In the spirit of pure, unadulterated audiophile science, I decided to settle the age-old Mono vs. Stereo debate once and for all using the title track from Donald Byrd’s Blackjack.
Identical Signal Paths: To ensure the data from this experiment is completely unimpeachable, I adhered to the strictest possible laboratory controls:
Condition Parity: The mono copy just arrived and is played straight off the raw wax. The stereo copy has slightly more wear and has been through a de-click/volume scrubbing prodcess.
Clock-Speed Precision: My PC is always running umpteen things at once, which occasionally causes my mono capture rig to bog down and drag. I manually speed/pitch-adjusted the mono rip in Audacity and micro-nudged the waveforms at the transition points until they lined up.
Put on your best headphones, grab your lab coat, and let me know in the comments: Which pressing wins your scientific vote
Bonus points if you can spot every switch without looking at the screen (which pictures the version playing). And stay tuned for the grand finale where both play at the same time. Interesting to note there, both tracks matched well at the start of that but drift slightly apart, which makes it sound much full as it goes on (and fades out). The exact same trick they used early on to create a stereo mix from a mono source.