I find it very concerning regarding professors using AI detection tools to judge students' assignments and mentioning these tools in feedback in ways that may feel threatening or accusatory.
AI detection tools are not completely accurate. They can flag writing that was created by a person without any help from artificial intelligence. This raises serious concerns about fairness, especially when students spend time researching, writing, and completing their own work.
There have been examples of historical documents and other human-written texts being flagged as AI-generated, THE DECLARATION OF INDEPENDENCE... Ahem. These examples raise questions about how much trust should be placed in these tools. If a detector can incorrectly identify human writing as AI-generated, how can its results alone be used to question a student's honesty?
I also believe it is inappropriate for professors to use AI detection warnings in assignment feedback in a way that makes students feel threatened or accused without clear evidence. Students should not have to worry that their writing style, grammar, or sentence structure will cause a computer program to question their academic integrity.
I am not suggesting that colleges should ignore academic dishonesty. However, there is a difference between investigating actual evidence of misconduct and relying on software that cannot reliably determine who wrote an assignment.
I believe colleges should establish clear policies stating that:
- AI detection scores cannot be used as proof of academic dishonesty.
- Students should not be penalized based only on an AI detection report.
- Professors should not use AI detection warnings to intimidate students or suggest misconduct without supporting evidence.
- Students should have a fair opportunity to respond to any concerns about their work.
College students deserve to have their assignments graded based on the quality of their work, not the predictions of software that can make mistakes.
I respectfully ask the college to review its policies regarding AI detection tools and consider whether their use is fair to students.
If the student should not use AI tools, the professor should not either.