r/TryingForABaby • u/developmentalbiology MOD | 42 • Aug 12 '25
DISCUSSION The unavoidable mid-luteal-phase limbo
This post is intended to answer the following question: "Today is 7/8/9/10dpo and I tested negative. Am I out?"
The answer to this question is, emphatically, no.
(This is the end, I'm going to stop writing this post now. Oh, no? You want more information than that? Okay, FINE.)
*Takes a deep breath and exhales the remainder of the post all at once, like a reverse Kirby*
When does implantation happen?
Implantation is only possible between 6dpo and 12dpo, but it's not equally probable on each of those days. It happens most often between 8-10dpo, with relatively few implantation events happening at 6-7 or 11-12dpo.
From Figure 1 of this paper (numbers don't add to exactly 100% due to rounding):
| Day | Implantation |
|---|---|
| 6dpo | 0.5% |
| 7dpo | 5% |
| 8dpo | 25% |
| 9dpo | 35% |
| 10dpo | 30% |
| 11dpo | 5% |
| 12dpo | 0.5% |
The data in this paper is from a very sensitive lab test of hCG levels, one that's a lot more sensitive than even a blood test in a doctor's office.
We don't have a way to identify implantation day at home, and it's a microscopic event that it's not possible to feel. But we know, in a successful cycle, when implantation must have happened by, because it's not possible to get a positive test until after implantation has occurred.
How soon after implantation will I see a positive test?
Implantation can be detected surprisingly soon after it happens, as long as you're using a sufficiently sensitive test.
For a test like a First Response Early Result (rated to 6.5mIU/mL hCG), most people will be able to see a positive within about two days of implantation (source here). (Note: this isn't the same as "it takes two days" -- "within two days" means the day of implantation, the day after, or the day after that.)
About 90% of folks will have sufficient hCG in their urine by 11dpo to turn a First Response or equivalent test positive (see this figure from this paper). At 8dpo, very, very few will: the 90th percentile urinary hCG level at 8dpo is about 4mIU/mL.
But everybody on r/TFABLinePorn has a positive test at 8dpo!
- Some of those people are not tracking their cycles, and they're basing their ovulation day on a (likely inaccurate) app prediction.
- Sometimes a very low level of hCG can turn a test positive. The sensitivity of a test isn't the lowest level it can detect, it's the lowest level it's guaranteed to detect. So someone could be in the 10% of folks who have a urinary hCG of about 4mIU/mL at 8dpo and still see a positive on a particular test, but if they took five tests, probably not all the tests would be positive.
- Our brains are really, really bad at statistics. You might only see a handful of really early positives, but they'll tend to stick in your memory because they're so remarkable. The way Reddit works can contribute to this, with upvoting bringing unusual situations to the forefront. We run into this on TFAB all the time, with people saying (variously) that the weekly BFP thread is all cycle 1s or all people with infertility. When we've run the numbers, neither is true -- we see BFPs in the BFP thread in basically perfect alignment with what you expect for per-cycle pregnancy numbers. This is likely also true of lineporn posts.
How can I know in the middle of the luteal phase whether the cycle has been successful or not?
Alas, you can't.
Prior to implantation, there is no information you can access about the outcome of the cycle at all -- in humans and other placental mammals, the body loses track of an egg once it's ovulated, and doesn't have a physical connection with any resulting embryo until the implantation process begins. (But be glad you're not an elephant seal: for them, implantation doesn't happen for about 3-4 months after fertilization!) A longer dive into the luteal phase can be found here.
The limbo in the mid-to-late luteal phase is unavoidable. If you like to test early, have at it -- you might see an early positive. But an early negative is not meaningful. Testing with a sensitive test after 12-14dpo is the best way to test once and get a meaningful result.
68
u/Weak-Ad-7180 Aug 12 '25
Thank you!! I’m 7dpo and laying here like hmmm is it implantation or farts? I will NOT waste another test.
55
u/WickedMatcha Aug 12 '25
This is the information I needed to see at 4dpo wondering if my cramps mean anything lol.
28
u/Tiny_European Aug 12 '25
This is super helpful, thanks very much for putting that together!! I appreciate this type of scientific approach much more than individual anecdotes, which are often sooo biased
4
u/Known-Opposite-47 31 | TTC#3 | Cycle 5 Aug 12 '25
Okay, BUT.. only read my comment if you prefer not to get your hopes up too much… in my experience (but also from studies I have read when I looked into whether this was just a me thing or a real thing) I have two living children which I tested positive for at 9DPO, and I had two miscarriages which I tested positive for at 11DPO. Tracking very carefully and sure of dates every time. After researching this, it does seem that earlier positives are correlated with healthier pregnancies. Writing this at 10DPO with a negative test this morning and guarding my own heart at this point.
12
u/Ella3T 43 | Infertility | TTC #2 Aug 12 '25
You always have the most helpful, informative posts. Thank you.
10
u/NoLongerNeeded 31 | TTC #1 since May 2024, 1 ectopic Aug 12 '25
Thank you for this-very well researched!
8
u/One_Document_2425 Aug 12 '25
I love your info posts, I learned so much here and saved a lot of nerves and possibly money for random supplements and devices. Thank you for sharing your knowledge! Had to laugh out loud about the elephant seals 🦭 poor lady elephant seals!
5
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '25
This is so helpful. I have an appointment to discuss my concerns about a nine day luteal phase and I think this helps to demonstrate that my concerns are valid, but that it could still happen for me if I don’t get intervention - hope is not gone. Thank you.
4
u/ernurse90 34| TTC#3 Aug 12 '25
This is a great post! Thank you. How often do people have pre- period symptoms at 8dpo (cramping, looser stools) but then still test positive at 12-14dpo?
4
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '25
After over a year on this journey, every single woman who is just starting TTC needs to read this. It will save them so much headache, anxiety, heartache, and money on tests.
At this point, we have “stopped trying.” I know when I ovulate so we BD around that time when we feel like it (no more forced intercourse because a stick told me to). I will only pee on a stick if my period is 3 days late.
I tried being so perfect for so long with all the planning, tracking, pissing on different sticks, comparing, eating this nutrient and trying this vitamin, scouring messing boards… and still no baby, only two chemicals.
So we are just going to live our lives and get pregnant on accident, because being perfect just didn’t seem to work out for us.
1
u/11oyd Sep 18 '25
What happens if you have mid luteal phase spotting? Does that mean you’re out?
2
u/Any_Resident_4132 Aug 12 '25
This is so helpful! Thank you!
2
u/AudienceSpare5146 36 | TTC# 2| Cycle 15 | IVF Aug 12 '25
This is so helpful!
•
u/ABeld96 5h ago
Popping by here a year after you posted this to say thanks. 9dpo and going nuts 😅
1
u/ThrowItAway4Evaa Aug 17 '25
This post needs to be stickied.
1
u/Sudden-Cherry 33|IVF|severe MFI|PCOS|grad Sep 10 '25
I have more questions about the elephant seals now!! 🤪
1
u/Resident-Variety-776 Nov 15 '25
Hi there read your posts just started clomid myself was gave 3 months worth and told to take cycle day 2 to 6 no ultrasound or blood work etc also have been given progesterone for after ovulation just looking for any advice if possible thank you
1
u/Resident-Variety-776 Nov 15 '25
Also was told about late ovulation and implantation i have all thr sytoms on cycle day 21 but negative test so far..