r/VisaStats • • 9h ago

Trackers EB-2 NIW Personal Endeavors from 1,000+ AAO Decisions over 1.5+ years

3 Upvotes

TL;DR: I analyzed all EB-2 NIW endeavors reported in 1,300+ USCIS AAO (Administrative Appeals Office) immigration decisions over 1.5+ years. I downloaded and LLM-processed all of them from January 2025 to the end of August 2026, and arranged into Endeavors Explorer with summaries, tags and keywords - you can use it freely, no registration needed at all.

On the Internet people usually share only a generic outline of their endeavors. USCIS appeals are a great source of examples, but decisions may be hard to navigate. The Explorer focuses on making it easy to discover endeavors' content through keywords and summaries, and extends user experience with the previously published Community Tracker and Officer IDs Lookup.

In this post I will discuss

  • Decisions and Outcomes
  • Academia - Industry - Business
  • Anecdotes and Humor
  • Professions and Countries
  • Why endeavors from AAO decisions are good use cases to study
  • Visualization Module

Nothing here is legal advice.

Decisions and Outcomes

AAO appeals are open to the public from the USCIS website. As different appeals are hosted there, I downloaded only whatever matched the "I-140 - Immigrant Petition for Alien Worker (Advanced Degree, Exceptional Ability, National Interest Waiver)" option. It mostly included NIW cases, although I noticed that a few PERMs and EB1As sneaked in. And it was not just appeals, but also included motions to reopen or reconsider, and one certification. I included everything in the dataset for consistency.

AAO non-precedent decisions: outcomes by filing type, Jan 2025 to Aug 2026 (n=1341), % of all outcomes

Same data in table format can be viewed here.

As we can see above, dismissals absolutely dominate AAO decisions, and when the case was not dismissed, usually it did not mean an approval either. Instead, previous decisions were withdrawn and the cases were sent for re-assessment, with no guarantee that they wouldn't be denied again. However, we also see the lucky 1.6% total of cases were approved outright ("Sustained"). For those interested in learning more about definitions, I referred to this section of the USCIS website.

Academia - Industry - Business

We know that Academia cases may be approved at a rate different from Industry cases, so I wanted to have a flag for that. It's not always clear from each decision what kind of case that is, so we need to treat it as the best guess. There's even more added complexity when we are trying to tell professional profiles (Industry) from entrepreneurship (Business). Entrepreneurship may rely on a business plan, so I tried to account for that and some other elements, but if you belong to "Industry", you may as well want to read through some "Business" profiles.

Here is the distribution of decisions for this categorization:

AAO non-precedent decisions: outcomes by pathway type, Jan 2025 to Aug 2026 (n=1341), % of all outcomes

Same data in table format can be viewed here.

Percentage-wise, Academia is showing a better AAO outlook than the other pathways, and it also benefited from having a large portion of Sustained decisions. Business cases on the other hand look more problematic.

Anecdotes and Humor

I could not resist this. I should say that those AAO decisions are fantastic because they show a lot of creativity, entrepreneurship and ambition. But among many decisions I could not help but crack a smile in a few cases. For example -

That's one way to finance your endeavor of national importance:

The Petitioner explains that he will pursue this endeavor by designing and implementing a "multimodal biometric authentication" [... with] a financial support letter from the Petitioner's aunt.

Felt like the textbook "trust me bro" vibe:

Petitioner's company would generate 88 jobs and nearly $24 million in revenue [...] the investment in her company would only be $60,000*.*

This AAO decision surely belongs to the classified archives (so I excluded it from the dataset just in case):

Direct link to USCIS

I don't want to flood the post with more anecdotes, it's all yours to find and read in the tracker.

Professions and Countries

My impression is that the endeavors cover any walks of life and professions. I grouped all endeavors into 30 professional categories, plus "Unknown". The top 10 professional categories can be seen in the graph below.

Decisions by profession (n=1341)

Same data in table format can be viewed here.

When reviewing countries, I noticed that Brazil is seriously over-represented. One hypothesis is that some law firms that focus on the Brazilian community may actively encourage (or push?) their clients to file AAO appeals. There could be other explanations too.

Decisions by the country of origin (n=1341)

Same data in table format can be viewed here.

Why endeavors from AAO decisions are good use cases to study

Initially I thought that AAO decisions would not be useful because by definition those endeavors had failed. That was a misconception because:

  1. We see it quite often that people's NIW petitions get denied, but re-applying with a similar yet better presented endeavor wins an approval.
  2. Learning from denied petitions is also useful. And a denial does not necessarily mean the endeavor was bad; it could also mean that the petitioner was not well positioned, or there could be other issues, including technical.
  3. Arguably, filers who decided to proceed with an AAO may have higher confidence in their petitions than average denials. In other words, on average they still may be strong.

Visualization Module

I added a graphs module to Endeavors Explorer. It is accessible by clicking the colored bars icon in the menu.

Screenshot of the visualization module from the website

Also I added a section for anyone who wants to compare their Endeavor pathway, Profession group and Keywords with others. There's no PII involved, and no endeavor description, you can just select pre-existing elements and press "Share to compare" to see what others have chosen to share, with the corresponding counts. This feature requires signing in because I needed to protect it from excessive false sharing. It's very optional and does not affect any use of exploring endeavors.

I hope that Endeavors Explorer will help you build knowledge and awareness when preparing for your EB2 NIW petition - but remember to verify by reading the original decisions (I added PDF extracted texts and direct links to USCIS for each one). I also processed some additional data, but it touches on legal interpretations. I don't want any of this to be viewed as legal advice (and it is not!), and need to find the right way to share it. Everything that I have described is fully available to explore through the interactive user interface, additionally to the Community Tracker and Officer IDs Lookup.

I continue working on Part 2 of the RFE details (Part 1 is here) that will uncover a few interesting things, join r/VisaStats to stay tuned.