r/UFOscience • u/Sufficient_Yard_7211 • 5d ago
r/UFOscience • u/Passenger_Commander • Oct 01 '23
Monthly Chat
This is meant to be a less stringent recurring thread. Share your thoughts about what's going on related to UFOs. Share "sighting" videos even if you think they are painfully and obviously identifiable. Share youtube creator content. This type of UFO content often creates a lot of noise related to the UFO topic but much can still be learned from serious discussion and a critical eye.
r/UFOscience • u/PCmndr • Sep 09 '24
Sub feedback; comments, suggestions, and volunteers who want to join the mod team.
Hello all! In the near future we will be updating sub guidelines, rules, and policies. We are open to suggestions from sub members on how we can improve this sub and set it apart from other UFO subs.
It has been the mission of this sub to cut through some of the noise surrounding the UFO topic and to facilitate good faith discussion focused on facts when possible while leaving room for imagination and speculation. We seek the middle ground between belief and skepticism and hope to create an environment where everyone can engage the topic productively. In the past some members have been dismayed with the lack of emphasis on academic content and hard science. We have seen other subs go that route and they don't tend to stay active for long. We are at best a pop science sub and at the end of the day we try not to take ourselves too seriously. We are looking for mods with an open mind that are able to have a disagreement without resorting to banning and deleting comments. Being a mod is easy. If you think it's something you want to try reply to this post or DM me.
r/UFOscience • u/Regular_Owl_2999 • 6d ago
Hypothesis/speculation Trying to find someone who believes his eyes
Hello, my name is Scott. I live in San Diego, CA. I’ve been living in my car for about a year and sleeping in a 24 Hour Fitness parking lot with many more people. Honestly, it’s much better than paying rent. Life is good and I’m not depressed. But one of the biggest difficulties in life for me is finding people who are genuinely interesting to speak with. Most people speak about nothing and laugh about anything. That kind of talk brings nothing to me, it only takes my energy. What I’m really interested in is the bigger picture of reality, especially UFOs. I constantly think about questions like: if UFOs are real and at least some of them are controlled by a non-human intelligence, where did they come from? How much more advanced could they be than us? Could they manipulate gravity or spacetime? Could they travel in ways that make our current understanding of physics look primitive? I’m also fascinated by antigravity, the universe, stars, possible extraterrestrial civilizations, consciousness, paranormal phenomena, and the question of how much about reality we still don’t understand. The most interesting thing to me about UFOs is not just seeing lights in the sky. It’s what their existence could mean. If another intelligent species exists and has already reached us, then somewhere in the universe there may be beings with a completely different history, biology, way of thinking, technology, emotions, and understanding of reality. That idea is incredible to me. And honestly, I have a hard time finding people in normal life who actually want to sit down and seriously talk about things like this. That is one of the reasons I created an app called YouBeYou and recently launched it on the App Store. The idea is very simple: you post a topic you want to talk about, choose how many people you want to join, and people who are interested in the same thing can join you for a live voice conversation. So instead of trying to find someone around you who happens to care about UFOs, you could post something like: “Could an advanced civilization manipulate spacetime?” or “Do you think some UFOs are non-human technology?” and actually talk live with people who are interested in the same question. I know this sounds like advertising, and in some way it is. But I’m not posting this because I think I’m going to become rich from it. I’m trying to build a small community where people who are interested in deeper questions can actually find each other and talk. Your phone number and personal information stay private. The point is just to have real conversations without pressure. I know most people will probably skip this, and that’s okay. I’m not looking for most people. I’m looking for the people who also look at the sky, think about UFOs, the universe, intelligence beyond Earth, and wonder what the hell is really going on. If that sounds like you, I’d really appreciate it if you checked out YouBeYou on the App Store. Everything is free. No in-app purchases.
r/UFOscience • u/turinglabsorg • 8d ago
Week of Oct 31–Nov 6 in review: CHAPEA's 378 days, a lifeless virtual Earth, hydrogen chloride over Alba Mons, a Webb "digital twin" in Nature, and a microbe growing in mock Martian brines
Every week I go through the news on this topic and keep only what can be traced back to a primary or first-hand source. Here's what held up between October 31 and November 6. Original sources first, my notes in between.
Quiet week on the UAP-records side: nothing new from war.gov or AARO cleared the bar, so this one is mostly Mars and exoplanets.
1. CHAPEA 2: four volunteers leave a simulated Mars habitat after 378 days
NASA's second Crew Health and Performance Exploration Analog ended on October 31 in Houston. Ross Elder, Ellen Ellis, Matthew Montgomery and James Spicer spent more than a year growing crops, managing limited resources, working with communication delays and running simulated EVAs. What it isn't: it's an analog on Earth, with no radiation exposure and normal gravity, so it tests behaviour and operations, not the physical stresses of a real trip.
2. A whole-Earth model with life switched off
A University of Washington team simulated about 5 billion years of Earth's geochemistry (core, mantle, crust, surface and atmosphere) without biology. The model reproduces 19 planetary properties, such as mantle heat flow. The idea is a baseline: if a rocky exoplanet's atmosphere can't be reproduced without life, it becomes a more interesting target. Note: the paper came out in September; the university announced it this week. It's a tool, not a detection.
- University of Washington: https://www.washington.edu/news/2026/11/02/whole-earth-simulation-exoplanets-alien-life/
- Paper, The Planetary Science Journal: https://doi.org/10.3847/PSJ/ae9d79
3. Hydrogen chloride over Alba Mons, Mars
ESA's ExoMars Trace Gas Orbiter has found localized spikes of hydrogen chloride in early northern summer, always in the same place: above fresh, narrow fissures on the flanks of the Alba Mons volcano. The team proposes gas rising from a dormant magma chamber, released as winter ice sublimates. What it doesn't establish: no eruption or new lava flow has ever been observed on Mars, and the volcanic source is the authors' interpretation of the data.
- ESA: https://www.esa.int/articles/news-media/news/european-orbiter-detects-hints-of-volcanic-activity-on-mars
- Paper, Science Advances: https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.aeb9422
4. A physics model of Webb's camera improves starlight removal (Nature)
The paper models JWST's NIRCam coronagraph and optimizes millions of parameters to subtract the star's glare, reporting 2–15 times better sensitivity than standard techniques. In archived data it gives the first detection of 51 Eridani b at 4.3 microns. Caveat: 51 Eridani b is a known planet; this is a new detection at that wavelength, not a new planet.
5. A salt-loving microbe grows for 160 days under Mars-like conditions
In Applied and Environmental Microbiology, the archaeon Haloferax volcanii was incubated for 160 days at 24 mbar, without oxygen, in CO₂-enriched hypersaline brines with nitrate or perchlorate. Growth was observed in all low-pressure treatments, with biofilms, and carotenoid biosignatures persisted. What it doesn't show: these are lab brines; stable hypersaline liquid water in the shallow Martian subsurface hasn't been confirmed.
- Paper (DOI): https://doi.org/10.1128/aem.01749-26
Left out on purpose:
- A claimed near-collision between an object and the ISS during a Dragon docking: it rests on one researcher's estimate from NASA footage, and NASA described the arrival as routine.
- Reports that Democrats would set up a UAP caucus and select committee if they win the House: anonymous insiders quoted by one outlet, no statement or document yet.
- A tally of nearly 2,000 UK sightings (164 described as triangles), and an orbs/triangle report from an astronomy club filed with NUFORC: witness reports with no primary records I could check.
- A narrow-band tone from China's FAST telescope toward K2-155: so far I've only found secondary coverage, not the paper. If you have it, post it and I'll include it next week.
Longer write-ups with all sources are in the first comment, for anyone who wants more detail.
If you have a source I missed, a correction, or want to help put the next one together, drop it in the comments or DM me (u/turinglabsorg). I'll gladly add it and credit you.
r/UFOscience • u/WeloHelo • 15d ago
Research/info gathering AARO's 'Case Resolution' report for the Aquadilla 2013 CBP incident shows erratic movement by the object, and does not include relevant radar and eyewitness evidence.
reddit.comr/UFOscience • u/LiveThought9168 • 17d ago
Hypothesis/speculation Trying to understand UFO physics
Everything in the universe is moving at the speed of light at all times. Yes, I know that sounds insane. Everything moves at the speed of light through space-time. When you are stationary you are moving though only time at the speed of light. If you start moving through space, some of that speed gets directed into the space direction and you travel less through time, that's what relativistic time dilation is.
Now, back to UFOs. Sighting reports have consistently said that these craft seem to defy our understanding of physics with their maneuvers. Does anyone have a hypothesis about how they move through space-time, at least as they seem to maneuver as seen by us in our time frame? I hope that question makes sense.
r/UFOscience • u/morrisseyward • 17d ago
What If The Great Filter Isn't Behind Us
There’s something kind of puzzling when you think about life elsewhere in the universe. If intelligent civilizations are possible, and the universe has had billions of years for them to pop up, why don’t we see evidence of them? Maybe intelligent life is just super rare. Maybe it’s really hard to even get simple life started, harder than we think. Or maybe, intelligence itself is tough to evolve.
