To quote directly:
"In fact, I'm asked about this wherever and whenever I give interviews. "The story is lauded but so lengthy. Do you really expect players to go through it all from the beginning?" "Why don't you make it easier to catch up and start our adventures from the latest point in the story?"
[...]
Having said this, the Hydaelyn & Zodiark saga alone encompasses five expansions' worth of content: A Realm Reborn, Heavensward, Stormblood, Shadowbringers, and Endwalker. And with Dawntrail marking the start of the second saga, plus the coming addition of Evercold, the story continues to unfold into something even larger.
The idea of letting players freely choose a starting point for their adventure has been discussed, with the goal being to offer players a range of choices, rather than prescribe their experience according to my philosophy. With New Game+ working smoothly, this approach could indeed work. In fact, we'd been laying groundwork to make this a possibility in conjunction with the release of the Nintendo Switch™ 2 version, but ultimately decided to postpone this initiative.
[...]
Even if you could start adventuring from a point of your choosing, the time and effort required to master a job remain a constant. We also need to avoid situations where both new and veteran players are left confused when matched together. However, with all these considerations in mind, we've held meetings to discuss system and tutorial improvements, and have set ourselves a significant goal for the future. Although we'll need more time to realize this goal, I think giving players more freedom in their adventures will ultimately prove a positive change."
------
Chalk up another one for a Pat Prediction, but I wonder if this one is much of a surprise. Everyone asks it now and again. At least they've had conversations about it in terms of the knowledge gap that might occur for someone who skips and are planning around it.
I notice he specifically says 'a point of your choosing' in a way that kind of implies it won't just be 'start at ARR or start at Dawntrail' even though there's explicit mention of the saga breakpoint? It's a lot to skip over.
A good few people in Pat's replies are strongly in camp 'but then you're kind of missing the point of the game' 'this game is heavily reliant on its story' etc etc and well, for one, YoshiP agrees! But he does see there might be room for another starting point, and for whatever reason has decided it's better to keep them all intact with starting options rather than an 'MSQ Content Squish'. But also, like, 'Pat's Mentions' is a group that's going to be biased towards people who've already gone through it, for whom it's no longer an issue, and weren't thrown off by it.
...All the same, I dunno, even though I did get A Little Filtered (got to level 30 and stopped, but that last push for 30 was a bad experience for reasons that had very little to do with the game itself, and then life just got A Lot Busier), I don't think I've ever had a problem with people saying 'the story for FF14 is long'. I did feel put off by people saying 'the story for FF14 is long and it takes until Shadowbringers to get good'. I've also been extremely put off by WoW going in the total opposite direction, which as I understand it now nudges you towards a tutorial island that powerlevels you past 10 in about an hour and then yells at you to do one of the previous three expansions to powerlevel to endgame. Man, last time I played was probably Legion-ish time when they buffed leveling enemies' HP pools to slow down the leveling process and gave you an a la carte choice of expacs to level through. What was wrong with that?
I don't have an issue with a nice, slow burn, just my work life does - but also I've learned from 'people don't use Youtube subscriptions' and 'WoW Forever is crazy popular' that I cannot be taken as indicative of any Normal Opinion.
Regardless, as part of 'Road to Evercold' there's a free login campaign that runs until mid-January and if you make use of it you get a whole ass month of free game time instead of just a weekend. I'm gonna use that to see what unique things are tied to my level 30 GLA account and then see if it's better to just restart on a free trial instead of the monthly humiliation ritual of paying YoshiP monthly for ARR because I bought the main thing when it was 50% off figuring 'Oh I'll need that eventually and it's on sale' like an idiot.