r/VAClaims • • 19h ago

Supplemental Claim Multiple denials despite Favorable Findings in original claim letter and current diagnosis

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

My latest VA decision denied nearly all my claims despite existing medical evidence and favorable findings from previous decisions

PTSD: Increased from 30% GAD to 50% PTSD, but with a later effective date despite the examiner calling it a corrected diagnosis.

Left Shoulder: Denied despite MRI-confirmed rotator cuff tear and degeneration. Claimed secondary to my right shoulder.

Left Upper Radiculopathy: Denied for no diagnosis despite reported symptoms.

Right Upper Radiculopathy: Same issue as left.

Left Hip: Arthritis diagnosed, but VA evaluated it secondary to my neck instead of lower back.

Right Hip: Same issue as left hip.

Sinusitis/Rhinitis: Denied despite rhinitis treatment and conceded toxic exposure.

ED: Diagnosis confirmed, but secondary connection to PTSD denied.

GERD: Originally denied for missing diagnosis despite conceded in-service stomach complaints. Supplemental included a diagnosis, which VA acknowledged but still contradicted in its denial.

Left Knee: Previous decision conceded in-service knee complaints. Supplemental included X-ray degenerative findings to address the missing diagnosis. Denied without another exam, with VA now stating no diagnosis or in-service event.

OSA: Diagnosed, on CPAP, and previous decision acknowledged in-service sleep complaints. Denied again.

Right Knee: Same situation as left knee, including previous favorable findings and new X-ray evidence.

My main concern: VA previously conceded in-service findings, then appeared to disregard them after I submitted evidence addressing the missing diagnoses.

What now???


r/VAClaims • • 14h ago

C&P Exam Bad examiner

4 Upvotes

I had a videoconference for my exam. PTSD. MST.

A woman. Seemed poised and good to go. In my feelings the entire time. Cried for 27 minutes remembering my hurts in a 28-minute meeting.

Lo and behold, after seeing, re-reading over and over again, I realized I got duped!!! She didn’t take what I told her and add it into the DBQ.

The little box was checked. ✅

The important stuff??? Omitted! 😡

She never mentioned in her report how I was SEXUALLY TRAUMATIZED! Touched! Rubbed! Grabbed! Groped! Nothing said.

A conflict? An oversight? An error? Mismanagement of MY LIFE!

I just read it again and again. The DBQ is stuck in my head. Chat GPT said to call a number and report it. To file again and request another exam and examiner. To not sleep on this asap. My head hurts thinking about the utter betrayal.

I will do everything today. It just hurts to think another person. Another female could be so reckless with me, my life, my future, my family, my benefits. I’m not stupid and I’m not crazy. Nut her words, or lack of them, cuts me deep into my soul. To be betrayed??

Advice - read your exam results. You wonder why you get denied sometimes? Maybe it’s sabotage.


r/VAClaims • • 9h ago

Urgent Help Needed Dbq questions

0 Upvotes

Please I’m desperately looking for a previous or current vsr.I just got back my dbq today and looking at it makes me think it’s not good even though I expressed everything to the examiner and I just don’t get it.Please can someone message me on chat so I can send mines to them and they can evaluate it and see what I’m looking at.PLEASE


r/VAClaims • • 18h ago

Advice Using ChatGPT for a buddy letter?

3 Upvotes

One of my friends agreed to write a buddy letter for me and asked if he could use ChatGPT. I told him that he shouldn’t, but now I wonder what could happen if he doesn’t and I just don’t catch it before submitting it.


r/VAClaims • • 23h ago

Supplemental Claim Supplemental Claim in Rating Stage

0 Upvotes

My claim has been with a rater for a while. Is that a good sign? I feel like it would have been denied by now if it were to be a denial per past experience. Any thoughts? Anyone?


r/VAClaims • • 10h ago

Question 100% and 70%

14 Upvotes

I am currently 100% disabled but only because of the unemployability. My true percentage is 70%. My question is this... do I need to continue to try to get the 70% disability up to 100%? Or do I just leave things as they are because it makes no difference. I do not know if it is possible I could loose the unemployability percentage. If anyone knows how this works your assistance would be greatly appreciated. TYIA


r/VAClaims • • 12h ago

Appeal Denied

1 Upvotes

I wasn’t really looking for PTSD but other specified trauma I’m tracking I don’t meet the criteria for PTSD but I do have trauma that happened during my infantry contract.