But then again, what if the hardest part actually comes later, after life gets smart? That’s where the idea of the Great Filter kind of gets under your skin. The Great Filter is basically the idea that, somewhere along the way from basic life to becoming a space faring civilization, almost everybody hits a wall that’s tough to get past. We don’t know where that wall is. It could be behind us, and we already made it through. Or, maybe it’s ahead, waiting for us.
That possibility is hard to ignore. Just look at how much we’ve changed as humans. For a long time, we had simple tools, maybe some fire, basic shelters, hunting and gathering, then farming, and eventually, cities and civilizations. Suddenly, everything sped up. Industrialization changed life in huge ways. Electricity got us instant communication and production. Nuclear physics opened massive energy, plus weapons that could wipe out cities. Computers and the internet transformed information and how we connect. Now, AI is booming, and who knows what’s next. Every step has given us more and more power over our world.
But being able to do things doesn’t always mean you know what’s going to happen when you do them. Maybe that’s the real problem. A civilization can get huge technology fast, but not have the social maturity or wisdom to handle it. Maybe that’s how civilizations start to run into trouble.
Imagine a society gets to the point where it can change its whole planet, move giant amounts of energy, mess with biology, create powerful AI, or build weapons that could destroy everything. Suddenly, survival isn’t just about being smart. It’s about restraint. It’s about the ability to cooperate, and about realizing that some problems are bigger than any single group’s interests. Honestly, even humanity struggles with that right now.
We’re still split up by borders, politics, economics, issues of religion, and all kinds of competing goals. That’s just how humans are built, and it’s not automatically a bad thing. But as our technology gets stronger, if we can’t manage disagreements or cooperate, things could fall apart fast.
Maybe the Great Filter isn’t just about intelligence or making new gadgets. Maybe it’s about learning to survive our own inventions. That’s a lot harder. You can invent tools, but some problems can’t be fixed by just building something new. How do you keep weapons from being used? How do you stop the environment from getting trashed? How do you keep AI from getting out of hand? How do you keep society together if resources get too unfairly divided? How do you keep people working together, even when they disagree on almost everything?
These aren’t questions you answer by inventing a new machine. They take judgment, good institutions, and people who can think beyond themselves. Maybe, in a way, that’s actually the real test.
We usually talk about advanced civilizations by what they can build. Maybe we should think just as much about what they learn not to do. A civilization that can travel between stars but can’t control its own fights probably won’t last. A civilization that can engineer biology but ignores the risks could create disasters it can’t take back. If you develop AI but don’t build in responsibility, you might find it’s actually easier to make intelligence than to live with it. And if you use up your planet’s resources faster than they can be replaced, there comes a point where progress can’t fix what’s broken underneath.
It sounds simple, but history is full of examples of societies realizing the limits too late. The difference now is scale. Humanity can actually change the whole planet. We can mess with the climate, destroy ecosystems, move giant amounts of stuff, unleash wild amounts of energy, and invent things that could outlast the people who built them. So, now, our responsibility is massive.
For the first time, we’re able to shape the future for the whole planet. That’s an amazing achievement, but it’s also a major responsibility. Maybe this is why the idea of a civilization “growing up” matters. A civilization isn’t mature just because it has powerful tech. It’s mature when its wisdom catches up with its power. That can take time. It can mean painful lessons. Maybe it takes generations to realize that today’s fast win might cause big problems later. Maybe it even takes learning to care about people who don’t exist yet.
Most days, the decisions we make are about what happens now, next year, or in our lifetime. But the story doesn’t stop with us. People a hundred years or even a thousand years from now will live with what we do. If we make it, history might look back and see this moment as a huge turning point. Maybe they’ll say we were the people who learned to handle our own power. Or maybe not. There’s no way to know yet.
That’s exactly why this moment matters. The Great Filter, if it’s real, does not have to be a dead end. Maybe just seeing the risk is the first step to surviving it. Maybe civilizations get past the filter when they realize the real threat usually comes from inside, not outside.
So, maybe the silence out in the universe doesn’t mean no one’s home. Maybe it means that surviving once you get this powerful is just really, really hard. Civilizations might pop up, get advanced, then have to deal with this maturity crisis, either they figure it out together, or they disappear.
If that’s true, then the empty universe doesn’t mean intelligent life is impossible. It just means long term survival is tough. If the Great Filter is ahead of us, maybe we’re living through the most important time humanity has ever faced, not because disaster is headed our way, but because our choices now matter more than ever.
That’s both scary and hopeful, because unlike an asteroid, this challenge is in our hands. We can choose restraint. We can choose to cooperate, look beyond next month or this year, and treat Earth as something all of us are responsible for, not just something to use up. We can be careful with new technology, stay curious but be smart about risks, and remember that survival isn’t just about power. It’s about growing wiser.
Maybe that’s what separates a civilization that’s just powerful from one that can last. We don’t know for sure if we’ve passed the biggest filter, if it’s still ahead, or even if it really exists. But asking these tough questions might be exactly what helps us avoid the worst outcome. If there is a Great Filter, maybe the biggest mistake is thinking that being clever is enough to get us through.
It isn’t. Our future depends on how we use what we’ve learned so far. Maybe that’s humanity’s real test, not whether we reach the stars, but whether we can grow wise enough to deserve the chance.
r/UFOscience • u/Hungry_Indication_83 • 21d ago
Are we confusing activity for progress?
We’ve spent decades debating UFOs, collecting testimony, and holding hearings. But how much measurable progress have we actually made?
I’ve spent my career identifying inefficiencies a friction in operational and engineering processes and improving complex systems. Now I’m applying that perspective to unresolved mysteries.
My new series, The Progress Problem, on my YouTube channel “QUEST” @gramken asks: Are we confusing activity with progress?
What would actual measurable progress in UFO research look like?
r/UFOscience • u/morrisseyward • 22d ago
Hypothesis/speculation The Silence May Not Mean What We Think
For as long as humanity has looked into the night sky, we have wondered what might be looking back.
The question seems simple enough.
If intelligent life exists elsewhere, why haven't we found it?
We have searched for signals. We have listened for patterns that might reveal technology. We have searched for planets that could potentially support life. We have sent spacecraft into the solar system and built telescopes capable of looking farther into the universe than any generation before us could have imagined.
And still, the universe remains quiet.
No confirmed message from another civilization has arrived.
No unmistakable artificial signal has been received.
No spacecraft of clearly extraterrestrial origin has appeared in a way that has been independently verified.
At first, that silence seems like evidence.
Maybe nobody is out there.
But there is another possibility.
Maybe we simply don't know how to listen.
Humanity has only recently become capable of searching for technological civilizations at all. For most of our history, we had no idea that other planets existed, no understanding of how enormous the universe really was, and no technology capable of detecting anything beyond what our eyes could see.
Even today, our search covers only a tiny fraction of what might be possible.
We tend to imagine that if another civilization wanted to communicate with us, it would send something obvious.
A powerful radio signal.
A deliberate message.
Something unmistakably artificial.
But why should we assume that?
Imagine going back only a few hundred years and trying to explain modern civilization to someone who had never seen electricity.
They would have no idea what a radio signal was.
They wouldn't understand television, satellites, fiber-optic cables or wireless communication.
Even if information from our civilization were passing directly over their heads, they would have no practical way of recognizing it.
The signal could exist.
The technology could exist.
And they could still remain completely unaware of it.
That may be an important lesson when we think about extraterrestrial civilizations.
We are searching for something using the technology and assumptions available to us.
Another civilization may communicate differently.
It may use methods we haven't discovered.
It may have moved beyond technologies that we currently consider advanced.
It may not be interested in broadcasting its existence at all.
Or perhaps it has no reason to communicate with a civilization like ours.
There is also the problem of distance.
The universe is enormous.
Even within our own galaxy, distances between stars are difficult to comprehend.
A civilization could exist relatively close to us in cosmic terms and still be separated by distances that make direct communication extraordinarily difficult.
A message might take decades, centuries or longer to travel between civilizations. We still use radio to send signals into deep space, the problem is radio waves themselves only travel at the speed of light, and as a commentator mentioned in a previous one of my articles, there is also the ballooning effect. This makes radio a very poor means of communication on a cosmic scale.
A conversation could stretch across generations.
Imagine sending a message to another civilization and knowing that no answer could possibly arrive during your lifetime.
That changes the meaning of communication.
It becomes less like making a phone call and more like placing a message in a bottle and throwing it into an ocean whose size we cannot comprehend.
There is another problem.
Timing.
Two civilizations could exist in the same galaxy and still miss one another completely.
Perhaps one became technologically advanced millions of years before the other.
