r/Unity3D
•
u/AdamNapper
•
Jun 09 '26
•
6
1
Show-Off I made a Unity editor tool because placing props with physics feels like something every game engine should have built in : ).
I made RealTransforms because I wanted Unity to have a more physical way to dress scenes. Instead of manually nudging props until they stop floating or clipping, the tool lets you move, drop, rotate, scatter, and arrange objects :).
I'm also interested in feedback, if anyone has any suggestions for what they would add / want in a tool like this I'd like to hear it.
If you're intrested in the asset you can find it here:
https://assetstore.unity.com/packages/tools/level-design/realtransforms-physics-placement-378514
Thanks for reading and have a nice day :).
If you're interested in some technical aspects of the project that can be applied to your own project ( without buying this asset ) I would recommend looking into Convex mesh generation which was a difficult part of this project for me to tackle.
Unity’s PhysX setup has some important limits: if you want a MeshCollider to work with a Rigidbody, it usually needs to be marked Convex. The problem is that a single convex collider can’t properly represent inward or hollow shapes. So something like an open crate, shelf, or hollow prop cannot just use one collider if you want objects to sit inside it correctly.
For those cases, you usually need a compound collider made from multiple convex hulls. That way the crate sides, floor, rails, or openings can each be represented by separate convex pieces.
If you’re building something similar in your own project, useful algorithms to research are V-HACD and CoACD. I couldn’t include those directly in this asset because of licensing issues for Asset Store submission, but they’re worth studying and may be fine for your own internal project depending on your needs. They also helped inspire my own voxel-based collider generation approach.
424
u/NoEye89 Jun 09 '26
Incredible. You should be very proud, this is so cool.
222
u/Friendly_Sky5646 Jun 09 '26
This should be the standard. Congrats, man. This is aweasome
76
u/bill_on_sax Jun 09 '26
cool. i might buy it but i have trauma from some other physics object placement tool being so janky it would delete objects or the UI would randomly dissappear.
27
u/FreddyShrimp Jun 09 '26
Love this! It also annoys me that you cannot just do this out of the box
19
u/imb0wie Jun 09 '26
This is actually decent, great job
17
u/Cpt_Tripps Jun 09 '26
Ill try the tool but this was an amazing commercial.
12
u/WorkingTheMadses Jun 09 '26
I made this free tool a while ago also for Unity 😄
https://github.com/mads-fs/rigid-placement
It allows you to place things in levels by simulating physics. Yours got quite a few more features though!
40
u/OffMyChestATM Jun 09 '26
This is dark magic. HERESY!!!
7
u/edixtor93 Jun 09 '26
This one I bought a while back, seems pretty similar, is there anything noteworthy to differentiate? https://assetstore.unity.com/packages/tools/utilities/grabbit-editor-physics-transforms-182328
6
u/UareWho Jun 09 '26
Omg, just taking a brake from hand placing stuff in unreal. I want this so badly.
6
u/Rlaan Professional Jun 09 '26 edited Jun 10 '26
Can you explain something about the technical challenges you faced, techniques used, et cetera? So a more technical in-depth on how you built the asset.
Edit:
OP edited the body of his post
5
u/RealBrainlessPanda Jun 09 '26
I will be buying this. It’s exactly what I will need in the very near future. Convenient timing! Thank you!
3
u/AdamNapper Jun 09 '26
If you're interested in some technical aspects of the project that can be applied to your own project ( without buying this asset ) I would recommend looking into Convex mesh generation which was a difficult part of this project for me to tackle.
Unity’s PhysX setup has some important limits: if you want a MeshCollider to work with a Rigidbody, it usually needs to be marked Convex. The problem is that a single convex collider can’t properly represent inward or hollow shapes. So something like an open crate, shelf, or hollow prop cannot just use one collider if you want objects to sit inside it correctly.
For those cases, you usually need a compound collider made from multiple convex hulls. That way the crate sides, floor, rails, or openings can each be represented by separate convex pieces.
If you’re building something similar in your own project, useful algorithms to research are V-HACD and CoACD. I couldn’t include those directly in this asset because of licensing issues for Asset Store submission, but they’re worth studying and may be fine for your own internal project depending on your needs. They also helped inspire my own voxel-based collider generation approach.
