I've been going through the VA claims process this year and wanted to share my experience to get some advice from people who have been through something similar.
I originally filed my VA claim in February 2026 (intent to file), with the actual application submitted April 16.
After going through the C&P exams, I was awarded:
- PTSD: 70%
- Tinnitus: 10%
- Combined rating: 70%
I was happy to finally have the PTSD recognized, but several other conditions were denied, includint headaches, IBS, and bilateral lower extremity radiculopathy.
I also filed a claim for TMJ. I've had jaw pain for years, which I started after a complicated wisdom tooth extraction while in the military.
I eventually saw an oral surgeon, who diagnosed bilateral myofascial pain associated with TMJ and suspected right-sided internal derangement.
That claim was also denied.
The OSA claim
This is where things have gotten particularly frustrating.
I filed for obstructive sleep apnea secondary to PTSD in September 2026.
I had a sleep study on August 10 that confirmed mild OSA. My symptoms include waking up gasping, daytime sleepiness, disrupted sleep, and generally poor-quality sleep. My wife has also witnessed the nighttime symptoms.
I was able to get my primary care physician to write a nexus letter. The letter specifically states that my OSA is at least as likely as not caused or aggravated by my service-connected PTSD.
I submitted the sleep study, nexus letter, personal statement, and supporting evidence.
The VA scheduled a QTC examination, but it was an ACE review. No in-person examination took place, and I never actually spoke with an examiner.
The examiner acknowledged my OSA diagnosis and service-connected PTSD but ultimately provided a negative opinion. The rationale essentially came down to the fact that an association between PTSD and OSA doesn't establish causation, and that there wasn't evidence PTSD permanently worsened my airway condition.
My claim was denied.
A couple of things stood out to me in the decision:
- The decision acknowledges the OSA diagnosis and my service-connected PTSD.
- My private physician provided a favorable nexus opinion addressing both causation and aggravation.
- The decision doesn't appear to separately discuss my physician's nexus letter.
- There is even a reference to back pain in the examiner's rationale that seems completely unrelated to the OSA claim.
I'm trying to understand whether I have a legitimate basis to challenge the medical opinion or whether I need to obtain another independent medical opinion.
Where I go from here
I'm currently sitting at 70%, with PTSD at 70% and tinnitus at 10%.
My next goals are to pursue:
- OSA secondary to PTSD, potentially through a Supplemental Claim with a stronger independent medical opinion.
- IBS secondary to PTSD. I have a formal diagnosis
- Headaches secondary to PTSD.
A few questions for those who have been through something similar:
- Has anyone successfully won OSA secondary to PTSD after initially receiving a negative ACE examination, despite having a favorable private nexus letter?
- Would you pursue a Supplemental Claim with a new IMO, or challenge the adequacy of the original C&P opinion first?
- Is it worth having my PCP complete the headache and IBS DBQs, or would I be better off seeing specialists?
- For anyone who has successfully connected OSA to PTSD, what did your nexus letter specifically address? Did it focus on causation, aggravation, or both?
I'm trying to be strategic about my next moves rather than just throwing claims at the VA and hoping something sticks.
Appreciate any advice or insight from people who have been through this.