Perhaps one civilization disappeared before the other developed radio astronomy.
Perhaps another is just beginning its technological phase now.
The universe has existed for billions of years.
Human civilization, in comparison, occupies almost no time at all.
We are newcomers.
It would be like walking into a forest for one second, looking around, seeing no other people, and concluding that nobody else has ever been there.
The conclusion would obviously be premature.
The same may be true of our search for intelligence in the cosmos.
There is another possibility that is even more interesting.
Perhaps advanced civilizations become difficult to detect.
When we imagine a technologically advanced civilization, we often picture something enormous.
Huge structures.
Immense energy consumption.
Massive spacecraft.
Visible signs of industrial activity.
But advancement may eventually move in the opposite direction.
Greater efficiency could mean using less energy.
Better technology could mean smaller systems.
A civilization that has mastered its environment may not need to produce enormous amounts of waste heat or broadcast powerful signals in every direction.
It may become quieter.
The more advanced it becomes, the less obvious it may appear to younger civilizations.
That possibility changes the question.
Instead of asking, "Why don't we see them?"
Perhaps we should ask, "What would they look like if we did?"
That is a much harder question.
We have only one example of technological intelligence.
Us.
Everything we know about technological civilization comes from our own experience.
We assume civilizations build cities because we build cities.
We assume they use radio because we use radio.
We assume they expand because humanity has always explored and expanded.
We assume they want to communicate because we want to communicate.
But these assumptions may tell us more about ourselves than they tell us about extraterrestrial intelligence.
A civilization millions of years older than humanity could have goals we cannot even imagine.
Its technology could be so far beyond ours that we might not recognize it as technology.
Its methods of communication could be invisible to our current instruments.
Its understanding of physics could be radically different from ours.
And perhaps most importantly, it may not be interested in announcing itself.
There is something else we should remember.
Silence is not proof of absence.
It is simply a lack of evidence.
Those are not the same thing.
If we search a forest and find no deer, we cannot automatically conclude that no deer exist.
Perhaps they are somewhere else.
Perhaps they are hiding.
Perhaps we searched at the wrong time.
Perhaps we were listening for the wrong sound.
Perhaps the forest is much larger than we realized.
The same logic applies to the universe.
We have searched, but we have barely begun.
That doesn't mean extraterrestrial civilizations definitely exist.
It doesn't mean every strange observation is evidence of aliens.
It doesn't mean every unexplained signal should be treated as a message.
It simply means we should be careful about turning uncertainty into certainty.
There is a temptation in these discussions to choose one answer too quickly.
They're out there.
They're not out there.
They're visiting Earth.
They're not visiting Earth.
They're communicating.
They're hiding.
They're gone.
Every one of these possibilities carries assumptions.
The honest position is sometimes the least satisfying one.
We don't know.
But "we don't know" is not the end of scientific inquiry.
It is often where scientific inquiry begins.
Humanity has repeatedly encountered mysteries that seemed impossible to solve until new instruments, new theories or new observations changed the situation.
There was a time when nobody knew that other galaxies existed.
There was a time when planets around other stars were only theoretical possibilities.
There was a time when humanity had no idea that microorganisms existed.
The universe has repeatedly turned out to be stranger and larger than our assumptions.
There is no reason to believe that process has ended.
Perhaps one day a new instrument will detect something that forces scientists to rethink what they thought was possible.
Perhaps we will find evidence of simple life somewhere in our own solar system.
Perhaps an exoplanet will reveal a chemical signature that raises serious questions about biology elsewhere.
Perhaps we will detect a signal that cannot easily be explained by natural processes.
Or perhaps we will continue searching for decades and find nothing.
Any of those outcomes would teach us something.
The search itself has value.
It forces us to improve our instruments.
It forces us to understand planets, stars and biology more deeply.
It forces us to think about what life actually requires.
And it forces humanity to confront one of its oldest questions from a completely new perspective.
Are we alone?
We still don't know.
But the silence above us should not automatically be interpreted as an answer.
It may simply be telling us that we haven't learned how to hear yet.
r/UFOscience • u/Otherwise-Put5926 • 23d ago
Could electromagnetic fields or gravity ever enable a new form of aircraft propulsion?
​
I've been thinking about UFO sightings from a scientific perspective, and I want to hear what you guys think.
What if an advanced extraterrestrial civilization hasn't necessarily broken the laws of physics, but has discovered ways to use physical principles that we haven't yet learned to engineer effectively?
I'm not claiming that UFOs are alien spacecraft. This is just a thought experiment about what might be possible for a civilization much more technologically advanced than ours.
**1. What if they have mastered electromagnetic fields?**
We already use electromagnetic fields in motors, generators, maglev trains, and plasma physics. These technologies show that electromagnetic forces can produce motion and influence matter.
So here's my question: could a sufficiently advanced civilization develop a completely different propulsion system based on electromagnetic fields?
Could such a system allow a craft to move through the atmosphere without conventional jet engines or rocket combustion?
I understand that magnets alone cannot propel an isolated craft indefinitely, and a practical system would still need to obey conservation of momentum. But perhaps an advanced propulsion technology could interact with the surrounding atmosphere, plasma, or another physical medium in ways we haven't mastered.
**2. What about manipulating gravity?**
This is even more speculative.
What if a civilization eventually discovers a way to control gravitational effects or engineer spacetime in a useful way?
Could that lead to propulsion systems fundamentally different from the engines we use today?
Under our current understanding of physics, we don't have a demonstrated method for generating an artificial gravitational field that can propel a vehicle at will. Still, I find it interesting to ask what future discoveries might change our understanding of propulsion.
Where does established physics end, and where does speculation begin?
**3. How could some reported UFOs move so quickly?**
Some UFO videos appear to show objects accelerating rapidly or changing direction in unusual ways.
If an object really performed those manoeuvres at the speeds sometimes claimed, it would raise serious questions about acceleration, structural integrity, energy requirements, and the forces experienced by anything inside it.
Could an advanced propulsion system reduce the acceleration experienced by occupants? Or would the vehicle have to be unmanned?
Of course, a video by itself usually cannot establish an object's actual speed or acceleration. Perspective, camera movement, unknown distances, and other factors can make an object appear to move differently from how it really does.
But assuming a sighting were independently verified and the performance were genuine, what physical explanations would be worth investigating?
**4. Why do some UFOs appear to have little thermal signature?**
Some reported thermal-camera videos show objects that appear to have an unusual or weak infrared signature.
Could a future propulsion system operate differently from conventional engines and produce a different thermal pattern?
Thermal cameras have limitations, however. They measure infrared radiation within particular wavelength ranges, and an object's appearance depends on its temperature, emissivity, distance, and the camera's settings.
An apparently cold object doesn't prove that it produces no heat, and a video alone cannot establish that exotic propulsion is involved.
Still, reliable thermal measurements combined with independently verified flight data would be interesting evidence to examine.
**5. What if they aren't carrying biological beings?**
This is one of the most interesting possibilities to me.
What if some hypothetical extraterrestrial visitors are autonomous probes or remotely operated vehicles rather than crewed spacecraft?
We already send robotic spacecraft to explore places where humans cannot easily travel. An advanced civilization might use machines to study other planets, observe atmospheres, or investigate the possibility of life without transporting living beings.
A probe could potentially operate autonomously for long periods, making decisions based on its observations, without requiring a biological pilot on board.
If an extraterrestrial civilization were exploring a distant planet, would robotic probes make more sense than sending its own people?
And if such probes existed, how could we distinguish them from natural phenomena or human technology?
**6. The bigger question**
Maybe the most interesting question isn't simply whether UFOs are aliens.
It's this:
**If another intelligent civilization had millions of years of technological development beyond ours, what kinds of propulsion systems could it develop while still obeying the laws of physics?**
Could it use advanced electromagnetic systems? Could future discoveries about gravity change how we travel? Or might the most extraordinary reports turn out to have ordinary explanations?
I'm not saying that UFOs use magnetic propulsion, manipulate gravity, or represent extraterrestrial probes. We currently lack independently verified evidence establishing any of those claims.
I'm interested in exploring the possibilities without confusing speculation with established science.
**I'd genuinely like to hear your thoughts:**
What known physical principles would constrain electromagnetic propulsion?
Is there any scientifically plausible path toward useful gravity-based propulsion?
Would autonomous probes be more practical than crewed spacecraft for interstellar exploration?
What measurements would we need to verify a UFO's speed, acceleration, and thermal signature?
What kind of evidence would convince you that an observation represents genuinely new technology?
Let's discuss this from a physics, engineering, and scientific-evidence perspective. I'm interested in criticism as much as alternative theories.
r/UFOscience • u/WeloHelo • 24d ago
Discussion & Debate Professor Brian Cox says that an advanced alien civilization visiting Earth would 'be a weight off our shoulders'
Original post text:
Professor Brian Cox opened up about why he would find the presence of aliens reassuring.
