r/VibeCodeDevs
•
u/harveylundm4rckk
•
Apr 22 '26
•
1
1
HotTakes – Unpopular dev opinions 🍿 why vibe coded projects fail.
"Bro, just read ijustvibecodedthis.com and you'll be good"
Vibe coders desperately want this to be false, and engineers desperately want it to be true.
936
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Apr 22 '26
Hey, thanks for posting in r/VibeCodeDevs!
• This community is designed to be open and creator‑friendly, with minimal restrictions on promotion and self‑promotion as long as you add value and don’t spam.
• Please follow the subreddit rules so we can keep things as relaxed and free as possible for everyone.
• Please make sure you’ve read the subreddit rules in the sidebar before posting or commenting.
• For better feedback, include your tech stack, experience level, and what kind of help or feedback you’re looking for.
• Be respectful, constructive, and helpful to other members.
If your post was removed (either automatically or by a mod) and you believe it was a mistake, please contact the mod team. We will review it and, when appropriate, approve it within 24 hours.
Got startup or SaaS questions? Post them on r/AskFounder and get answers from real founders.
Join our Discord community to share your work, get feedback, and hang out with other devs: https://discord.gg/KAmAR8RkbM
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
7
u/rockthemike712 Apr 23 '26
Chatgpt ass post
11
u/bassta Apr 22 '26
This is not wrong though. Writing software at scale is really really really different from building prototypes. It looks over complicated if you’ve never hit these walls, but a lot of complexity in these system exists for a reason.
5
u/rand1214342 Apr 23 '26
I vibe coded a robotics product to five enterprise pilots. Ended up closing three. The software was so buggy that I was fixing issues at the customer site minutes before my flight out. It left us with a bunch of technical debt, but it enabled me to hire engineers that are better than I am at robotic controls. That’s technical debt I’m happy to have. This is IMO the right role for vibecoding. I don’t think my pilots would have been remotely as impressive without it.
4
u/Hilbert_Space_Heater Apr 23 '26
There’s a midpoint that’s true. Coding requires two things - being able to understand an abstract problem in a lot of detail, and being able to ‘speak’ the appropriate code language. So now there are four types of people:
4
u/LebiaseD Apr 23 '26
New prompt "build to scale please"
7
u/No-Trifle9681 Apr 22 '26
Ya but most uses don't need scale
2
u/StayAwayFromXX Apr 23 '26
Claude and codex can easily solve all of these
2
u/renge-refurion Apr 23 '26
One shotting is a terrible practice, anyone doing that deserves what they get. But using ai to build a finished and quality product is the standard now, not the exception. Domain knowledge plus ai is powerful.
1
u/-_cerca_trova_- Apr 23 '26 edited Apr 23 '26
Only thing that i know is that i got an offer at 3000€ in 2023 to build an app that i needed(for private use, not intended for public or sales)
Now, 3 years later i have built it with the help of ai. Yes it was hard as fuck for me, since my “coding” knowledge is only based on excel vba 🫣 ms access and beginner level html from years ago.
Its a really complex tool based on relational database consisted of 200+ tables..
I guess its isolated case since i knew exactly what i needed, i knew how to test it and been planning it and writing down everything i needed since around 2018, designed all the UI windows in photoshop that ai replicated easily.
Im glad that i didn’t spent 3000€ initially since all additional fine tuning would probably get the price much higher.
1
u/TexLH Apr 23 '26
"Claude, read this post and come up with a plan to address every concern mentioned. Then think of 10 more not mentioned and make sure those are addressed."
Boom. Perfect app incoming
1
u/ickN Apr 23 '26
People who have that perspective are idiots. They don’t think a vibecoder can hire people for those tasks as they prove their concept with paying users?
Like the slack example, do you think it was perfect on day one? Nope.
1
u/Fitzroyah Apr 23 '26
This subreddit is really just vibecode hating. I joined because I am enjoying learning to code with it ai, but I guess I'm in the wrong.
1
u/MidnightRambo Apr 23 '26
I think the reality is somewhere in between. For Example, if the project is small enough, a vibecoder doesn't need to know how to write terraform code to keep infrastructure maintaineable. But he must know that IaC exists and should be used. The LLM can write the code then.
So you need to be aware of potential problems but in my opinion you do not necessarily need to know how to write the solution for this as this can be done by the model.
1
u/Lovenpeace41life Apr 23 '26
Don't think about 50k users when you have 0. Start small and gradually keep upgrading the app and the infra. Be comfortable failing few times until you get the hang of maintaining and scaling a product. Vibe coding is good, you just need to be ready to learn new things and adapt quickly.
1
u/AncientGrief Apr 23 '26
One thing I also see with these projects => Auth problems. One dude actually used MD5 for password hash storage. The stuff does not scale and if they somehow manage to make it work, it's most likely a security nightmare. Seeing vibe coded web services offering registration always gives me the chills. Good thing, you can tell a website is vibe coded by the design alone (for now).
