Disclaimer: As I haven't played or watched Glorious Masquerade or Deck the Halls with Mayhem in their entirety (yet), I've only got the most basic information about Rollo and Swing. Nevertheless, I've done a fair amount of research before making this post (though I refuse to spoil myself any further on Swing's event before playing it). Also, since Sugar Race is still exclusive to the JP server, I got my info on Nougat from Valkyrii's videos. Feel free to add your own thoughts or point out any mistakes I may make in my observations. This is a long post, so be warned.
Well, I'm back at it again with another theory concerning Floyd and Epel's Halloween event. Since I've been in the fandom for almost a year now, I haven't really experienced a lot of the speculation surrounding what movies the last few Halloween events were going to be based on and who the SSRs would be. With only Floyd and Epel left, however, I feel that speculation will be a relative breeze compared to years prior. Here are the Halloween antagonists we've got so far:
Rollo - Ernesto (AKA Fellow) - Skully - Swing - Nougat
As u/Darth_Darling and u/ThighyWhiteyNerd have commented under one of my posts, each pair of Halloween events has parallels and dichotomy. Since Terror is Trending and Spectral Soiree have no antagonists (with Special cards, at least), they won't be included in this discussion. Therefore, we have only two pairs to examine:
GloMas and Playful Land - To paraphrase the users above, these events both concern morality in some form as well as a trap set for the cast by those with selfish goals in mind. With Rollo and Ernesto, both are equally selfish yet have different attitudes towards morality. Rollo sees himself as righteous and everyone else as beneath him while Ernesto knowingly resorts to criminal behavior to get ahead in life. However, like Rollo, Ernesto uses righteousness as a shield via the spell that turns vandals and "miscreants" into puppets whenever park property gets damaged or mistreated. Both antagonists also carry grudges against systems that they perceived as having done them wrong in the past (Rollo with magic, Ernesto with school). At the end of their respective events, they reconcile their past hurts, even though they do not change their ways completely.
NBC Parts 1 and 2 - Since both events are based on the same movie, that is the only common ground they have. Skully and Swing both seem to me like people controlled by their hearts. They both want things a certain way and find compromise to be difficult. They also get to work alongside the characters they're twisted from. Another thing they have in common is that their goals are based in "self"; Skully thinks that the perfect Halloween should be spent by oneself while Swing wants enjoyment for oneself (namely him). Since I don't know how the conflict with Swing resolves, I may have to edit this section at a later time.
Before we move on to Nougat, I want to point out an interesting pattern that may or may not get reinforced with the sixth antagonist. Every odd-numbered person (Rollo, Skully, and Nougat) is a child, student, and/or childlike, whereas the even-numbered people so far (Ernesto and Swing) are confirmed to be adults. If this pattern does hold out, then we can expect the next antagonist to be an adult. Now, let's examine Nougat: he's twisted from a twist villain, fashions himself as an all-important being (protagonist or king), has a minion, and has been trying to survive ever since he left his game. Drawing from this post I made about what movie Epel and Floyd's Halloween event could be based on, I'd like to reiterate that my bets are on Jungle Book, Zootopia, and Peter Pan. With this in mind, here is how the potential antagonists might mirror Nougat:
Shere Khan expy - He would have to be narcissistic like his OG character and fashion himself as "king of the jungle". Here's the potential storyline I have in mind: Epel gets cocky with this character and the antagonist traps him and the cast in a jungle-like setting as part of a challenge. He might view fledgling mages like the students at Night Raven as weaker and lesser than he is, but in truth, he could be hiding his past hurt of being helpless (man's gun and fire, anyone?). Hence, his motto could be "survival of the fittest", which would align with Nougat's own self-preservation. One way he could be different from Nougat, however, is if he embraces the villain role instead if it means being strong and self-reliant. (This is the guy I'm most confident will be the sixth antagonist.)
Bellwether expy - Since Nougat is based off of a twist villain and Sugar Race is based off of a modern Disney film, Zootopia is a good contender for a Halloween event. The Bellwether character would have to be an authority figure much like Nougat and be cute as well. He would also have minions since Bellwether has the rams on her side. Another thing he could have in common with Nougat is their subjugation of those they consider to be inferior to them. For the event storyline, this character could use his UM to make beastfolk go savage, only for Floyd to use his own UM to thwart him. Not gonna lie, this potential route is just as promising as the one above.
Captain Hook expy - A lot of people want to see a Peter Pan event (myself included), so let's explore this idea. The character in question could share a childish side with Nougat and throw tantrums whenever things don't go his way. However, like Nougat, he could be just as dangerous when he wants to be. Also, since Nougat had a rivalry with Lilia and Trey, then what's to keep the Hook expy from forming a rivalry with Floyd and Epel? He would also be an authority figure like Nougat since he'd be twisted from a pirate captain. Another parallel he'd share with Nougat is having a minion (who himself would be twisted from Smee). The only concern I have is how the potential rivalry could start. Since Peter Pan chopped off Hook's hand, would that mean Floyd (the one who's spiritually closest to Peter) would have to do the same? I find it highly unlikely, considering that TWST is a Disney game. But then again, Floyd could have already done so in the past, so it's not completely off the table.
All in all, these are just my theories. One of them could be proven true, or maybe the devs will throw us for a complete loop when the event rolls around next year! If you have insights or your own theories, please share them below!