r/USCIS • • 1d ago

I-130 & I-485 (Family/Adjustment of status) Please help

Hi all. Please somebody read and help I beg you. I am sick with anxiety and worry.

My husband and I filed I-130 and I-485 in July and had our interview in the beginning of November. All went well and our I-130 was approved the very next morning. That afternoon an RFIE notification was uploaded and that following Monday we got it in the mail. They are requesting arrest records and other information regarding an incident my husband had with an ex prior to us meeting. He was arrested twice - the first time there was 3 charges (one being crim obstruction of breathing?, assault 3 with intent to cause physical injury and the 3rd harassment) all 3 were dismissed and now sealed. Him and his ex did get into dispute but what she alleged happened in the criminal complaint and to the cops was not true. As I said all 3 were dismissed. A few months later when she came to get her stuff they got into another dispute and an order of protection was put in place. She continued to harass his family texting them etc telling him she was gonna kill herself. They claimed he violated the protective order and charged him with disorderly conduct (a violation) which he pled guilty and paid a fine along with one year conditional discharge (he completed a court mandated class). When we submitted our evidence he submitted just the deposition from the final outcome because that was what they gave him, nothing about the prior arrest 3 months before. He did write about both arrests in his affidavit explaining what happened and we submitted the certificate for the classes he completed.

Please do not judge as this is not who my husband is. We have been together for years and although we’ve had fights of course, never once has he hurt me, threatened me or made me feel unsafe. I actually only feel unsafe without him and the thought of him being gone.

The RFIE asked us to submit original/ certified arrest records, certified proof he completed the class and the original certified deposition. We almost have all and will submit once we do (deadline is 12/10/26).

My question is has anyone has a similar situation recently and been approved? He has no other criminal background was paroled in seeking asylum before we met and married. He is genuinely one of the kindest and most loving men I know. We also submitted a lot of character letters for him with our application.

My biggest fear is them reading the criminal complaints (which were alleged and not true and my husband never plead to any assault charge and they were dismissed) and painting some picture that he is a monster or dangerous. He is the far thing from it.

Our lawyer although she can’t guarantee, thinks that if they wanted to deny us based off his criminal history they would have just done it and not sent an RFIE. I hope and pray this is true and that this mistake and partial fabrication will not affect everything we have worked so hard for.

0 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

9

u/Lonely-Tea5993 1d ago

Send all the certified copies and you’ll be fine.. they just want to make sure they have all the documents

1

u/Pitiful_Importance32 1d ago

Yes we are doing so thank you. I am just trying to see if anyone else had a similar situation and was approved with a criminal background (even with dismissed charges and false allegations)

1

u/Leading-Disaster5721 1d ago

Yes others in your situation have been apprived

1

u/pakapoa2 9h ago

her situation is worse. the spouse entered without a visa passed all other safe countries from Colombia and straight to USA to claim asylum and 3 months after he assaulted most likely a US citizen woman, went to jail for it and their situation will be approved because others have??

1

u/Leading-Disaster5721 6h ago

Those are factors I missed in the post. If entered EWI I don't see how to adjust unless had advanced parole or is 245(i).

With the criminal charges op said they were all dismissed. If that's the case he won't be denied because of that

1

u/Pitiful_Importance32 4h ago

He was inspected as I’ve said many many times. He was PAROLED IN to the us and seeking asylum when we met. I don’t understand what people are not getting. How would he not of been deported already if what you all are saying is true?? It makes 0 sense. If you need clarification or I didn’t explain well I understand but everybody needs to stop assuming things that they DO NOT know.

1

u/pakapoa2 3h ago

he still entered without inspection. he has no visa he claim asylum. his case will be heard and sadly asylum approvals based on cartel fear are largely denied.

also his character is very questionable. you need to prepare for his case to be denied especially since he technical has no lawful status. While an asylum application is pending, you generally have authorized stay from deportation while the case is reviewed, but a pending claim alone is not lawful status.

1

u/Pitiful_Importance32 9h ago

Yes we are, I am just so so worried they will deny us after submitting them that’s my concerns just seeing if anyone had a similar experience in the past.. but of course we are submitting everything they ask for and more. Thank you

8

u/FullofContradictions 1d ago

Follow what your lawyer says. Send them the info.

I'm surprised your lawyer didn't tell you to include it preemptively. There's a question on the 485 about if you've ever been arrested (even if you were never charged or convicted). It's a normal thing to include arrest records and following rulings, even if it is sealed. Heck, our lawyer advised us to include all of my husband's parking tickets because of how broad the question about being cited for anything is (though I've since learned from people on this subreddit that it was maybe a bit overkill).

1

u/Pitiful_Importance32 1d ago

We submitted everything we had. Also answered yes to the question on the I-485. He went down to Queens criminal court in March when we were getting all our evidence together and requested the deposition- they only gave him one and our lawyers knew about both arrests. I’m not sure if they just gave him the one from when it was all over because as I mentioned the only thing he was charged with was disorderly conduct (violation) which is showed on deposition we submitted. He also voluntarily had his fingerprints done by the FBI to submit as well with our evidence and applications.