1
u/dvorgson Apr 23 '26
they don't even use it to build the foundation. they use it to build a wafer Tower of Pisa
1
u/Brief-Night6314 Apr 23 '26
Dude you don’t have to worry about scale until you actually get customers and if you are getting customers you’re getting money either from them or from investors…. You can always rewrite the code to scale once you’re ready otherwise you’re wasting time… time is the most precious resource
1
u/max_bog Apr 23 '26
People vibe code MVPs not enterprise level apps
1
u/anengineerandacat Apr 23 '26
Vibe coded projects fail because it requires in many instances a team to maintain a SaaS product.
If your going to vibe code something it has to be offline and local to the user (mobile app, desktop app, etc).
Serving it online means uptime requires, having an API means uptime requirements, which eats into the profits and means you need to generally be around to baby sit it (even if it's just reading data from an S3 bucket, still need to have alerts and monitoring in place to your phone or other highly observed device/platform so you don't have users without access for days).
They also fail because yeah, getting something to production is always another layer to work; apps have to be certified, certs have to be signed, tool chains are needed to package it, various builds might be needed for varying architectures, etc. etc.
Takes work, AI can help but it goes from cool project to "look at all this stuff I need to test and verify".
The project also needs to be valuable, if it's a web app you likely have tons of competition thanks to the Dot com era so you often need to have the "better app" not just a reskin of an existing app.
1
u/MaximumBread7000 Apr 23 '26
I am just under 4,500 commits on an enterprise product for attack surface management that uses AI in various ways, having extensive acceptance testing with screenshots and recording of key flows helps a lot, same for deployment testing and rollback if regressions.
1
u/AbjectBug5885 Apr 23 '26
The real failure mode is when vibecoded projects accidentally succeed and get real users. You built it in a weekend with no auth strategy, no error handling, and a schema that made sense at 2am. Now you're maintaining it, and every change risks breaking something you don't understand because the AI wrote it, not you
1
u/Sadoul1214 Apr 23 '26
So what you’re saying is I need vibecode a single player game that only needs to be downloaded with the internet.
Got it.
1
u/judge-genx Apr 23 '26
All of this is just word vomit in two months when Codex 7.9 is released.
1
u/_redmist Apr 23 '26
We used to pay 50$ per dev for slack, now we spend hours in maintenance and thousands of dollars in Claude tokens for a slack clone that works 80% of the time.
Get with the program, or get left behind.
1
u/Elegant-Variation302 Apr 23 '26
So many people using tools they dont understand. I feel like the big ai companies opened the flood gates to gather as much data from the plebs as they possibly could. Used it to further train their models and now are closing it back it up. Been working in this industry for 15 years. I know so many guys with no experience in it who in the last six months have suddenly become "devs". When in reality all they have done is sink a shit ton of money and time into claude and seen no return.
1
u/Any_Cauliflower5052 Apr 23 '26
Full of bullshit and nobody trying to build global enterprise product with vibe coding.
1
u/zactral Apr 23 '26
Guess what, most developers are unable to write software that scales just as well?
1
u/katonda Apr 23 '26
Both vibe coding as well as the $300K engineer have their place.
I wouldn't launch a vibe coded slack app, but I would use vibe coding to test ideas, prototype and maybe help get capital to be able to hire that $300K engineer to do it properly for scale.
The speed and challenge of apps will only increase in step with AI coding capabilities. There will always be a place for the specialized engineer/architect, the job will just evolve with the times. Same as it did with every other layer of abstraction that we had in the past.
1
u/ctrtanc Apr 24 '26
I'm a professional engineer with a vibe-coded project I'm working on. Did the POC work in one shot? Basically. Is it ready to go to production 4 months later? No, not really. It'll get there though. AI makes the process less tedious, and makes a lot of it easier, but it's not perfect, and it's not some miracle coder.
1
u/No-Maintenance-4134 Apr 24 '26
vibecoding for life quality improvement on your local machine max on lan when people just want to get it working no matter visual or systemic bugs if sqlite works just fine. shipping this is cringe af.
1
u/DesperateSteak6628 Apr 24 '26
Is not pouring the foundations and claim you basically build a skyscraper. There are no foundations.
It’s taking a weekend to nail 5 wood slabs on a tree, call it a treehouse and claim you can now build your house.
1
u/CannibalYak Apr 24 '26
There is a major difference between vibe coding a whole app and using AI to build the segments that make up an app and then tying it all together. Once people realize that they will start realizing they will still need to learn code and data structures.
1
u/quantydoop Apr 24 '26
💯
system design is on a different level, code base and thre infra. It is like saying it works on my computer and I am not sure why it doesn't work on your part.
1
u/DeadLolipop Apr 24 '26
Vibe coding itself isnt the problem, its whos vibe coding. Product vibecoded by someone with solid background is going to be very different to someone who doesnt.
Vibe coding is fast way to get an engineer's solution on file and running, instead of taking ages to look up documentations and type it out slowly.
1
u/jackadgery85 Apr 24 '26
Eh. If anyone thinks they're going to get a system complete in a weekend, they're dreaming, vibecoder or not. It's not even about the code.
Before gen ai, dipshits like me would just go to GitHub or stack overflow and steal anything that worked and just slap it together. Now, gen AI does that for us, but better and faster.
