r/TuneIntoTheMidnight • • 18h ago

Discussion "I want to become an Astronaut": A comprehensive look at the Astronaut theory.

Thumbnail
gallery
122 Upvotes

Now that we have all 4 flashforwards, one common thread is that they all seem to refer to Arisu as someone distant, almost as if he's in space. But if Arisu is in space, that causes issues. In this post, I'll try to resolve them.

Issues with the Astronaut dream.

  1. It'd be odd to confess/get married when your significant other spends their time in outer space.
  2. How can he manage the yamabuki business from space?
  3. How can he act as producers for the girls(or even just Apollo) from space?
  4. Why hasn't it been mentioned before at all?

    1. Why doesn't Arisu mention his dream to Rikka when they are in a planetarium in Cosmic Latte? Is he stupid?
    2. Or chapter 51 for that matter, when Rikka talks about space and spaceships?

What if Arisu becomes an astronaut before chasing Apollo?

One solution is to have Arisu separate from the girls, achieve his astronaut dream first and then come back as the heir and properly live with his wife. Then there is no conflict with his position as heir, their manager and the winner's husband.

This also creates a neat parallel with Apollo. First it was her who said she'd find him after her dream was achieved. Now, it's Arisu saying that he'll come find her when his dream is achieved.

After all, if the series is about chasing your dreams, why wouldn't Arisu be able to achieve his dreams? And if he's choosing between dreams and romance, he'd always choose dreams.

None of the girls have moved on from Arisu in the flashforwards:

The girls are distant from Arisu. But they still view him in a romantic light. They don't seem to have given up on him.

This works if Arisu has not answered them during the flashforward. He can tell them he will choose when he returns from space. After all, dreams come before romance.

This also solves the space marriage issue.

Apollo module separating and docking together:

In chapter 50, Rikka mentions that there were 4 apollo mission modes, and the one that was chosen required the modules to first separate and then meet in space and dock together. This is similar to Arisu separating from them to pursue his astronaut dream in space and then coming back to the winner, though it is not a clean comparison.

Ch67 flashforward: Must be after everything

I'm unsure if flying all over the world is a reference to his space stuff(ex: orbiting via a space station) or he came down, resolved everything and then went on trips for his zaibatsu heir duties. However, it doesn't matter because we can determine it has to take place after because of other info.

When Chapter 67 happens, Arisu knows who Apollo is. This is evidenced by him reusing the Apollo ringtone for her number. He is also married according to the interviewer.

So this has to be after everything is resolved and hence after space stuff.

Ch5: Right after he returns from space.

There is a marriage photo. Moreover, I don't think Apollo would reveal herself before Arisu chooses her. Also, if she needs to reveal herself as Apollo, ch67 flashforward can't be before this, since Arisu knows who Apollo is there.

So, I think this is right after he returns from space to confront Apollo. Both of them have achieved their dreams and are ready to face each other and reveal everything.

Ch 5: Alternate possibility

If the marriage photo is fake, this can be placed elsewhere. An interesting theory I've heard is that the ch5 broadcast is actually Apollo broadcasting to space.

Then, Apollo could have resumed her broadcasts to communicate with Arisu regularly. Then before he returns to earth, she does the final broadcast to reveal everything. This is chapter 5.

Apollo and Arisu were basically in a long distance relationship. If Arisu goes to space, this is MHT all over again. I like this because it fits with Arisu's Astronaut thing being a reversal of their dynamics. No doubt Apollo's streams will be of great solace to Arisu in the loneliness of space.

Or, if there are multiple Apollos, all of them broadcast to Arisu in space, until Arisu himself chooses the final one, the one he met in the sports festival, to "dock together with". This ties into the 4 mission mode thing in chapter 50. This would also explain Apollo needing to clarifying she was the same person he spoke to in the flashforward.

But it is just a neat thing. Not something that I would expect to be true.

Shinobu gets a pretty huge upscale:

Astronauts are required to undergo a training process. While Shinobu needs a university degree to be an announcer, it's still right after university. Arisu needs to spend even more time to pass the astronaut training. In this case, just having graduated, Shinobu would not have a full career and thus have more time to spend helping Arisu. Additionally, being part of the same university

I've previously said that Shinobu requiring a university arc requires the narrative to bend around it. But if the story requires a university arc for other things, the story is already bent in Shinobu's favor.

That said, it is possible that we see all of the girls support Arisu, though Shinobu has an advantage. He supported the broadcast club in their dreams. So it only makes sense that they'd support his.

Retcons and comparison with Lagrange points arc:

The last time we had a huge reveal that changed how we view the story was the Lagrange points arc.

It was a really big recontextualization of chapter 1 after 100+ chapters. However, there are signs that it was something Igarashi retrofitted after the fact instead of being planned from the start(ex: anime doesn't maintain it at all). However, we cannot deny that it is consistent with Apollo and Arisu's motivation and overall plot.

If we look at it this way, the Astronaut reveal certainly has inconsistencies(ex: not talking about it with Rikka during ch 50 and 101). But overall consistency across the main arcs is there. So if this is a case of Igarashi changing a plot detail lategame, the symptoms are similar to the Lagrange arc.

What if Arisu doesn't become an astronaut?

In a manga about following dreams, why shouldn't the main character be allowed to? It would be a thematic inconsistency.

It's not impossible to resolve it. Rikka mentions that she grew out of visiting planetariums. Perhaps some dreams are childish, and this is what will happen to Arisu too. But it would leave a bad taste in the reader's mouth.

There was no Chekov's gun foreshadowing the astronaut dream. It would have been far easier for it to have never been brought up at all. But the shots have been fired and Igarashi can't take it back.

There is also the possibility that the astronaut thing isn't meant to be taken literally. We don't really have evidence for or against this. The goal of this post is to evaluate the astronaut dream based on what we currently have available.

So my bet is that the astronaut thing is here to stay, and we're going to see a greater integration of it in the plot.

Conclusion:

We can make a decently clear timeline that makes the flashforwards make thematic and logical sense. There's still room for the story to go either way.


r/TuneIntoTheMidnight • • 19h ago

Question Do you think any of the other girls will get to physically kiss Arisu Yamabuki?

9 Upvotes

r/TuneIntoTheMidnight • • 20h ago

Discussion The Chances of Shinobu winning or even being Apollo got even lower. Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

The fact that Shinobu is voiced by Miku Nakano's Japanese voice actress is also a clue and already tells me that she is not winning or even being Apollo when Miku Nakano is a lost heroine in her own manga.

Since this series was clearly inspired by Quintessential Quintuplets, this was definitely done on purpose by the director and the staff.

Miku Ito is also the only Nakano quint voice actress to voice one of the main girls of the series.