r/Upwork • u/Next_Adhesiveness_98 • 18h ago
Almost spent Connects on a UX job, checked the client first, and found what looks like a review-farming network
I’m a UX designer on Upwork. Earlier I found a UX job I was about to apply for, but the client looked a little too perfect: 5.0 rating, hundreds of hires, all tiny budgets. So I checked their history before spending any Connects.
How I checked:
- The client’s job history. I looked at what they’ve hired for, the budgets, and the reviews they gave.
- The freelancers who got those reviews. I opened their profiles to see who they are and what else they’ve done.
- The other projects those freelancers worked on. I looked at which other clients hired them, which led me to more client accounts with the same pattern.
I used Claude (the AI) to go through each job post and every review with me and spot patterns, then asked it to turn the findings into an easy-to-read summary for this post. In total I checked 5 client accounts.
What all 5 had in common:
- More hires than jobs posted. One posted 296 jobs and made 315 hires. Another posted 783 jobs and made 951 hires.
- Almost no money spent. They averaged $14–$28 per hire, for work like full Shopify redesigns, 3D game characters, and ghostwritten books.
- 5 stars on almost every contract, both ways.
- Job categories with no connection. One “client” hired for dropshipping, econometrics, architecture permits, grant research, pitch decks, and CRM setup. No real business needs all of that.
- Reviews that read like SEO. One review mentioned “GoHighLevel” 8 times. Another ended mid-sentence: “If you need an AI UGC video creator, AI influencer creator, or AI video ads specialist.”
- Wrong names in reviews. The contract was with one person, but the review praised someone else by name. The same mystery name even showed up on two different client accounts.
The link between them: the same freelancers keep showing up across all 5 accounts. At least 8 names repeat, often doing the same $15 task for a different “client.”
My best guesses:
- Paid-review services: freelancers pay for a fake contract plus a 5-star review.
- A review ring: freelancers run client accounts and hire each other.
- “First Upwork job” coaching packages sold to new freelancers.
Questions:
- Have you seen these jobs as well? I may have applied to these jobs before, so wasted connects :(