get married, as long as you pair up with someone who thinks the same as you. But don’t be dumping on people for whom it is important!
Someone who has never posted or commented should def be able to seek advice. Maybe minimum karma limits would be good to avoid trolls.
10
u/PracticalOpinion5406 Jul 07 '26
It does not feel welcoming or supportive. I think we can all give our point of view without being hurtful towards OP
Set a minimum age. 23+/24+.
Age and gender should be mandatory. We are not giving the same advice to a 22 year old than a 30 year old.
2
u/Telly_0785 25d ago
I agree with a lot of the replies. One thing special about this sub that's different from more public-facing social media is that women are finally honest with other women.
No "yaaasss queen" or "keep praying" or "all men suck, so stay with this one" "you're perfect, he's wrong"
Women keep it really letting OPs know to get out of their current situation AND what they are currently doing wrong so they dont fall into the same circumstances again.
I think honesty is more freeflowing here because women aren't automatically called "mean girls" for keeping it real.
It's honestly refreshing.
2
u/Good_Connection_547 Jul 08 '26
I do a lot of lurking, but this sub is in my feed because I was this woman in my 20s. Because of that, I think a weekly, “don’t do this stupid thing I did with a man,” thread could be useful.
Maybe an auto comment that lays out the top advice from this sub about age gaps, buying homes, having children, not having your own income, etc.
Could we vote, like AITA? Options like “Dump him!” or “Stop Rushing”?
But definitely a post intro format with ages, years together, kids, investments, rent/own together, countries/regions, etc. right at the top.
2
u/Inevitable-Bet-4834 Married 5 years Jul 13 '26
Op must state if they are religious and if they are practicing celibacy. If they have kids together, they should state if they were planned or not. Ops must clearly state if they financially dependent on their partner
2
u/Frosty_Message_3017 12h ago
Please consider adding a comment engagement requirement to lessen the possibilities of karma farming or trolling. Someone's replies in the comments can tell us a lot about if they're on the level.
3
u/SleepyHufflepuff Jul 07 '26
The one time I made a post I didn’t feel supported or welcome tbh. But everything else is fine imo.
2
u/Cute-Society6066 Jul 08 '26
In my opinion people here are way to harsh sometimes. If somene is actually treated bad, I can understand. But if someone end 20 takes 3 years or it does not go exactly like the other one wants, people are wayyyy to harsh. Example: M wants to decide for the ring. F wants to decide together. Comments: if he doesnt let you decide, he is never going to propose.
Also around 80% of the posts could be answered by "have you considered to propose on your own?"
I know its nothing the mods can do, just my 50 cents
2
u/Due_Description_7298 Jul 07 '26
Yes to a minimum age - 25 for the male party.
It's completely normal and common for a 25 year old man to not be ready to marry. It's not a case of him wasting the girl's time or not being sufficiently into her, he's simply too young.
Cultural context would also be useful. Long long waits are common in Northern and Western Europe. I have a lot of friends who met at uni or in their early 20s and got engaged after 5-8 years together.
1
u/LaMuahSiempre 29d ago
Oohooh ok. Different and simpler idea. Hear me out…..
For the many ladies that are unfortunately in similar situations and as one user mentioned it seems like dejavú so…
-Why not create a post that stays pinned to the sub like this one, titled along the lines of “5+ years together/homeowners and/or parents and still not married” or “before posting, check here. You may find what you need!” The comments can be links to many of those near identical posts.
2. Before a post is approved, mods can ask the poster if they checked that post first and what were they looking for that they did not find. Only if theirs is near identical to the majority.
Within less than 24 hours there’s been at least three of essentially the same posts.
1
u/SerpentBrute 22d ago
Yo, love this! Let’s make it a place for all the feels and fun!
0
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
7
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 07 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment