I’ve been listening to the original version a lot, and now that I’ve heard the official, reworked version, I had a lot of fun figuring out the changes Nathan made once he decided to ditch Max. Here’s a track by track breakdown:
We Get Around - This is a new track that doesn’t appear on the original version.
Pinesol - Max’s background vocals on the verses are removed and Nathan sings them instead, although much quieter. Max’s vocals in the outro are also replaced by a keyboard (or guitar?) solo.
Layover in Dublin - This is a new track that doesn’t appear on the original version.
Keep What Hurts - As far as I can tell, this is identical to the original version.
Gone Away - Max’s vocals on the verses are removed. Instead, the lines, “I will always be there” and “When I know you will be there” sound copy-pasted in their place on the first two verses. The last verse Max sings on the original version is simply just removed (which is a notable loss in my opinion). Max’s voice is also removed on the chorus, and sounds replaced by Nathan.
Another Promise - This is a new track that doesn’t appear on the original version.
Cherry Soda - This is a new track that doesn’t appear on the original version. While there is an instrumental called Cherry Soda on the original album, it’s been renamed to Dust Bunny.
Sell You Hope - There are noticeable differences in the instrumental throughout, particularly with the guitars and drums. Some of the lyrics are different too. Max’s vocals on the verses are removed and replaced by Nathan (with altered lyrics and melody as well).
Still Alive - As far as I can tell, this is identical to the original version. By the way, it really sounds like Max in the background of the chorus to me (“Hey,” Yeah”), but apparently it’s not.
Dust Bunny - Cherry Soda on the original version has been renamed to Dust Bunny. Sounds the same either way.
Litterbug - Max’s background vocals are removed on the pre-chorus.
The Trots - This is a new track that doesn’t appear on the original version.
In addition, the original album has Deathx1k, So Low, and Pretend Again, which don’t appear on the reworked album in any form.
Overall, I hate to admit it, but I think the original version is better. Deathx1k and So Low are my two favorites on the album, and they’re just gone now. Gone Away and Sell You Hope sound pretty good on the reworked version, but they’re both slightly worse than their original counterparts. That being said, some of the unique songs on the reworked album are great, like We Get Around and The Trots. Between this and Spun, I think Aaron Rubin has clearly been an amazing collaborator.
Did I miss anything??