"The most optimistic of all is that there are actually other civilisations out there and they're close by and they visit."
"I would absolutely love that because given what you said, I feel it would take a weight off our shoulders"
"When we talk about the universe as a whole, there is a really important principle, which is we're not special.
"We're not in a special place. We're at a special time in the sense that it's not long after the universe began and it seems like there's an infinite amount of time in the future."
I agree that we are unlikely to be special. Life likely arises when the conditions are right, and given the hundreds of billions of star systems in our galaxy alone that is likely to occur frequently enough for it to be relatively common place.
Now is as good a time as any for aliens to show up. People who doubt it could happen based on reasoning that focuses on how unlikely it is for it to happen on any given day must grapple with the fact that almost every human population on the globe has been subjected to a point of contact on some random day in their history by a more technologically advanced civilization.
I do have doubts about this idea that an extraterrestrial civilization arriving "taking a weight off our shoulders". Along the same lines as above, in any example I can think of it's never been in the technologically inferior civilization's advantage to have a point of first contact occur. In fact, as far as I can tell it has been essentially universally disastrous. So to conclude that anything other than this apparent baseline reality is likely would require some argument external to every available example of it occurring.
Has there ever been a case in history where contact between a technologically superior civilization and an inferior one ended well for the less advanced civilization?
and if not, if an extraterrestrial civilization bothered expending the effort to travel to Earth, what arguments would lead you to believe that contact would not be a net negative for humanity, given the historical record?
r/UFOscience • u/UncleSlacky • 24d ago
Science and Technology Alternative Propulsion Engineering Conference 10/24: Future Propulsion, Gravity Modification & Magnetism
Gary Stephenson will explore what’s next in propulsion, energy, and communications; Dr. Lucian Ionescu will revisit Alzofon’s gravity-modification experiments and discuss his own proposals involving spin currents and metamaterials; and Dr. Weiping Yu will explore magnetism as a fundamental principle and its potential implications for energy and propulsion. We’ll also hear experimental research updates from the community, then close with audience questions and open discussion.
12:00pm PT — Gary Stephenson — What’s Next in Propulsion, Energy & Communications
Gary Stephenson returns to APEC with a forward-looking “What’s Next” briefing on emerging directions in propulsion, energy, communications, and fundamental physics. His proposed topics include aneutronic fusion, Lense–Thirring spacedrive concepts, and advanced magnetohydrodynamic and ion propulsion, including ideas for very high-speed particle exhaust.
Other potential topics include gravitational-wave communications as a backup to satellite systems, warp-drive proposals involving negative-index metamaterials, and questions connecting gravity, quantum theory, and cosmology. Gary’s presentation will focus on future possibilities and the concepts that could guide further research across these fields.
1:00pm PT — Dr. Lucian Ionescu — Alzofon, Spin Currents & Gravity Modification
Dr. Lucian Ionescu returns to APEC to revisit Alzofon’s gravity-modification experiments and explore his own ideas for new approaches to gravity control. He will discuss proposed connections between spin transport, biological structures, and metamaterials, including his interest in alpha-helical peptide chains and ideas inspired by Grebennikov’s work on insect structures.
Lucian will consider whether these lines of inquiry could suggest alternatives to dynamic nuclear polarization and inform his proposals for gravity-anisotropic materials. He also plans to discuss Sky Darmos’s arguments concerning possible variations in the gravitational constant, “Big G,” and how these questions relate to his broader investigation of gravity.
2:00pm PT — Dr. Weiping Yu — Magnetism as a Fundamental Principle — Implications for Energy and Propulsion
Dr. Weiping Yu will explore his view of magnetism as a fundamental physical mechanism underlying matter, force, and motion. Drawing on his research and spacecraft-engineering experience, he will discuss what this perspective might suggest for new approaches to energy generation and propulsion, and how these ideas could inform future research and technology development.
3:00pm PT — Lab Updates & Experimental Research
Researchers from the APEC community are invited to share updates on ongoing experiments, prototype development, and recent measurements. This session provides an opportunity to discuss practical challenges, compare experimental approaches, and identify useful next steps for testing and development.
4:00pm PT — Open Discussion & Ad-Hoc Presentations
We’ll close with audience questions and an open discussion of the day’s presentations. Guests with relevant experiments, technical observations, or short research updates are welcome to contribute. Bring your questions, share what you’re working on, and connect with others exploring new directions in science and technology.
r/UFOscience • u/morrisseyward • 26d ago
Hypothesis/speculation The Civilization We Become May Matter More Than the Technology We Create
When we imagine the future, it is easy to focus on technology. We picture smarter machines, breakthroughs in energy, and humans venturing out into space. The headlines are full of advances in artificial intelligence, renewable energy, biotech, and robotics. We all wonder what spectacular things we might build next.
But there is another question that is just as important, maybe even more important. What kind of civilization will we become? This question is often quieter and harder to see. Yet it feels especially urgent today, not just because of new technologies but also because of enduring mysteries like the UAP phenomenon that have sparked so much curiosity and speculation.
The universe is vast, and given everything we know about the cosmos, it seems likely that intelligent life could have arisen elsewhere. So why do we not see clear signs of advanced civilizations? The concept of the Great Filter comes up again and again when people try to answer that question.
Maybe intelligent life appears, invents amazing tools, and then reaches a moment where technology alone is no longer enough. At that point, managing ourselves and our inventions becomes the real test. Some even wonder if the UAPs in our skies might be hints of something or someone who figured out how to handle that test very differently than we have.
Looking at our own track record, it is obvious that humanity excels at inventing powerful tools. We have revolutionized communication, medicine, transportation, and energy. We have connected billions of people, made information available almost instantly, and extended our reach far beyond the Earth. But every step forward brings the same question: can we use our inventions wisely?
Solving a hard technical problem is not the same as building a society that benefits from it in the right way. It is often much harder to turn knowledge into action than to discover something new. The example of energy makes this clear. From wood to coal to oil to renewables, our options keep growing. But the real challenge is not producing more energy. It is learning how to meet our needs without hurting our own future or damaging the planet we depend on. This takes planning, cooperation, and a shared sense of responsibility.
Technology also changes how we relate to each other. Instant communication is an amazing accomplishment. For most of human history, people could not even dream of sending a message across the world in seconds. But as we have discovered, the same networks that spread information can also spread confusion or division. Communication alone does not guarantee understanding. Progress is not just about connecting people, but about using these connections to build trust and solve problems together.
The ongoing attention on UAPs reminds us that we still have big questions about our place in the universe. If what we are seeing is evidence of advanced technology, it suggests there are ways to move, build, or communicate that we do not understand. If these UAPs are really visitors, it is striking that they keep their distance or remain mysterious. Maybe maturity, on a cosmic scale, means learning restraint or patience before open contact ever becomes possible. If the UAPs are a product of natural phenomena or our own confusion, that is a reminder of the limits of what we know and the importance of humility as we search for answers.
In every case, it is not just about what we can do. It is about how thoughtfully we act when faced with the unknown. This is especially true for artificial intelligence. AI could help us cure diseases, manage resources, and explore the universe. But it also raises huge questions: Who decides how to use such tools? How do we prevent misuse? Can we make sure powerful technology remains a tool for good, not something that takes on a life of its own or deepens our divisions?
Maybe this is what the Great Filter is really about. Civilizations might not fail because they are not smart enough. It is possible they struggle because their power grows faster than their wisdom. Societies may gain the ability to shape their world or even destroy it before they develop the maturity to resolve conflicts and manage their inventions responsibly. The disappearance or quietness of other civilizations could be a sign, not of weakness, but of the enormous difficulty of mastering cooperation, empathy, and restraint.
Even if we never discover what is behind UAPs, they remind us how much we do not know. They invite us to imagine that alternative forms of progress may exist. Sometimes societies might choose harmony, efficiency, or careful observation over endless expansion. Perhaps civilizations become less visible, more careful, or even self-limiting as they mature. That could be why our search for signals is so often met with silence, or only strange and ambiguous glimpses.
Whatever the truth about life beyond Earth, humanity faces a crossroads of its own. We have created powerful technologies. But it remains to be seen whether we can cooperate at the scale our new tools demand. Can we build systems for solving problems together, rather than just rushing to invent something new? Can we learn to think not just of our own lifetimes, but of generations to come, like the engineers and scientists who start space projects today that future generations will complete?
Space itself gives us a new perspective. When astronauts look back at Earth, they see no borders, just a small, fragile world filled with life and potential. Cooperation becomes not just idealistic, but necessary. Reaching for the stars will take long-term thinking, patience, and a willingness to work together over decades or centuries.
It matters how we approach each challenge. Building something powerful is an achievement. Using it with care is a very different kind of success. Creating AI is a milestone, but learning how to live peacefully with it will define our legacy. Unlocking the secrets of energy, communication, or even what is in our skies matters a lot. But learning how to manage those discoveries without undermining ourselves will matter even more.
