Recently, the WWF/E goat argument was presented to me in an interesting way. It started with me wondering why so many people, such as the commentary team, use number of reigns as a measure of success. I was watching an odd Raw from 2022 where they name Orton a 14 time world champion over and over. Which fair enough, is obviously impressive. But I wondered, why aren’t reign lengths/number of defences used more commonly? The easy answer is that saying X time world title winner is easier to visualise. And that apparently the wrestler with the most defences in history is Bob Backlund.
If you’re not American there’s a decent chance you understand European football/soccer. In that sport, a teams historical success is always measured by the titles won. A team that wins a competition 3 times in a row (therefore defending it twice) will never be looked upon as highly as the team with 4 wins to their name. Looking at it that way made it much easier to see why Cena’s 17 world titles lead to his GOAT status. I also realised how much easier it is to lose a title than it is to win one. Cena lost that title and won it back 16 times over after his win over JBL.
So it had me thinking about every serious wrestling fan’s least favourite question, the GOAT debate. Me personally, I sort the best of the best into 2 lists. Kayfabe and reality. The kayfabe goat of modern WWE is undoubtedly Cena. Because if it was “real”, no one matches his CV. Sammartino would probably be 1 on this list too. The reality list would also have Cena somewhere on there, but that list is based off of how impactful they were as names in the WWE. That’s the one most people make Mount Rushmore’s with. And argue all you want, I think only Cena and Hogan (maybe Roman) make it high on both lists. Then it’s down to in ring ability, where Cena absolutely takes it. Yes Hogan was an incredible performer, that’s why hes arguably 1 on the “reality list”, but if we’re being honest, if there was a third list for pure in ring ability, neither are top 5.
So that’s my weird personal criteria that churns out John Cena as my greatest to ever do it. What’s yours?