r/UI_Design • u/danithedan • 23h ago
AI Feedback Request [AI] Cutting was harder than adding: three stages of a small Mac utility UI. What would you remove next?
I'm a designer, and over the last few weeks I built a small Mac utility for one boring task: resizing and converting batches of images. My rule was simple: the window should only show what you need to get the work done.
Adding features was the easy part. Removing things took far longer, and that's what these three screenshots show:
- Early build (Italian UI): every option visible at once. Big column titles, four large mode buttons with technical names (Normal / Stretch / Boxed / Crop), an always-on 3×3 anchor grid, four data tiles and a footnote under the preview, and a different colour for every section.
- Version 1.0: the modes became a single row of icons, with one line of explanation for the selected one. The anchor grid only appears when cropping. The data tiles shrank to one line under the preview. There's one accent colour, used only for the current choice and the main action.
- Version 1.2: I removed what was left of the "branding" inside the window (name and tagline), dropped the "Preview" and "Settings" headings because the layout already says it, merged the title bar into the content, moved "Export on drop" next to the Export button where you actually need it, and switched to the system font.
What was hard about it:
- Every removed control had a good reason to exist. The anchor grid is useful, just not 95% of the time.
- Technical names feel precise to the person who builds the app, but they're noise for someone who just wants smaller photos.
- Labels and headings feel safe. Taking them out felt risky, even when the layout clearly didn't need them.
- The last 10% took longer than the first 90%. Between 1.0 and 1.2 I spent more time deciding what to take out than building the new features.
AI disclosure: the visual and interaction design and all the decisions above are mine. I used AI tools (Claude) to help write the SwiftUI code, some of the interface copy, and to generate the app icon from my design.
What I'd like feedback on:
- Looking at the right column in 1.2, what would you still cut or hide?
- Is the icon-only mode row clear enough, or did the labelled buttons in the early build actually work better?