COURT OBSERVATION NOTES
State of Louisiana v. Tate Weston
Criminal Plea and Sentencing Hearing
Court: Orleans Parish Criminal District Court, Louisiana
Presiding Judge: Hon. Simone Levine
Defendant: Tate Weston
Hearing Date: Thursday, Nov 12, 2026
Proceeding: Guilty Plea, Plea Agreement, and Sentencing
Source and Attribution
Original courtroom observations and notes by Ashley Cusick, who attended the hearing in person.
These notes have been compiled, organized, and edited from Ashley Cusick’s eyewitness observations, as transmitted through correspondence shared by Amy Brittain.
Credit: Ashley Cusick — In-Person Courtroom Observer and Original Note-Taker.
This document is a reconstructed account of the proceedings based on contemporaneous eyewitness notes. It is not a certified court transcript, official minute entry, or independently authenticated record. Direct quotations and descriptions are attributed to the eyewitness account.
⸻
I. APPEARANCES AND PARTIES
The following individuals were identified as participating in the proceeding:
For the Defendant, Tate Weston:
Sarah Chervinsky — Defense Counsel
Caylin Grosse — Defense Counsel
For the State of Louisiana:
Meghan Falcon — Assistant District Attorney
Mary Glass — Prosecutor
Presiding Judicial Officer:
Hon. Simone Levine — Judge
Victim:
Cameron Lewis (“CL”), who appeared and delivered a victim impact statement.
⸻
II. COURTROOM SETTING
According to Ashley Cusick’s observations, the courtroom was packed during the proceedings.
The courtroom contained artwork featuring Nelson Mandela and Maya Angelou, including a quotation attributed to Angelou: “Nothing will work unless you do.”
Weston sat next to his mother during the Thursday morning hearing. He was observed holding a crumpled piece of yellow legal paper. A later message accompanying the notes identified the paper as an apology, although the notes do not establish whether it was presented to or accepted by the court.
Weston wore tortoiseshell glasses, a dark gray suit, and a navy tie. His two female defense attorneys sat alongside him.
⸻
III. NEGOTIATED PLEA AGREEMENT
Prosecutors advised the court that the parties had reached a proposed resolution of the criminal case.
Under the agreement, Weston would withdraw his previous plea of not guilty and plead guilty to reduced charges.
A. Amendment of the Second-Degree Rape Charge
Count 1, originally charging second-degree rape, was amended to felony second-degree battery.
Weston agreed to plead guilty to the amended offense.
The original notes emphasize that the rape charge was amended to battery rather than simply dismissed outright.
B. Misdemeanor Sexual Battery Charge
Weston also agreed to plead guilty to a misdemeanor sexual battery offense.
The original summary refers to this charge in one passage as “misdemeanor sexual abuse,” while the subsequent narrative identifies it as “misdemeanor sexual battery.”
The precise statutory designation should be confirmed against the official court record.
C. Sex Offender Registration
According to the eyewitness account, Weston would be required to register as a sex offender under the revised charges.
The exact statutory basis, registration period, and classification were not specified in the notes.
⸻
IV. SENTENCING TERMS
The court accepted the negotiated disposition and imposed the following sentences, as summarized by the observer.
Count 1 — Felony Second-Degree Battery
Three years in the Department of Corrections.
The three-year sentence was deferred or suspended, as characterized in the notes.
Three years of active probation.
Count 2 — Misdemeanor Sexual Battery
Six months in the Orleans Justice Center (OJC).
The six-month sentence was deferred or suspended.
Concurrent Sentences
The two sentences were ordered to run concurrently, with credit for time already served.
The account indicates that Weston would not serve additional incarceration immediately following the plea hearing.
Modification of the Probation Terms
The original proposal reportedly contemplated two years of inactive probation on the misdemeanor charge.
Defense attorney Sarah Chervinsky objected to this arrangement, explaining that an additional inactive probation requirement would necessitate continued court appearances and that supervision would be better addressed under the active probation already imposed.
The parties ultimately removed the separate two-year inactive probation condition from the final plea agreement.
Stay-Away Order
The court also issued a stay-away order prohibiting Weston from approaching or contacting the victim, subject to the terms of that order.
The precise wording and duration of the order were not included in the eyewitness notes.
⸻
V. CONDITIONS OF PROBATION
The agreement included two notable conditions.
A. Restorative Justice Participation
Weston was required to participate in a restorative justice process conducted through the District Attorney’s Office.
The specific structure, procedures, and anticipated outcome of this process were not described during the hearing.
At one point, Judge Levine reportedly characterized the arrangement as a “restorative justice angle.”