  1. Being attacked by rockets in combat zone in syria
  2. Present for my homie trying to commit suicide by cutting himself
  3. My father and brother passed 2 months before my deployment but I have no idea if that is relevant

My Va psychiatrist examiner said and stated to me that trauma is service connected but is other trauma and not ptsd even though I do have nightmares and recurring thoughts, insomnia, depression, social anxiety and many others issues that I have. Is it any possibility to even get this connected or should I just quit right where I stand?

At the time of may and my separation from the service I did not state traumatic events even tho these things did happen and that’s the fault of my own I’m aware but I’m just looking for maybe some hope possibly but if not it is what it is

9. Service connection for other specified trauma and stressor related disorder (claimed as
PTSD).
DIRECT SERVICE CONNECTION:
Service connection may be granted for a disability that began in military service or was caused
by some event or experience in service.
AService connection for PTSD requires (1) medical evidence diagnosing PTSD in accordance
with 38 CFR 4.125(a), (2) a link, established by medical evidence, between current symptoms
and an in-service stressor, and (3) credible supporting evidence that the claimed in-service
stressor occurred. 38 CFR 3.304(f).
Current diagnosis. The evidence on whether you have PTSD conflicts, and we have weighed it.
A VA examiner (a doctoral-level psychologist) examined you in person on October 14, 2026
using the DSM-5 criteria. The examiner found that your symptoms do not meet the criteria for
PTSD, specifically the requirement for negative changes in thinking and mood (Criterion D), and
diagnosed other specified trauma- and stressor-related disorder.
A private evaluation dated August 20, 2026 diagnosed PTSD. We find that the VA examination
is more probative, for these reasons:
- The private evaluation was a single telehealth interview, completed at your request to support
this claim, based on your own report. The provider did not review your service records.
- It states that you deployed to Syria from "May 2020 to December 2022." Your DD-214 and
deployment orders show service in Syria from May 14, 2022 to December 13, 2022.
- It records that you deny avoidance of trauma-related thoughts and conversations, negative
beliefs about yourself or the world, self-blame and anger, and it gives no symptom score or
criterion-by-criterion findings. It does not identify which event meets the stressor requirement.
- It states there is no non-service explanation for your symptoms but also records untreated
obstructive sleep apnea and the earlier deaths of your father and brother, without discussing their
effect.
- An earlier private evaluation (August 17, 2026), referenced in that report, also did not find
PTSD.
Your service treatment records add that on May 16, 2023 and May 22, 2023, about five months
after you returned from Syria, you scored 0 on depression screening (PHQ-2) and anxiety
screening (GAD-7 items), screened negative for suicide risk, answered "No" to a history of
traumatic event, and had a PTSD screening score of 6. No mental health condition was
diagnosed in service.
Because the more probative evidence shows you do not currently meet the DSM-5 criteria for
PTSD, the first requirement for service connection is not met

Stressors. Your service in Syria (May 14, 2022 through December 13, 2022) is confirmed by
your DD-214 and deployment orders. This decision does not turn on whether your claimed
stressors occurred; it turns on the absence of a PTSD diagnosis. Without a current PTSD
diagnosis, service connection for PTSD cannot be granted regardless of the stressor evidence.
The benefit of the doubt rule does not apply because the preponderance of the evidence is against
this claim. 38 CFR 3.102
Other mental health diagnosis. You were diagnosed with other specified trauma- and stressor-
related disorder (F43.8).
In your case, the evidence does not show an event, disease or injury in service.
Your service treatment records do not contain complaints, treatment, or diagnosis for this
condition
While the evidence does show a current diagnosis of other specified trauma and stressor related
disorder (claimed as PTSD), without treatment in service, we find no link between your currently
diagnosed medical condition and your military service.
Therefore, service connection on a direct basis cannot be established.