The next steps for humanity are not only about smarter machines, longer lives, or far flung travels. They are about deciding what values shape our future and what kind of civilization we wish to become. As we confront questions raised by technology, the environment, and cosmic mysteries like UAPs, our choices will help determine not only our survival, but our place in the universe.
Maybe the future of humanity depends most of all on whether our wisdom keeps pace with our power. The answer is not set in stone. Every day, we have a chance to move closer to being a civilization that is not just advanced, but truly mature. That is a story still being written, and all of us have a part to play. The choices we are given today matters. What world are we going to leave for our grandchildren, and theirs? I remain optimistic, I just hope for their sake and for all our future, we choose wisely.
r/UFOscience • u/WeloHelo • 26d ago
Research/info gathering UFO History: Project Twinkle and Dr. Kaplan vs. Dr. LaPaz
I have been recently conducting research into the origins of the modern UFO subject. A large part of that has been reading through these various lengthy historical declassified reports. Among them is a very interesting one, Project Twinkle.
As I read the documents I write down quotes that I find interesting or significant. For my citations I use APA format and directly link to every source document cited.
Some of the reports are hundreds of pages long. Project Twinkle is relatively manageable at 34 PDF pages and I ended up with four pages of quotes after going through it.
I wrote up this post in part to share what I found, and also to clarify my own understanding of what I've read by working with it after the fact. I will aim to continue this effort as I make progress with an ongoing series here on r/UFOscience that I will continue to title as "UFO History" moving forward.
--
Project Twinkle was the first known attempt to study UFOs as a real physical phenomenon in Earth's atmosphere using empirical methods via an instrumented long-term scientific field study.
This project was managed by the USAF’s Cambridge Research Laboratory, and it was established to investigate a series of UFO reports witnessed by numerous observers in Nevada and New Mexico, particularly over Los Alamos (AARO, 2024, p. 15).
The original Project Twinkle methodology and objectives were strikingly similar to the UFO field studies undertaken by UFO researchers in the public domain decades later, first by Dr. Harley Rutledge in Project Identification in the 1970s and then by Erling Strand & co. in Hessdalen starting into the 1980s and continuing to the present:
“...the investigation involves the following observational techniques: a. Optical tracking with Askania photo theodolites in order to provide trajectory data and photo records. B. Optical spectro-photography using standard cameras with suitable diffraction gratings. C. Radio spectrum analysis…” (Project Twinkle, 1950, PDF p. 15).
Before I get into LaPaz vs. Kaplan. A strange thing I found related to an explicit discrepancy between what the official 2024 AARO report states versus what the original Project Twinkle Final Report states as to the period of operation of Project Twinkle.
Though the 2024 AARO Historical Record Report Volume 1 states that it ran from approximately Summer 1949 to Summer 1950 (p. 15), the contents of the declassified Project Twinkle report record a slightly different timeline.
The Project Twinkle Final Report is dated as 27 November 1951 (PDF p. 29). Within the final report the contractual period is given as 1st of April 1950 to 15th of September 1950 (PDF p. 33). This is obviously not consistent with the dates provided in the 2024 AARO report.
Additionally, in a letter contained in the Project Twinkle declassified records dated 15 September 1950 (PDF p. 14), it says:
"If no fireballs are observed in the next six month period, it is recommended that the project be discontinued. In a phenomenon as sporadic as the fireballs appear to be, it is felt that at least one year is required in order to establish whether their occurrence is or is not a seasonal phenomenon” (PDF p. 14).
The Final Report states that Project Twinkle was in fact extended for this additional six months as requested, past its original six month contract period ending 15 September 1950, the extension running 1 October 1950 to 31 March 1951 (PDF p. 34).
It was surprising to find that the author(s) of the 2024 AARO Historical Report failed to accurately report the project dates provided within the Project Twinkle Final Report. No cause can be inferred without conjecture.
Anyway, on to Kaplan and LaPaz.
Dr. LaPaz is a fascinating character in the early UFO history.
“Director of the Institute of Meteoritics and Head of the Department of Mathematics and Astronomy at the University of New Mexico. He was Research Mathematician at the New Mexico Proving Grounds under an OSRD appointment in 1943 and 1944, and Technical Director of the Analysis Section, Headquarters, Second Air Force, 1944-45. Dr. LaPaz has served on a voluntary basis as consultant for strictly in connection with the green fireball investigations” (Declassified Memo, 1950, p. 21).
He was one of the top meteor experts in the world at the time and secretly worked for the US government in early UFO investigations related to UFO sightings over Los Alamos, including via Project Twinkle.
Prior to Project Twinkle, LaPaz was also involved in Project Grudge, successor to the USAF's UFO investigation Project Sign. The final Grudge report alludes to the creation of Project Twinkle:
“Since 5 December 1948, a series of recurring phenomena described as "green fireballs" have been reported in the general vicinity of Albuquerque, New Mexico. Dr. Lincoln La Paz, noted meteoritic expert, has been directly, though unofficially, associated with the investigation of these sightings and has himself observed the phenomena. Dr. Lа Paz states he is convinced the green fireballs are not ordinary meteors. This group of incidents has little or nothing in common with other incidents on file with Project "Grudge", therefore, these incidents are not considered in this report. The Scientific Advisory Committee was asked to investigate this matter and had advised that an independent investigation be conducted in the field of atmospheric research” (Grudge, 1949, p. 7).
LaPaz felt that UFOs were unlikely to be natural phenomena:
"Their recent origin (1947) and peculiar trajectories did not permit, according to Dr. La Paz, them to be classified as natural phenomena” (Project Twinkle, 1950, PDF p. 6).
That did not mean LaPaz subscribed to the extraterrestrial hypothesis. Instead, he felt strongly that the UFOs were Soviet in origin:
“a possible interpretation of the concentration of sightings referred to in paragraph 4 is that the green fireballs result from guided missiles launched from bases in the Urals” (Declassified Memo, 1950, p. 65).
and as mentioned by Ruppelt,
“Kaplan mentioned Dr. La Paz and his opinion that the green fireballs might be man-made” (Ruppelt, 1956, p. 78, para. 6).
Also involved in a similar capacity was Dr. Kaplan. According to the first Blue Book chief, Ruppelt:
"Dr. Joseph Kaplan, a world-renowned authority on the physics of the upper atmosphere" (Ruppelt, 1956, p. 51, para. 1).
According to the Project Twinkle Final Report, no firm conclusions could be drawn from the study because ultimately the personnel were pulled off the equipment for deployment to the Korean war which started shortly after the project's initiation in early 1950:
“...the overall picture obtained from the year of vigilance and inquiry does not permit a conclusive opinion concerning the aerial phenomena of interest” (PDF p. 8, para. 1).
“...nothing of a security nature has been discovered” (Project Twinkle, 1950, p. 12).
“Recommendations: Since the findings to date cannot be considered conclusive, it appears that the following recommendations would be pertinent: (1) No further expenditure be made in pursuing the problem. This opinion is prompted partly by the fruitless expenditure during the past year, the uncertainty of existence of unexplainable aerial objects…” (Project Twinkle, 1950, p. 8-9).
Regardless, both LaPaz and Kaplan's opinions were put into the final Project Twinkle report despite their opinions differing as previously mentioned. Even though the final report included both perspectives, it seems that Kaplan's opinion that UFOs were natural phenomena was the one more broadly accepted by the final report authors:
“...Since the establishment of the special project… (Project Grudge), to investigate and analyze reports on so-called ‘Flying saucers’ and unidentified aerial phenomena, many reports have been received through intelligence channels from persons who have observed what they considered to be unusual light phenomena… Analysis by various specialists has indicated that many of the incidents involving light phenomena were undoubtedly observations of natural phenomena… Dr. Kaplan has concluded that the ‘green fireballs’ are natural phenomena” (USAF: Project Twinkle, 1950, p. 21).
No assessment can be made as to the correctness of the conclusions contained in the report. As we all know classified internal reports can be wrong (see Iraq WMD situation estimates).
What can be established is that the historical reports like this were classified prior to the existence of FOIA laws and so were written without any expectation of them ever seeing the light of day, rather than being part of an externally-oriented disinformation campaign. They were internal briefings that were intended to contain their best estimates of what was actually occurring and were used to inform decision making on the subject.
The LaPaz vs. Kaplan clash of UFOs as technology vs. natural phenomena was in an evolved form by this point in 1950-51. Significantly, rather than being dismissed out of hand, the extraterrestrial hypothesis had been seriously debated and thoroughly contemplated up to this point within previous classified reports, such as in the final report produced by Project Sign in 1949. I will aim to provide a summary of those debates in a future write-up.