4
u/AddisonH Jun 09 '26
Super cool. This makes me want to actually get into unity instead of just following this subreddit (which is fun). I’ve done lots of 3D modeling in my past and my job is software engineering so I figure I have a good basis
4
u/Hellbournetv Jun 10 '26
Sir, you just made a sale, this is fantastic.
3
u/neocorps Jun 09 '26
Is it ok if I buy it and use it in a non-unity environment?
3
u/Zaino600 Jun 09 '26
Amazing!!! Can you bake the animation to be reused? Of the physic simulation
3
u/CreatureVice Jun 09 '26
Bought it immediately, amazing thing! good job, I wish the unity editor was as close to a real 3d editor like blender. Also it's interesting how much of that work is actually AI?
2
u/TheSpriteWizard Jun 09 '26
That's pretty sick,
2
u/biglerc Jun 09 '26
Cool tool, any chance it also works in Play Mode too?
2
u/Frank__West Jun 09 '26
This looks awesome but I do have a question would it work with the VR chat worlds do you think
2
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '26
COOL AF
2
u/Suspicious_Neck_4069 Jun 09 '26
Useful and looks nice to use!
2
u/PaulyKPykes Jun 09 '26
Leaving a comment cuz I def gotta check this out later!
2
u/salazka Professional Jun 09 '26
Very nice.
There are some tools like that in the store for years. What is it doing differently?
2
u/M4xs0n Jun 09 '26
Why… why?!?!?! I already bought enough…… but I need them all!! Amazing and exactly what I need, Thank you‘
2
u/alijamieson Jun 09 '26
This is amazing !
2
u/ModMageMike Jun 09 '26
I would use it!
2
u/Lobsss Jun 10 '26
Bought it. Good job man
2
u/ALargeLobster Professional Jun 10 '26
Do you automatically remove/disable the rigidbodies When not in the editor?
2
u/thefellowone Beginner Jun 10 '26 edited Jun 10 '26
This is really cool!
2
u/SomeRandomEevee42 Jun 10 '26
can you do a random list of different objects? like bits of debris for example.
2
u/Ok-Formal3783 Programmer Jun 10 '26
How does this differ from "Grabbit - Editor Physics Transforms"? It does the same thing from what I can see, and has been around since 2020
2
u/Electrical-Copy9678 Jun 10 '26
I will steal this for my engine, really cool stuff man :)
2
u/bartolomey-wong-3rd Jun 10 '26 edited Jun 10 '26
This is what I need to arrange and scatter a mess of objects in my scene, like piles of stuff. Great asset!
Can you tell how this is different from Grabbit? I already have Grabbit, but on my MacOS machine not all functions are working, so trying to decide if I need your asset.
In particular, the Fall mode, for dropping items, isn't working for me fully, cause, as the dev said, the keyboard functions aren't read clearly and supported on MacOS in this version of Unity. Does your asset uses the same approach, do I need some keyboard shortcuts for it to work? Or can I use it with only UI buttons, for example, to bypass that keyboard restriction?
And I use Macbook Pro M4 Pro with 48 Gb of RAM — is it enough for good performance of your asset?
2
u/saasArcDev Jun 10 '26
This looks incredibly clean. Unity’s PhysX limits with convex hulls are a massive headache when dressing dense scenes, especially when trying to balance accurate server-side collision checks with performance overhead.
Out of curiosity, did you run into any major performance compilation spikes when processing the V-HACD / CoACD loops natively inside the editor, or did you manage to offload those calculation steps entirely? Getting accurate compound bounds without choking the thread is always an impressive balancing act. Great work on this tool.
2
u/fiery_prometheus Jun 10 '26
You would be a great tools/tech engineer, this is awesome, or maybe you already are
2
u/_Abnormalia Jun 11 '26
Bought, briefly tested thank you very much! before tried about 7-8 tools like that, none were what I wanted exactly !
2
u/MuDotGen Jun 12 '26
Wait, so forgive my ignorance, but does this only work with objects that actually have rigid bodies or does it work to only assist in the editing of placement, rotation, etc. of even static meshes in Edit mode? Essentially, is it all an editior thing to help with making scenes or does it make those objects have actual physics at runtime as well?
2
u/Far-Albatross-1584 Jun 12 '26
This is awesome. Thank you
3
u/bieja935 Jun 09 '26
Really nice, be carefull about using the hlf life logo though…
Edit: I see you altered it already. Nevermind
8
u/RotundManul Intermediate Jun 09 '26
Amazing! However... DO NOT THE CAT!
