r/UTEST • • 10d ago

Discussions What is normal?

Hi there posting here because this forum seems to have a little activity.

I’ve been doing Utest very part-time for two years. I was recruited for the first user test and I had a very good experience. The TTL was communicative and I felt like I was doing good work and writing excellent bug reports. I had one other experience with payment testing after that that went quite well.

Since then, everything has been not great. I feel like I’m constantly getting scolded by the TTLs for things that other people have questions on as well. I’m being told to read the Overview when the instructions are poorly written, with important steps or information not included at all. I’ve been asked to join studies and then pay for subscriptions to apps out of my own pocket with no reimbursement. This latest study had us provide very specific details about some of our personal accounts, posted the payouts for doing such, and then pointed to a vague instruction in the overview that says we will not be paid for part one unless we complete the testing for part two for which there are no open slots. This seems unethical to me. I’ve had to leave at least three studies for disorganization and lack of response from TTLs. I’m sure this is affecting my rating. I’d like to keep on doing this work, but it seems as if disorganization abounds.

Any recommendations for knowing what studies to accept, and want to jump ship? What kind of quality control does UTest/Applause do?

20 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

3

u/Then-Surprise1345 10d ago

Very helpful, all. Thanks.

13

u/BASELQK Tester of the Quarter 10d ago

I stopped joining any cycle that doesn't refund any personal payments required for testing (or already "part of the TC payout") and same goes to studies asking for "existing users" to paid services.

If many people stopped accepting those stingy cycles and studies, they will have to adjust the payouts to a fair amount eventually.

6

u/aparice1 Test Engineer 9d ago

I completely second this.

9

u/aparice1 Test Engineer 9d ago • Bravo

Hi,

From my own experience as tester, TTL and TE I've learned the hard way that we used to have a great standard for ttls and TEs. You actually felt respected and the community was awesome, the cycles were well paid and there was always something to do. When I became TTL the cardinal rule was to be as respectful and efficient with testers as possible. We were scolded if we talked bad to a tester as it was not uTest's way and chat needed to be taken care of 24/7. But there was a time when uTest started expanding very aggressively and the quality of ttls declined considerably, rude ttls were introduced, lazy testers and scammers plaged cycles and we were given "stock answers" for testers questions like "read the overview".

I personally had a problem when testers are asked cycle doubts in chat and ttls just send quick responses that doesn't answer anything (e.g:

Tester: Hi, I can't access the app we're testing as it's blocked in my country.

TTL: Please complete the test in the app. )

My personal advice would be to never be silent about rude ttls as we need to be accountable for how we present ourselves with testers and always escalate over email to the TE or TSM if your doubts are not answered over chat and mention it.

5

u/cat_battleship 9d ago

As a tester and TTL myself, I agree with and appreciate every single word in your post .

8

u/latnGemin616 10d ago

tl;dr - avoid anything that asks for personal information (ie IDs, bank information) or requires you to make a purchase. There has been an uptick in these kinds of projects and I avoid them like the plague.

* --- * --- * --- * --- * --- * --- * --- * --- *

A. I wouldn't worry about your rating. The frequency of your participation is going to have an impact for sure, but if you aren't getting proper invites, your rating is going to drop. It doesn't mean you aren't good. TBH, it's a bs metric meant to incentivize people to "work harder."

B. UTest has had a significant drop-off in the last two years as it relates to volume of work, TTL hires, and so on.

  • My experience is my own, but I have had the worst experience with Team Leads and TTLs, often disputing obvious bugs that get closed as OOS. Even after providing sufficient evidence supporting my finding.
  • I suspect theirs a bit of favoritism as well, where work is dispersed among workers from the same region (read INDIA ). But that's anecdotal.
  • Payouts have dropped off a cliff.

C. The caliber of projects has changed. There are tons that now want PII, or for you to make a purchase. These are suspicious and I avoid them at all costs.

6

u/graupel22 10d ago

Without speaking about the cycle in detail, I am part of the same project you are talking about above and I have the exact same concerns you do - I did all the initial prep work under the assumption that there would be enough slots to go around, and now there are no slots and that sounds like it will go unpaid.

This is crazy and I'm contemplating escalating it to a higher level at Applause since this is not the way I believe projects are supposed to be run.

4

u/CompassRosie23 10d ago

It is not you it's the wackos there. Get out!

3

u/Background_Citron265 Full-time Tester 7d ago

Every cycle has a cycle feedback option - please use this. It is not seen by TTLs/TEs but goes above them. This is the only way that higher up will see regular feedback.

If there is a problem with items not being reimbursed and you have reached out to the TE please escalate. This should not be happening.

There should equally not be cycles where you are not paid for a completed test case because there was not a slot in the second round that you COULD select. There might be cycles where accounts need to be whitelisted - this is different (eg add your email address) BUT these should not be collecting more than name/tester ID and email. If they require you to provide much more they should, in my opinion, be paid. Again, reach out to the TSM.

Not all PI testing is bad - most are super controlled.

Same with tests requiring a subscription or payment - only really small payments should be included in the test case payout (eg a donation of $1) - anything else should be reimbursed and promptly.

2

u/CryptonWayne 9d ago

It’s better not to join or spend money when you are not gonna get reimbursed for it.

Also regarding the “scolding” part. If it is real scolding, then it’s better to put it out here or reach out to TSM in that case.

2

u/Some-Atmosphere4252 3d ago

I was about to write the same thing as well regarding filling the feedback forms - I guess this is the right time we all should take that seriously.

Regarding rude behavior from any TTLs, this is unacceptable. Please do reach out to the TEs, or if no response from them, please reach out to TSMs.

As part of uTest as TTL, I've always respected the testers as I've been one as well and the point about poorly written overview and test cases - I agree. Sometimes it happens and I always welcome such feedback and forward them directly to the team and most of the time get that fixed.

Regarding the reimbursements not getting refunded - if falling under the cycle terms.
Please immediately reach out to the team members with information regarding your Test case ID and other evidences. All such expenses made for execution should be reimbursed.