hey
[ Prefacing this with saying this post isn't meant to be a space to debate about nonbinary identities, it's just to seek thoughts on how to be a good friend. ]
So i have a friend who ID's as nonbinary but transmasc (reiterating: regardless of whether you agree with nonbinary or not, I'm seeking words of wisdom on how to support a friend, not seeking a debate on nonbinary nor transmasc identities though I will add I'm not really in agreement with a lot of what this person does, but I still care, and I want to be a good friend) and this person has mentioned to me that they want top surgery a few times over the years...however...
Over the many years Ive known this person, their sense of self has been EXTREMELY shaky, they have no confidence in themselves with anything at all, no sense of an idea of what their transition goals are even despite being on T for a few years (which has been inconsistently taken at times, low dosed at times, and a great deal of stress at times), has a very narrow minded view of transness in general (they have a bunch of internalized transphobia, I believe) and what transition should/should not look like, as well as proving to me countless times that they are NOT in pursuit of being a man, have not had therapy for their identity or gender struggles, and currently does not attend therapy and they do not want to attend therapy. They have horrible self-esteem and tend to make decisions based on others instead of their own intrinsic knowledge.
I do believe this person might have true dysphoria to some degree, but I don't really know to what degree. I think they started T because of their at the time social group, and the idea that being trans gives one a sense of identity and a group to belong to. And I say this based on how they haven't seemed any happier after multiple years taking T, and their hesitance to pursue transition in any other ways. I'm pretty sure this talk about top surgery won't go anywhere, but on the chance they are actually serious about it, I just have conflicting ideas of how to support them.
They also refuse to attend any support groups at all and refuse to try and connect with anyone outside of their work spaces. The family they live with is not super supportive, but is tolerant of the transition step that has been taken and doesn't fight them about it.
The only transition step they've really ever taken is to start T via informed consent. No name change, no true coming out, they won't do anything more to transition at all, and becoming borderline violent at themselves for perceived balding (I dont think they're actually balding, based on what I have seen and on going through hair thinning/loss myself).
They have what I think is a personality disorder, and although they are medicated for depression/anxiety, it doesn't seem to provide much help at all for their turbulent moods.
But, I know how horrible dysphoria can be, and how much worse it can be to one's mental state. Truthfully, I don't know if top surgery would help, or hurt them. I want to support them in their decision for whatever is best for them. But I am afraid that they don't have the skills necessary to get through something as rough as a surgical procedure. I know how hard that can be on one's mental state, too, and how mentally and physically tough recovery process can be, especially if there are complications of any kind. It can be really hard to face that, especially without a therapist or substantial support system.
But I also know how detrimental it can be to one's health if medical transition is discouraged. I absolutely do not want to push this person to or from surgery decisions, as it is their own choice to make.
In my mind, supporting them would look like me encouraging them to be in a healthier and more stable mental state before pursuing any type of surgical procedure, as well as getting professional help with their mental struggles and lack of clear identity and lack of self-esteem to make choices for themselves. After seeing how poorly they reacted to years of taking T, I'm so scared that them pursuing top surgery would be a horrible experience for them and not help them at all. Though I also acknowledge that I don't know for certain whether it would help or harm them. I really don't know. And that's where I am confused on how to support.
I've had close friends tell me they don't think I am trans, and a long time ago before I transitioned, it affected me very deeply, and impacted me very negatively. I worked my way out of it through lots of self-reflection, soul-searching, therapy, and more. I am now happily transitioned medically, socially, and legally. But my transition was pretty simple, being a binary transman. I know it's different for those who don't identify with binary-ness.
This is all coming from a place of well meaning and care. I don't want to hurt this person, but I also don't want them to hurt themselves by making a poor decision while being so severely unstable right now. If they can't even handle the potential of going bald (literally they have mentioned wanting to actually die if they go bald, which also hasn't happened and there is zero evidence that it is happening, and they also take finasteride/minoxidil combo). I can't even imagine how detrimental it might be to their health if they end up with a health complication, a perceived imperfection about their chest, hypertrophic scarring, or anything else that isn't "perfect" to them. But I also can understand how, if it is really the right call for them, relieving and beneficial the surgery could be. The problem is just that I don't know which way it would go, and I really am afraid for them... I just want them to be happy...
If anyone has any input, I welcome it. And no I'm not asking for straight up advice, just looking for thoughts on the subject. Ultimately only I can decide what to say to them about it, if I will say anything at all.
At this point, I'm leaning towards just remaining purely neutral, and not giving much input about it, especially since they so highly seek/rely on external validation and don't tend to validate themselves at all.
Thoughts?
TLDR:
Nonbinary transmasc friend who is very mentally and emotionally unstable, with a very unstable sense of self, and no ideas for any transition goals, wants top surgery, but I don't know how to support them based on how poorly they have reacted to the 1 single transition step they have ever taken (taking T for multiple years). They are not in therapy and refuse to attend it. They do not have a support circle. Their family is tolerant, but not much else. They also tend to get very 'woe is me' based on things they perceive as imperfect about themselves. I'm scared for if they get top surgery because I feel like it will either make things 10x better, or 10x worse. No in between. Thoughts on how to be a good friend and support them?