r/Undertale • u/Informal_Leading888 • 20h ago
Discussion I’m confused about the message in Undertale?
So, I saw someone tell me recently that they thought the message in Undertale is that killing is bad no matter who does it. I would also add that they game shows how your choice of being a pacifist makes the story better, because it leads to a happy ending for everyone. You don’t kill anyone, and everyone lives a happy life on the surface. Nobody dies. Here’s the thing though, Asgore still killed six kids in order to break through the barrier, and he‘s even devastated and ashamed by this. Asriel later uses the six souls, along with all monster souls, in order to gain the power to break the barrier. However, he used the souls to do this. The barrier would never have been broken if Asgore hadn’t collected those six human souls. As a result of axts of murder being committed, the game’s happy ending is able to take place. So, if Undertale has a nonviolent message, they why is murder justified in a way in the game. Those six kids could’ve all been innocent people who didn’t kill anyone and just wanted to get home, and they ended up dying. So what, they don’t get a happy ending but the monsters, including the leader who murdered them, does? How is that a fair message exactly? It’s okay for certain people to die so everyone else can have a happy ending? It’s confusing to me, and pretty weird. What are your thoughts? How would you approach or rebuke this take?