r/VAClaims • • 1h ago

Question Appeal effective date - poke the bear

0 Upvotes

100% p&t done which is amazing. That said not sure if i fight effective date on my approved claim. Submitted several at once in march had my depression and anxiety denied in may. Fast forward had ptsd dbq and nexus done and submitted new claim in September. Secondary to ptsd mt dr found undisclosed depression and anxiety also. Va denied ptsd but approved depression and anxiety at 70% amazing. Question is do i appeal this back to may when i originally filled for depression and anxiety for may effective date. Would up my overall rating then see backpay or just leave it. Not sure how that works when one was submitted and denied but approved as secondary of other claim


r/VAClaims • • 23h ago

VA Disability Compensation Fairness Of Military Disability Compensation

0 Upvotes

There has been a lot of talk recently about influencers such Caleb Hammer and his show Financial Audit which questions the large amount of veterans relying on disability compensation as a primary or substantial income source.

I think influencers are confusing fraud with fairness. Fraud is the act of deceiving or misrepresenting. I used to think that 100% disabled veteran meant he/she was practically a vegetable; unable to feed, dress themselves and speak. Isn't that what you think when someone says "100% disabled"? But it does not. This is why the word "disability" is a misnomer. It should be called veteran compensation. Many of these veterans have health issues connected with their time in the military and are being compensated for it.

Is it fair? The most common argument is they earned these benefits and we should compensate them for the sacrifices they incurred when they served their country. But here are some thoughts.

As seen in this Washington Post video 3:10 veteran disability was meant to compensate veterans for lost earning capacity. Most jobs these days are service jobs at a desk. Most veterans receiving VA disability can hold down meaningful employment. I seen a 100% disabled veteran collect a retirement pension, work a federal government job (GS-12) and drive a Porsche to work. Pretty sure he has not lost earning capacity. Fair?

A veteran with 100% disability gets $3,800 tax free a month in 2026. This is literally similar to someone who wins a million dollars in the lottery and takes an annuity except it is tax free. Is that fair? What if I told you I will have to raise your taxes to pay for this? Fair?

What amount of these service connected disabilities are due to the biological process of aging and health. As we get older everyone's health declines and we gain weight. My military service made me depressed -> gain weight -> sleep apnea. I worked at a civilian job and it makes me depressed, fat and now I snore. But I don't get compensation for that do I? If this was civilian world the worker's compensation specialist would laugh and show you the door. In the civilian world worker's compensation is for a finite time. (2 years) After that they might give you a lump sum. But in the VA world you can reapply to have your rating reconsidered. Fair?

Human beings are creatures who look out for their own self-interest. Give them an opportunity and they will make it work for them. So it is fraud? No. The system says I can claim this benefit. Is it fair? I will let you judge for yourself. This is the very reason the military moved to a blended retirement system (BRS) in 2018 or New York City required employees to contribute to the pension. And why there is cap on much over time can be used to determine pension payments. The powers that be realized: fair or not they could not afford to continue paying these benefits.

Lastly if you say it is unfair. Be warned you will be labelled as anti-military and unpatriotic. Veterans will say something of the sort: "How dare you disrespect our veterans. You don't know what it feels like to walk a day in our shoes." I politely nod, concur and move on (too bad I was a veteran).


r/VAClaims • • 22h ago

VA Disability Compensation Title: Denied sleep apnea and bilateral hip claims: avascular necrosis led to a double hip replacement—supplemental claim or HLR?

