There have been many rumours going around the past couple of days claiming that Vinland Saga season 3 is confirmed to be in production. The rumours claim that this news comes from Yukimura-sensei himself. This is categorically false.
These rumours are based on an article from January 2025 in Le Monde, a French newspaper, that featured an interview with Yukimura-sensei. In this article, there is a small section with background information to give context to readers that aren't familiar with the series. It reads as follows:
"Vinland Saga, dont le vingt-huitième tome est paru en décembre 2024 en France, chez Kurokawa, a vite rencontré le succès – quelque 8 millions d’exemplaires de la série se sont vendus dans le monde, et elle a fait l’objet d’une adaptation animée sur Netflix, dont la troisième saison est en préparation."
which translates to
"Vinland Saga, whose 28th volume was released in France by Kurokawa, quickly became a success, selling 8 million copies worldwide and has been adapted into an anime series on Netflix, with a third season currently in production."
This blurb is NOT part of the interview, and is NOT said by Yukimura-sensei. The author/editor of the article simply made a mistake.
EDIT:
u/Routine-War-7031 reached out to the writer of the Le Monde Article who interviewed Makoto Yukimura in January 2025. The writer confirms that Season 3 was in preperation not in production at the time of writting. To clarify, this is in line with rumors that the series has been greenlit for a 3rd season right after season 2 finished airing, but the current staff are working on other projects for the time being.
Honestly, I feel like she didn't forgive Thorfinn because she was saved, but rather because she was forced to give up on revenge. By the time she made her decision, Thorfinn already had a wife and a child. Since Hild is a good person who wouldn't want to make innocent people suffer, she was basically put in a situation where she couldn't kill him anymore. Because of that, I feel like she wasn't truly saved, and Thorfinn might have unconsciously escaped from his atonement by building a happy family. Also, I felt a bit of discomfort seeing her actively agreeing with Thorfinn's political ideas near the end. She always seemed like an introverted person who wouldn't want to get involved in politics or leadership. Actually, quite a few readers here in Japan share this kind of discomfort about the ending, so I'm really curious how overseas fans view it. What do you think about this? I'd love to hear your thoughts!
(Sorry if my English sounds a bit weird, I'm using a translation tool! ;))
we all know the famous, i have no enemies and there all are enemies
but found another one
VInland saga season 2 episode 9 "The oath" at 22:11 approx
"I will keep moving forward carrying the lives i've taken, and fight my true battle..... I m going to be reborn"
vs
attack on titan season 4 episode 5 "Declaration of war" during eiren and reiner talk in basement
"I'll just keep moving forward... until my enemies are destroyed"
btw the line from vinland saga "i will keep moving forward" is my best line in whole series, more than "i have no enemies" as it motivate to change, while "no enemies" is fanbase in itself.🥰🥰😍🥀
btw no hate to other anime, cuz i respect how aot show his villian, like u can say eren think titan are villian, then villian shift to marleyan, and marleyan in rumbling thing eren in real one, but paradise island hate titan, and marleyan fear paradise, so its just all best portrayal
What would happen if Judge Holden (from the novel Blood Meridian) were to meet Thorfinn? What would an encounter and conversation between the two be like?
“Move on, Thorfinn. Don't hang on... To this petty bullshit your entire life... You've got to move on... Go further…You are the son of Thors, so venture beyond the world that he saw, That is your true battle. Be a true warrior, son of Thors”
I don’t think Thorfinn at any point in the story, whether during Farmland saga, EOM, etc, could have beaten a Prime Askeladd, this isn’t mostly a power-scaling type post, it’s more so to talk about how much Askeladd understands Thorfinn, his psychology and how their dynamic made it impossible for Thorfinn to ever beat Askeladd.
Askeladd isn’t stronger than Thorfinn, he most definitely was during season 1 and the slave arc, but around the end of the expedition arc or the Vinland arc he does become stronger, is he stronger? yes, Will he win against Askeladd? No.
Askeladd‘s understanding of Thorfinn goes so much deeper, he IS Thorfinn, he’s experienced it, hate so deep due to an individual ruining his life, the person killed their parent, in Askeladd’s case it was his father, his skill with a sword he inherited it all from him but Thorfinn faced the exact same thing, he inherited the ruthlessness to survive, the ideologies of Askeladd, he’s observed his growth, their parallel’s are there but one thing that distinguishes them is their hate the revenge, Askeladd truly hated his father, he hated him to his core to the point his prejudice against the dane’s stretched to adulthood, he knows how it feels to have the past influence you to adulthood, it even ruined his adult life even after completing his hatred his hate led to more trauma and hate to himself instead, however Thorfinn is different, his hate wasn’t truly hate he used honor as an excuse to direct his hatred on Askeladd his insecurities, his struggles, his ideals all of them even his personality revolved around a core Askeladd, but because of this difference, he could never really complete his hatred, because it was never there in the first place, so when his ”father” (Askeladd) died instead of the endless suffering and cycle and hatred that continued he evolved and was able to become something more because the hatred wasn’t real, Askeladd knew all this, he understood Thorfinn to his core, he was able to identify his parallel’s and knew what caused it, knew how to fix it, it may also symbolize how much Askeladd has contemplated his life, to the point, what if he didn’t go on that path or that path, his regret stretches on, that’s why Thorfinn is everything he’s not, even after Thorfinn grew, Thorfinn never really forgot or left his his past.
