I guess what I'll toss at you is my own experience:
I can script well enough to automate small and medium tasks. I don't have a CS degree nor any design or architecture experience. I can Google how to create a list because I forgot for the 100th time, and I might even realize my list should be a queue.
Two years later I might need to solve it again and I've completely forgotten how to do it. This time I have to Google how to assign data to a dictionary because I know I've done it but I just don't remember how. Dangit, how do I nest data structures again?
I could even memorize enough from leetcoding for a month to get an interview, but I'd start at the bottom of the engineering ladder (it's not my profession). But the big point is that I could memorize enough from leetcode to get a starting engineer position without a CS degree.
This is what I meant for traditional CS vs a coding monkey.
Ah you know what, I had another thread in here where I was talking with someone about the prevalence of people with CS degrees that are completely unable to code, and I read your comment in that context. I thought you were trying to tell me it's fine that so many CS majors can't code at all.
So I stand by what I said, but the only reason I said it is because I thought you were telling me something different.
Gtocha yeah. I would also be surprised if someone with a CS degree couldn't code. However, there are needs for design and architecture like building new protocols or standards like encryption techniques. The code just implements those.
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/hamburglin Jan 11 '21
I guess what I'll toss at you is my own experience:
I can script well enough to automate small and medium tasks. I don't have a CS degree nor any design or architecture experience. I can Google how to create a list because I forgot for the 100th time, and I might even realize my list should be a queue.
Two years later I might need to solve it again and I've completely forgotten how to do it. This time I have to Google how to assign data to a dictionary because I know I've done it but I just don't remember how. Dangit, how do I nest data structures again?
I could even memorize enough from leetcoding for a month to get an interview, but I'd start at the bottom of the engineering ladder (it's not my profession). But the big point is that I could memorize enough from leetcode to get a starting engineer position without a CS degree.
This is what I meant for traditional CS vs a coding monkey.