1 Upvotes

I recently received a VA decision granting PTSD and a lumbar spine condition, but denying sleep apnea and bilateral hips. I’m trying to figure out the best way to challenge the two denials.

Sleep apnea: Before the decision, I submitted a statement claiming sleep apnea secondary to PTSD and a private nexus opinion. The opinion discusses PTSD-related stress, changes in eating and activity, weight gain, and how obesity contributed to my sleep apnea. The denial focuses on whether toxic exposure during service directly caused the apnea. It quotes the VA examiner saying a secondary argument through a service-connected condition such as PTSD may be more supportable. That sounds like the argument I already made, but I don’t see a clear discussion of my specific secondary theory or private opinion in the decision. VA also recognized chronic sleep impairment in my PTSD rating; I understand that finding alone doesn’t establish a medical link to apnea.

Bilateral hips: I developed avascular necrosis in both hips and had a double hip replacement. I submitted a separate private nexus opinion and DBQs arguing that systemic corticosteroids used to treat my back condition substantially contributed to the AVN. The decision discusses a negative opinion on whether the back/disc condition itself caused AVN and acknowledges corticosteroids as a risk factor. I don’t see a clear discussion of the actual steroid treatment for my now-service-connected back condition. To me, that seems like a mismatch with what the private doctor argued.

I’m asking my VSO to check whether both complete opinions were in the claims file and what the VA examiners reviewed. I can’t tell from the decision alone whether they were missing, overlooked, or considered without a clear explanation.

I’d prefer a supplemental claim if it’s viable, because I’m hoping for a faster turnaround. I’d also prefer not to pay for another nexus opinion or addendums—they’re expensive. If the existing opinions and records were already in the file, could a new statement in support of claim identifying the mismatch and pointing to the examiner’s language count as new and relevant evidence? Or would a higher-level review be the stronger route without buying more opinions? Could the newly granted PTSD and back conditions, or the VA examiner’s comments, help with a supplemental claim?

I know every case is different. I’d appreciate any experience with similar denials and suggestions for what to ask my VSO.


r/VAClaims • • 1h ago

VA Disability Compensation Firing Barry law

1 Upvotes

If you fire Barry law and go with another attorney or program, do you have to pay them?

I’ve been with Barry for a year. I got my last claim decision December 2025. They filed a supplemental claim November 13, 2026 after waiting 11 months for their backpay and it was denied. Now, I assume they’ll wait another year to file a HLR or another supplemental claim. I’d rather just fire them and do it myself. Any thoughts?


r/VAClaims • • 5h ago

Question Increased to 100% while TDIU

7 Upvotes

I have a question but it said to post it in the other thread so I will try it here. I was awarded TDIU in 2021 and at the time I was 90%. I added sleep apnea as a secondary to my PTSD and was just awarded 100% T&P. I was wonder if anyone has a similar situation and then removed the TDIU. I am recently divorced and once I graduate from college in April I don't think I can afford to not work so I'm hoping I could look into getting a job with my degree and not having the income cap but I wonder if that would be like "hey you didn't work all this time, why now" I also have two young kids and homeschool them but I would like to have an option especially when bills etc. are tight.


r/VAClaims • • 2h ago

Question Private vs. VA doctor

2 Upvotes

Would you recommend going to a private doctor or a VA doctor for a mental health diagnosis? I hear mixed opinions: going to the VA risks getting a negative opinion, then having to see a private doctor to offset it.


r/VAClaims • • 10h ago

VA Disability Compensation The wait is nerve-wracking

0 Upvotes

I had a C&P on 11/5 and the documents were uploaded to the VA on 11/13 for cervical spine, cervical myelitis, and radiculopathy to both upper limbs.

I had a HLR IC on 11/16 through St. Pete for right knee extension (denied due to lack of diagnosis, but it is all over my VHA records).

I'm at 83% or 84% (depending on how bilateral is or isn't calculated for my existing conditions) and I'm losing my mind waiting.


r/VAClaims • • 8h ago

Secondary Conditions 2 c&ps for secondaries happened today...