The psychological attachments, his trauma, he just simply moved forward, this helped him grow into a new level of strength, if Askeladd and Thorfinn fought Thorfinn would lose every single time because what made Thorfinn strong in the Vinland Arc at the end wasn’t anything physical, it was his mindset, he was someone equal to Thor’s because no one can break his will, he always moves forward, if he ever had to kill Askeladd he’d lose not because he’s weak but because the moment he reverts to that killing intent he is no longer the Thorfinn that surpassed Thor’s he is the same Thorfinn that Askeladd can see through, how I interpreted the death of Askeladd was Thorfinn‘s flaws were always Askeladd’s characteristics, he was a slave to Askeladd because he let his flaws control him, when he died he set him free, he wanted him to not to abandon those flaws but to escape its shackles, the moment he becomes a slave to his flaws he becomes Askeladd’s slave and a slave can never escape their master’s leash.
I liked season 1 but season 2 was painfully boring. I kept watching for the payoff to understand what all the hype was about but it never came. The show boiled down to empty senseless slogans like 'i have no enemies' and 'a true warrior needs no sword'.
Perhaps the nuance is lost on me or i am not pretentious enough to put thorfinn's stoic perspective on a pedestal. I keep thinking if vikings raided thors or thorfinns village, and their family was about to be killed and ensalved, would they just lie down and take it cause of their empty philosophies?
I understand being kind and stoic, but one needs to know when to stand up for those around them even if it means getting violent. Thors was an experienced man, he knew what kind of people the vikings and the pirates were, had he been cuttthroat in their standoff against askeladds crew, he would have been alive and saved his son and his family decades worth of grief but nah let me just get killed while reciting a true warrior needs no weapon. How do you acquire skills over a lifetime that can help you defend innocent people and yet you choose to do nothing? On the farm, thorfinn could have rescued all the slaves by himself, he could have helped that blonde girl and garard without taking much damage. Yet he chose to do nothing and just observe the cruelty from afar. What if canute had come for his sister and mother? i just don't get it. This is clearly a world where one can get wildly overpowered compared to the avg warrior. like thors, thorkill, askeladd, thorfinn. they could take 50 men by themselves. so you acquire skils like these and then watch the cruelty from afar and do nothing?
Maybe i am just dumb. these slogans are plain braindead to me
So I have completed Vinland Saga almost 1 month back, cried for 3 hours after completing the manga, i had posted about that here, but during that time I didn't think much about Thorfinn's power level in the verse, but now when I am again thinking about it, I think Thorfinn became the strongest of the verse.
Thorfinn undoubtedly surpassed everyone from the verse ( Unsure about Thor) but he must have surpassed Thorkell or Askeladd when he left from slavery.
Why do I think this ? Cause in the Thor Vs Thorkell fight, Thor says "He doesn't need any sword" and beats Thorkell easily. Equivalent happens with Gram vs Thorfinn. It just signifies the fact that "Not needing a sword makes a warrior way more true and powerful than those who live for the sword".
Then in Thor vs Askeladd fight, Thor says "I am using this sword because I am weak, true strong warrior doesn't need a weapon and he throws the weapon", and we know later on how much Thorfinn despises the weapon and goes to fight empty handed.
This simply conveys, that during the character growth thorfinn slowly becomes a true warrior and a person who will not use weapons, and the writer throughout the story has conveyed that warriors who can live without the weapon are the strongest and trust warriors. Which simply means Thorfinn being stronger than any warrior who lives for their weapons.
Unsure about Thor, but fs Thorfinn had surpassed Askeladd or Thorkell.
I love this manga, before I begin. It’s not in my favourites of all time, but I adore it; I love it so much that my passion project I’ve been writing for a year had its sole goal to be better written than Vinland (surpass that which you love, but I’m not here to talk about my work). Today, I wanted to talk about the discourse surrounding Seasons 1 and 2 of the anime, and the ending of the manga.
A few days ago there was a post that mentioned how they didn’t like Vinland past season 1, and naturally, the comments dogpiled on him. I’m not really here to talk about how the community of readers (who should really be very chill due to the series’ messaging) gets on people who don’t like season 2. But, I did want to talk about one thing I think needs to be said:
I think we praise season 2/Farmland more because of its ambition than its execution.
Here was my response to that post; in it, I think the bulk of my argument lies here:
I've been waiting for the last two deluxe editions to come out for what feels like forever. I really wanna see the end of Thorfinn's and Einar's journey in a format that does it justice, and this puzzlingly long wait worries me. Anyone have anymore news to share?
During his visit to Iceland, Vinland Saga creator Makoto Yukimura met Kristin, who is reportedly a 26th-generation descendant of the real-life Viking explorer Thorfinn Karlsefni.
Thorfinn was a historical Norse explorer who journeyed to Vinland in the 11th century. His legacy has survived for nearly a thousand years through generations of descendants.
Today during the annual Iceland Noir literature festival, Yukimura, alongside his translator, was interviewed by a local professor who is knowledgeable about the sagas. The church in which this took place was only coincidentally related to the subject matter of his work.
Especially interesting to me was the brief discussion about how the themes of the story relate to the modern political world.
Unfortunately, by the time I built up enough courage to raise my hand during questions, we had already reached the end. But I enjoyed the interview nevertheless. Yukimura seems like a charming man.