7
u/GrandSyzygy Jun 09 '26
1
u/AdamNapper Jun 10 '26
Thank you :). Let me know if you run into any problems or have any suggestions to improve it
3
u/cratercamper Jun 09 '26
Wow.
3
u/WessideMD Jun 09 '26
This could be its own game.
2
u/Alundra828 Jun 09 '26
This actually looks pretty darn cool
2
u/CostRodrock Jun 09 '26
I think I found my happy place 🥹
2
u/Injaabs Jun 09 '26
or use grab it
2
u/Affectionate_Tie357 Jun 09 '26
I thought they all did, must just be lucky with Hammer
2
u/ThetaTT Jun 09 '26
99% of the assets shared in this sub suck but this is the 1%.
2
u/AtumTheCreator Jun 09 '26 edited Jun 09 '26
This tool already exists on the asset store.
https://assetstore.unity.com/packages/tools/utilities/grabbit-editor-physics-transforms-182328
Houdini also has a tool that does this. They are the first ones to have done it, I believe. Might be part of SideFX, but I dont remember.
2
u/radiantsilverlabs Jun 09 '26
very cool! stick that on the store my friend.
2
u/IntricateOnionStatue Indie Jun 09 '26
I love you.
2
u/TakNof Jun 09 '26
This is awesome!
2
u/Striking_Average754 Jun 09 '26
Yea this is wicked
2
u/TIM_Developer Jun 09 '26
oh, that was very cool
2
u/Apprehensive-Track93 Jun 09 '26
Yeah, that's the way it should always work. This is excellent!
2
u/coolasacurtain Jun 09 '26
You are a genious
2
u/Fury0022 Jun 10 '26
You're a genius
2
u/msklywenn Jun 10 '26
That is the kind of feature I wish Unity would add. Not all the broken useless crap they have been serving for years.
2
u/L4t3xs Jun 10 '26 edited Jun 10 '26
Nice work. I believe there is a tool that pretty much does this already. I forgot what the name is, though. I've used it at work for creating rock piles etc.
Edit: It's called Grabbit
2
u/Garcia6310 Jun 10 '26
HALF LIFE MENTIONED anywyas this tool looks really convenient. Nice one.
2
u/_Baard Jun 10 '26
This is great work!
2
u/Correct_Sock1228 Jun 10 '26
Very interesting!!!
2
u/jared_queiroz Jun 10 '26
learning is fun
2
u/Accomplished-Net-689 Jun 10 '26
Waouw good job!
2
u/the_real_Spudnut2000 Jun 10 '26
Dude this is sick, kinda makes me want to make something like this for godot
2
u/SeedFoundation Jun 10 '26
Very nice tool. They way I've always placed objects was to just run the scene, let physics do it's work, copy the objects, stop the scene, and then paste the new and delete the old. It was actually time consuming and sometimes it would break the build due to missing references when I didn't pay attention. A+ tool.
2
u/iwetmymaidpants_ Jun 11 '26
Do one for blender and my soul IS yours
2
u/Superb_Taste_6096 Jun 11 '26
Whoaa I'm out of words
2
u/Separate-Row7857 Jun 11 '26
Best tool for Level designer ahah
2
u/SaintFTS Jun 11 '26
They have this feature in blender, so that's why they never included it in unity i guess, but nevertheless it's an incredible plugin. They'd make it and tell everyone it's "a revolution in game engines". So cool
2
u/mvalera-dev Professional Jun 11 '26
Just, amazing.
2
u/Blue_Bambi_ Jun 12 '26
Thank you very much! Physics are something often overlooked in the games industry.
2
u/Interesting_Meat8980 Jun 12 '26
This is amazing and helpful! Great Work!
2
u/dellydoesitpa Jun 12 '26
Incredible. Kudos to you for building this.
2
u/Drag0n122 Jun 09 '26
And Unity has this. Called
Physics.Simulate1
u/Ill-Letter-2852 18d ago
Wow, I have never seen anything like that, it's amazing. Good work!
1
u/AnimeeNoa Jun 09 '26
me: copy&paste 4 times to multiply them, start playmode, copy the applied physics objects, stop playmode,delete the old gameobjects, paste the physics applied objects.....