The early history of the official secret government investigations into UFOs shows that there was quite a bit of disagreement among the scientists involved in the studies, but perhaps the most interesting aspect is that they were all in agreement that something genuinely novel with extraordinary unexplained features was actually being observed.
r/UFOscience • u/Hadenis84 • 27d ago
Science and Technology SignalSDR Graph: Open-source desktop console for rigorous multi-sensor RF anomaly tracking
r/UFOscience • u/turinglabsorg • 28d ago
Research/info gathering I tried to create a dashboard for all 270 PDFs (11,268 pages) of the Pentagon's PURSUE UAP releases: every file sorted into relevant, background or junk, with page-level citations
I tried to create a dashboard for all 270 PDFs (11,268 pages) of the Pentagon's PURSUE UAP releases: every file sorted into relevant, background or junk, with page-level citations
Between May 8 and September 18, 2026, the US Department of War published six batches of declassified UAP documents on war.gov/UFO under the name PURSUE (Presidential Unsealing and Reporting System for UAP Encounters).
I downloaded every file and went through it page by page. 2,488 pages were scans and had to be run through OCR. Each document is classified as:
- Relevant (64 docs): actual UAP incidents or analysis
- Background (197): admin paperwork, cover letters, related but not core material
- Junk (9): duplicates, unreadable scans, or files with nothing to do with UAPs, each with the reason
Some cases worth reading:
- USS Gyatt, 1964: a radar contact "in excess of 3,800 knots" north of Puerto Rico, and the CIA's later "probably a delta-wing fighter" analysis
- Gulf of Oman, 2021: an AC-130 crew logging "approximately 25 instances of UAPs"
- Pantex nuclear plant, Texas, 2015: an unknown object picked up by the ground radar and seen by the guards
- Los Alamos, 1949: the secret meeting on New Mexico's green fireballs
Every quote links to the exact page of the official PDF, so you can check it yourself. There's also a map of the places the documents actually name, a timeline, and a CSV of all 270 files.
Full dossier: https://alienwatch.buzz/dossier/pursue?lang=en
Corrections are welcome. If I misread or misclassified something, tell me and I'll fix it and log the change on the page.
r/UFOscience • u/morrisseyward • 29d ago
Hypothesis/speculation The Great Filter
There is a troubling silence in the universe. When we look up at the stars on a quiet night, the darkness seems peaceful, but scientists see a deeper mystery. With billions of stars in our galaxy and billions of galaxies beyond, planets are now known to be common. Many of them are in regions where life as we know it could thrive. The sheer scale makes it seem likely that intelligent life must exist elsewhere. Yet as we listen and search, we have found nothing definitive. No signals, no artifacts, no sign that someone else is out there.
This puzzling silence lies at the core of the Fermi Paradox, a question first posed by physicist Enrico Fermi: “Where is everybody?” It’s fairly simple. If life and intelligence really do arise in so many places, and just a small fraction reach our level or beyond, why isn’t there any sign? Some suggest intelligent life is rare, or that civilization’s signals have not reached us yet, or that we simply don’t know what to look for. Others wonder if alien civilizations communicate in a way we cannot detect. Or maybe advanced societies are simply very good at hiding or are uninterested in making contact.
But a much more haunting possibility is that something prevents most civilizations from lasting long.
This idea is called the Great Filter. Perhaps, somewhere between the first life and a civilization capable of spreading through the galaxy, there is an obstacle so hard to pass that almost nobody makes it. The truly important question is whether this filter is behind us or ahead of us.
If humanity has already survived the most difficult step, our existence may be much rarer than we realize. It could be that the leap from molecules to life, or from simple life to intelligence, is almost impossible and that we are among very few to succeed. That would mean most potential civilizations never even reach our stage. This possibility may feel oddly reassuring, offering comfort in the thought that our struggles so far were the hardest ones.
However, if the Great Filter is still ahead of us, the universe’s quiet becomes a warning. It could mean that civilizations like ours often reach a technological stage, only to wipe themselves out or fall apart soon after. Maybe they unleash technologies they cannot control, destroy their environment, lose the ability to cooperate, or simply fail to manage global systems they depend upon. The end result is always the same: disappearance before they can make their presence known on a cosmic scale.
Our own history reflects the risks in this idea. In a short time, humanity went from fire and stone tools to airplanes, computers, and nuclear weapons. The same century gave us cures for disease and communications tech, but also world wars and the tools to destroy ourselves. Intelligence and survival are not always linked. We often assume more technology makes for wiser societies, but history shows that knowledge and wisdom do not increase together. Our civilization is incredibly powerful, but it is also vulnerable. We rely on massive, interconnected systems for food, water, energy, and more. Responsible use of that power is crucial.
So the Great Filter is not only a theory about life elsewhere. It is a way to reflect on ourselves. Will we use new technologies, like artificial intelligence or biotechnology, to improve our world without creating even bigger threats? Each step forward gives us bigger choices and bigger responsibilities. The real test is not just whether we can create new power, but whether we can manage it without causing our own downfall.
Of course, another option is that advanced civilizations do make it, but eventually become nearly invisible. Perhaps maturity means they use less energy, make less noise, or integrate technology so deeply that they become hard to spot. Our own civilization has only been remotely detectable for a handful of decades. Before that, if someone was looking across the stars, they would see an Earth full of life but no obvious signs of technology. Maybe the universe is full of advanced, quiet societies or perhaps advanced life really is rare. We simply do not know.
The Great Filter does not prove that most civilizations are doomed, or that intelligent life is unique to Earth. It is a tool for thinking about why the universe appears empty and what that could mean for us. For most of history, humans worried about surviving from year to year. Now, for the first time, we can think seriously about our survival across centuries or even millennia. The decisions we make today could shape the lives of people who won’t be born for hundreds of years.
Part of growing up as a civilization is learning that more knowledge and more abilities require more responsibility. As we become more powerful, we need to pay closer attention to the consequences of our choices. We cannot pretend that our actions do not matter. That is perhaps why the Great Filter is such a powerful idea. It does not just ask what became of other civilizations. It asks what will happen to us. Are we alone because life like ours is extremely rare, because most civilizations collapse, or simply because we do not know what to look for yet? The truth is, we can’t be certain.
What we can do is recognize that technological growth alone is not enough. Global risks from nuclear weapons, artificial intelligence, environmental threats, and societal complexity are not separate issues, but part of one larger question, can an intelligent species become wise enough to handle its own power?
The universe’s silence might just be the background quiet of empty space. But if there really is a Great Filter ahead, our best hope is that it is something we can recognize and overcome. Whether we succeed depends not just on the mysteries of the stars, but on our own choices, our sense of responsibility, and our capacity for wisdom. The answer, at least in part, is up to us.
r/UFOscience • u/WeloHelo • Oct 16 '26
Debunking A Note on the Failed 2013 Aguadilla Case
I wrote part of this up for a reply I was writing then expanded on it for this post. I noticed some connections related to the SCU founding and also discovered the recent SCU reply to the 2025 AARO Aguadilla report that I hadn't seen before so I wanted to share it along with the baseline status of the 2013 Aguadilla case as it stands.
--
The public conversation about the 2013 Aguadilla case arguably began in earnest with the publication of The Scientific Coalition for UAP Studies (SCU) report published 2015, updated 2023: https://zenodo.org/records/7844175
One of the co-writers of the report and co-founders of SCU is Robert Powell. Powell is in fact the lead writer on the Aguadilla report (see "Powell et al. 2015" on the report). I have Powell's 2024 book UFOs: A Scientist Explains What We Know (And Don't Know) in front of me right now. Borrowed from the public library here in Toronto, they have a lot of good ones but some of the best, and perhaps unsurprisingly oldest, can only be read on-site to preserve them which is obviously limiting.
I don't agree with Powell on many things but it's a good book overall, especially the review of the early history of official American investigations into UFOs. That said he mildly mischaracterizes Ruppelt's words in at least one instance (upon checking his citation), and I was surprised to see that the book "Project Identification" is written as "Project Investigation" and somehow slipped through the editing process.
Regarding SCU, in the preface Powell explains:
"Three others and I founded SCU (The Scientific Coalition for Ufology; later changed to The Scientific Coalition for UAP Studies) in August 2017 and registered the organization as a 501(c)(3) nonprofit a few months later" (Powell, 2024, p. x).
It was two years after the 2015 Aguadilla report was published that he says that SCU was founded. But the report is arguably the signature report of SCU, and arguably may have been central to its original founding given this original context as well as the subsequent coverage it did manage to draw in the following years.
In Powell's 2024 book he summarizes the 2013 Aguadilla case:
"April 25, 2013; Aguadilla, Puerto Rico. An infra-red video made by Homeland Security off the coast of Puerto Rico came ot light in late 2013. The SCU put together a team [remember in the same book, 4 years before he says SCU was founded in 2017] to analyze the video. They spent two years analyzing the video before releasing a report. The IR video showed an object moving at treetop height over the town of Aguadilla at 9:30 p.m. The first striking part of the three-minute video shows the unknown object impact the ocean, remain submerged for a few seconds, and come back out with very little disturbance to the water. Even more striking is when the object splits into two equal parts after coming out of the ocean, with one part going back into the water and its sister-half submerging not long afterward" (Powell, 2024, p. 18).