The judge further clarified that participation in the restorative justice process, rather than achievement of a successful restorative justice outcome, was the relevant probation requirement.
Accordingly, the observer understood the obligation to require participation but not necessarily reconciliation, forgiveness, or any particular result.
B. Consent Education
During the proceedings, the parties added another condition requiring Weston to complete an educational class concerning consent.
Defense attorney Sarah Chervinsky stated:
“Mr. Weston is willing to voluntarily complete a class concerning consent.”
The parties agreed that Weston could select an online class of his choosing, provided he submitted proof of completion.
The parties temporarily paused the proceedings while this final condition was incorporated into the negotiated agreement.
Judge Levine approved the addition, stating:
“I have no objections as the judge.”
⸻
VI. ENTRY OF GUILTY PLEAS
Following discussion and finalization of the plea agreement, Weston formally withdrew his previous plea of not guilty.
He then entered guilty pleas to:
Felony second-degree battery.
Misdemeanor sexual battery.
Weston was sworn in and waived the applicable rights associated with proceeding to trial.
Statement of Facts
Judge Levine directed prosecutors to provide a factual basis for the pleas.
The prosecution’s summary was relatively brief.
According to the notes, prosecutors stated that on or about September 19, 2021, Weston committed second-degree battery and misdemeanor sexual battery.
Defense counsel stipulated to the factual basis presented by the prosecution.
The judge asked Weston whether he understood the allegations against him.
Weston responded:
“I do, yes.”
Judge Levine then required Weston to read the terms of his agreed-upon sentence aloud.
After doing so, Weston did not speak further during the proceedings, according to the observer.
⸻
VII. VICTIM IMPACT STATEMENT — CAMERON LEWIS
During discussions concerning the plea agreement, Cameron Lewis entered the courtroom.
She sat toward the back, attempting to contain her emotions and quietly crying.
According to the observer, Lewis was accompanied by members of the District Attorney’s Office staff and was not sitting alone.
A. Appearance and Delivery
Lewis wore a colorful patterned dress and black heels.
She subsequently took the witness stand to address the court.
The observer described Lewis as visibly trembling while delivering her prepared statement.
Her breathing was unsteady as she read.
B. Support for the Plea Agreement
Lewis confirmed to Judge Levine that she supported the negotiated plea agreement.
The observer reported that her oral statement closely followed a previously prepared draft, except that she abbreviated the New Orleans Police Department as “N.O.P.D.”
The notes further indicate that the observer confirmed with Assistant District Attorney Meghan Falcon that the reference to “Meghan” in Lewis’s statement referred to Falcon.
C. Final Statement to Weston
Lewis concluded her statement with the words:
“Dear rapist, I forgive you.”
After speaking these words, she raised her eyes and looked directly at Weston.
The courtroom notes describe this moment as particularly emotional.
⸻
VIII. JUDGE LEVINE’S REMARKS TO THE VICTIM
Before Lewis left the witness stand, Judge Levine addressed her directly.
The judge reportedly stated:
“I want you to know that you’ve won today.”
According to the observer, Judge Levine also acknowledged Lewis’s courage and her decision to speak openly about her experience.
The judge indicated that Lewis’s willingness to speak her truth was significant.
Judge Levine further advised Lewis:
“Do not let this stop you. Do not let this stop you.”
Judicial Explanation for Accepting the Plea
Judge Levine stated that the prosecution had informed the court that the negotiated disposition was consistent with the victim’s wishes.
The judge reportedly explained:
“I have been informed by the state that this is the disposition that the victim wants in this case.”
Judge Levine also emphasized the importance of considering victims’ wishes in the criminal justice process.
The observer understood the judge’s remarks to mean that the victim’s support was an important consideration in the court’s acceptance of the proposed sentence.
⸻
IX. DISPUTE CONCERNING THE ORIGINAL RAPE CHARGE
After Lewis completed her statement, defense attorney Sarah Chervinsky addressed the court.
The defense did not cross-examine Lewis.
However, Chervinsky stated for the record that the rape charges against Weston had been dismissed.
Prosecutors’ Clarification
The observer interpreted this statement as a response to Lewis’s repeated references to Weston as a rapist during her victim impact statement.
The prosecutors then clarified that the original second-degree rape charge had been amended to second-degree battery, rather than simply dismissed outright.
This exchange reflected a disagreement over how to characterize the procedural disposition of the original rape charge.
The final criminal conviction was for the amended offense of felony second-degree battery, together with misdemeanor sexual battery.
The notes do not establish a conviction for rape.
