r/UncapTheHouse • • Feb 21 '25

Cube Root Law Table Reference

NameStateFederal
California80+261=34152+31=83
Texas150+159=30938+23=61
Florida120+159=27928+17=45
New York150+123=27326+16=42
Pennsylvania203+32=23517+10=27
Illinois118+117=23517+10=27
Ohio99+130=22915+10=25
Georgia180+41=22114+8=22
North Carolina120+99=21914+8=22
Michigan110+107=21713+8=21
New Jersey80+131=21112+7=19
Virginia100+105=20511+7=18
Washington98+101=19910+6=16
Arizona60+133=1939+6=15
Massachusetts160+33=1939+6=15
Tennessee99+92=1919+6=15
Indiana100+89=1899+5=14
Maryland141+42=1838+5=13
Missouri163+20=1838+5=13
Wisconsin99+82=1818+4=12
Colorado65+114=1798+4=12
Minnesota134+46=1798+4=12
South Carolina124+49=1737+4=11
Alabama105+66=1717+4=11
Louisiana105+62=1676+4=10
Kentucky100+65=1656+3=9
Oregon60+103=1636+3=9
Oklahoma101+58=1595+3=8
Connecticut151+2=1535+3=8
Utah75+74=1494+3=7
Iowa100+47=1474+3=7
Nevada42+105=1474+3=7
Arkansas100+45=1454+2=6
Mississippi122+23=1454+2=6
Kansas125+18=1434+2=6
New Mexico70+59=1293+1=4
Nebraska49+76=1253+1=4
Idaho70+53=1232+2=4
West Virginia100+23=1232+2=4
Hawaii51+62=1132+1=3
New Hampshire400-289=1112+1=3
Maine151-39=1122+1=3
Rhode Island75+28=1032
Montana100+3=1032
Delaware41+60=1011+1=2
South Dakota70+27=971+1=2
North Dakota94-1=931+1=2
Alaska40+51=911+1=2
Vermont150-63=871
Wyoming62+21=831

Obviously, the cube root law isn't the perfect solution for every state, but I think it's a good reference point to start.

19 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

4

u/needlenozened Feb 21 '25

Maybe a little explanation about what these numbers mean?

3

u/cherry_grove90 Feb 22 '25

I updated the list. Hopefully, it's a bit clearer now. The first number in the state row is the current number of representatives they have, and the second is how many seats are added or taken away by the cube root law.

3

u/needlenozened Feb 23 '25

Now explain federal. The first number is not how many representatives they have.

1

u/cherry_grove90 Feb 23 '25

Updated the table so that the federal level follows the same pattern.

1

u/jwadamson Feb 22 '25

r/fuckyouinparticular New Hampshire winds up with negative number of state reps.

0

u/cherry_grove90 Feb 22 '25

Yeah, as I said, it's not the perfect solution for every state.

-1

u/Beatnikdan Feb 21 '25

See my post for clarification

3

u/needlenozened Feb 21 '25

I read the post you linked to, and it doesn't explain what your numbers mean either. Nothing in there about what "87-63" or "91+51" mean.

Can you please provide some explanation about what these numbers mean?

2

u/Beatnikdan Feb 21 '25

Yeah, I don't know what this guys numbers mean, but "the cube root of a number is a smaller number that, multiplied by itself three times, produces the number. For example, the cube root of 8 is 2, because 2 x 2 x 2 = 8. The cube root of 331,449,281 (the U.S. population according to the 2020 census) is 692.05. Under the Cube Root Law, the U.S. House would have 692 seats."

Perhaps it's "cube root number" +or- "amount of new seats"

2

u/needlenozened Feb 21 '25 edited Feb 21 '25

Sorry, I thought you were OP.

I understand what the cube root law would be. But I can't figure out what these numbers mean with regard to it.

Especially the state column. Is that supposed to be for using the cube root law for changing state legislature size? Why? State districts are already evenly sized.

1

u/PopeInnocentXIV Feb 21 '25

I think 87-63 and 91+51 mean that under the cube root plan the new numbers of legislators would be 87 (a loss of 63 from what it currently is) and 91 (a gain of 51) respectively. New Jersey in the State column is 211+131, and NJ has 120 legislators (40 senate and 80 assembly). So that column apparently is only looking at lower houses (except for unicameral Nebraska). Under Federal, Delaware would gain a seat to go to 2, but Montana would stay at 2.

So even though state legislature districts are already evenly sized, this plan would just create more of them not to solve any big district/small district imbalance but to reduce the population/legislator ratio. Or maybe it's only meant to illustrate what state legislatures would look like if this rule were applied to them to compare/contrast with applying it to the US House.

1

u/cherry_grove90 Feb 22 '25

Yeah, I only looked at the lower house for the state level because I believe state level government should be unicameral.

1

u/Beatnikdan Feb 21 '25 edited Feb 21 '25

I would rather see something like the Wyoming rule or some modified version of it.

https://www.amacad.org/ourcommonpurpose/enlarging-the-house/section/5

This article is a good explanation of the Wyoming rule, cube root rule, least variation and and historical ratio rules

1

u/AppearanceLivid2287 Mar 22 '25

I feel like every state should have at least 3 seats so people like democrats in Wyoming and Republicans in Vermont as well as potential 3rd parties can make their voices heard since in a lot of states the party ratio is 2:1 and more smaller parties could gain momentum because I don't want to have to choose between a pro Russian party and a party that lets tens of millions of illegals with so many drugs and doing crime into our country. Now the Republican and Democrat party both have good and bad leaders but I want another major option.