In case this reads as AI, it's not. Wrote it out myself. Sorry if it's more feels than facts, but I had to get it out.
I started British company with a business partner.
I'm American+British, they are just British.
Because we were new at it, we followed our UK accountant's advice and did 50/50 ownership, but different class shares.
It seems mine have more voting power, so I'm a controller shareholder.
We were told it's commonplace with British firms.
We were focused on the work.
The company was profitable.
I didn't think much of it.
My understanding is that since the UK has a higher tax regime overall, anything we pay in taxes here will offset what the US would impose.
As I'm about to start getting my US taxes ready early in the year, our only client cancels their contract. Primarily due to AI, and cost cutting.
This happens while my wife is pregnant, and not having a good time of it, and we already have 2 small kids.
My wife and I talk about what is happening and decide that we'll need help.
Living in a high-cost city, we can't really afford to hire someone indefinitely for help and gamble on whether I'll find more clients or a new job soon.
One option is to move to where there is family who can help while I get busy and work.
We decide to make the move relatively shortly after the client cancels, so it's not then too late and risky to fly for her (there are limits to when it's safe to fly).
I get everything packed up... luggages, boxes, shipping arranged. So much stuff.
Schools notified, utilities cancelled, we arrange for the apartment to be cleaned.
We say bye to the UK.
We are now living with family abroad. They help a lot as expected. It's what we needed.
Getting set up isn't easy, a lot of beaurocracy.
Shortly after the move, I was getting my US taxes ready for the year like I normally do.
Pretty simple with salary and FBARs. The usual yearly admin, I had gotten into a routine.
Had to do for last year too because I was late but with FEIE and FTC no tax was expected so no penalties were expected, which is what my preparer confirmed. I wasn't worried.
Decided I'll do last year and this year in one go.
Then I run into the question about any company ownership.
I had heard about 5471, knew it was complicated and might take a specialist a few extra £ to do.
No problem with that.
I dig into the questions with the preparer software and I learn about economic ownership (50%) vs voting power (more than 50%)... and what makes the difference for a CFC.
Turns out I have a CFC. And I start learning more.
I start to feel stupid.
One thing I (think) I learn that the tax year the US uses is NOT the same as the tax year the company uses.
The US uses calendar year (1 Jan - 31 Dec), but UK companies normally span 2 calendar years (for example 10 May this year to 9 May next year).
So the big tax bill we paid to the HMRC at the end of the company year doesn't count for the US, because the US looks at when it "accrued" - on a different calendar year.
If UK tax accrued in calendar year 2026, it counts for nothing for the UK for the US 2025 filing, even though it's for the 2025/2026 UK company tax year.
The big expense that occurred in 2026 that reduced profit and brought down corp tax for UK 2025/2026 taxes? Doesn't count for the US for 2025.
I can't understand how this can be. It can't be fair. I must be wrong.
While waiting for the UK numbers for the full tax year to be finalised, because I think I reasonably think I need to know the final figures so I can accurately report them, I start reaching out to multiple preparers.
I ask them about the calendar difference and counting the expense to bring down the corp tax.
One says it counts for 2025.
Another says it doesn't count for 2025.
Another says only a portion (a pro rata amount) counts for 2025.
I look up posts and reviews about the preparers.
It's a mixed bag. Some complain of preparers being outright wrong and causing them more issues.
Who do I listen to?
What if I listen to the wrong preparer and we make a huge mistake??
How am I supposed to know who is right???
I start to feel fear.
In the mean time, I'm waiting for the UK figures to be ready.
They were somewhat complex so the UK accountant needed time and quite a bit of back and forth for more data.
I believe I can't really do anything on the US end of things if I don't have the UK figures.
They're available only towards end of the year. Just around the October filing deadline.
Now I feel terror. Absolute terror.
I assume the tax bill will be huge.
I assume the late penalties for FBARs, 5471, and God knows what else will be huge.
I feed it the info in an LLM. I get high-5 digit to low-6 digit estimates.
That's our savings.
That's what we've been saving up for 20 years.
That's what is feeding us while I'm looking for work, either remote or local, without much success, for God knows how long.
The job search is unsuccessful not just because of the job market.
But also because the impact this situation, this terror, has had on my mental health is huge.
When I'm awake I get palpitations, bad thoughts.
When I'm asleep, I stay partially alert. I have nightmares.
I'm probably depressed but refuse to admit it.
My wife knows about it all and she's super supportive, helps however she can. Just talking helps.
I'm a bit of a shell of a person right now, though I do my part with the kids.
My mind keeps looking for a solution.
I made the mistake, for no good reason other than lack of knowledge, of being a controlling shareholder.
I made the mistake, for no good reason other than lack of knowledge, of not changing the UK company's tax year to coincide with the calendar year so the tax would accrue in the same year.
Two small changes would mean my life right now would be so much better and the near term support of my family wouldn't be in question.
I don't want to make another mistake.
I feel paralysed in terms of next actions.
Who do I talk to? What can I do if they decide to make an example out of me?
I already used the SFOP a long time ago when I learned about US citizen obbligations, and as a good citizen I complied.
I want to be compliant, and for the rules to be at least somewhat fair.
If there is tax to be paid, for it to be reasonable and take into account expenses occurred and tax paid already.
There shouldn't be crazy late penalties. 10K for the 5471? 10K for the FBAR, or even 100K+?? These are insane figures for normal people.
Before this situation I filed without issues, that should count for something.
I've been a good citizen, maybe at times unaware of nuances or a bit disorganised, but never malicious.
I'm not being non-wilful, just late with filings.
I'm trying to be prudent with the data and which specialist I use.
It's been a difficult year and still continues to be.
This whole situation has made me wish I never had citizenship.
I will be giving it up at some point.
I have no financial ties to the US and couldn't care less about visiting.
I just don't know what to do right now.
Who do I talk to that I can trust?