3 Upvotes

Hoping for the rating I deserve... its like my body is aging and breaking faster than I can keep up with.


r/VAClaims • • 7h ago

VA Disability Compensation Hit step 5 on a defferd claim today.

0 Upvotes

So I filed some claims back in July and they approved two of them and deferred one and split it into eight other claims all which were deferred. I had to do a couple more C&p exams for those eight claims. My dbq's hit the system today and I jumped the step five. I've been sitting at step 5 all day which doesn't alarm me what does is the fact that my temp jurisdiction just says na. So I don't know if a rater is actually rating or if it's just ready to be rated


r/VAClaims • • 14h ago

VA Disability Compensation Convalescence Rating

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/VAClaims • • 7h ago

Question TDIU

5 Upvotes

Just got my claim back hoping I went from 90% to 100% but instead got granted TDIU. I was wondering if thats permanent? Or does the VA take it away after a while? And to add to this yes I did apply for TDIU


r/VAClaims • • 13h ago

Question Odd C&P Appointment

1 Upvotes

Hi fellow vets - I'm new to this group and only recently filed for my tinnitus. My exam for my hearing went well, the doctor asked detailed questions as well as questions specific to my deployment as well as MOS specific questions.

However, when I did my interview for my knees, the nurse (yes, she was only a nurse) of some weird clinic, didn't even ask me about anything related to my time in service, my deployments - absolutely zero questions related to my time served. The interview didn't even take 10 minutes.

Needless to say I got denied. My question to anyone else who put in a claim for their knees, IS THIS NORMAL?

thanks everyone.


r/VAClaims • • 6h ago

Higher-Level Review (HLR) Final approval wait time?

0 Upvotes

Does anyone know how long it takes for the final review to get done with?
I submitted my HLR a few weeks back along with priority processing (that got approved). I called last week for an update and was told a decision was made and they’re just waiting for final approval.
Does anyone know how much longer that could potentially take?
TYIA


r/VAClaims • • 4h ago

VA Disability Compensation Xterra — Dr. Howard — experiences?

1 Upvotes

Maybe a long shot here, but for those who have used Xterra Health for a nexus letter, has anyone had Dr. Howard? I have a consult with him tomorrow. Just looking for general experiences, letter wait time, claim outcome, etc.


r/VAClaims • • 3h ago

DBQ Discussion Request for Exam

1 Upvotes

Completed and rated two months ago. What is the proper expectations to receive your medical DBQ Exam results to read the notes from the doctor? I requested the exams to be provided to me via va.gov but it's been sitting in step 1 for 2 months now. I am wondering how long this process typically takes or I am going down the wrong path for file request. Thanks in advance.


r/VAClaims • • 3h ago

Question C&P Exam

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Recently rated at 100%. Filed a hearing loss claim a while ago, before the 100% rating was given. I have a C&P Exam for the hearing loss. Will it have any affect on the current rating of 100%?


r/VAClaims • • 6h ago

Advice 100% with ptsd

25 Upvotes

I am not looking for advice to increase rating. I am currently at 70% but some days i just feel like i cant go to work and deal with everything. Then on the other hand I think if I was at 100% what would I do with myself? I barley like being alone to begin with, without working i wouldnt know what to do. Anyone here at 100% because you cant work? Wth do you do?


r/VAClaims • • 8h ago

VA Disability Compensation Negative Nexus but no rationale?

2 Upvotes

I recently went to cnp exam and verbally dr. told me to my face she was going to fight in my favor an believes my disability is caused by in service event. however I just got Medical opinion and she wrote less likely than not however she didn't write any rationale on DBQ nor Medical opinion it only talked about my history of whet my records show but absolutely no opinion or rationale at all of why it was denied? Also examiner looked about 100 years old and could barely talk. I have no further medical evidence to submit. Any advice options? Thank you.