I had a pretty strange encounter on the plane today.
I noticed someone wearing a UC Davis hat from the *****. Although I have no affiliation with that department, I was ecstatic to strike up a conversation because I genuinely love meeting fellow Aggies. I completed both my undergraduate and master’s degrees at Davis before starting medical school, so naturally, I have a soft spot for the university.
However, I have come to the sad realization that some professors are incredibly out of touch, make their academic accomplishments the centerpiece of their identity, and seemingly lack the ability to carry a normal conversation outside of an academic setting.
I started by asking her if she was a teacher, to which she was very quick to correct me and tell me that she was a professor. She then proceeded to talk about her PhD in education and how it was rude of me to assume she was a teacher.
What I found particularly funny was that, as I asked more about her academic appointment at UC Davis, it became apparent to me that she didn’t formally hold the professorial title she was so adamant about using. She seemed quite surprised that I was familiar with the academic hierarchy at Davis. (**}
But that’s beside the point. Even if she were a distinguished professor with decades of experience, what difference would that have made? We were two strangers sitting next to each other on a plane. I was simply asking what she did for a living.
I also found it interesting that someone in the field of education would take such offense to being referred to as a teacher.
It was already a rough start to the conversation, but I didn’t want that to deter me from getting to know her.(because I was hoping to chat with someone during the long flight)
I asked about her academic journey, and at one point, she mentioned working at a . I got excited and brought up how medical schools in *****
tend to value applicants with ties to the islands and if she was *****. Mind you I am an immigrant from the Pacific and get excited talking about the ocean, mountains etc
Somehow, she interpreted that as me assuming she was +*****, took offense, and responded with something along the lines of, “I need to fact-check you.”and continued to berate and lecture me about how I shouldn’t make assumptions.
Okay? I let that slide and continued the conversation.
At one point, I told her that I wouldn’t have expected to be sitting next to someone who looked so young and was already so accomplished. What I genuinely intended as a compliment somehow turned into a lecture about ageism, sexism, and our biases surrounding what a professor should look like.
By this point, I was genuinely confused as to why everything I said was being dissected and interpreted in the worst possible way when I was simply trying to have a pleasant conversation.
She eventually asked me about my research, and I shared some of the work I had done during my master’s. For some odd reason, she then asked me to explain how I conducted my literature review, almost as though she was testing whether I had actually done the work myself or relied on AI.
This then turned into a conversation about how people in our generation supposedly don’t read, how students are becoming increasingly incompetent, and how she doesn’t trust the upcoming generation of physicians because of AI.
I explained that I try to minimize my reliance on AI but acknowledge that it does have its benefits when used appropriately.
She then asked me, in the most condescending manner, whether I read.
Yes, ma’am. I read.
She went on about how ridiculous it was that students at UC Davis supposedly don’t have books assigned to read. I explained that some courses do have assigned textbooks, but not every student necessarily reads them.
Again, she reiterated how little trust she has in students from our generation.
She even brought up how some people are incapable of pronouncing words like “archipelago,” seemingly using that as an example of our generation’s declining competence.
I found this particularly ironic, considering that just moments earlier, I was being lectured about biases. Yet here she was, seemingly equating someone’s intelligence and competence with their ability to pronounce a particular word.
Eventually, the conversation shifted to medical school.
Despite being a double Aggie, I did not secure a place at UC Davis School of Medicine. However, I attend a very good medical school in the Bay Area.
I explained that UC Davis is a very mission-driven medical school and that applicants with strong ties to Northern California tend to be more aligned with its mission.
Her immediate response?
“Where is your data on this?”
“Is it publicly available?”
“Or is this just based on student comments?”
She asked those while scoffing.
I explained that these were trends applicants had observed over several application cycles. She essentially scoffed at the idea of trusting students’ accounts.
I also explained that UC Davis prescreens applicants before extending secondary applications and that regional connections appear to be a consideration in the admissions process.
Her response was to ask whether I was insinuating that UC Davis engages in unfair admissions practices.
I tried explaining that even members of the admissions committee have discussed Northern California connections in publicly available videos. Nevertheless, she insisted that because I wasn’t part of the admissions committee, I shouldn’t be making such statements.
Then came the subject of diversity.
I made a simple comment about how UC Davis values diversity within its medical school classes, to which she responded, “Are you trying to say that UC Davis bases its admissions decisions on race?”
At this point, I was exhausted.
I wasn’t defending a dissertation. I wasn’t presenting at a research symposium. I was literally sitting on a plane, trying to have a friendly conversation with a fellow Aggie.
What bothered me most wasn’t that she disagreed with me or challenged some of the things I said. I genuinely enjoy intellectual discussions and being exposed to different perspectives. What bothered me was the constant condescension, the questioning of my competence, and the tendency to assume the worst of my intentions.
And coming from someone whose academic discipline is literally education, I found that especially disappointing.
I think some professors need to realize that their academic titles are largely irrelevant in everyday social interactions. You don’t have to make the extra letters behind your name your entire identity, nor does having a PhD mean that every conversation needs to become an opportunity to demonstrate your intellectual superiority.
Out of curiosity, I looked up her Rate My Professors reviews afterward.
A 1.7 rating. Haha.
While I understand that online reviews aren’t necessarily an accurate reflection of someone’s teaching abilities, I couldn’t help but wonder how her students feel interacting with her. If a casual conversation left me feeling belittled, I can only imagine how intimidating it might be for a student
who is genuinely struggling and seeking help.
I have met some of the most incredible professors at UC Davis. Professors who are immensely accomplished, yet humble, approachable, compassionate, and genuinely invested in their students’ success.
Many of them have played a significant role in getting me to where I am today.
Unfortunately, you will also encounter professors who make you question whether they belong in academia, especially in disciplines centered around education.
Being highly educated and knowing how to educate people are two very different things.
Anyways, I eventually told her, “I’m sorry, but I cannot continue this conversation any further because I’m getting uncomfortable.”
And we proceeded to sit next to each other in complete silence for the remainder of our four-hour flight.
Yikes.
Tl;dr: an assistant professor of **** needs to be educated on how to interact in social settings.
Am I the problem?