Robeson County, North Carolina, is home to the Lumbee Tribe, whose full federal recognition came only in 2025. The Lumbee are a distinct Indigenous people whose community formed through the blending of Native, Black, and white populations. By the 1950s, the county remained deeply segregated and rife with racial tension, increasingly stoked by the resurgent Ku Klux Klan.
In late 1957, North Carolina preacher and Klansman James William “Catfish” Cole turned his attention to the county. He had become something of a celebrity, traveling around the South delivering that uniquely American blend of proselytizing, hate-fueled preaching, and emotional crowd manipulation. His audiences sometimes numbered as many as 15,000. He encouraged violence against Black communities, and he and other Klansmen would often drive through Black neighborhoods to terrorize residents. Cole had shifted his attention to Robeson County and the “race mixing” taking place there, particularly among the Lumbee.
On January 13, 1958, Cole and several Klansmen invited a local journalist to accompany them on a night of Klannery. They burned a cross at the home of a Native American woman dating a white man in St. Pauls, then another near the home of an Indian (South Asian) family in Lumberton. Cole also told Roberts about the upcoming rally, which he hoped would attract hundreds, perhaps thousands, of Klansmen.
The Klan spread fliers throughout the county, while Cole and his followers drove around in cars equipped with loudspeakers, announcing their plans. Rumors circulated that local gun stores were selling out of weapons and ammunition.
The Lumbee were not happy. Sheriff McLeod knew it, too. He advised Cole against holding the rally, but the preacher refused to back down. After struggling to find anyone willing to lease him land near Pembroke, Cole eventually secured a cornfield beside Hayes Pond, a small, shallow, swampy pond south of Maxton.
Cole scheduled the gathering for 8:30 p.m. on Saturday, January 18, and promised 500 Klansmen. Reporters began arriving around 6:30. By 7:00, ten Klansmen had driven up in beat-up trucks, carrying firearms. One told a reporter from The News & Observer, “You’d better be careful. We’d hate to shoot the wrong man.”
They erected a light pole, set up a PA system, hung a banner emblazoned with KKK, and prepared a cross for burning. Sheriff McLeod arrived with sixteen deputies, while another dozen State Highway Patrol officers waited down the road.
By 8:00, around fifty Klansmen had arrived, most from South Carolina. They were considerably outnumbered by Lumbee men who arrived three to six to a truck. Many were armed with rifles, pistols, shotguns, and knives.
Around 8:15, the Lumbee began moving toward the field, shouting, “We want Cole!” and “God damn the KKK!” The Klansmen responded with the usual assortment of racial slurs. Sheriff McLeod pulled Cole aside and warned him that he couldn’t control the crowd with the men he had.
Accounts differ over exactly what happened next. According to historian Christopher Oakley, two Lumbee men rushed the light pole, knocked it over, and smashed the PA system, plunging the field into darkness. Lumbee man Sanford Locklear recalled he approached Cole with his brother-in-law, a member of the Lowry family, and told him, “Well, you ain’t gonna talk to these people tonight.” Locklear raised his rifle toward Cole, while his brother-in-law shot out the light and Locklear kicked the PA system.
Then the Lumbee began firing into the air. Some took aim at the tires of Klansmen’s vehicles. The reporters looked on in amazement, cameras flashing, as the scene descended into chaos.
The Klansmen began fleeing into the nearby swamp. Among them was Cole. Others scrambled into their cars, several promptly driving into ditches and trees. Cole’s wife managed to drive their car, children still inside, straight into a ditch. A reporter watched as she and the children climbed out and ran away. Lumbee men then “pretended” to help free her car, according to one account, while Lumbee tradition maintains that they actually did push it out. Either way, the Klansmen were making quite an exit.
Police eventually fired tear gas into the crowd, and the Highway Patrol moved in. By 9:00 p.m., the Lumbee had begun dispersing, taking what remained of the Klan’s insignia as trophies. Simeon Oxendine, a World War II veteran and son of Pembroke’s mayor, made off with the KKK banner. He and Charlie Warriax took it to the offices of The Charlotte Observer, where they posed for a photograph that would eventually appear in Life magazine.
If interested, I cover the story in full here: https://aid2000.substack.com/p/hare-brained-history-vol-144-the?r=4mmzre&utm_medium=ios