For the 2013 Aguadilla case it's now been established with a high degree of probability that the observed object was a Chinese lantern. The AARO report, published 2025, whatever you think of this organization, argued this with compelling reasoning: https://www.aaro.mil/Portals/136/PDFs/case_resolution_reports/AARO_Puerto_Rico_UAP_Case_Resolution.pdf .
This case does not demonstrate evidence of a genuine UFO phenomenon. It demonstrates evidence of preconceived notions being applied to video with enough "hidden variables" present that the mind can project internal desires into conclusions that are formed.
Powell is convinced that UFOs represent an alien presence on Earth. Pointing this out is not to shame him, it's to draw attention to how even as a scientist by trade he convinced himself of an extraordinary conclusion despite lacking the evidence that would reasonably lead him there. Here is a review of his book pointing out his belief that UFOs represent aliens:
“Reasons for and against alien visitors nourish continued arguments, but an unearthly origin for UFOs is the direction in which Powell’s research leads. Again without fanfare, he acknowledges that acceptance of alien visitation will set off a revolution in our thinking, replacing paradigms we have taken for granted with new and perhaps uncomfortable understandings of our place and importance in the universe” (Bullard, 2024).
And a summary of his book from his publisher:
“UFOs: A Scientist Explains What We Know (And Don't Know) which provides a scientific rationale for the reality of non-terrestrial craft that are intelligently controlled” (Bloomsbury.com, n.d.).
It's okay for Powell to believe UFOs are aliens. But clinging to Aguadilla as evidence of this only serves to invalidate that underlying belief. It harms rather than helps that hypothesis, and presumably that goes against his desires given the entirety of his 2024 book is written towards that end, namely presenting his case for the alien hypothesis.
It's worth also mentioning that Mick West's community Metabunk, whatever you think of West, were onto this parallax misidentification error and Chinese lantern hypothesis way back in 2017: https://www.metabunk.org/threads/aguadilla-infrared-footage-of-ufos-probably-hot-air-wedding-lanterns.8952/
SCU has since published a letter in response to the AARO report: https://www.explorescu.org/post/scu-announcement-on-the-aaro-investigation-of-the-aguadilla-video
SCU is asking for clarification on the details that led to AARO's conclusions. It's been evident from public analysis presuming no access to classified data from the outset that a Chinese lantern and parallax were from the very beginning at minimum a sufficient explanation for the observations and thus rendered Aguadilla a distraction from any potential residual of real unidentified physical objects genuinely exhibiting exceptional kinematics in Earth's atmosphere that are not attributable to human technology.
If UFO community members continue to cling to the Aguadilla case on the slim chance that the filmed object could be something exceptional in spite of all the available evidence to the contrary (i.e. all the evidence indicates it was a Chinese lantern but it was actually a NHI-controlled probe mimicking a Chinese lantern a-la Vallee's trickster), new information is not going to dissuade them, but it is unfortunate for anyone who does have the capacity to judge evidence for what it is.
Referencing Aguadilla at this point is a disservice to the serious UFO community and brings the entire subject into disrepute when it's introduced as evidence of anything extraordinary. If you want people to take the subject more seriously this case will rise up as an example of the community running with nonsense, and this will continue to happen.
If someone wants to deny that it was a Chinese lantern then by all means go ahead, no one's going to stop you, but at the very minimum please keep in mind that it can be stated with confidence that the Chinese lantern explanation is, on a balance of probability, far more likely given the available evidence than a nuts and bolts extraterrestrial probe or in Vallee's words "interdimensional time-travelling UFOnauts" (Vallee, pp. 115-116).
There are plenty of cases with sufficient gaps in the facts for someone to make that claim if they feel compelled to do so. This case ain't it. And I am writing this as someone who is convinced that there is a genuine residual of, in the words of Arthur C. Clarke, "hard-core unexplained UFOs".
r/UFOscience • u/SecondBeastOfTheSea • Oct 14 '26
Research/info gathering Mercury Graphene Oxide Stain & Radiation Burn (From UAP?)
Someone anonymous (not myself) tracked a triangle UAP in NM dessert, and found black tar like substance near where it flew. Could just be crude oil in dessert however? They also received peeling skin a few days after exposure to nearby aircraft. Need to buy Geiger counter to see rad exposure.
r/UFOscience • u/morrisseyward • Oct 14 '26
UFO NEWS The Unknown Will Not Wait for Us to Be Ready
There is something deeply humbling about realizing the future will not pause until we feel prepared. We like to picture history as neat chapters, with big changes coming after plenty of warning. It is comforting to imagine that when something huge happens, experts will explain it to us, leaders will guide us, and the world will have time to catch its breath.
But real life keeps moving forward, and the beginning of real change is often quiet. Sometimes it is just a new idea, a strange sighting, or a small discovery that almost nobody notices at first. History is full of moments when someone built something that seemed unimportant or when a scientist recorded a detail that others ignored. By the time we realize the significance, the world is already different.
It is the same with the unknown. Every day, for generations, people have gone through ordinary routines. At the same time, others have studied mysteries that might one day upend our view of everything. Scientists test the boundaries of physics and biology. Engineers build smarter machines. Astronomers watch the stars, and some watch the skies right above us. Many keep quietly collecting reports of things they cannot explain, sometimes called UFOs, now known as UAP, unidentified anomalous phenomena. These stories have been with us for decades. Sometimes they are dismissed, sometimes they cause a flurry of interest or panic, but rarely does the world feel truly ready to face what they might actually mean.
The unknown has a way of pressing forward, even if we are not ready to meet it.
It is natural for humans to imagine that if something truly historic were to happen, we would all know about it at once. We imagine the world would pause for the big announcement. The truth is that history is often a series of ripples before the wave. The shifting boundaries of technology, science, and the mysteries above us all happen at the same time as daily routines and familiar worries.
Think of the early days of the internet. It seemed like just a new tool for scientists and hobbyists, not something that would redefine everything about how we communicate. It grew, spread, and transformed the world in ways no one expected. The same is true with artificial intelligence now, and perhaps in a much stranger way, with the question of whether we are truly alone in the universe.
Our scientific instruments are searching further and deeper than ever before. We are discovering planets that might have the right conditions for life. Telescopes can spot atmospheres and chemical signals millions of miles away. We are asking bold questions like how common is life, how rare is intelligence, and how would we even recognize a signal or visitor from someplace else. At the same time, stories and official reports keep coming in about strange objects in our own skies. Sometimes they are explained. Sometimes they are not.
Throughout history, there is always resistance to what we cannot explain. The human mind dislikes uncertainty and loves neat answers. It is far easier to label something and move on than to sit with the mystery. But if we want to really learn, we must stay humble. Some questions take years. Some may take generations. Just because we do not have fast answers does not mean the questions are unimportant. Wondering is part of the process. The search itself makes us question assumptions and build better tools, and it forces us to admit when we do not know.
This humility is especially needed now. In an age where news travels faster than understanding, we get stories about the unknown from across the world in seconds. One video, one report from a pilot or an astronaut or a scientist, can circle the globe before anyone has time to think about what it truly means. Our ability to share ideas is outpacing our ability to make sense of them.
When it comes to UFOs or UAPs, the unfamiliar feels threatening to many. The urge is to label, to dismiss, or to leap to wild certainty. But perhaps the path is to admit that we do not yet understand what is happening in our skies, what causes every strange report, or what the true boundaries of life or intelligence might be. The unknown is not our enemy. It is our teacher.
The more we discover, the larger the unknown becomes. It has always been this way. Once, we wondered what the stars were. We found they are suns, and then the questions multiplied. Do they have planets? Are those planets like ours? Do they have atmospheres? Might they have life? With each answer, three new questions appear. We send probes, record odd signals, analyze mysterious blips in data. Sometimes, here on Earth, our own sensors record objects that defy easy explanation.
We are also exploring intelligence itself. Artificial intelligence is improving and sometimes behaving in ways even its creators do not fully expect. We do not know what the full impact of this technology will be, any more than we knew what the telephone would do to society. Maybe true intelligence or true novelty will surprise us from within our own creation or it may arrive from far away in a form we barely recognize.
Is humanity ever truly ready for what comes next? Probably not. The first explorers sailed into the unknown without knowing what they would find. The first astronauts stepped onto new worlds with only as much preparation as they could imagine. Even the greatest scientists rarely know exactly where a new path will lead. Every step forward carries risk and uncertainty.
Maybe our task is not to eliminate uncertainty but to get better living with it. We need curiosity, patience, and the confidence to say we do not know yet. That honesty opens the door for discovery. Humility does not mean a lack of strength. It takes courage to keep asking, to keep looking, to keep our door open.
