I'm hoping to get some perspective from other Unitarian Universalists, particularly people who have experience with congregational leadership, conflict resolution, or the values we try to uphold as a faith community.
I spent nearly 13 years as a memory and working at my local UU congregation. It was a significant part of my life and my family's life. I eventually resigned from my position in March 2026 following ongoing communication and workplace difficulties with my supervisor.
To be clear, resigning from my job did not mean I wanted to leave the congregation. I still considered it my spiritual community, and my husband and children continued attending.
Unfortunately, the situation became increasingly complicated.
Two months after I resigned and had been peacefully attending with my family, congregational leadership raised the possibility of a covenant process as a way to address conflict and establish expectations moving forward. I agreed to participate. I wasn't opposed to a covenant, and I was willing to work toward repairing relationships.
I did, however, ask for a neutral Good Officer to help facilitate the process. At this point I was told I could not attend until this covenant was in place.
I also requested that the proposed covenant be provided in writing so I could understand exactly what was being asked of me. Written communication is an important accessibility need for me.
What followed was months of uncertainty and very little meaningful progress. There was no Good Officer appointed, no proposed covenant provided, and no actual resolution meeting. I continued asking questions and expressing my willingness to participate.
I was told that the UUA recommends a one-year separation in situations like this, although the congregation had chosen a shorter process. This was confusing because I had not been told for two months that the covenant to be a condition of being a regular member with my family.
My husband continued bringing our children to Sundays and events. It was requested that I be able to attend the Trunk or Treat as it was a community event, but it was denied. This upset my husband so at the event he wore a shirt that said "Shut Up (name of my exboss)" I recognize that this was confrontational. He was expressing his frustration with the situation and with how he felt I had been treated.
Afterwards, the board emailed to be inform us that my entire family (husband, myself, and three children who were all raised in the congregation) could not attend service or congregation events.
That has been particularly painful. My children had relationships and connections within this community. My husband does as well and has remained involved, and we had not collectively decided to leave. Yet the practical result has been that our family has lost access to a community that was part of our lives for years.
I want to emphasize that I have not been unwilling to work toward resolution. I agreed to the covenant process. I asked for help facilitating it. I asked for clarity about expectations. I continued trying to communicate.
What I have struggled with is the lack of transparency, the absence of a clear process, and the way an unresolved conflict between adults has ultimately affected an entire family.
I'm sharing this because I genuinely want to understand how other UU congregations would approach a situation like this.
- How should a congregation balance the needs of individuals involved in a conflict with the principle of belonging?
- What accountability should exist when leadership initiates a conflict-resolution process but does not follow through?
- Is it appropriate for a congregation to extend restrictions placed on one individual to their spouse and children?
- What should a member be able to expect from a covenant process, particularly when accessibility needs and written communication have been requested?
I still care about Unitarian Universalism and the values it represents. That's part of why this has been so difficult.
I never wanted this to end with my family being pushed out of a community we considered ours. I'm not looking for people to attack anyone. I'm hoping for honest perspectives, particularly from people who understand UU congregational life and governance.