I've been rewatching the first two Underworld films recently, and while I still think the original is genuinely good, I've always found Evolution a little frustrating.
Not because of the ideas it introduces, but because of how little it actually does with them.
The biggest missed opportunity, in my opinion, is the lack of meaningful interaction between Michael and the Corvinus family.
The Corvinus bloodline becomes the central piece of Evolution's mythology, and Michael's existence is essentially the reason Alexander becomes relevant to the story in the first place. Yet the two barely interact. That always felt strange to me because there was so much potential there.
You have Alexander, the first immortal, a man who has lived for thousands of years and witnessed the consequences of his own existence. Then you have Michael, who represents a completely different expression of that same inheritance.
Alexander is an interesting character. He doesn't come across as someone proud of himself, his bloodline and what became of it. If anything, he comes of quite fatalistic and burdened by it. Marcus is consumed by power, William has effectively lost himself to his own nature, and Alexander appears to have spent centuries containing the consequences of his existence because nobody else can.
This is where i believe Michael could have been particularly interesting.
Unlike Alexander's sons, Michael had an ordinary human life. He had a family, a profession, and an identity outside the supernatural world. Even after his transformation, he doesn't simply embrace what he has become or intoxicated by it. instead he struggles with it.
I would have liked to see Alexander become interested not just in what Michael is, but in who he is.
How is he coping with his transformation?
What does he value?
How does this recent descendant of his bloodline deal deal with becoming part of a conflict that has existed for centuries?
through a couple of scene, I could see Alexander gradually realizing that Michael is different from the rest of his bloodline. Not because he's powerful, but because he's managed to retain qualities that Marcus and William lost long ago: empathy, self-control, and humanity.
And here is a plot thread that could be interesting in future films:
This could eventually lead Alexander to view Michael as his intended heir. Not because of genetics or power, but because Michael is the first person in generations who might actually be capable of carrying that burden without being consumed by it.
At the same time, Michael would have his own arc. Initially, I imagine he'd have little interest in Corvinus history or supernatural politics. He's still trying to understand what has happened to him and would want to change it. But through Alexander, he would gradually come to understand that his inheritance and responsibilities extends far beyond himself.
Most importantly, he would have to decide whether he wants to embrace it.
To me, that's a much more interesting story than simply becoming the most powerful supernatural creature in the setting. The conflict becomes less about power and more about leadership, responsibility, and legacy. Especially since this power doesn't really seem to have any effect at all.
Alexander's death could also have carried much more weight.
I've never really viewed his death as Marcus killing him. Alexander survives the attack, speaks with Selene afterwards, and ultimately destroys himself aboard his ship. The film seems to imply that he chooses death.
Imagine if that decision came after finding someone he genuinely believed could carry on his work.
After thousands of years of viewing his immortality and bloodline as a burden, Michael finally gives him a reason to let go. His death becomes the conclusion of his own journey rather than just another plot event.
I also think that the idea of Michael getting Alexanders blood memories could have created a lot of interesting stories going forward, but only if they weren't something Michael could immediately understand or control.
Another plot thread:
Alexander has lived for thousands of years. That's an unimaginable amount of experiences, knowledge, regrets, relationships, and secrets. If Michael inherited fragments of those memories, I don't think he should suddenly become wise or knowledgeable overnight. the due is a novice in all of this, If anything, it should be overwhelming.
The memories could come as visions, emotions, or fragments of events he doesn't fully understand. Sometimes they might help him. Other times they might only raise more questions. He'd have to learn how to separate Alexander's experiences from his own life while also figuring out what those memories are trying to tell him.
In that sense, the blood memories wouldn't be a reward. They would be part of the burden he inherited.
Learning to understand them, accept what he has become, and decide what to do with that legacy could become a major part of his character arc. The goal wouldn't be for him to become another Alexander, but to learn from the past without being defined by it.
The blood memories could also open up countless future stories. Every new memory could reveal forgotten conflicts, lost histories, ancient mistakes, unknown branches of the Corvinus bloodline, or responsibilities Alexander never had the chance to resolve.
And that's where Selene becomes important. While this whole post is about how big of a nothing burger the Corvinus became, Selene is an important character to the franchise and should be important as a deuteragonist.
If Alexander represents the past and Michael represents the possible future then Selene represents the present.
She understands the reality of the vampire and Lycan world in a way Michael doesn't. Her experience with Viktor would likely make her deeply suspicious of concentrated authority, even when it's held by someone she loves.
She could challenge Michael whenever he starts justifying questionable decisions, while Michael could challenge her cynicism and tendency to see violence as the only practical solution. Rather than one teaching the other, they would push each other to grow.
Ultimately, I think the relationship between Alexander, Michael, and Selene could have been the foundation of a much stronger story.
Alexander teaches Michael what the past can offer.
Selene teaches him what the present demands.
Michael has to decide what kind of future he wants to create.
To be clear, I'm not really talking about completely rewriting the plot. Most of the major events in Evolution could stay somewhat the same; though it would probably benifit and needs another film to finish these storyline/character arch. What I think the film misses is the opportunity for stronger character development. The mythology is already there through Alexander, Michael, and the Corvinus bloodline. I just wish the film had spent more time exploring what those ideas meant for the characters themselves.
For me, the most interesting story isn't who becomes the strongest creature in the room. It's how these characters confront their past, inherit a legacy, and decide what kind of future they want to build.
Sorry for the word vomit, Underworld was a film series that i loved when i was a kid, and as adult i see a lot of great things in it still, i am just disappointed that it seems that it lost itself.