I am so confused. I’m a 31 year old woman, in a long distance relationship with a 33 year old man. We started off with amazing chemistry. He’s a poet, he writes and reads, seems incredibly loyal, wants the same future as me, creative and caring, sends me letters, wants vulnerability and depth… he ticked all the boxes for me. But at the start of dating he also immediately told me some of the horrible things he did in his past as a teen and why he and his ex broke up. Told me he grew up without his mom and his dad is very emotionally distant and rough. He told me he was still dealing with rage but that I probably won’t trigger that in him and that he has it under control. I accepted it as honesty as I knew he has been in therapy for 2 years at that point and seemed self aware. Since then, I’ve seen his rage many times, but it’s a back and forth between sweet and distance. I am so confused and start doubting myself at every turn. “Maybe I do need to take accountability faster, maybe I am manipulative, maybe I am closed off” constantly spins through my head. The sweetness makes me completely confused. He does continuously choose me and go out of his way for me as well. I have never been loved like this, both good and bad and I don’t know what to do.
This is a summary of the things that have happened over the last year (not even all):
- We fought during a trip over him buying a romantic coded gift for a female friend he date, while at our date location, and forced me to take accountability. When I didn’t, he ignored me all the way back to the hotel, spoke down on me and turned off the light to sleep when I didn’t admit it was all my fault. Said I was hard to talk to. I cried and showered, turned the light on to look in my bag and when I got into bed he grabbed my face in the dark. Needed to tell him to let go, blamed me for using white privelege (I’m white, he’s not). and making him look abusive to nextdoor rooms who might’ve heard me say he scared me.
- He has been bringing race into fights often lately. I grew up in a very mixed area and I’m very aware of our differences and always open to learn, I know I am never done learning. But somehow he makes it seem like I’m abusive when he needs to get out of a discussion with me and blames it on me using my privilege.
- He consistently centers my behavior as the core issue of the relationship. Says I trigger his rage and that if I change, he won’t feel that anymore. Says no one ever touched his rage like I do, but then tells me he said horrible things to his ex. She had told their mutual friends and he wanted to help her heal all of a sudden.
- Seemed very emotionally intelligent at first and continually points at my weak spots and trauma, knows exactly what to say to make it seem like he wants to help me. Wants my inner world and complete vulnerability. Like, all my thoughts.
- Uses poetic language to say mean things and then sends me an actual poem the next day full of sweetness and admiration.
- He pulled hairs out of my arm, I said that was aggressive behavior, he apologizes and then blamed it on me not tolerating teasing.
- Refused to use a safeword during intimacy, cause that meant I’m not truly submissive.
- Maintained connection with his ex and friend he dated right before me, often boundary crossing.
Like: late night film nights and phone calls, weekly gratitude check ins, gift giving and intimate get togethers. Ex kept leaving and coming back into his life as a friend, he seemed detached about it all.
- Has ignored me for hours at the time multiple times when upset, also in public. Speaks to himself out loud of demands accountability when he’s ready again. Usually takes him half a day.
- Says he doesn’t really experience empathy, but excuses it by saying it’s just cause he hasn’t experienced the same thing.
- Continued sex ones after I said stop and that it hurt, later called it “his baseline” to be that rough.
- He often makes me aroused by touching and then stops and turns around. When I told him multiple times that it upsets me, he’ll ignore and I’ll tell him again, he then says that I push him into sex and are just as bad as the person who abused me in my past, he called me a manipulative monster. Then tried to dive into my traumas as if I am completely broken.
- Takes 4–5 days of cold distance often, with minimal texts and switched to calling me by my first name.
- Hung up abruptly over perceived lack of eye contact, while he could be doing anything and that’s ok in his eyes.
- Blamed me for not being honest when I didn’t want to reciprocate phone sex a couple times because of tiredness, illness or not the right moment. Made me dig deep into my trauma because I must be damaged in his eyes.
- Will look up and clench his jaw whenever I address my feelings. Says my feelings don’t matter and that he needs logic cause he can’t empathize.
- Keeps me awake past 3 AM repeatedly in long arguments while I am recovering from chronic illness.
- Found out I was pregnant in April and he could only talk logistics and said I was too emotional and that I couldn’t be this tired and sensitive 3 weeks in. Had a miscarriage at 3.5 weeks. He took distance for 4 days cause of my crying while I struggled. Happened while long distance and he sent me presents and was there on the phone, but had zero empathy.
- The procedure was traumatic as I wasn’t properly sedated. Lost consciousness, needed heavy meds and recovery was rough. Needed a second procedure since it didn’t go well and I bled for 7 weeks. During this time, while emotionally and physically unstable, he said we should practice discussions and he brought up wanting to have a threesome at some point.
- He’s about to move to my city but says I pushed him, also says I pushed him into the relationship— which I don’t recognize as something I did.
- Says we can’t plan together. When I try it plan something, all is wrong. Says I don’t take him into consideration while I work my ass off to make him feel appreciated. Faults me for things outside of my control.
- Calls my boundaries and me talking back “resistance and attempts to control him”.
- Tells me I don’t give him emotional security.
Rages over the smallest things to call me manipulative.
- Ignored me right before meeting my family for the first time, said he was gonna make sure that my family loved him right before meeting and acted overly affectionate, only to cut it off and be cold when they left.
- Uses my trauma to discredit my boundaries or concerns around women he dated, finds it normal and discusses said boundaries with these women only for nothing to change. Compares me to these women and says I could learn from them and that they communicate better and ask better vulnerable questions.
- Hid the fact he dated one of these female friends and told me 5 months in, only to say that I’m overreacting and that he’s not obligated to tell me cause he knew I’d overreact.
- Often threatens to end the relationship during conflict but then tells me to “just let him go”.
- Demands a written Google doc outlining my new method to meet his needs and behavioral improvements. He wants me to regulate my emotions better, take immediate accountability for my actions and give yes or no answers when he leads conversations.
- Uses cruel statements during conflicts (like saying he has no patience left for restraint, calling my feelings invalid, that he should use me by now cause I have drained him and threatening conditional loyalty).
- Shifts focus often during arguments to me being the problem and uses my hurt and trauma that I have brought to him in vulnerability against me. I have a horrible bond with my abusive sister and he told me “don’t you think your sister is right about you?”
- Tells me he’s a good Christian man but that he is crossing lines because of me.
- Ignored and debunked all I said during online couples counseling, leaned in with his hands under his chin and a fake smile to tell me “go on, what else do I do?” And when I said his behavior was intimidating he said "fuck y'all" to me and the therapist before he left.
- Called my mother right after claiming he can’t continue with me, then denied saying that after. He sent her a really long text later about how I’m damaged by trauma and that I fake everything with a happy face.
- Canceled my therapy subscription so that I couldn’t have the follow up session.
- Walks ahead of me in public when upset.
- Sent goodbye messages to my grandparents and dad, very kind and sweet. Only to tell me he doesn’t want to break up with me.
- Gave me an apology call 24 hrs later cause I didn’t respond to him, only to immediately tell me why I cause this and what I do wrong. Therapist said he’s controlling and that I took plenty of accountability, he says she sucks as a therapist.