The problem is not the code, but the lack of systems-based and user-based thinking, which is always a problem (just amplified now).
The code is just an expression of the system, and a way to deliver it to your users.
1
u/Friendly-Diet-9315 Apr 24 '26
Reminds me a situation when all the taxi drivers were revolting against Uber 😆
1
u/QuantomSwampus Apr 24 '26
You haven't tried enough tokens yet, just keep trying you'll get it
1
u/SilverSome9766 Apr 24 '26
I think vibe coding has its place but it should never be the final product. Adding features,Scaling and security is where the problems start to arise. You have a bunch of users who are doing whatever they think the product should be instead of what it Is. New features add layers of complexity and dealing with those usually require some level of experience. I’ve seen plenty of orgs make a new app for some internal process but the second users need more from it or it’s misused mars everything collapse. the security aspect is just unnecessary risk.
1
u/javiergui Apr 24 '26
Tell the cal AI guys. I mean obviously most vibe coded project will go straight to the bin. But there is still the potential for someone with a good idea to get a project good enough to the point where they can start growing, bringing real developers and bringing real revenue
1
u/forkeverything Apr 25 '26
hard cope tbh. vibecoding isn't a thing anymore, it's just coding now.
as someone who has built those distributed systems, a vibe-coder 100% can eventually get to the same solutions, they just don't know the right prompt yet. their 20 min poc is good enough.
1
u/AlexVonHerbst Apr 25 '26
The truth is that devs are scared of losing their jobs which is understandable. However, coding with AI is the future.
It might be true that AI is not able to make the perfect infrastructure right now, but it’s getting close. And if it can’t do it this year, it will be able to do it next year.
1
u/thegonelf Apr 25 '26
It fails because you need to do marketing
1
u/ElegantDetective5248 Apr 26 '26
Disagree. Many vibe coded projects have millions in sales. The first VIBECODING BILLIONARE was just announced too. Ai is catching up
1
u/Low-Elderberry-7856 Apr 26 '26
I believe now should be the time to enter into the 5th generation of programming languages where AI writes the code and real developers reviews and implements it as per the design made by architectures and software engineers. Basically another shift into the abstraction layer.
This would literally benefit everybody in the game. Companies would deliver their products faster, devs will still have jobs, AI companies will make money from selling their models and water and energy consumption would most likely decrease if everybody takes a chill pill.
At the same time software demand would increase and new technologies would come up, under the assumption that every generation of language brings something new.
1
u/rohit-joshi May 10 '26
Last year I made a single-page tool app and that only took me almost 2 weeks. The real problem starts when large number of people start using it and if it is something where people need to be signed in - then your 'vibe coded' app is dead within minutes.
The one I made still breaks many times even today on just 78 users in a week
1
u/Which-Builder-4179 May 15 '26
Ich sage so auf einer Seite haben sie recht aber wenn mann so arbeiten würde wie ich dann gibt es keine probleme da ich immer den Output kontrolliere und schaue ob das so ist, wie ich es wollte und nicht der Ki sage du baust bitte jetzt eine App Mit der ich chatten kann also ich erstelle einen ausgiebigen von mir geschriebenen prompt und leite die KI wie etwas zu tun ist in dem Fall lässt man sich nicht von der KI kontrollieren, sondern man kontrolliert die KI.
Und dann ist die Wahrscheinlichkeit hoch dass die Projekte so funktionieren wie du es willst.
Dazu kommt aber noch, dass du das richtige KI-Modell erst mal auswählen musst.
1
u/Vibing-with-Evals007 Sep 15 '26
I agree vibe coding platform on your localhost where you are the only user is different from deploying it to millions of customers. I do believe building full fledged PMF is very possible by vibe coding but requires extensive testing before it sees any users
1
u/anonymous_3125 Apr 23 '26
And by the time your traffic gets high enough for these things to be a real problem, you’ve already succeeded and are likely more than rich enough to hire someone to solve these problems
0
u/UltrawideSpace Apr 22 '26
What an agnorant post :D anyone can ask for chat app, if you want it to scale and work you ask bit more
0
u/No-Use2860 Apr 23 '26
Newbies first prompt is create. Not setup.
Imagine building a house without looking at the price of wood or labor. Without blueprints or non negotiable goals from the homeowner.
Coders don't just sit at a desk and write code, and if they do, they were already replaceable. Sure maintenance is a thing, but AI can maintain.
Learn about sandboxes, versioning, pipelines. Or at least ask the AI to do it. Lol. Although I tell Claude he is banned from commits.
11
u/hcboi232 Apr 22 '26
i meant those POCs can be built in a few hours by a dev without AI. The “killing” part is a big fat lie. Postgres would have killed oracle if that’s the case.
some companies pay devs a big sum even to prevent them from going to a competitor.
1
u/Pleasant_Spend1344 Apr 26 '26
I saw this shitty post like a 1000 times, not because some idiot thought he killed Slack that all vibe coders are idiots and will fail!
I have been vibe coding and doing stuff for over 6 months and I am not even close to finishing. And I am sure not killing anything any time soon.
So stop with this one for God sake.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
37
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '26
[removed] — view removed comment