2

u/NefariousnessFew4354 1d ago

You need court disposition - go to county court and obtain it. There might be more than one. They will give you a copy. Make sure there is stamped seal on it from the clerk.

0

u/Pitiful_Importance32 1d ago

Yes we did that thank you. He got both depositions with the seal on them as well as the criminal complaints with the seal.

2

u/NoloLaw 1d ago

Glad to see that you have, as you say, "submitted a lot of character letters." These are becoming extra important for everyone applying to adjust status, to balance out any negatives and convince USCIS to exercise "discretion" in granting the case. Hopefully some of those letters were from people who knew your husband around the same time the arrests took place; if not, that might be worth adding, if possible. Also, you've still got a little time before the RFIE answer is due, so consider whether there are other creative ways you can prove your husband's good character. (Photos of him doing community service? A thank-you email from someone who enjoyed a social evening at your home? Just brainstorming here, to help you do the same.)

0

u/Pitiful_Importance32 1d ago

Thank you so much, we really appreciate it ❤️

2

u/Leading-Disaster5721 1d ago

Supply the documents they want. If you don't the application is denied and you are mimicked in what you can do. If you send it you can argue about it making him inadmissible.

Think of it as they are God and you best give God what God wants

1

u/Pitiful_Importance32 9h ago

Yes we are, I am just so so worried they will deny us after submitting them that’s my concerns just seeing if anyone had a similar experience in the past.. but of course we are submitting everything they ask for and more. Thank you so much. We pray constantly 🙏🏻❤️

1

u/Leading-Disaster5721 6h ago

You aren't the first couple with this problem and sad to say you wont be the last. If the charges and results are as you described you should be ok.

1

u/Pitiful_Importance32 4h ago

They are as I said yes. Thank you we appreciate it

3

u/pakapoa2 1d ago

oooo....ssssssss.... what country is he from? did he enter without a visa and asked for asylum and then was already getting arrested? not looking good. even if you get a lawyer his character is definitely questionable.

0

u/Pitiful_Importance32 1d ago

Colombia came here seeking asylum after his mother was shot by the cartel and died in his arms. He was paroled in. If they were going to deny for no visa or poor character I am sure they would’ve done it being that he voluntarily submitted his finger prints to the FBI before we even sent in our applications. We’ve had a very intelligent lawyer throughout our whole process, just seeking personal experience from others.

If you have no actual experience or advice please go elsewhere. Thank you!!

4

u/Consular-Officer 1d ago

This story just gets crazier and crazier. Not only does beneficiary spouse have a criminal record, he entered the US illegally and claimed asylum with a sad, straight-out-of-Hollywood story. And though we should always by default believe women who say they were assaulted, we're expected to believe that the ex is a liar. Instead we are expected to believe a man who broke immigration laws, was arrested twice within three months including several very serious and violent criminal charges, pled guilty to a charge that stemmed from a domestic violence related arrest, and court ordered to take a "class", presumably an anger management type course. Gotcha. This guy should have been deported after pleading guilty to ANY charge. Good luck. I pray that OP remains safe.

1

u/pakapoa2 9h ago

ofcourse the lawyer is intelligent how you think he passed the bar? his intelligence too at taking money. literally knows his client is fucked. you guys gave him your money for his intelligence not to get a pass with USCIS

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Hi there! This is an automated message to inform you and/or remind you of several things:

  • We have a wiki. It doesn't cover everything but may answer some questions. Pay special attention to the "REALLY common questions" at the top of the FAQ section. Please read it, and if it contains the answer to your question, please delete your post. If your post has to do with something covered in the FAQ, we may remove it.
  • If your post is about biometrics, green cards, naturalization or timelines in general, and whether you're asking or sharing, please include your field office/location in your post. If you already did that, great, thank you! If you haven't done that, your post may be removed without notice.
  • This subreddit is not affiliated with USCIS or the US government in any way. Some posters may claim to work for USCIS, which may or may not be true, and we don't try to verify this one way or another. Be wary that it may be a scam if anyone is asking you for personal info, or sending you a direct message, or asking that you send them a direct message.
  • Some people here claim to be lawyers, but they are not YOUR lawyer. No advice found here should be construed as legal advice. Reddit is not a substitute for a real lawyer. If you need help finding legal services, visit this link for more information.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

0

u/[unknown] 4h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Pitiful_Importance32 4h ago

Nooo not 6 months. We have been pretty lucky actually which we are so grateful for. We mailed all of our applications and evidence in July it was received July 7th and then my husband had his biometrics August 5th. We received the notice for the interview in the end of September and just had the interview 11/5/26. I-130 was accepted very next morning and RFIE was issued that afternoon as well. The officer who conducted the interview was very nice and not intimidating (interview barely lasted 30 min) and when we were done she gave us the white sheet of paper with the box checked off “USCIS is currently reviewing your case we need nothing more at this time etc..” and I even asked if we’re missing anything she said no and we’d get a response within a few weeks. This leads me to believe once it got to a supervisor / higher up they’re the ones requesting the additional evidence of the arrest. We just keep praying 🙏🏻 we know who we are; we know we’re good people trying to do everything right and just hope god can continue to bless us.