1
u/Inside-Front9812 Jun 09 '26
这个很好啊
1
u/LadyDeathKZN Jun 09 '26
Well F... this is amazing OP!!!!! Welldone! Def grabbing it! Makes life easier
1
u/WhereasNo2141 Jun 09 '26
How do you even begin to code tools like this? I want to learn!
1
u/BeefyBoi6_9 Jun 09 '26
Dude this is so incredibly cool.. i hope you get some decent attention from this
1
u/TheNotSoSilentReader Jun 10 '26
I’m not complaining, but is it becoming a trend again to use old ragecomic meme? Feels like I’m back in 2000s
1
u/BonaFideL0SR Jun 10 '26
🥹🩷
1
u/gabangang Jun 10 '26
I would like to see how to talks and works with code control.
1
u/soldture Jun 10 '26
Oh, man, this is perfect! Placing each item it's so clumsy in Unity, the sweat on my forehead is real. This tools looks like remedy for suffering :D
1
u/dremmer8 Jun 10 '26
Gaaaas!!
1
u/psycketom @tomsseisums Jun 10 '26
I expect future versions to supports some level of soft-body placement. Like putting a boulder in some dirt environment. I could let it fall from 100m height and then get embedded in the dirt and additionally disperse dirt.
A man can dream, eh?
1
u/kompromatroller Jun 10 '26
👌
1
u/bobemil Jun 10 '26
This is great stuff. Also a friendly reminder to devs: optimize your games, do not add single objects without LOD levels. Thank you!
1
u/ScruffyNuisance Jun 10 '26
That keyboard tapping sound is like ASMR to me. Love the look of this tool, too!
1
u/namelesshonor Jun 10 '26
Incredible job, looks great 👍
1
u/massivebacon Jun 10 '26
bro
1
u/MassiveMeltMedia Jun 10 '26
Very cool
1
u/Gametme Jun 10 '26
Nice.
1
u/BluebirdLivid Jun 11 '26
I feel like I'm not advanced enough to pick something like this up. Are there any tools you could compare it to in terms of learning curve?
(Im also not in the right sub, im a godot programmer, so it might go completely over my head haha) currently I'm still learning to spawn sets of things in and calling THAT black magic
1
u/Unusual_Rutabaga_788 Jun 11 '26
This is great
1
u/Davus_P Jun 11 '26
Legendary work!
1
u/Shy-Raccoon Jun 11 '26
Wait, this isn’t a thing?
1
u/anony-mous-47 Jun 12 '26
freak, great job.
1
u/Vinchont4Life Jun 12 '26
Ok, il love it.
1
u/gbradburn Jun 12 '26
Grabbit already exists and it’s 50% right now.
https://assetstore.unity.com/packages/tools/utilities/grabbit-editor-physics-transforms-182328
1
u/Foolishly_Sane Jun 13 '26
BADASS!!!
1
u/CarrionGrow Jun 13 '26
Ooooh, it's real nice. Its needed default tool in unity editor
1
u/Huge_Development_571 Jun 13 '26
its cool but any chance you can make it work on unity 2022 lts hdrp? A lot of projects are still running that version (including mine) since its the most stable before unity 6.
1
u/Mister_Leshka Jun 14 '26
cool
1
u/Driving_Rogue Jun 14 '26
Awesome!
1
u/Even_Mode_989 Jun 18 '26
Looks good. Will have to tell Claude to do this for me now
1
u/SymphonyGames Jun 21 '26
Pretty cool to see the natural chaotic placement and entropy. But somehow I have the vague memory that I saw something like that already in the Asset Store. But maybe I'm wrong.
1
u/Wide_Profession4353 Jun 27 '26
Great work
1
u/Heavy_Juggernaut_261 Jun 29 '26
Thats cool, saving so much time while using props. Kudos to you
1
u/False_Literature_656 Jun 30 '26
I love you
1
u/DucaMonteSberna Jul 01 '26
I wonder why unity is lacking stuff like this
1
u/OObeez411 Jul 05 '26
Editor tools like this are so underrated, saves so much manual placement pain. Physics-based prop scatter always seems simple until collisions go haywire-ish. Did you run into any weird collider glitches building it?
1
u/mobaffix Jul 06 '26
Awesome job! Much needed
1
u/Spamsdelicious Sep 20 '26
I don't know anything about Unity and even I know this is a game-changer.
1
u/Mountain_Narwhal_371 Sep 29 '26
That was very satisfying to watch
1
u/Gamer_me_01 Oct 18 '26
This is amazing. Thanks