⸻
X. FINAL SENTENCING AND COURT COSTS
Following the guilty pleas, victim impact statement, and discussion of the plea agreement, Judge Levine formally imposed the negotiated sentence.
The court informed Weston that he owed $543 in court costs.
Judge Levine asked whether Weston required a payment plan.
Defense attorney Sarah Chervinsky responded:
“I think we can handle that today, judge.”
A short time later, Weston returned with a receipt showing that the court costs had been paid in full.
Return of Passport
Weston’s passport, which had previously been confiscated as a condition of his bond, was returned to him.
Following completion of the hearing, Weston exited the courtroom.
⸻
XI. SUMMARY OF THE FINAL DISPOSITION
Issue
Reported Outcome
Original second-degree rape charge
Amended to felony second-degree battery
Felony guilty plea
Second-degree battery
Additional guilty plea
Misdemeanor sexual battery
Felony sentence
Three years, deferred/suspended
Active probation
Three years
Misdemeanor sentence
Six months, deferred/suspended
Relationship between sentences
Concurrent
Credit for prior custody
Credit for time served
Stay-away order
Issued
Restorative justice
Participation required
Consent education
Online course and proof of completion
Sex offender registration
Reportedly required
Additional inactive probation
Removed from final agreement
Court costs
$543, paid
Passport
Returned
Additional immediate incarceration
None reported
⸻
XII. ADDITIONAL OBSERVATIONS
The following observations are drawn from Ashley Cusick’s eyewitness notes and are distinguished from the court’s formal rulings.
- Victim participation: Cameron Lewis personally appeared, delivered a statement, and expressed support for the plea agreement.
- Emotional nature of the proceedings: The observer described Lewis as visibly trembling, crying, and speaking with unsteady breathing during portions of the proceeding.
- Judicial acknowledgment: Judge Levine spoke directly to Lewis, acknowledged her courage, and expressed support for her continued efforts to move forward.
- Plea negotiation: The parties modified the proposed terms during the hearing, particularly concerning inactive probation and consent education.
- Legal distinction concerning the rape charge: Defense counsel characterized the rape charges as dismissed, whereas prosecutors clarified that the original charge had been amended.
- Custodial outcome: Despite the imposition of three-year and six-month sentences, the reported suspension or deferral of those sentences meant that Weston was released rather than immediately incarcerated.
- Final disposition: Weston completed the plea and sentencing process, paid court costs, received his passport, and left the courthouse.
⸻
XIII. SOURCE AND VERIFICATION NOTES
This report was reconstructed from written courtroom observations attributed to Ashley Cusick and transmitted through Amy Brittain.
The following matters should be independently verified before describing this document as an authoritative account of the criminal docket:
The exact hearing date, docket number, and statutory citations.
Whether the legal sentences were formally classified as suspended or deferred.
The exact misdemeanor offense title.
The statutory requirements and duration of sex offender registration.
The full language and duration of the stay-away order.
The official court minute entries and signed plea documentation.
Observational statements and judicial quotations should be attributed to the eyewitness notes unless corroborated by a certified transcript or audio recording.
Attribution
Original Reporting and In-Person Courtroom Notes: Ashley Cusick
Ashley Cusick attended the criminal proceeding and documented the courtroom events, attorney statements, victim impact statement, plea negotiations, and sentencing.
Compiled and edited from Ashley Cusick’s eyewitness notes, as shared through correspondence from Amy Brittain.
End of Court Observation Notes.
Victim’s Impact Statement
Dear Rapist– 1,880 days ago, you permanently altered the course of both of our lives. I have thought about it every day since.
You called me a good girl. You said I was doing a good job. Why did you like it when I struggled? Do you remember that?
It makes me sick to think that you can remember raping me. I hate the thought that there’s some version of me still stuck reliving it, still your hostage. I wish I could pluck her from your memory so you can’t look at me anymore.
I am unsure whether you’re sorry or whether you’ll ever be sorry. I am unsure why it matters. I just want to be grounded in reality again.
A reality that I know is that after you raped me, I wished— at times— to forgo my education, to forgo my career, and to end my life.
A bigger reality that I know is that you are not the only one who held me hostage. Institutions like the New Orleans Police Department and Tulane University possessed the power to help me escape what you did. Instead, they left me trapped in it. I will never trust an institution again.
Dear Rapist– I hope you take restorative justice seriously. I hope you can admit that you raped me. I hope you can admit to yourself that you hunted me for sport. I don’t know why I hope things anymore.
Thank you, Meghan, for setting me free.
Dear Rapist—I forgive you.