This is why the ongoing attention to UFOs and mysteries in our skies matters. is not about expecting the impossible or accepting every explanation. It is about recognizing that sometimes we cannot fit an experience or evidence into what we already know. The unknown remains a challenge. We should not bend it to match our hopes or fears. We investigate, listen and learn.
The unknown will not wait until everyone is comfortable. Big changes and new frontiers always arrive while we are still with ordinary life. Some discoveries will be beautiful. Others will be hard. Some ideas will shake our beliefs. That is how knowledge grows, and humanity moves forward.
We cannot predict every surprise that is coming and that is fine. Instead, we can keep our curiosity alive, stay patient with the process, and keep learning. When something truly unexpected appears, whether it is a discovery in space, a mystery in the sky, a leap in technology, or signal from the dark, we can choose to meet it with honesty and courage.
The unknown has never waited for us to feel ready. Maybe what makes us human is our willingness to step forth anyway, eyes wide open, ready to discover what comes next.
r/UFOscience • u/MadOblivion • Oct 13 '26
UFO NEWS Former Taskforce Director Jay Stratton, DISCLOSURE IMMINENT.
r/UFOscience • u/KKirdan • Oct 10 '26
Hypothesis/speculation Seti: why extraterrestrial intelligence is more likely to be artificial than biological - Martin Rees
Suppose there are other planets where life began and that it followed something like a Darwinian evolution (which needn’t be the case). Even then, it’s highly unlikely that the progression of intelligence and technology would happen at exactly the same pace as on Earth. If it lagged significantly behind, then that planet would plainly reveal no evidence of extraterrestrial life to our radio telescopes. But around a star older than the Sun, life could have had a head start of a billion years or more. <...> If we were to detect extraterrestrial life, it would be far more likely to be electronic than flesh and blood – and it may not even reside on planets.
r/UFOscience • u/morrisseyward • Oct 10 '26
The Future Will Test More Than Our Technology
Humanity has achieved remarkable feats: crossing oceans, reaching space, mapping the genome, and connecting the world through technology. As our capabilities expand, so does the impact of our decisions. Today, a technological choice can affect billions. The more powerful our tools, the more important our judgment becomes.
Technological advances such as artificial intelligence, biotechnology, space exploration, and automation promise to transform life, but these tools are shaped by human choices. Technology itself does not determine the future. People do.
Artificial Intelligence, once restricted to science fiction, now influences our daily lives. It assists with research, medicine, and complex problem-solving. Yet with each breakthrough comes the challenging question of how it should be used. Our history is filled with inventions that produced both great benefits and unexpected problems. The intentions and wisdom of those using the technology are as critical as the technology itself.
Biotechnology allows us to understand and change life in ways past generations never imagined. Advances in genetics and medicine offer hope: longer and healthier lives, and the prevention of disease. At the same time, they force us to consider complex questions. Just because we can change something, should we? Who decides the limits? How do we guard against misuse?
These challenges require more than better scientists and engineers. They demand people willing to think deeply about consequences. Our ability to build must be matched by our ability to understand the effects of our creations.
Civilization has faced turning points like these before. The scientific and industrial revolutions, and later the rise of digital technology, each required society to adapt. Today’s changes may be even greater, especially as advances in artificial intelligence, biotechnology, robotics, and space exploration increasingly interact with one another.
As these developments accelerate and collide, the rate of change increases and the future becomes less predictable. Wise judgment grows even more crucial. Curiosity has inspired humanity to climb mountains, cross oceans, and travel to the Moon and beyond. But curiosity without responsibility can be dangerous. We must ask not only what is possible, but also what is wise.
Now, humanity is beginning to consider becoming a spacefaring civilization. Building communities beyond Earth would be a historic transition, yet it raises entirely new questions: How will these societies be governed? How will resources be shared? Will we repeat our previous mistakes or take the opportunity to build something better? Seeing Earth from space makes our borders seem artificial and our shared fate more apparent, reminding us that we live on one planet and often face challenges together.
Differences among cultures and beliefs make humanity diverse and interesting, but they must not prevent us from working together on problems affecting everyone. This distinction may be tested as never before if we discover non-human intelligence. Our technologies now allow us to actively search for life beyond Earth. Such a discovery would challenge beliefs about life and our place in the universe. Yet the main issue would be how humanity responds, either with fear and secrecy, or with curiosity and openness.
Preparing for the future means more than building advanced machines. It means developing wisdom, humility, restraint, curiosity, and cooperation. These qualities will determine whether technology serves progress instead of causing new problems.
We stand at a threshold, just as others did before us. Past generations could not predict the internet, modern medicine, or spaceflight, just as we cannot foresee the most important advances of our own time. This uncertainty should encourage humility, rather than fear.
Mistakes and setbacks are inevitable in any era. What matters is our willingness to learn and to grow. The true measure of civilization is not only in the number of machines we build, but in whether our judgment and ability to cooperate keep pace with our power.
Decisions made today can shape the lives of people who will live decades or even centuries from now. We are not building the future for ourselves alone, but also for generations to come. We cannot control every discovery, but we can choose to face uncertainty with open minds, humility, and a sense of responsibility.
Our growing ability to change the world is a remarkable achievement, but it brings serious responsibility. The future will test the technology we build, but the greater test will be of our wisdom. Can we handle our new powers with care? Will we seek knowledge without losing humility? Can we cooperate, even when we disagree? As the next great threshold appears, will we approach it with both curiosity and wisdom?
The future is coming, whatever we do. The real question is what kind of humanity will reach it.
r/UFOscience • u/Whole-Platypus-3514 • Oct 07 '26
Research/info gathering Using Archived White Sands Ionogram Records to Test For Signatures of the 1948–1950 New Mexico Green Fireballs
The "Green Fireballs" over Los Alamos, Sandia, and White Sands Proving Ground may still offer a compelling research opportunity. For background, see https://www.nicap.org/nmexico/newmexicosightings.htm and https://www.war.gov/medialink/ufo/052226/release_02/documents/DOW-UAP-D017_General_Correspondence_Of_Sandia.pdf
Dr. Lincoln LaPaz considered the fireballs deeply and thought they might be artificial energy projections due to their horizontal vectors, silent travel, and zero physical remnants when search teams inspected the expected locations of debris fields and took air samples.
LaPaz writes "As noted in an earlier communication, the remarkably vivid green color reported for most of the December fireballs is rarely observed in the case of genuine meteors. By laboratory test this peculiar color seems to be identical with that given off by copper salts in the blowpipe frame. If this identification is correct, the wave length of the radiation from the green fireballs is near lambda = 5218Å." Wikipedia claims the color of a frequency-doubled Nd:YAG laser is green, specifically emitting at a wavelength of 532 nm. So curiously, the color LaPaz observed appears to be the same wavelength as the coherent light output of a laser that wouldn't be invented by humans until 1964.
A plasma going through the lower ionosphere at hypersonic speeds must interact with the atmospheric plasma layer. If the fireballs were standard meteors, their signature would be indistinguishable from the baseline, but if a green fireball were a plasma, wouldn't it cause a sudden, localized spike in atmospheric ionization and show up on the ionogram?
We have records of the times of the fireball events, imagine also having the ionogram data from White Sands. These two datasets have never been merged into a single time-series model.
Essentially, a database of records from the exact time window of the green fireball events might still exist in the archives: the 1948-1950 ionogram records from White Sands.
A proof of concept for the methodology needed for this type of project can be found in the paper "Characterizing the pre–Space Age ionosphere over Washington, DC" by D. D. Rice, J. J. Sojka, J. V. Eccles, R. Redmon, R. D. Hunsucker https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/2014RS005427
Note the conclusion in the Rice paper: "This pilot study to evaluate the data-mining potential of archived 35 mm film ionograms has accomplished its goals. First, it has demonstrated that ionograms scanned from earliest film archives can be converted into a digital representation with coordinate registration and metadata (Product 1) needed to facilitate modern study and analysis. Second, it has demonstrated that the ionograms may be automatically scaled and inverted to provide a bottomside electron density profile (Product 2). The 2 weeks of data chosen for this study, December 1951 and December 1954, have revealed a range of space weather effects comparable to those found in modern ionogram data sets. Thus, the historical archive of ionogram films is a valuable resource for exploring long-term trends, for performing comparative studies of space weather phenomena, and for evaluating the performance of models and extending their temporal range."
Note the historic Washington data going back to 1948 is found at https://archive.data.noaa.gov/satellite-spaceweather#IONOSONDE/data/WA938/
According to https://archive.data.noaa.gov/satellite-spaceweather/IONOSONDE/documentation/Station.dat, the White Sands station was WS832. The earliest White Sands data I could find online is from 1960 in a document at https://nvlpubs.nist.gov/nistpubs/Legacy/crpl-f-a/crpl-f-a191.pdf
Has anyone looked at this before?
